00:00:00When radical students on university campuses say they feel threatened, do they really?
00:00:07That's my subject on today's Fiomengo File.
00:00:19I'm Janice Fiomengo of the University of Ottawa. In a recent article for the Wall Street Journal,
00:00:25American author and journalist Heather McDonald discussed the appalling student thuggery we've
00:00:30seen recently on college campuses. McDonald is, amongst other things, a critic of the Black Lives
00:00:36Matter movement and therefore not very popular on university campuses in the United States. And
00:00:42when she tried to speak at Claremont McKenna College in Claremont, California in early April
00:00:472017 a group of black lives matter supporters attended her talk and surprised the assembled0.96
00:00:54audience with their civility articulateness and cogency of argument no of course not
00:01:02the usual thing happened an uncivil protest shut down the talk and campus security essentially
00:01:08did nothing about it mcdonald ended up giving a live stream version of the talk to an empty room
00:01:15but even then BLM activists disrupted it with shouts and curses. The details of this kind of
00:01:21thing have become so common as to prompt little public interest. Hundreds of protesters assembled
00:01:28at the entranceways to the building stopping attendees from getting inside. Anyone who tried
00:01:33to push past them was repelled and according to the campus newspaper at one point quote a1.00
00:01:38crowd of white students screaming fuck white supremacy, fuck white supremacy, pushed an1.00
00:01:44elderly white professor away from the building entrance, end quote. Well, isn't it lovely to1.00
00:01:50think of rich white kids so fired up by the idea of racial equality. So what makes such bigotry and
00:02:00incivility so popular amongst students? The students, at least the black students, claim that
00:02:07they are, quote, under threat, that their actions are not violent intimidation, but necessary
00:02:13self-defense in an urgent fight for their very right to exist. Do they believe their own rhetoric?
00:02:21In the Wall Street Journal article, Heather MacDonald disagreed with the idea popularized
00:02:25by Jonathan Haidt and Greg Lukianoff in their article, The Coddling of the American Mind,
00:02:30an interesting article, by the way, where they explain the attempt to silence offensive or
00:02:36hurtful speech as stemming from an emotional or psychological weakness caused by students being
00:02:42infantilized by overprotective parents and therefore incapable of dealing with conflict
00:02:47in an adult manner. McDonald doesn't really buy that explanation. She asks if risk-averse
00:02:54child-rearing is the source of the problem, why aren't heterosexual white male students demanding
00:03:00safe spaces. She alleges instead that, quote, campus intolerance is at root not a psychological
00:03:07phenomenon, but an ideological one based on, quote, a worldview that sees Western culture as
00:03:13endemically racist and sexist. So to extrapolate from McDonald's argument, when students claim
00:03:20that their existence is threatened by a dissenting opinion, that's an act of clever ideological
00:03:25manipulation, not a genuine expression of fear. But it seems that Macdonald and Haidt and Lukianoff
00:03:32are both correct. There is a psychological as well as an ideological component to our present crisis.
00:03:39Yes, we have a cultural Marxist ideology that sees Western culture as thoroughly corrupt and0.96
00:03:44hates heterosexual white men above all because they have traditionally been its standard bearers.0.92
00:03:50And the rejection of all that the West has created is both an expression of and a contributing cause of psychological pathology.0.78
00:04:00So ideology and psychological abnormality become inextricable, creating cases in which radical activists are both deadly earnest and in a sense manifestly fake.
00:04:13Let's look at one example of a claim of existential threat, which from a common sense
00:04:18standpoint is thoroughly irrational, yet is a passionately held belief of many radical students
00:04:24today. Following Heather MacDonald's visit to Claremont McKenna, three black students and a
00:04:31couple dozen co-signatories wrote an angry letter to the outgoing president of Pomona College, one
00:04:37of the Claremont Colleges, protesting his defense of free speech and claiming that people like
00:04:42Heather MacDonald should never be allowed on the Claremont campuses again because their words,
00:04:48quote, condone violence against black people, end quote. Now we've heard this line of argument
00:04:54before, of course, but this letter is truly remarkable in the degree of its frenzied
00:05:02expostulation and I encourage everyone to read it. In a long rant the students make no attempt
00:05:09to defend their contention that engaging with McDonald is quote a form of violence against
00:05:15black students and indeed they make no attempt to defend their libelous contention that McDonald
00:05:21is not only a racist but actually a racial exterminationist which they repeat multiple0.93
00:05:26times, alleging that she denies, quote, the right of black people to exist, end quote. More than0.97
00:05:34that, she is, according to the letter writers, in an almost laughably comprehensive list, wait for1.00
00:05:39it, a fascist, a white supremacist, a war hawk, a transphobe, a queerphobe, a classist, and ignorant0.99
00:05:47of interlocking systems of domination that produce the lethal conditions under which oppressed0.99
00:05:53peoples are forced to live end quote one has to wonder whether the letter writers have read
00:05:59anything heather mcdonald has actually written they certainly don't refer to even a single
00:06:04utterance of hers to anchor their exponentially proliferating list of her sins of thought0.70
00:06:10the letter is a melodramatic tirade against all things white supremacists which include apparently
00:06:16and this is what is most stunning and bizarre about the letter, include the ideal of objectivity
00:06:24and the search for truth. That's right, the search for truth is an aspect of white supremacism.
