The Fiamengo File - April 13, 2017


Feminists Weigh in on Weight - TFF Episode 59

Sons Of Feminism Update - TFF Episode 58 Instructors Getting Dumber By the Day - TFF Episode 60

Episode Stats


Length

11 minutes

Words per minute

133.67

Word count

1,596

Sentence count

71

Harmful content

Misogyny

5

sentences flagged

Toxicity

2

sentences flagged

Hate speech

3

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 Is fat a feminist issue? That's my subject on today's Fiamengo File. 1.00
00:00:13 I'm Janice Fiamengo of the University of Ottawa. A few weeks back, Carleton University in Ottawa,
00:00:19 Canada, came in for some criticism when it decided to remove the weight scale from its student gym,
00:00:24 citing concerns that some students with body issues might be triggered by the scale.
00:00:30 And you can bet Carleton's wasn't the first university gym to make such a move.
00:00:35 In 2015, gym staff at the California State University removed its way scales for one day
00:00:41 in honor of National Eating Disorder Awareness Week.
00:00:45 And I think we can trust the manager of Carleton University's wellness program, Bruce Marshall,
00:00:49 to know what he's talking about when he claimed, in an interview with CBC News,
00:00:54 that the removal of the scale was, quote, in keeping with current fitness and social trends,
00:01:00 the movement away from focusing on body weight. Reaction of the students was interesting. Some
00:01:07 students thought it was a good idea, but some bodybuilders and athletes who need the scale
00:01:12 to monitor their weight were quite annoyed, seeing it as yet another example of politically
00:01:17 correct sensitivities run amok. A student named Aaron Benz denounced the move as, quote, the next
00:01:23 escalation of trigger culture. Hashtag bring back the scale trended on Twitter with one
00:01:31 Carleton student lamenting, next it will be the mirrors. The last I heard, Carleton had
00:01:39 weighed the pros and cons, no pun intended, and had decided to return the scale to its place in
00:01:44 the gym. But I suspect this is not the last we've heard of such matters. Because what started as a
00:01:51 fringe subject in women's studies with the publication of Susie Orbach's Fat is a Feminist
00:01:57 issue in 1978, is now a full-blown scholarly field that's increasingly at odds with reality.
00:02:07 Fat studies informs us that bias against fat people, particularly against fat women,
00:02:12 is a human rights issue of equal importance to racism, expressed in countless microaggressions
00:02:20 such as the encouragement to care about one's weight.
00:02:24 If you're interested in a lengthily sourced scholarly discussion of current thinking about
00:02:30 weight, you might want to check out a chapter entitled Scientific Weightism,
00:02:36 A View of Mainstream Weight Stigma Research Through a Feminist Lens.
00:02:41 It's co-written by Rachel Caligaro, Tracy Tilka, and Janelle Mensinger, and it's from a book
00:02:47 called Feminist Perspectives on Building a Better Psychological Science of Gender,
00:02:53 published in 2016. The chapter will give you an illuminating glimpse into new frontiers of
00:03:00 so-called feminist social science operating at the intersection of obesity research and
00:03:06 social justice ideology. The three authors of the chapter are all tenured or tenure-stream
00:03:12 professors at North American universities. Rachel Caligaro is a professor of psychology at the
00:03:18 University of Western Ontario with expertise in the social psychology of gender, class, inequality, 0.96
00:03:25 and body image. Tracy Tilka is a professor of psychology at Ohio State University with expertise
00:03:31 in body image and eating behavior. And Janelle Mansinger is a professor in the College of Nursing
00:03:37 in health professions at Drexel University in Philadelphia with expertise in weight stigma.
00:03:44 The main argument of the chapter is, not that surprisingly, a social constructionist account
00:03:50 of obesity. The authors argue that the stigma associated with obesity is entirely social.
00:03:59 In other words, there's nothing wrong with fat people. There's something wrong with people who
00:04:03 think there's something wrong with fat people. And although the authors do use the phrase fat
00:04:08 people, I suspect they prefer their phrase people at the higher end of the weight spectrum. They
00:04:14 refer frequently to, quote, thin privilege and to, quote, weightist assumptions. A weightist
00:04:22 assumption involves false and bigoted ideas about weight, including that weight has any real world
00:04:32 relationship to human health. Yes, you heard that right. The authors deny that there are any
00:04:39 negative health consequences of obesity. They insist that there are correlations between
00:04:45 obesity and disease, but that correlation isn't causation. They also deny that obesity is a
00:04:54 condition that is within an individual's power to control or modify. Therefore, they see discussing
00:05:02 obesity as a problem, as itself a problem, because it targets fat people and therefore increases
00:05:10 prejudice against them. The authors assert that what we should focus on when it comes to obesity
00:05:16 is not obese people, but what the authors call the discourse that stigmatizes obese people,
00:05:24 including health discourses that encourage weight loss. In line with their feminist perspective,
