The Fiamengo File - April 06, 2017


Sons Of Feminism Update - TFF Episode 58

The Masculinity Confession Booth -TFF Episode 57 Feminists Weigh in on Weight - TFF Episode 59

Episode Stats


Length

11 minutes

Words per minute

160.39

Word count

1,770

Sentence count

61

Harmful content

Misogyny

3

sentences flagged

Toxicity

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

2

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 This is an update on Sons of Feminism.
00:00:11 I'm Janice Fiumengo from the University of Ottawa.
00:00:15 I received over 60 submissions, ranging in length from a few hundred words to over 17,000 words in response to the question,
00:00:24 to the question how has feminism affected your life one book can't hold all those essays so
00:00:31 right now i'm making a first selection in the hope that a second edition of the book will be feasible
00:00:37 and also that some of the essays can be published online i'm in communication with an american
00:00:42 publisher right now just in the very early stages and if i can't find a commercial publisher for the
00:00:48 book, I will self-publish it.
00:00:51 Before I say a few things about the essays, I want to stress how much it is meant to me
00:00:57 to be trusted with these stories.
00:00:59 I'm honored to have been allowed to read them and to prepare them for publication.
00:01:05 It's not an exaggeration to say that putting this book together feels like the most significant
00:01:11 public project I've ever undertaken.
00:01:15 some of you know, I got the idea for the book when I started to receive emails from men saying things
00:01:22 like, I was in the audience at the talk you gave at Queen's University, or I saw your video this
00:01:27 week about campus sexual assault tribunals, and then they would tell me about what had happened
00:01:34 to them. And I came to believe that it was important that stories like theirs be widely
00:01:39 shared because it was so powerful to read them all. Men told me about how they'd been falsely
00:01:46 accused of sexual assault at university and spent months trying to prove their innocence.
00:01:53 They told me of their own experiences of sexual assault by women, one man when he was 14 years
00:01:59 old by a gang of older girls. Men told me about false accusations of sexual harassment at their
00:02:06 workplace and how they didn't even have a chance to try to prove they didn't do what the women
00:02:11 complained about. They were just let go without any proper investigation at all. I heard about 1.00
00:02:18 a feminist vigilante group that drove a man out of his job, accusing him of murder after a mentally
00:02:24 ill woman who had been in love with him committed suicide. One man showed me irrefutable evidence of
00:02:31 the near impossibility of advancing in his academic job, while women with far fewer publications
00:02:37 could land plum positions because of the push to hire women into STEM fields. 0.92
00:02:44 One man told me about being beaten by the police and left permanently disabled because of a woman's
00:02:50 false allegation. Men told me about how one day their wife just up and left, took the kids, said
00:02:56 I don't want to be married to you anymore, said you're going to pay me so that I can live well
00:03:00 without you. And if you fight me in court about any of this, I'm going to say you sexually abused 0.99
00:03:05 our kids and you'll never see them again. And in some cases, even though they paid, they still
00:03:10 didn't see their kids again. And their lives were ruined because of experiences like these and
00:03:16 nobody important cared or even acknowledged it. I heard from young men who said that from day one
00:03:23 in public school, they were told explicitly and implicitly that girls' lives mattered more,
00:03:29 that girls needed to be respected and treated well and supported and encouraged and boys didn't need
00:03:36 that or deserve it. They learned that boys needed to be reformed through lectures about the dangers
00:03:43 of their masculinity, that they had to learn that they could hurt girls, sometimes just by liking
00:03:49 them or looking at them. They were told that boys had always had it better than girls and they needed
00:03:55 to be ashamed of that fact and get used to a different era now, a supposedly more enlightened
00:04:00 one, in which everything in the culture was going to favor girls. And if they objected to any of 0.86
00:04:06 that, it just proved that they had something wrong with them. It just proved why we needed
00:04:10 even more promotion of girls and anti-sexism propaganda. I heard from young men about what
00:04:17 it was like to be raised by a mother who didn't like men and who made them terrified of their own
00:04:22 sexuality. I heard from young men about what it was like to be raised by a violent mother who
00:04:27 verbally and physically assaulted them and their fathers and all along claimed to be a victim.
00:04:34 These emails I received totally contradicted the feminist narrative of how relatively easy it is
00:04:40 to be male in our culture, how men have a sense of entitlement with regard to women, how men have
00:04:46 power and women don't, supposedly. And how if men are angry about feminism, that's because they
00:04:52 don't like the idea of sharing all that power with women. But these men, they didn't mind sharing
00:05:01 power. That was the last thing they objected to. What they objected to was a woman-focused system
