00:00:00Why do university students think they have the right to shout down speakers they don't like?
00:00:06Well, because their university professors tell them so.
00:00:10That's my subject on today's Fiamengo File.
00:00:21I'm Janice Fiamengo of the University of Ottawa.
00:00:24Most of us know what to expect when it comes to the guardians of political correctness
00:00:28on university campuses whether it's sandra corn in the harvard crimson newspaper a couple of years1.00
00:00:35ago who argued that academic freedom should be replaced by what she called academic justice
00:00:41or more recently the students of wellesley college who allege that quote shutting down rhetoric that
00:00:48undermines the existence and rights of others is not a violation of free speech end quote
00:00:54these students are enthusiastic about the suppression of so-called hate speech.
00:00:59Most of them can't provide a definition of what that is, but given that even the Supreme Court of
00:01:04Canada has had trouble doing so, it's not that surprising that undergraduate students struggle
00:01:09to explain coherently what they're so keen to outlaw. But when the same type of anti-free speech
00:01:17drivel comes from university professors then the illogicality incoherence and lack of historical
00:01:25accuracy are shameful today i want to take a look at an anti-free speech open statement issued by
00:01:33something called the president's advisory committee on building an inclusive community
00:01:39at mcmaster university this is a large group of faculty students and staff at mcmaster which is
00:01:45in Hamilton, Ontario, who decided to issue a statement opposing Professor Jordan Peterson's
00:01:52scheduled talk at McMaster in March of 2017. In their public statement, the advisory committee
00:01:59said it looked forward to, quote, public critical opposition to Peterson's ideas, end quote,
00:02:06and declared in their final sentence that Peterson's talk was, quote,
00:02:10not an exercise of freedom, but instead poses a threat to us all, end quote.
00:02:19That statement explicitly encourages students and others that in shouting down Professor Peterson,
00:02:26they are defending against a serious threat to society.
00:02:31So how do we get to this point that university professors believe they have a moral duty to encourage disruptive protest?
00:02:39I would invite you all to take a look at the website of McMaster University's President's Advisory Committee on Building an Inclusive Community, or PAC-BIC for short.
00:02:51Their mandate, as they explain it, is to, quote, identify and anticipate issues affecting, quote, equity-seeking communities, and to advise the president on these issues and on inclusive policies.
00:03:06The committee writes annual reports that are posted on its site, and if you're interested in a kind of one-stop shopping hub that aggregates all the social justice projects of the modern university, you will find much of interest on the PACBIC site.
00:03:21This group issued its open statement on March 16, 2017, just a day prior to the scheduled St. Patrick's Day talk by Professor Jordan Peterson on the subject of freedom of speech and political correctness.
00:03:35And as many of you know, the event was planned as a panel discussion, but all the invited speakers except Peterson backed out as a result of the controversy that it generated.0.99
00:03:45And the talk was ultimately shut down by social justice coons who engaged in their usual thuggish tactics of loud chanting, noise making and physical intimidation, all in a good cause, of course.0.99
00:03:58The President's Advisory Committee began their statement by saying how, quote,1.00
00:04:02deeply troubled the group is that a man of Professor Peterson's, quote,
00:04:07notoriety, as they call it, was invited to McMaster University in the first place.
00:04:13They characterize his invitation as an opportunity for him to once again articulate his, quote,
00:04:18callous disregard, end quote, for the, quote, personhood of trans and gender non-conforming
00:04:25people, and this is the first of many misrepresentations of Professor Peterson's
00:04:30carefully articulated platform, which anyone who has listened knows has nothing whatsoever to do
00:04:37with disregarding anybody's personhood. There are many outrageous statements made by this group,
00:04:45including the boast that the advisory committee members understand the science of gender better
00:04:52than Professor Peterson. That's right. They have the chutzpah to accuse him of having
00:04:58quote, limited knowledge and being quote, entirely unaware of new developments in various disciplines
00:05:05related to sex difference, where supposedly the male-female binary has been quote, long
00:05:11debunked. That's pretty rich, coming from a group of activists amongst whom I could find
00:05:17precious few, if any, actual scientists. The past chair of the committee, Dr. Jane Aronson,
00:05:25was a professor of social work, not exactly a hard science or even a particularly intellectual
00:05:32discipline, and the current chair, Emil Joseph, is also a professor of social work. But their
00:05:40assertions on this point, ludicrous as they are in my opinion, are not my main focus. What most
00:05:47intrigues me about the advisory committee's statement is the section in which they argue
00:05:52that Jordan Peterson's public speech shouldn't fall under the category of protected speech.
