The Fiamengo File - June 29, 2017


Toxic Masculinity and Suicide - TFF Episode 69

You Deny My Right To Exist - TFF Episode 63 Are Universities About Truth Or The Protection of Approved Ideas? TFF-75

Episode Stats


Length

11 minutes

Words per minute

125.42

Word count

1,481

Sentence count

54

Harmful content

Misogyny

4

sentences flagged

Hate speech

1

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 Does toxic masculinity lead to suicide? That's my subject on today's Fiumengo File.
00:00:19 I'm Janice Fiumengo of the University of Ottawa. On June 13th of 2017, the Canadian
00:00:26 state broadcaster the cbc published an article called toxic masculinity may be quadrupling the
00:00:33 suicide rate for canadian men written by mark beaulieu i can't say i was surprised that once
00:00:42 again under the guise of caring for men the cbc blamed masculinity for male suicide and this on
00:00:50 the day set aside for men's mental health awareness no less the subheading of the article is a choker
00:00:57 we're advised to quote have the conversation no one else is having well given that the cbc is
00:01:04 funded by taxpayers to the tune of well over 1 billion dollars a year the vast majority of that
00:01:10 money coming from men you'd think the first place the cbc should be looking to assign blame for the
00:01:16 the lack of discussion of men's mental health issues would be itself. But actually, I would
00:01:23 prefer the CBC remain totally silent on the issue rather than repeat the feminist mantra about how 1.00
00:01:30 everything associated with masculinity is bad. In case we're under any doubt about the anti-male 0.69
00:01:38 perspective of the writer, Marc Beaulieu uses terms throughout, such as toxic, poisonous,
00:01:46 destructive, unmanageable, noxious, and wince-inducing, to characterize masculinity.
00:01:54 He cites a number of studies, the most definitive being a comprehensive meta-analysis by Joel
00:02:00 Wong of Indiana University that supposedly demonstrate, in Beaulieu's words, a, quote,
00:02:07 definitive link between cliched machismo and poor mental health in men, end quote.
00:02:15 Reading this, I thought, okay, here we go, yet another study confirming what we already think
00:02:20 we know about masculinity as a disease. Beaulieu claims that the study, quote, supports and confirms
00:02:28 research done in the last 60 years that people who conform to masculinity have poor mental health,
00:02:35 end quote. And not content with that, he gives his own gloss of pop culture triumphalism,
00:02:41 telling us, quote, the hard truth is that manning up is tearing people down, and we've had a sense
00:02:48 of it for decades, end quote. His message, we should have got rid of masculinity a long time ago.
00:02:56 The one small problem with Beaulieu's article, though, is that Beaulieu didn't actually read
00:03:02 the study he refers to, or if he did, he failed to report on it accurately. Even that sentence
00:03:11 about, quote, people who conform to masculinity and, quote, having poor mental health isn't
00:03:18 accurate in isolation as a summation of the study. Yes, the study does say explicitly that, quote,
00:03:25 overall, conformity to masculine norms was significantly and unfavorably associated,
00:03:32 end quote, with negative mental health outcomes, though only, quote, modestly so.
00:03:38 But that's not all the study found. In fact, it went on to say that, quote,
00:03:44 the substantial degree of heterogeneity in the ESs, effect sizes, for these relationships
00:03:51 highlights the need to disaggregate the generic construct of masculine norms and their
00:03:57 differential associations with other outcomes, end quote. Sort of baffle gap, but in other words,
00:04:04 it is wrong to say that masculine norms overall are the problem. Only certain very specific
00:04:12 dimensions of masculinity show a clear negative correlation with health outcomes, and some show
00:04:19 a positive correlation, according to the study. So, even in a study that seems to accept a lot
00:04:26 of feminist assumptions about male power and sexism, far more than I would prefer to see,
00:04:34 even in that kind of a study, the study author doesn't believe in toxic masculinity in general,
00:04:41 and in fact never uses that term or any of the other negative terms that Beaulieu was so enthusiastic
00:04:47 about. Let's look just briefly at what the study actually says. And I freely admit I have zero
00:04:54 training in psychology, so I would encourage anyone interested and with the expertise to
00:04:59 look at the study and tell me what I've missed, as I'm sure I've missed a great deal.
00:05:03 But here's a brief overview to show just how poorly the CBC author summarizes it.
00:05:11 The study, and it is remarkable, the lack of honesty and accuracy in this article.
00:05:19 It's mind-blowing.
00:05:21 The study, published in the Journal of Counseling Psychology in 2017, entitled
00:05:27 Meta-Analyses of the Relationship Between Conformity to Masculine Norms and Mental Health-Related Outcomes,
00:05:34 is, as it states, a meta-analysis, meaning it's a study of studies.