00:06:31Here's part of what the students say as preamble to their demand that speakers who disagree with
00:06:36their fanatical views be barred from their college and that everyone in the university
00:06:41administration and on the college newspaper has to offer them an abject apology here it is
00:06:49historically white supremacy has venerated the idea of objectivity and wielded a dichotomy of
00:06:57subjectivity versus objectivity as a means of silencing oppressed peoples the idea that there
00:07:02is a single truth the truth is a construct of the euro west that is deeply rooted in the
00:07:08Enlightenment, which is a movement that also described black and brown people as both subhuman
00:07:12and impervious to pain. This construction, the construction, I guess, of the search for truth,
00:07:18I'm not sure, is a myth and white supremacy, imperialism, colonization, capitalism, and the0.53
00:07:24United States of America are all of its progeny. The idea that the truth is an entity for which
00:07:30we must search in matters that endanger our abilities to exist in open spaces is an attempt0.55
00:07:36to silence oppressed peoples." Well, it's hard to know how to respond to a statement defining
00:07:42the search for truth as a white supremacist, colonialist, and imperialist plot, and equally
00:07:47hard to calculate the level of intentional rhetorical exaggeration or sincere delusion
00:07:54that the letter might manifest. Do the students really believe that the primary products of the
00:08:00Enlightenment have been dehumanization, silencing, and the subjugation of brown and black peoples?
00:08:05which non-enlightenment societies throughout history have done better at reforming their own
00:08:12errors and extending freedom and prosperity to a majority of their members i'm not sure what the
00:08:18students preferred society would be north korea perhaps or iran's saudi arabia china south africa
00:08:26venezuela well all that is clear is that these students who are privileged members of their
00:08:32society, attending a prestigious post-secondary institution, an opportunity many poor whites in
00:08:38the U.S. are denied, seem excessively pleased with themselves for rejecting the core principles of0.71
00:08:45their culture, principles historically responsible for creating individual opportunity, security, and
00:08:50material abundance like no other culture on earth ever provided for its citizens, and for which they
00:08:56obviously feel not one bit of respect or even awareness, it seems, only contempt. One might
00:09:04point out to the letter writers that rejecting truth is a bizarre tactical move, making it
00:09:10impossible for them to claim that their contentions about history and oppression have any greater truth
00:09:15value than the contentions of the people they wish to borrow from campus. Or one might note that
00:09:20people oppressed by white supremacy don't tend to behave as these students do, inviting confrontation
00:09:26with administrators and security personnel and making reckless defamatory accusations against
00:09:32intellectual leaders in their society. At some level they must know that far from being imperiled
00:09:39they themselves are protected and catered to as few other social groups have ever been in recorded
00:09:45history their aggressive intolerance and preposterous immaturity and ignorance are
00:09:51placated forgiven and even encouraged but on another level they do believe their own hype
00:09:58and their self-pitying rage has real effects most obviously in their willingness to break the law
00:10:05and even to use violence in the name of what they say is resistance as we've seen on so many campuses
00:10:11lately, and more generally in their demand that innumerable special concessions and privileges
00:10:17be given to them to accommodate the chains and shackles they claim that their society has forced
00:10:23them to wear. This letter testifies to how easy it is to destroy a culture. You do it by teaching
00:10:32a significant minority of its members, especially those who will take positions of influence in
00:10:38journalism, education, social policy, government, and the law, you teach them that they live in one
00:10:45of the worst countries in the world. You teach them there isn't anything in their culture's1.00
00:10:51traditions or historical record worth cherishing, and that anyone who loves that culture is an
00:10:58oppressor who must be silenced and effectually destroyed. And universities have been teaching
00:11:06this for decades in our humanities and social sciences programs and we shouldn't be surprised
00:11:13when students act on what they've been taught.