The Fiamengo File - March 23, 2017


What If Men Are Smarter - TFF Episode 56

The Scandal of ‘Human Rights’ - TFF Episode 55 The Masculinity Confession Booth -TFF Episode 57

Episode Stats


Length

20 minutes

Words per minute

134.1

Word count

2,685

Sentence count

111

Harmful content

Misogyny

37

sentences flagged

Hate speech

8

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 Evidence suggests that there are more genius-level men than women in some of the most notable
00:00:07 areas of human endeavor.
00:00:09 Do we have to pretend not to know this? 1.00
00:00:13 And might our society's pretense about female intellectual equality hold a clue to feminist 1.00
00:00:19 rage? 1.00
00:00:20 That's my subject on today's Fiamengo File.
00:00:29 I'm Janice Fiamengo of the University of Ottawa.
00:00:32 Recently, I was re-watching a video conversation on TV Ontario's program, The Agenda.
00:00:39 It featured University of Toronto psychologist Jordan Peterson, now well-known to many of us,
00:00:45 and a University of Tel Aviv feminist neuroscientist named Daphna Joel,
00:00:51 who claims her research shows that male and female brains are indistinguishable. 0.99
00:00:57 The feminist professor made two notable claims during the program
00:01:01 that represent the standard feminist position on sex differences. 0.66
00:01:06 The first is that scientific research into innate male-female differences 0.94
00:01:11 should be seen as, quote, politically illegitimate.
00:01:15 in her words. And the second is that even if we had proof of innate cognitive and behavioral sex
00:01:22 differences, that wouldn't make any helpful difference to social policy. Her example for 0.65
00:01:30 this position was that proof of a greater male tendency to aggression shouldn't make any
00:01:36 difference to how we raise young men, our practice of teaching young men not to be aggressive.
00:01:43 Now her assumption here is that if we believe that something is biologically determined,
00:01:49 then we will see it as unalterable and in fact good. But really we've believed for centuries
00:01:55 that men are in general more aggressive than women and we have not only taught cultural values such
00:02:01 as self-control and indeed chivalry to men, but have also sought to harness male aggression in
00:02:08 socially productive ways. So knowledge and wisdom don't always go together, of course,
00:02:14 but there is certainly no evidence that suppression of knowledge leads to wisdom.
00:02:20 And it is deplorable to see a scientist declaring certain research out of bounds altogether.
00:02:27 But this is now the standard SJW position, that we must suppress the search for knowledge in the
00:02:35 name of equality. According to Professor Daphna Joel, research into biological sex differences
00:02:42 will always be used for political ends to justify misogyny and discrimination against women and
00:02:49 special privileges for men. Like so many feminist assertions that have been generally accepted, 0.98
00:02:56 this claims unfalsifiability has not so far weakened its persuasiveness. In other words,
00:03:03 it is neither provable nor disprovable, but it feels right, even though it requires us to assume
00:03:09 what is patently unlikely that the majority of non-feminist researchers, both male and female,
00:03:15 have some kind of vested interest in justifying inequality. And even though the claim skirts the 0.86
00:03:22 obvious fact that feminist research will definitely be used for political ends, since that is its 0.96
00:03:29 declared purpose, to promote feminist conceptions of what society owes women and to make those the 1.00
00:03:36 foundation of often costly and far-reaching social policies. So why should we be more inclined to 0.92
00:03:43 trust a feminist researcher with a declared ideological bias than to trust a non-feminist 0.92
00:03:49 researcher with no declared bias and a dedication to following evidence wherever it leads?
00:03:56 Daphna Joel's research has in fact been widely, and as far as I could discover,
00:04:01 mostly uncritically reported in major magazines and newspapers across the Western world.
00:04:08 Using MRI brain images, she and her team at Tel Aviv University have, it is claimed,
00:04:13 found no significant differences between male and female brains. According to a late 2015 report in
00:04:20 the magazine Science, the majority of male and female brains studied by Joel's researchers were
00:04:26 a mosaic of male and female structures. Here's the key quotation from the report.
00:04:32 Quote, depending on whether the researchers looked at gray matter, white matter, or the
00:04:38 diffusion tensor imaging data, between 23% and 53% of brains contained a mix of regions 0.61
