The Fiamengo File - April 20, 2017


Instructors Getting Dumber By the Day - TFF Episode 60

The Unisex University - TFF Episode 46 Philistia, aka McMaster University, vs. Jordan Peterson - TFF Episode 61

Episode Stats


Length

12 minutes

Words per minute

142.6

Word count

1,731

Sentence count

59

Harmful content

Misogyny

17

sentences flagged

Toxicity

4

sentences flagged

Hate speech

2

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 What's been happening at universities lately? I mean, aside from the bloody riots, the physical
00:00:06 attacks on visiting speakers, the expulsion of male students on nonsensical charges, the anti-Trump
00:00:11 hysteria, and the safe space infantilism. What's been happening is the steady dumbing down of the
00:00:18 entire institution to the point at which one has to ask, are academics smart? That's my subject
00:00:25 on today's Fiamengo file.
00:00:34 I'm Janice Fiamengo of the University of Ottawa.
00:00:38 Universities have become quasi-religious institutions
00:00:41 in which faith in doctrines like rape culture and male privilege
00:00:45 has become more important than intellectual integrity.
00:00:48 This has been going on for years, and it's going to keep getting worse.
00:00:52 A few weeks ago, a story out of Ryerson University in Toronto, Canada, revealed that a sociology
00:00:59 instructor explicitly directed a student in an email that the student was wrong to want to write
00:01:05 a paper on the pay gap myth, and that instead the student should write a paper on the feminist 1.00
00:01:10 doctrine of the glass ceiling, relying exclusively on feminist sources. Quote, do not use business
00:01:18 sources the screenshot shows the instructor telling the student why not quote they blame women
00:01:25 the reality is patriarchy the instructor went on to say you need to do a lot of research 1.00
00:01:31 feminists have been writing about the gender division of labor the feminization of work and 1.00
00:01:36 the glass ceiling since the 1970s there is a ton of feminist research on this topic 0.96
00:01:43 When the student's sister posted the email on Facebook, it went viral and became a news story.
00:01:50 For those of you who don't operate in the corridors of moral rectitude and pious thought
00:01:55 that is academia today, that seemed a shocking revelation of instructor bias.
00:02:01 What happened to teaching students? How to research rather than telling them
00:02:05 what position to take and what ideologically pure sources to use.
00:02:09 but for those of us who do reside in academia's hallowed halls the email wasn't a shock the only
00:02:16 thing at all remarkable about it was the ungrammaticality of the instructor's prose now
00:02:23 i know email encourages an abbreviated mode of writing but this was outright incompetent and i
00:02:31 think that incompetence is at least as shocking as the blatant ideological bias let's look at the
00:02:38 the email for a minute. Note that it was written almost entirely in simplistic five to six word
00:02:45 sentences. Some of them, like the reality is patriarchy, pretty much indistinguishable from
00:02:51 the feminist slogans we've all seen recently on women's march banners often adorned with 0.95
00:02:56 large pink female sexual organs. Now perhaps it's acceptable now to write like a student, 0.95
00:03:04 advocating, quote, a ton of research, but one would expect basic precision of word use and
00:03:12 coherent phrasing, at least when it comes to the actual subject matter. Not so here. The student
00:03:19 is told that there is a, quote, gender division of labor. That's wrong. It should be the past 0.93
00:03:26 participial adjective gendered ed at the end i mean gender division sounds like a squad of
00:03:34 feminist zealots telling us which pronouns we're allowed to use the student is also told that
00:03:41 feminists research something called the feminization of work now if there's anyone
00:03:47 in sociology out there correct me if i'm wrong but i'm pretty confident this is not the correct 1.00
00:03:52 phrase. If high-level work were being feminized,
00:03:57 presumably that would be a good thing from the feminist point of view and would 1.00
00:04:00 be the solution to the glass ceiling, but 1.00
00:04:02 clearly that's not what's being referred to here.
00:04:05 Now imagine this instructor who can't write
00:04:08 an intelligible email evaluating student work.
00:04:12 How would the instructor explain in writing how a student had gone wrong in
00:04:16 a paper? Would papers be evaluated for cogency of
00:04:19 argument and depth of analysis, or mainly for ideological correctness? Would this instructor
00:04:25 be capable of fairly evaluating a paper that took a position with which she or he was not
00:04:29 in agreement? It's hard to say for sure on the basis of one email, but the signs aren't
00:04:34 encouraging. Of just a few days after this, we saw a different example, but a related
00:04:40 incident regarding outrageous bias and intellectual mediocrity. The Canadian Broadcasting Corporation,
00:04:48 Canada's taxpayer-funded television news and culture station aired a segment about the
00:04:55 cancellation of a screening of The Red Pill. That's Cassie J's sympathetic documentary about
00:05:01 the men's movement. As some of you know the film has been heavily protested all across the world
00:05:07 and in this case the film was cancelled at the University of Calgary in Alberta
00:05:12 after a student with a conservative political group on campus promoted the film using the
00:05:18 phrase feminism is cancer in an email if the student had said mohammed farts he couldn't have
00:05:27 caused more consternation amongst the community of the righteous at the u of calgary in fact probably
00:05:32 that's the only other thing he might have said that would have caused equal upset the promotion 0.69
