00:14:28de Tocqueville was an aristocratic French intellectual born in 1805, fascinated by
00:14:35democratic government, and best known for his book Democracy in America. In the later work,
00:14:42cited by Nieli, which was published in 1856, Tocqueville explained the conditions that cause
00:14:48people to engage in violent revolution, conditions which are not always linked to objectively real
00:14:56oppression. Instead, he found, quote, extreme anger and hostility are often the result of a, quote,
00:15:03revolution of rising expectations in which certain groups come to entertain exaggerated hopes of a
00:15:12better future, hopes that the actual conditions of life inevitably disappoint, end quote. So, such
00:15:19unfulfilled expectations lead to frustration, bitterness, and outrage, which in turn lead to
00:15:26protests, demands for change, and even as in some cases, riots and violence. Leaving aside the
00:15:33question of whether the theory does indeed apply to black students on campus, we can see that0.99
00:15:38feminists too have been shaped by a, quote, revolution of rising expectations, end quote.
00:15:44The fact is that the position of women in Western societies is very good by nearly any measure except the feminist measure.
00:15:54The feminist dream and confident prediction was that once barriers to women's participation were removed,
00:16:00women would flourish in intellectually demanding fields such as high-level maths.0.91
00:16:05But women haven't flourished, at least not in the numbers feminists confidently expected.
00:16:11If we look at Nobel Prizes awarded since 1986, the year affirmative action hiring became federal law in Canada.
00:16:19That's why I chose it, though of course it doesn't apply to women in other countries.
00:16:23If we look at Nobel Prizes, we find that in the science categories, physics, chemistry, and physiology or medicine,
00:16:31women have won only 10 out of the 220 Nobel Prizes.
00:16:36That's about 4.5% of the total number of awards.
00:16:40to say that this is a disappointing outcome would be an understatement. It's not much different from
00:16:47women's performance in the bad old days of so-called patriarchal discrimination. In fact,0.98
00:16:52in the years 1900 to 1920, women achieved two out of the 60 prizes in the same categories,
00:17:00about 3.3% of the prizes. So rising expectations among feminists have met the stubborn reality0.56
00:17:09of female underperformance. If you're a feminist and you've accepted feminist claims that all of1.00
00:17:16gender is a social construct and that assertions about cognitive difference are male supremacist0.59
00:17:22fantasies only, then of course you're going to cry foul. You're going to believe that something's
00:17:28holding women back even though nothing is. Thus, feminists are forced to look for ever more subtle1.00
00:17:34but supposedly powerful and omnipresent reasons why women are not performing equally to men.1.00
00:17:41Sexism, sexism, and more sexism. And feminists use claims of sexism to justify yet more demands0.96
00:17:49for special accommodations and artificial advantages. We have seen a plethora of recent
00:17:55articles claiming that science itself is sexist, that women's perspectives are necessary to save
00:18:01science, and that gender bias continues to bar women from fulfilling their potential.
00:18:07It's always the same mantra, more needs to be done for women. These predictable formulaic paper-thin0.99
00:18:16complaints would be embarrassing and sad if they were not so socially destructive. A perfect vicious
00:18:23circle with no end in sight, whereby talented male scientists are barred from the enormously
00:18:29important and beneficial work they should be doing, and less talented women are shoehorned
00:18:34into positions for which they are not well-suited, with a corresponding likelihood that they will,1.00
00:18:39for a combination of reasons, feel resentment, anger, and a determination to bend the discipline
00:18:44to suit their needs rather than the requirements of science itself, and all because we are wedded
00:18:51to the false idea that gender justice can only be said to have been achieved when women occupy0.99
00:18:57at least 50% of the most prestigious academic, political, and business positions, whether they're0.67
00:19:03the best for the job or not. Maybe it's true that even 50 years after all the real barriers fell,
00:19:11we still don't know what women are capable of in these traditionally male-dominated fields.0.83
00:19:17But it's a certainty that pretending we do know and mobilizing against so-called politically illegitimate research and mandating female numbers in STEM will never produce a rational, healthy, or just society.
00:19:47more and better content. And don't forget to subscribe to us on Studio Brulee.0.96