00:04:45 that fell on the male end and female end of the spectrum.
00:04:49 Very few of the brains, between 0% and 8%,
00:04:53 contained all male or all female structures, end quote.
00:04:58 I make no claim to being capable of evaluating this finding,
00:05:03 but I can say that the manner in which the information is presented
00:05:06 seems to me at best unhelpful and at worst deliberately misleading.
00:05:12 For one, it is not at all clear whether brain structure is the sole or primary determinant
00:05:17 of male-female cognitive difference. For another, the percentages cited in the report do not
00:05:25 clearly make the case we're told they make. To say that depending on what variable is studied,
00:05:32 23% to 53% of brains contained a mix of male and female regions
00:05:38 doesn't prove that male and female brains are indistinguishable. The numbers reveal that
00:05:45 depending on the variable, a large majority of brains, as high as 77% if I'm doing the math
00:05:52 correctly, did not contain much of a mix. Tell me, am I wrong? It is stated that between 0 and
00:06:01 8% of brains contained all male or female structures, but I would like to know what
00:06:07 That percentage contained a preponderance of male or female structures.
00:06:13 Why are we not told that?
00:06:15 It would certainly seem to make logical sense that male and female brains would share many
00:06:21 structural features since many of the things men and women have to do in life are the same.
00:06:27 But it also makes sense that there would be some significant general differences given
00:06:31 our sexual differences.
00:06:34 research is presented in such a manner to prevent readers from thinking well about the reported
00:06:41 findings. And even more than this, I'm struck by the totalizing tenor of Professor Joel's own
00:06:49 conclusions about her findings. Usually, scientists worthy of the name are very conservative in the
00:06:56 conclusions they're willing to draw from their research. They are scrupulous about not concluding
00:07:02 more than the findings will strictly authorize. But not so Daphna Joel. She essentially declares
00:07:11 that as a result of her work, research into sex differences in the brain is all but over. She
00:07:17 actually has the temerity to say that from now on, this is what she says, quote, researchers studying
00:07:24 the brain may not need to compare males and females when analyzing their data. For another,
00:07:30 she says, the extreme variability of human brains undermines the justifications for single-sex
00:07:36 education based on innate differences between males and females, and perhaps even undermines
00:07:42 our definitions of gender as a social category, end quote. That was all a quotation from Professor
00:07:48 Daphna Joel. I've never before heard of a serious scientist declaring that her research results are
00:07:55 so conclusive that other researchers should simply stop pursuing related research. This goes beyond
00:08:02 confidence well into totalitarian arrogance. And unfortunately, it's not surprising that the same
00:08:08 professor who deplored the use of scientific research for, quote, political ends, immediately
00:08:14 moved to give her research a political application, in this case to discredit single-sex schools, 1.00
00:08:20 despite their beneficial impacts, and to support the feminist claim that gender is a social 0.99
00:08:25 construct. Such statements certainly make me wonder whether Daphna Joel shouldn't be regarded 0.96
00:08:31 as an ideologue rather than a real scientist, though you wouldn't know that from the credulous
00:08:36 manner in which her pronouncements have been generally received. And you certainly wouldn't
00:08:40 know of the mountain of evidence documenting the cognitive and behavioral differences between male
00:08:46 and female, some of it pretty difficult to refute through the social constructionist lens, such as
00:08:52 that research cited by Professor Jordan Peterson in the Agenda program that I mentioned at the
00:08:57 beginning of the video. He refers to a study by Simon Baron-Cohen showing fairly marked sex
00:09:03 differences in one-day-old male and female infants. The fact that Joel never acknowledges
00:09:10 this work seems a remarkably unscientific position. For a very different approach to
00:09:17 sex distinctions in cognition, consider the work of Doreen Kimura, who was a PhD in psychobiology
00:09:24 and a professor at the University of Western Ontario, and whose book Sex and Cognition
00:09:29 represents a lifetime's worth of objective research into the neural and hormonal bases
