The Fiamengo File - March 30, 2017


The Masculinity Confession Booth -TFF Episode 57

What If Men Are Smarter - TFF Episode 56 Sons Of Feminism Update - TFF Episode 58

Episode Stats


Length

10 minutes

Words per minute

123.08

Word count

1,285

Sentence count

62

Harmful content

Misogyny

7

sentences flagged

Toxicity

4

sentences flagged

Hate speech

5

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 Is the Masculinity Confession Booth satire or not? Is feminism satire? 1.00
00:00:08 That's my subject on today's Fiumengo File.
00:00:17 I'm Janice Fiumengo of the University of Ottawa.
00:00:20 By now you may have heard about the Masculinity Confession Booth,
00:00:24 sponsored by the University of Regina in Saskatchewan, Canada.
00:00:28 it's part of the university's man up against violence program a program that invites men
00:00:35 to accept their responsibility for ending violence against women from monday march 27th to thursday
00:00:43 march 30th participants are invited to make a confession the man up website tells us that quote
00:00:51 We have all reinforced hypermasculinity one way or another, regardless of our gender.
00:00:59 Come and share your sins so we can begin to discuss how to identify and change our ways.
00:01:08 A friend of mine in the men's rights movement wrote me a couple of nights ago to say that the
00:01:12 masculinity confession booth is actually a satire, that the whole revivalist drama of judgment and
00:01:19 redemption, of contrition and absolution, of hyper-masculine depravity and salvation through
00:01:27 feminist grace. It's all a bit of fun. I'm not sure. The event is still posted on the Man Up
00:01:34 Against Violence website looking real, and it has been widely reported as real. This is a vivid case
00:01:43 of what's called Poe's Law. That's an instance when it is impossible to tell whether something
00:01:50 is real or not because the underlying ideology is so irrational. It might be a mockery using
00:01:59 exaggeration and parody, or it might be a sincere statement of belief. That's what the feminist 1.00
00:02:07 assault on masculinity has become. And what makes determining the authenticity of the masculinity 1.00
00:02:15 confession booth so difficult is the fact that the language of the Man Up website is so similar
00:02:21 to other programs dedicated to reforming masculinity. These programs can be found
00:02:27 all across North American college and university campuses. Brown University, for example, offers a
00:02:33 program on unlearning toxic masculinity while Duke University has a nine-week men's course
00:02:40 the purpose of which is to rethink masculinity to make it less sexist controlling and violent as
00:02:48 as the website tells us. Needless to say women are never invited to unlearn their toxic femininity 0.96
00:02:55 the mere suggestion is unthinkable. So when I read that the University of Regina was inviting 1.00
00:03:00 students to confess their sins of hyper-masculinity, I figured this was simply a more explicit version
00:03:07 of what is already implicit in all the other programs, that masculinity is a kind of deformed
00:03:14 humanity. It's destructive, it's corrosive, and it's sinful. When I learned that it might be
00:03:22 satire, well, I was relieved. So the University of Regina doesn't actually believe that masculinity
00:03:29 is a sin. That's good. So does this mean that all of the statements on the Man Up Against Violence
00:03:36 website are satirical? There's a part there about encouraging men to, quote, accept their role as
00:03:44 advocates in the movement to prevent violence in our communities. That must be satire too.
00:03:51 After all, it would be sexist to say that men are the cause of all violence when statistics show
00:03:57 that women also commit violence against men, against children. In fact, women more often kill 0.98
00:04:04 their own children than men do. So it would be sexist to suggest that only men are responsible
00:04:10 for ending violence. This must be a satire on the sexist assumptions embedded in contemporary
00:04:17 feminist anti-violence propaganda. Amazing. This may also mean that the University of Regina
00:04:23 sexual harassment policy is a satire. After all, its definition of harassment is so wide
00:04:32 that it could conceivably refer to nearly any human behavior at all. It includes, quote,
00:04:40 unwelcome remarks. Jolene, get your fat ass over here. Unwelcome jokes. How long does it take a 1.00