00:05:59This is what they say. But freedom of speech doesn't now and hasn't ever meant that we can
00:06:06or should be able to say whatever we like in public spaces regardless of the impact of our
00:06:11speech on others that's okay they go on instead the concept of freedom of speech has most often
00:06:18been mobilized to protect specifically counter hegemonic ideas ideas that actually challenge
00:06:25rather than reiterate the status quo end quote so this is now a fairly standard position taken
00:06:34by those who believe that only their words deserve protection from being shouted down by goons and
00:06:39hooligans pacbic essentially claims that free speech does not and was never meant to include
00:06:47hate or even non-hateful speech that happens to support injustice in some way this is an incredibly
00:06:55broad net that they're spreading and this line of argument culminates in their claim that quote
00:07:02freedom of speech was not conceived as a means to protect normative ideas from contestation
00:07:09by marginalized communities but to protect those whose speech might actually contest
00:07:15normative or nationalist ideals from censure, punishment, and retaliation by state forces."0.86
00:07:21First of all, it's worth saying that this is ridiculous. Nobody is protecting
00:07:27normative ideas from contestation by marginalized communities. The so-called marginalized are0.98
00:07:34perfectly free to contest Professor Peterson's views all they want and to hold their own talks
00:07:40and forums, and presumably that's what PACBIC does every time it meets to discuss
00:07:45LGBTQ issues. But never mind that. I want to pause over what they say about free speech,
00:07:52because it is actually extraordinary, and because I've heard versions of this fairly frequently
00:07:59lately though never so far with a citation to tell me exactly who didn't conceive of free
00:08:08speech protections extending to normative ideas who is this authority that they're referring to
00:08:14yes herbert marcusa the frankfurt school cultural marxist said something along these lines in his
00:08:211965 essay repressive tolerance a must read by the way for anyone who wants to understand
00:08:28the SJW particular tone deafness on free speech. It's a short essay, an easy read, and one that's
00:08:36breathtaking in its assumption that only righteous revolutionaries get to decide what kind of speech
00:08:42can be heard. For Marcuse, tolerance was not a virtue if it meant tolerating injustice, and
00:08:49therefore tolerance shouldn't be extended towards any public words that uphold a repressive status
00:08:56quo. Marcuse was also a man who stated quite openly in the same essay that violence on the
00:09:02part of the have-nots, as he called them, against the haves, wasn't really violence, or at least
00:09:08not the sort one need worry about too much. He's hardly a proponent of what any reasonable person
00:09:14could call a free and democratic society. So where does the idea come from that in Western democracies
00:09:22we have any sort of tradition of protecting only so-called counter-hegemonic ideas.
00:09:30I challenge the President's Advisory Committee to name its source because this is a profoundly
00:09:37anti-democratic statement, and it's one that leads without much of a stretch to exactly
00:09:43what we saw at McMaster University when Professor Peterson spoke there.
00:09:49Certainly, their idea is not found in the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, in which
00:09:54all Canadians, not just those with non-normative ideas, are guaranteed freedom of thought, belief,
00:10:01opinion, and expression, and freedom of peaceful assembly. Yes, Canada has very problematic hate
00:10:07speech laws, in my opinion, but these are to be applied after the fact, not before someone has
00:10:14even had a chance to speak. And what about the great architects of British liberty who created
00:10:20the intellectual climate that made our charter possible? They certainly didn't define free
00:10:27speech in anything like the terms of the advisory committee's McThinkers. John Stuart Mill in On
00:10:34Liberty in 1869 spoke of the fundamental necessity of being able to defend an idea from objections to
00:10:41it. Obviously impossible if one can't even express the idea in a public forum without being shouted
00:10:48down. We could go even further back historically to John Milton and his Areopagitica of 1644,
00:10:55in which the search for truth is paramount and in which wrong ideas cannot defile the righteous
00:11:02mind. In fact, they're even necessary to the strengthening of that mind. Milton would have
00:11:07found the advisory committee's formulation very strange indeed.
00:11:12The fact is that no thinking person can seriously claim that the worth of an idea is dependent
00:11:20on whether it is, quote, normative or not.0.83
00:11:24This is a ridiculous, vacuous, and smug formulation by a group of people falsely claiming to be0.94