00:09:35 of behavioral and cognitive sex differences. Unlike Professor Joel, whose ideological agenda
00:09:41 is clear, Professor Kimura pursued her research to increase human knowledge, not because she
00:09:48 began with a cherished theory that she was determined to support. Through a multitude
00:09:54 of controlled tests in problem solving, memory, and other cognitive abilities, Kimura's research
00:10:00 found that on average, men outperformed women in a variety of spatial tasks, especially involving
00:10:06 identifying objects in altered orientations. Men also excelled at tests of mathematical reasoning.
00:10:14 This is worth emphasizing. Men excelled at tests of mathematical reasoning with the differences
00:10:21 between the sexes most remarkable when it comes to the most brilliant mathematicians. Women, 0.91
00:10:29 in contrast, were generally better able to recall the spatial layout of an array of objects, 0.99
00:10:34 to scan arrays quickly to find matching objects, and to recall words.
00:10:40 Kimura found that such sex differences, which occur across cultures, usually begin at an early
00:10:45 age, before puberty, and last a lifetime. Unlike Tel Aviv's university's Daphna Joel,
00:10:53 Western university's Doreen Kimura was never interested in dictating what kind of research
00:10:58 other scientists should pursue or how society at large could make use of scientific findings.
00:11:05 She co-founded the Society for Academic Freedom and Scholarship to protect the freedom of scholars
00:11:12 to pursue the research that most interested them. She was one of the few brave souls to defend
00:11:18 Professor Larry Summers of Harvard University when he got himself into trouble after speculating
00:11:24 about the reason more men than women excel at very high-level mathematics.
00:11:30 Kimura was interested in scientific fact, not politics. In a report on her research,
00:11:36 she was quoted as regretting the insistence on equality of outcome in STEM fields. This is what
00:11:43 she said, quote, engaging in coercive social engineering to balance the sex ratios may 0.99
00:11:50 actually be the worst kind of discrimination, she claimed. It also serves, she went on to say,
00:11:57 to entice some people into fields they will neither excel in nor enjoy, end quote. This last
00:12:06 point about enticing women into fields they won't excel in or enjoy got me thinking about the 1.00
00:12:14 flipside to feminist professor Joel's insistence that research into sex 1.00
00:12:19 differences is illegitimate, even dangerous. Maybe not pursuing sex 1.00
00:12:27 differences is more dangerous. Now I can understand Joel's concern to some small
00:12:33 extent. If society accepts what seems to be the case that there are more genius
00:12:39 level men than women in the field of mathematics, it's possible that there
00:12:43 would be some discrimination against women wishing to study mathematics or to enter mathematics-related
00:12:49 fields, such as engineering and physics. This is possible, as I say, but highly unlikely in our
00:12:55 current gynocentric climate. After all, no one claims that there are no female math geniuses, 1.00
00:13:03 only that there are fewer than male math geniuses. A society that values individual excellence will
00:13:10 naturally honor and promote true math ability in women. Women should and will have the right if 0.99
00:13:17 they are intellectually equipped to pursue mathematics-related work. The risk of discriminating 1.00
00:13:23 against women in math seems vastly outweighed by the far more dangerous risks for women, men, and
00:13:31 society overall of insisting on women's equal intellectual ability and thus of pushing women 0.58
00:13:38 into such positions in the name of gender justice. I've touched on this problem in some previous 0.59
00:13:43 videos, but I just recently came across an article in a publication called Academic Questions that
00:13:50 gave this problem a name and an interesting backstory. The article is called, quote,
00:13:56 Snowflake Jacobins, Black Rage on Campus. In it, the author Russell Neely provided an explanation
00:14:04 for the outburst of angry accusations and radical demands by Black students on American college
00:14:10 campuses over the past couple of years. Nieli refers to, quote, a phenomenon long known to
00:14:16 historians and social scientists that might be termed the Tocqueville effect, after its first
00:14:22 extensive description by Alexis de Tocqueville in his book, The Old Régime and the French Revolution.
00:14:28 de Tocqueville was an aristocratic French intellectual born in 1805, fascinated by
00:14:35 democratic government, and best known for his book Democracy in America. In the later work,
