The Fiamengo File - December 19, 2016


The Scandal of ‘Human Rights’ - TFF Episode 55

Save Us from Social Justice - TFF Episode 54 What If Men Are Smarter - TFF Episode 56

Episode Stats


Length

13 minutes

Words per minute

146.1

Word count

1,908

Sentence count

84

Harmful content

Misogyny

5

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
00:00:00 If your business is failing, do you have the right to fire an employee you can't afford to keep on?
00:00:07 Not necessarily, according to the Ontario Human Rights Tribunal.
00:00:11 That's my subject on today's Fiamengo File.
00:00:22 I'm Janice Fiamengo of the University of Ottawa.
00:00:25 In my last video, I talked about the human rights tribunals that operate in Canadian provinces
00:00:31 which decide cases of alleged discrimination under the Human Rights Code. These tribunals
00:00:37 were originally supposed to be a quick and cheap way for people who had been discriminated against
00:00:42 in housing and employment to find resolution. But the tribunals quickly became Orwellian means of
00:00:50 social control in which extremely trivial and ambiguous cases of alleged wrongdoing
00:00:56 are adjudicated by social justice warriors keen to detect and punish even the subtlest forms of bias
00:01:05 in Canadian society. For this video, I chose two rulings, more or less at random, to give you a
00:01:13 flavor of how the tribunal implements its agenda. Some years ago, Ezra Levant wrote a book called
00:01:20 shakedown how our government is undermining democracy in the name of human rights in which
00:01:25 he examined some outrageous cases including his own i'm going to focus instead on ordinary cases
00:01:34 the everyday happenings at the tribunal where people are found guilty of all manner of
00:01:39 prejudice and made to pay for their sins in the first case i'm going to look at the respondent
00:01:45 was guilty, in my opinion, of a trivial form of discrimination and was given an extremely harsh
00:01:52 penalty. In the second case, the respondent was not clearly guilty of anything at all,
00:01:57 but was still punished. Now, I'm not a lawyer, as you know, so I invite you to look up the cases
00:02:04 yourselves and tell me if I'm wrong. First case. In a 2010 judgment, an unwary Toronto landlord
00:02:13 who didn't even show up for the hearing, whether because he knew he was doomed or because he didn't
00:02:17 understand the significance of it, was found to have contravened the Human Rights Code when he
00:02:23 refused to show a bachelor apartment to a 47-year-old man who wanted to rent it. He said
00:02:29 he thought the apartment was too small for the man and more appropriate for a young female student.
00:02:36 So it's hard to dispute that he did discriminate against the man, though in a manner that happens
00:02:42 nearly every day, I suspect, as landlords make quick judgments about who looks like a desirable
00:02:48 tenant. His error was in being honest about it. I found it very hard to believe the complainant's
00:02:55 testimony, which was that he, quote, felt very hurt, broken, and alone, end quote, as a result.
00:03:04 Disappointed, okay, yeah, really annoyed, sure, but broken seems a step too far. In the ruling,
00:03:12 were told the incident was, quote, a true affront to his dignity and that, quote, for a long time
00:03:18 afterwards, he didn't feel up to searching for another apartment and ended up staying in his
00:03:24 basement apartment as a result, end quote. Well, if true, this is surely an overreaction. But the
00:03:31 commission accepted and even magnified the complainant's sense of injury, reporting that 0.99
00:03:36 the harm was, in feminist lingo, intersectional in nature, i.e. it was a double discrimination 0.99
00:03:43 based on sex and age. I must admit I'm somewhat surprised that a white man of 47 years old would
00:03:51 be considered a victim at all, according to a feminist intersectional victim schema.
00:03:57 But the irony is staggering. Canada is a society in which white men are regularly discriminated
00:04:05 against in hiring, for example, by government mandate, the same government that's now so
00:04:12 worried about one white man's feelings. The difference is that government-mandated
00:04:17 discrimination is not, as here, a one-time incident. It's a systemic bias, and moreover,
00:04:24 it's one applauded by respectable society. But that's the way it is in Canada. It's okay when
00:04:32 the state does the discriminating, and it's not okay when it's one individual landlord making a
00:04:38 choice of tenant. In this case, the landlord was likely a Greek immigrant to Canada who may have
00:04:44 known little or nothing about our human rights legislation. His name was Panaitis Michlades.
00:04:51 For his act of discrimination, Michlades was ordered to set things right with a whopping $5,000
00:04:58 plus interest payment to the complainant, and he also had to pay out of his own pocket for a human
00:05:05 rights expert to draft a statement about the human rights code for him to post in his apartment
00:05:10 building. According to the adjudicator, the landlord's offense was made worse by the fact that
00:05:16 he was warned by the complainant when they met that it was illegal for him to refuse to rent to
00:05:22 him on grounds of age or sex. Apparently, quote, the respondent, the landlord, just walked away
00:05:28 and told the complainant he was crazy. So, according to the adjudicator, the, quote, callous
00:05:34 and blatant nature of the respondent's discriminatory actions exacerbated the
00:05:40 injury to the complainant's feelings and dignity, end quote. And that's what led to the relatively
00:05:46 high award. Now, the logic seems all wrong. It seems the landlord didn't know anything about
00:05:53 the human rights code. He may genuinely have felt that the complainant was too large, as he said,
00:05:59 for the small apartment, and that therefore he wouldn't be a long-term tenant. The point is,
00:06:04 he genuinely didn't know that what he was told about violating the code was correct. It struck
00:06:09 him as crazy, as he said. So this is far more likely a case of ignorance rather than blatant