00:05:08 that in every important way denied them basic rights. The right to parent their children, 1.00
00:05:13 the right to know what they were being accused of, the right to equality before the law,
00:05:17 equality of opportunity at work, and so on. They were objecting to a system that not only
00:05:23 didn't care about them, but actively discriminated against them and at the same time
00:05:28 kept haranguing them about their so-called privilege. These men didn't want to keep women
00:05:33 down. I never heard from a single man out of the hundreds of emails, maybe over a thousand that I
00:05:40 received who said equality of opportunity was a bad idea, or who wanted to go back in time to a
00:05:46 previous era when women didn't have abundant career opportunities, or who objected to working
00:05:51 with women, or who saw women as objects, or whatever feminists tend to say men's beef is.
00:05:57 In fact, the thing that probably struck me most over the past couple of years of
00:06:02 emails and in the submissions that I received for the book was the high regard that most men
00:06:08 still have for women in general, despite how they might object to feminist theory or might have had
00:06:14 a bad experience with one or more individual women, that was probably the thing that surprised
00:06:19 me the most. Men's mildness. This is the biggest lie of feminism, I think, that a lot of men hate
00:06:27 women, that misogyny is a big phenomenon of our culture. As a woman, when I first read feminist
00:06:36 propaganda about female oppression i was furious and i was furious at pretty much all men i got
00:06:43 out of that mindset because i could see it simply wasn't true based on my experiences and observations
00:06:50 but a lot of women some of whom have had bad experiences some of whom haven't
00:06:56 never got out of the mindset they made resentment into a state of mind for which
00:07:02 They expected to be congratulated and have been congratulated.
00:07:08 I've come across very few men who fit the category of a woman-hater even among those who've had a
00:07:13 lot of reason to be. The vast majority of the men I've heard from are hopeful about the
00:07:20 possibility of creating a better society in cooperation with women. A lot of them have a
00:07:26 worshipful or at least loving attitude. They want a society where men and women work together as
00:07:34 equals for mutual benefit. And I've just not encountered this attitude in the women I know 0.87
00:07:41 generally, apart from the women I've met in the men's rights movement and the anti-feminist
00:07:45 women that I know. But many women that I've talked to, they'll listen to what I have to say
00:07:52 and at the end of it just won't acknowledge men's issues at all and they'll harp on about some
00:07:58 relatively minor thing that happened to them 35 years ago some single remark one man made or some
00:08:05 incident they felt was sexist and that is what all these years later is stoking their anger
00:08:11 and their refusal to care about male suffering i've never met a man quite like that this is the
00:08:18 thing I didn't know about men overall before I started this adventure in the men's rights
00:08:23 movement. And it's made me realize that feminism could have achieved everything it said it wanted
00:08:31 in terms of expanded professional opportunities, sexual freedom, an end to sexist stereotyping.
00:08:38 It could have achieved all of that without the anger and the hatred against men. This is perhaps
00:08:44 an obvious point, but it feels like a big insight to me. And someday, we're going to have to confront
00:08:51 why it was that the anger and the hatred against men became such a central part of the feminist
00:08:58 movement, and why feminists, even women in general, seem so unwilling to give those up.
00:09:05 I was actually startled to find so much goodwill towards women amongst men.
00:09:12 a skeptic might say well of course the man who wrote to you or just one narrow slice of the
00:09:17 population mostly those who still believe change is possible so they're more hopeful and even if
00:09:23 they're not they're not going to vent hatred when they're writing to you but that's not the whole
00:09:29 story i've also spent a lot of time on various online forums with men who are angry and despairing
00:09:35 And even they, I think, are a lot less grudge-holding and a lot more forgiving than I would be in their situation.
00:09:45 So that's where it's at.
00:09:47 The book is coming together, and it's got incredible essays in it about the crazy world we're living in.
00:09:54 And I hope that these essays will touch some readers and encourage them to find out more about men's issues.
00:10:01 Now, I'm not a Pollyanna.
00:10:02 In fact, I'm one of the biggest pessimists I've ever met.
00:10:05 So I don't imagine that the publication of Sons of Feminism is going to transform our
00:10:10 cultural situation overnight.
00:10:12 There have already been a bunch of books and articles and videos by people like Warren
00:10:17 Farrell and Karen Strawn and Christina Hoff Summers and Paul Elam and so many others.
00:10:23 Wonderful people that should already have made the cultural transformation.
00:10:28 But I'm hopeful that along with all those other efforts to seek justice for men and boys, this book, Sons of Feminism, may open some eyes to what is surely one of the greatest and least recognized injustices of our time.
00:10:58 content, and don't forget to subscribe to us on Studio Brulee.