00:14:42 cited by Nieli, which was published in 1856, Tocqueville explained the conditions that cause
00:14:48 people to engage in violent revolution, conditions which are not always linked to objectively real
00:14:56 oppression. Instead, he found, quote, extreme anger and hostility are often the result of a, quote,
00:15:03 revolution of rising expectations in which certain groups come to entertain exaggerated hopes of a
00:15:12 better future, hopes that the actual conditions of life inevitably disappoint, end quote. So, such
00:15:19 unfulfilled expectations lead to frustration, bitterness, and outrage, which in turn lead to
00:15:26 protests, demands for change, and even as in some cases, riots and violence. Leaving aside the
00:15:33 question of whether the theory does indeed apply to black students on campus, we can see that 0.99
00:15:38 feminists too have been shaped by a, quote, revolution of rising expectations, end quote.
00:15:44 The fact is that the position of women in Western societies is very good by nearly any measure except the feminist measure.
00:15:54 The feminist dream and confident prediction was that once barriers to women's participation were removed,
00:16:00 women would flourish in intellectually demanding fields such as high-level maths. 0.91
00:16:05 But women haven't flourished, at least not in the numbers feminists confidently expected.
00:16:11 If we look at Nobel Prizes awarded since 1986, the year affirmative action hiring became federal law in Canada.
00:16:19 That's why I chose it, though of course it doesn't apply to women in other countries.
00:16:23 If we look at Nobel Prizes, we find that in the science categories, physics, chemistry, and physiology or medicine,
00:16:31 women have won only 10 out of the 220 Nobel Prizes.
00:16:36 That's about 4.5% of the total number of awards.
00:16:40 to say that this is a disappointing outcome would be an understatement. It's not much different from
00:16:47 women's performance in the bad old days of so-called patriarchal discrimination. In fact, 0.98
00:16:52 in the years 1900 to 1920, women achieved two out of the 60 prizes in the same categories,
00:17:00 about 3.3% of the prizes. So rising expectations among feminists have met the stubborn reality 0.56
00:17:09 of female underperformance. If you're a feminist and you've accepted feminist claims that all of 1.00
00:17:16 gender is a social construct and that assertions about cognitive difference are male supremacist 0.59
00:17:22 fantasies only, then of course you're going to cry foul. You're going to believe that something's
00:17:28 holding women back even though nothing is. Thus, feminists are forced to look for ever more subtle 1.00
00:17:34 but supposedly powerful and omnipresent reasons why women are not performing equally to men. 1.00
00:17:41 Sexism, sexism, and more sexism. And feminists use claims of sexism to justify yet more demands 0.96
00:17:49 for special accommodations and artificial advantages. We have seen a plethora of recent
00:17:55 articles claiming that science itself is sexist, that women's perspectives are necessary to save
00:18:01 science, and that gender bias continues to bar women from fulfilling their potential.
00:18:07 It's always the same mantra, more needs to be done for women. These predictable formulaic paper-thin 0.99
00:18:16 complaints would be embarrassing and sad if they were not so socially destructive. A perfect vicious
00:18:23 circle with no end in sight, whereby talented male scientists are barred from the enormously
00:18:29 important and beneficial work they should be doing, and less talented women are shoehorned
00:18:34 into positions for which they are not well-suited, with a corresponding likelihood that they will, 1.00
00:18:39 for a combination of reasons, feel resentment, anger, and a determination to bend the discipline
00:18:44 to suit their needs rather than the requirements of science itself, and all because we are wedded
00:18:51 to the false idea that gender justice can only be said to have been achieved when women occupy 0.99
00:18:57 at least 50% of the most prestigious academic, political, and business positions, whether they're 0.67
00:19:03 the best for the job or not. Maybe it's true that even 50 years after all the real barriers fell,
00:19:11 we still don't know what women are capable of in these traditionally male-dominated fields. 0.83
00:19:17 But it's a certainty that pretending we do know and mobilizing against so-called politically illegitimate research and mandating female numbers in STEM will never produce a rational, healthy, or just society.
00:19:47 more and better content. And don't forget to subscribe to us on Studio Brulee. 0.96