00:06:16 callousness. And I would have thought it might lessen the severity of the offense rather than
00:06:21 exacerbate it, but it doesn't. Furthermore, the adjudicator in the ruling seemed to find it
00:06:28 necessary not only to punish the landlord for the sin of preferring a different tenant, but also to
00:06:33 go on at length about how it wasn't really a punishment at all but a quote remedy. I'll bet
00:06:42 Panaitis Michelades felt it was a punishment. He was fined thousands of dollars for doing what a
00:06:49 lot of landlords do in one way or another. Do you think he learned something about equality?
00:06:56 Certainly the complainant learned something that it's profitable to catch somebody out in a crime
00:07:02 and pretend to be, quote, broken and alone over it. And for that, taxpayers were billed thousands
00:07:10 of dollars. In the second case, the decision is even more startling. This is a 2008 judgment
00:07:20 involving a small-town restaurant owner in Geraldton, Ontario, who terminated the employment
00:07:26 of one of her waitresses, a friend whom she had herself waitressed with before she started her
00:07:32 own restaurant. Now the waitress claimed that she had been terminated because of discrimination 0.98
00:07:37 because her spouse was HIV positive and had hepatitis C and restaurant patrons didn't like 0.90
00:07:46 her working at the restaurant. The restaurant owner didn't dispute that some patrons were
00:07:51 unhappy but said she had dismissed the waitress because the restaurant was struggling financially
00:07:58 and she simply couldn't afford to keep her on, not out of any bigotry. The waitress had been the
00:08:04 last person hired and therefore was the first person to be let go. There was plenty of evidence
00:08:10 of the restaurant's financial problems. There were NSF checks and so on. To complicate matters
00:08:17 slightly the complainant produced a letter by the restaurant owner in which she actually stated
00:08:21 that she was firing her because of complaints about her spouse's condition, but the restaurant
00:08:26 owner complained that she'd written the letter upon the request of the former employee who wanted
00:08:32 to, she said, get back at those who had gossiped about her. It sounds as if she had a lawsuit in
00:08:38 mind from the very beginning, and then in the event, she decided to go after her former friend.
00:08:45 A revealing side issue in the affair concerned the complainant's attempt to pressure a witness
00:08:51 to give false testimony about the restaurant owner in return, she promised, for a share in the damage
00:08:58 award that she was seeking. The adjudicator actually found that the complainant lied to
00:09:05 the tribunal, tried to mislead the tribunal. But still, drum roll please, still found that the
00:09:16 restaurant owner had contravened the Human Rights Code. According to the adjudicator, if any part
00:09:23 of the decision to fire the former employee had to do with her spouse's HIV status, then that is
00:09:29 enough to constitute contravention of the Human Rights Code. Here's the statement by the adjudicator,
00:09:34 quote, even if there are legitimate reasons for terminating an employee, if one of the factors
00:09:41 or considerations was discriminatory, then the termination will be held to be a violation of
00:09:47 the code, end quote. That seems a remarkably broad definition of a human rights violation.
00:09:55 In the adjudicator's mind, even imminent business failure can't provide justification for an
00:10:02 employer's action in firing an employee if grounds for discrimination have been established.
00:10:07 He writes as follows, quote, businesses are required to comply with the code not only when
00:10:13 it is economically advantageous or economically neutral, but even if they feel there is an
00:10:19 economic risk or disadvantage. Economic interests and rights do not trump human rights, end quote.
00:10:28 But is there a human right to be kept on by a restaurant owner even when the restaurant is
00:10:33 failing. The implication is that it's better for the entire restaurant to go out of business and
00:10:39 for all the employees to be out of work and of course the entrepreneur to be financially ruined.
00:10:43 That's better than for there to be even the appearance of discrimination. How good it must
00:10:50 feel to the adjudicator with a guaranteed fat salary paid by the state to preach to a struggling
00:10:56 small business owner on her moral duty to sacrifice her livelihood on the altar of human rights.
00:11:03 As for the complainant, despite being found to have sought to mislead the tribunal by pressuring
00:11:11 a witness to give false testimony, no punishment or even serious rebuke was forthcoming for her.
00:11:19 So she gets away with lying to a government body in an attempt to get money out of a former 0.69
00:11:25 employer. The only disappointment for her was that she failed to gain the financial compensation
00:11:31 she was seeking. The restaurant owner did not, in the end, have to pay her, but still didn't fare
00:11:39 very well. Though not forced to pay damages to the complainant, the adjudicator did mandate
00:11:46 that the restaurant owner give $2,500, money she could obviously ill afford, to a local AIDS
00:11:56 charity. Why? To show the great moral rectitude of the adjudicator, even though there was
00:12:02 no evidence whatsoever that the restaurant owner harbored any prejudice against persons with HIV
00:12:09 or was guilty of anything more than wanting to keep her little restaurant afloat. That's the
00:12:17 kind of work the Human Rights Tribunal is doing with taxpayers' money, making life difficult for
00:12:23 ordinary people in the name of social justice, and in some cases, I would say, creating the very
00:12:31 kinds of racial and other animosities that it claims to be curing. So those are the two cases.
00:12:39 Tell me if I'm wrong about them. And believe me, there are plenty more every year. It's quite a
00:12:46 system we've created in Canada, a forum for powerful elites to demonstrate their moral
00:12:52 superiority over the great unwashed, all the while being paid out of the taxes of the same
00:12:59 people they're set up to judge. It doesn't inspire confidence.