00:05:38 of a men's rights movie set a lot of feminists running for their smelling salts and gasping in 1.00
00:05:45 their corsets on campus. The CBC brought in a feminist professor, Dr. Rebecca Sullivan. 1.00
00:05:53 Professor Sullivan told us all how, quote, scary it was for her to wake up in the morning and hear 0.96
00:06:00 about this incident, even though, as Karen Stranas pointed out, what she was hearing about was how
00:06:04 the communications director had to resign and everybody apologized profusely for daring to say
00:06:12 something rude about feminism. I wish I had that kind of scary to deal with. Now, I was under the 0.99
00:06:20 impression that Dr. Sullivan, the middle-aged academic who perjured herself on our state-funded
00:06:25 broadcaster, was a women's studies professor, but as far as I can tell, she's technically part of
00:06:31 the English department at the University of Calgary. She's a specialist in feminist theory 0.86
00:06:36 and media studies and she has published one book and a number of co-authored books mainly on
00:06:42 Canadian television. Now I just said that Professor Sullivan perjured herself which of course isn't
00:06:49 true as she wasn't testifying in a court of law but symbolically she did. She came on to the show
00:06:56 as an expert in the representation of gender. She came on to discuss one thing the cancellation of
00:07:02 screening of the film the red pill and she did so without even having seen the film no one watching
00:07:11 this interview who has seen the red pill could legitimately link professor sullivan's bizarre
00:07:18 and fantastical statements with anything that's actually in the film which is about issues such
00:07:24 as discrimination against men in divorce the differential treatment of men under the criminal
00:07:29 code, man's much higher suicide rate, and so on. What did Professor Sullivan think she was doing
00:07:36 discussing the film as if she had seen it and making statements about it that had nothing to
00:07:42 do with the film? According to the learned professor, the men's rights message as portrayed
00:07:49 in the red pill is, and it's this incredible, quote, if only we could have sex with whoever and 0.99
00:07:57 whatever we want, whenever we want, then maybe we wouldn't have to rape you, end quote. After which 0.99
00:08:06 she and the interviewer sniggered companionably. Now there are already a number of response videos
00:08:14 by Karen Strawn and Paul Elam and a wonderful Australian with a skull avatar, for example,
00:08:20 but take apart Professor Sullivan's comments to show how farcical they were. So I will say only
00:08:25 that if you had tried to present a caricature of academic feminist misrepresentation of the
00:08:33 men's rights movement, you couldn't have done a better job than what Professor Sullivan came up
00:08:39 with, which she didn't even attempt to anchor in any single utterance by any self-identified men's
00:08:46 rights activist. In fact, if you were trying to write a caricature and had produced what Professor
00:08:51 Sullivan did, you might have thought it went too far that it sounded too much like Andrea Dworkin
00:08:56 at her most unhinged. Except that Andrea Dworkin, who was genuinely very smart if deranged,
00:09:03 would never have been so much at a loss for words, so quick to retreat into nonsensical
00:09:10 chuckles, raised eyebrows, coy facial expressions, exaggerated winks, grins, snide giggles,
00:09:16 head bobbing and grimaces just as in the ryerson university case there isn't anything surprising
00:09:24 in a feminist professor saying demonstrably untrue things about the men's rights movement 0.98
00:09:31 but it was noteworthy how very badly she said those untrue things this is a phd in communications
00:09:40 yet her language was so simplistic so vacuous so juvenile quote it was scary and I think we need 0.88
00:09:51 to name it as scary she said about the phrase feminism is cancer perhaps she was simply having
00:10:00 a bad day I can sympathize with that anyone who's watched me in a Q&A know that I can be slow and
00:10:06 tongue-tied, but Professor Sullivan's level of crude obtuseness of the first-year art student
00:10:13 mouth breather variety was really remarkable. And this is my point. Try to conceive of turning
00:10:21 on the television 50 years ago for an interview with a university professor and finding such a
00:10:28 low level of discussion with such little regard for accuracy or fairness or even basic verbal
00:10:34 competency. The advent of feminism and other social justice ideologies has profoundly corroded
00:10:42 the intellectual legitimacy of much of academia for two reasons. First, academic work is now
00:10:50 overwhelmingly about conformity of thought rather than intellectual inquiry. Real scholarly inquiry
00:10:58 is curiosity-driven, not agenda-driven. But sadly, academia is not any longer an institution in which
00:11:05 high intelligence is the primary qualification. Second, to make matters worse, the drive over the
00:11:14 past 30 years to hire women and other designated groups into positions in which their primary
00:11:20 mandate is to talk about the difficulties of being who they are, how scary it is, that has
00:11:26 inevitably attracted women such as Rebecca Sullivan and many others who have very little
00:11:31 of substance to offer. The result is an appalling corruption of research, evisceration of content,
00:11:38 gutting of standards, and overt politicization of academic subjects. Rebecca Sullivan and her
00:11:46 many colleagues are scary, and I think we have to name them as such.
00:11:56 support us on Patreon. If even half of our subscribers gave us one dollar per month,
00:12:01 we'd be well on our way to creating more and better content.
00:12:04 And don't forget to subscribe to us on Studio Brulee.