00:04:49 feminist to unscrew a light bulb. Unwelcome taunting about a person's attire. Chrissy, 1.00
00:04:56 that hat makes your ears stick out. Also, unwelcome physical contact. Sorry, I brushed
00:05:03 against you as I walked by. Or unwelcome invitations or requests. I make a mean chili.
00:05:11 would you like to come over and sample it? It must be that this list makes a mockery of the idea
00:05:19 that ordinary innocuous human behavior of the sort that occurs every day in workplace interactions
00:05:27 could be deemed harassment simply because it might be unwelcome to one person. I'm glad to know
00:05:34 that the university is taking a satirical stance against the excesses of the feminist policy 0.73
00:05:42 on sexual harassment. And it occurs to me that I may have been misunderstanding all the other
00:05:50 toxic masculinity write-ups. They must be satires too. They're so vicious in their portrayal of
00:05:58 masculinity as sick and depraved brown university's toxic masculinity website tells us that quote 0.99
00:06:06 men will often resort to violence to resolve conflict because anger is the only emotion that 0.99
00:06:14 they have been socialized to express even a five-year-old who had observed only a few men
00:06:21 would know that you can't pretend that the only emotion men express is anger and a university
00:06:29 program claiming to help men and to care about them would never create such a crude caricature
00:06:36 the website goes on to say that quote unfortunately the way that young men are conditioned to view
00:06:42 sex and their need to be dominant and have power over others also contribute to instances of sexual
00:06:50 assault and other forms of interpersonal violence on college campuses. That's incredible. Can you
00:06:58 imagine such negative and simplistic statements being made about any other identifiable social
00:07:04 group? It would never happen. That nasty stew of social constructionist jargon about how men are
00:07:13 quote socialized mixed in with essentialist claims about what men need it absolutely must
00:07:21 be a brilliant parody of the fundamental incoherence and hateful bias of anti-male
00:07:29 feminist propaganda this must be a magisterial statement by brown university that it refuses 0.51
00:07:38 to countenance the maniacal exaggerations and supremacist rhetoric of radical feminism
00:07:45 and duke university's men's project has got to be satire too and that's an incredible relief
00:07:53 because it includes a lot of hyperbolic anti-male verbiage about male privilege and about how
00:07:59 masculine men do nothing but damage others with their violent sexuality their men's project
00:08:07 discussions we're told seek to quote reckon with sexist systems that allow us that is men 0.61
00:08:13 unique advantages while disadvantaging others unique advantages like being considered guilty
00:08:22 of sexual assault on campus if you can't prove a woman said yes at every stage of a sexual encounter
00:08:27 unique advantages like being able to get drunk and be sexually assaulted by a woman while you're
00:08:33 passed out and yet still be charged with sexual misconduct? Unique advantages like being four
00:08:39 times more likely to commit suicide? I get it. This is a sharp satire on the general indifference
00:08:46 of North American society to male suffering and a tendency for everything masculine, especially
00:08:52 masculine sexuality, to be defined negatively. That's when we're told by a spokesperson for
00:08:57 the program that masculinity is quote a knife that can cut both ways both toward women and
00:09:03 non-male identified individuals and also against ourselves end quote well that has got to be a
00:09:10 satire right that old sexist stereotype about male sexuality as always dangerous and harmful
00:09:17 i could go on but i don't need to because it's obvious satire is alive and well in our universities
00:09:25 and the good news is that it's focusing on anti-male assumptions and stereotypes.
00:09:30 For a while, I was actually starting to believe that universities were seriously telling men
00:09:36 that the only way to be a good man is to hate your manhood.
00:09:42 I'm glad the masculinity confession booth at the University of Regina
00:09:46 has really highlighted the crazed evangelical fervor and the pseudo-religious claptrap
00:09:54 of feminist man-blaming. I only wish it were so.
00:10:24 You