00:05:40 It looks at the results of 74 individual studies analyzing the relationships between mental health outcomes
00:05:47 and something called the Conformity to Masculine Norms Inventory, which lists 11 typically masculine traits.
00:05:56 The traits are winning, emotional control, risk-taking, violence, dominance, playboy, self-reliance, primacy of work,
00:06:10 Power Over Women, Disdain for Homosexuality, and Pursuit of Status.
00:06:19 What's important is that the study concludes that the relationships between various masculine traits and health outcomes is far more complex than is claimed in the CBC article.
00:06:33 Only three of the masculine traits, self-reliance, power over women, and playboy,
00:06:39 were, according to the study's words,
00:06:41 quote, consistently and, quote, robustly linked with negative outcomes.
00:06:46 Other of the traits, such as winning, the pursuit of status, and dominance,
00:06:51 had no clear correlation with negative health outcomes at all.
00:06:54 And two of the traits, risk-taking and primacy of work,
00:06:58 had both positive and negative outcomes. So as the study author notes, quote, although an excessive
00:07:06 focus on work can be problematic for one's health and interpersonal relationships, work and career
00:07:12 can also be an important source of meaning in life, end quote. And as a result, according to
00:07:17 the study author, clinicians should guard against pathologizing individuals who adhere strongly to 0.83
00:07:23 the masculine norm of primacy of work, e.g. by labeling them workaholics. In relation to risk
00:07:31 taking, the study author states, quote, on the one hand, individuals who conform strongly to the
00:07:37 masculine norms of risk taking might engage in risky health behavior that might predispose them
00:07:42 to psychological problems. On the other hand, risk takers might also be more willing to seek 0.86
00:07:48 out opportunities to stretch themselves beyond their comfort zone, e.g. by trying out new hobbies
00:07:53 that provide opportunities for self-actualization, end quote. So, in sum, the complexity of the data
00:08:02 leads the study author to an entirely different conclusion from what the CBC author presented.
00:08:10 Joel Wong, the study author, stresses that, quote, it is not particularly meaningful to discuss
00:08:18 individual's conformity to masculine norms in a generic sense, in other words, overall.
00:08:26 So just being masculine isn't correlated with anything toxic at all, and Marc Beaulieu almost
00:08:35 entirely misrepresented the study's import.
00:08:40 Actually, I have a lot of trouble with studies like this, regardless of their conclusions.
00:08:48 Correct me if I'm wrong, but it seems that a study of this sort begins with an assumption
00:08:53 – in this case, that there's a direct correlation between certain masculine traits
00:08:57 and certain negative health outcomes – and then looks to confirm them.
00:09:02 And not that surprisingly, it does confirm at least some of them.
00:09:07 study author admits that these are correlations only, not causation. And the fact that we are
00:09:14 dealing with correlation raises a number of serious questions about the meaning of the data
00:09:19 and what conclusions can legitimately be drawn from it. How can researchers know whether a
00:09:26 playboy trait, to choose one of the examples, is a cause of negative mental health outcomes,
00:09:33 or whether the playboy trait is itself an effect of other issues, such as perhaps childhood sexual
00:09:41 abuse. Cause and effect are difficult to untangle when it comes to personality and behavior.
00:09:48 Furthermore, how do researchers know that other significant contextual factors, not even considered
00:09:55 by the studies, don't play a much larger role than the specific male traits? For example,
00:10:00 The study acknowledges racism as a potential cause of poor mental health outcomes in racial
00:10:05 minority men, something it says needs to be studied further, but it doesn't acknowledge
00:10:10 cultural man-blaming, misandry, as a potential factor in poor mental health outcomes for
00:10:16 all men. It doesn't consider whether unequal divorce outcomes, denial of child custody,
00:10:24 unfair legal treatment in cases of claimed sexual assault,
00:10:28 or just the general sense of being disliked by one's society,
00:10:33 whether any or all of these might play a major role in men's mental health issues.
00:10:40 A study that can't even consider such causes is, in my opinion, a fatally flawed study.
00:10:48 Well, I don't know enough about this field to be able to say more, 1.00
00:10:51 but it seems pretty clear that there is a desperate need for more male-positive researchers
00:10:58 in clinical psychology to pursue the causes of men's mental health issues. And there is also
00:11:06 a desperate need for journalists free of anti-male biases to give us a fair perspective on the
00:11:13 research that does exist. As for the CBC, Canada's own fake news site, I'd say
00:11:21 there's a direct correlation between its toxic political correctness and its
00:11:27 long decline into noxious irrelevancy.