00:05:30 the authors are particularly concerned about the negative impacts of weightism on women.
00:05:37 Now, I'm not a medical doctor, so I don't pretend to be able to pronounce on the precise relationship
00:05:43 between obesity and disease, and I agree with the authors that obese people shouldn't be treated
00:05:48 unkindly. But the question is, is it kind to tell obese people that no matter how overweight they
00:05:58 become, they can still be happy and healthy? I doubt it. I suffered from atrociously bad acne
00:06:06 as a teenager and adult, and so I know what it feels like to be unattractive, to have been told
00:06:12 that my skin was really fine wouldn't have helped me at all. And if I could have cured my problem
00:06:18 with diet and exercise, I would certainly have appreciated knowing that the information would
00:06:24 not in itself have been a source of stigma. The idea in this article seems to be in line with
00:06:30 much social activism today, that if we just think the right thoughts and force everyone else to
00:06:36 think them too, we can create a social utopia in which no one is ever unhappy. More specifically,
00:06:44 there are two things going on in this article and in the scholarship around it that are, to say the
00:06:49 least, very disturbing and are representative of the direction in which feminist social science is
00:06:55 generally moving. First, there's an obvious blurring of the lines between social justice 1.00
00:07:03 activism and scientific research that doesn't bode well for the future of fact-based empirical
00:07:10 inquiry. The authors of this chapter seem to be so passionately wedded to their goal of celebrating
00:07:18 body diversity and removing the stigma of obesity that it's hard to imagine them being able to
00:07:24 support research that pursued the correlations between obesity and disease. They see such
00:07:30 research as increasing the stigma around being fat, and therefore they see it as actually
00:07:35 unethical in itself. Their stated position is that, quote, weight stigma is a social justice issue
00:07:44 because people who are fat are denied their basic civil rights in every aspect of their lives,
00:07:50 including their right to be fat and to live free of unfair treatment, end quote.
00:07:56 Well, that's quite a claim, that one has a right to live free of unfair treatment,
00:08:03 especially when the authors define unfair so incredibly broadly,
00:08:08 because for them, merely to pursue the argument that obesity is medically harmful
00:08:14 is an example of unfair treatment.
00:08:18 Although the authors claim to value empirical research,
00:08:22 it seems pretty clear that they value their ideology far more. Second, these authors are
00:08:29 social justice totalitarians because they not only want to create a cultural climate in which
00:08:36 research that contradicts their objectives would be frowned on, they actually want to make it
00:08:41 illegal to dissent from their position of fat positivity. And they say this pretty clearly,
00:08:48 Quote, it is absolutely essential that scholars campaign for formal legislation
00:08:57 to protect against weight stigma and discrimination.
00:09:02 Imagine that, formal legislation to protect against weight stigma.
00:09:08 They want to make it illegal to stigmatize someone for being fat.
00:09:14 we know where such rights legislation inevitably leads to harsh penalties for having the wrong
00:09:22 ideas these radical scholarly ideas are also expressed in much more popular forms as in a
00:09:32 recent 2016 article called why is fat a feminist issue it's found on an online blog called this
00:09:41 body is not an apology. And here the author makes the explicit argument that fat women experience
00:09:47 discrimination because of the patriarchy. We are told that, quote, fat women are an embodiment of
00:09:55 exactly what patriarchal society does not want women to be, visible, end quote. Implicit in the 0.94
00:10:04 argument is that being fat is actually a form of resistance to patriarchy. In other words,
00:10:10 that there is something heroic about making yourself fat enough to take up more space than
00:10:16 patriarchy thinks you should, and that to suggest that someone could benefit from losing weight is
00:10:22 misogynistic. Where do fat men fit into this theory? Well, the author can't summon the same
00:10:28 degree of outrage over fat men's mistreatment. She says, quote, men are not expected to look
00:10:34 aesthetically pleasing. It is more acceptable for men to be fat than it is for women, end quote.
00:10:40 So there, as the title tells us, fat is a feminist issue and it belongs to women. 0.81
00:10:46 So, the scale at the Carleton University gym, back in place now, it's definitely just the beginning. 0.99
00:10:54 I found it interesting that the Carleton University wellness director told us in the interview that even without the scale,
00:11:01 you could still assess your fitness goals, for example, through what he called girth measurements,
00:11:07 measurements of torso, hips, chest, legs, arms, and so on. But that's sizist, isn't it?
00:11:15 Won't measuring oneself be likely to trigger those with body issues just as surely as weighing
00:11:21 on a weigh scale? Isn't it all part of a stigmatizing discourse? We know it is. So look out,
00:11:30 Carlton, and every gym throughout North America. The feminists will be coming for your tape 1.00
00:11:36 measurers soon and your fat measuring calipers as well. 1.00