The Fiamengo File - March 31, 2018


Are Universities About Truth Or The Protection of Approved Ideas? TFF-75

Toxic Masculinity and Suicide - TFF Episode 69 #MeToo Comes For Doctors - TFF episode 76

Episode Stats


Length

21 minutes

Words per minute

149.09

Word count

3,133

Sentence count

94

Harmful content

Misogyny

4

sentences flagged

Toxicity

3

sentences flagged

Hate speech

10

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 Canada's built on the genocide of indigenous people, it's built on the exploitation of like Chinese immigrants who came and built our own roads, it's built on the exploitation of black immigrants, it's built on exploitation and capitalism, and capitalism is inherently exploiting, it inherently exploits those who are like marginalized, like women and gay people and like people of color, and like I come from a very poor family and like I'm half white and half black. 0.91
00:00:30 Like, I get it. I come from a very poor family, and, like, my, like, six children, poor family, like, I went without dinner, I, like, was very poor growing up, and it was because of the disenfranchisement of, like, black women, single black women, and, like, the fact that, like, capitalism doesn't provide, like, platforms for these people, and that I very much struggle to pull myself out of that position, and I haven't even really gotten there. I'm still poor, I'm still, like, a worker. 0.65
00:00:58 Have you traveled the world? This is honestly the best place in the world to live.
00:01:02 These people are all very, very capitalist.
00:01:05 They're very much people who believe in the free market.
00:01:08 They're very much people who believe in free speech, free market. 1.00
00:01:11 They're all people who believe in exploiting third world countries because they... 1.00
00:01:16 I think that this state is built on genocide and built on exploitation
00:01:19 and that it needs to be dismantled and rebuilt.
00:01:22 I'm Elijah Badassi. I'm the founder and president of U Ottawa Students for Free Speech.
00:01:26 My major is, I'm first here, joint honors, philosophy and political science.
00:01:31 What they're accusing us online of being disgruntled right-wing Christian conservatives,
00:01:36 which I found very interesting.
00:01:37 They also accused me of being a white supremacist, which I found very interesting.
00:01:41 Obviously, I'm not a white supremacist.
00:01:43 Our group is actually, it shouldn't matter, but our group is pretty diverse, you know,
00:01:46 ethnically, ideologically, gender.
00:01:49 Well, the objective of the group is to keep opening the debate for people to speak,
00:01:53 so long as there's people calling people groups like us who just want to open the dialogue
00:01:57 these right-wing fascist nazi groups and our existence is justified our mandate is justified
00:02:02 we're still going to have to provide a platform for people to speak and debate and you know if
00:02:07 you want people to come together and understand each other you have to give them a chance to talk
00:02:10 our main challenge has been to student union they don't they don't like us very much they're not
00:02:14 they're very ideological and against the sort of idea of free expression and having different
00:02:19 people speak, and we have and we will in the future have to be bringing up motions and
00:02:24 such to keep them from banning certain viewpoints, that was actually sort of our cause for forming
00:02:28 is that they were banning certain viewpoints, whether it's all the Jewish clubs, the pro-life
00:02:33 club in the future, whatever, other clubs that don't align with their mandate or their
00:02:36 ideology.
00:02:37 Hi, my name is Rachel Gillian and I'm a member of U Ottawa Student for Free Speech.
00:02:42 I'm Trevor Stewart, I'm VP of Franco Affairs for U Ottawa Students for Free Speech.
00:02:49 We anticipated that there was going to be a protest because a few days ago the Ottawa Against Fascism group had made a long Facebook post about how we're bringing in a racist and misogynist speaker.
00:03:01 One of the members of the group came into the library a couple of hours before the event was supposed to start and disguised himself as a regular goer to the library.
00:03:10 And then, I guess, when the event was just about to start, he went and pulled the fire alarm. 0.99
00:03:16 They seem like commino-anarchists.
00:03:18 So they're going to use this event to say that it's misogynistic, it's racist,
00:03:24 it promotes white supremacy, it promotes this, promotes that,
00:03:27 but really what they're trying to do is push out their message of capitalism is wrong
00:03:32 and we want to keep going with communism.
00:03:35 Like these people are, I don't know, it's like the hammer-sickle represents like socialism.
00:03:41 Preventing people from speaking only to push their own narrative and that's pretty fascist on them.
00:03:45 No debate!
00:03:47 No platform for hate!
00:03:49 No debate!
00:03:50 No platform for hate!
00:03:52 No platform for hate!
00:03:54 No platform for hate!
00:03:55 I like to call her Janice Flamenco. 1.00
00:03:57 She's a rape apologist. 0.89
00:03:58 These people are all like very, very capitalist.
00:04:01 Like, free speech, free market, they're all people who believe in exploiting third world
00:04:07 countries because they, like, it's like these people are, I don't know, it's like the hammer
00:04:12 sickle, it represents like socialism.
00:04:14 Janice Femenko's got to go, hey, hey, ho, ho, Janice Femenko's got to go.
00:04:20 If you really want to be convinced that speech needs to be protected, just take a look around
00:04:24 you and see that people don't want it to happen and we need to be out here making sure that
00:04:28 people can talk.
00:04:30 The title of my talk is The University About the Pursuit of Truth or About the Protection of Approved Ideas.
00:04:48 I'm Janice Piamengo of the University of Ottawa.
00:04:51 Most respected academics today, if asked that question, would say that of course the university
00:04:59 is about the pursuit of truth and that there are no approved ideas. This is a paranoid right-wing
00:05:06 fantasy. But if pressed on the matter of free speech, they would say that the university is
00:05:13 a community based on the values of inclusion and diversity and that one must balance freedom of
00:05:20 expression with maintaining an environment where students can learn
00:05:23 without discrimination and harassment which sounds okay unimpeachable but what
00:05:29 it means is that considerations other than truth are now paramount at the
00:05:34 University and I would argue in society at large as well here for example is
00:05:39 President and Vice Chancellor Deborah McClatchy apologizing to Wilfred
00:05:44 Laurier TA Lindsay Shepard for the way Shepard was treated last fall she was
00:05:49 interrogated. She was accused of promoting transphobia for showing a short clip in her 1.00
00:05:55 class of a public television debate involving Jordan Peterson. This is what McClatchy said,
00:06:01 quote, let me be clear by stating that Laurier is committed to the abiding principles of freedom
00:06:07 of speech and freedom of expression, giving life to these principles while respecting
00:06:12 fundamentally important human rights and our institutional values of diversity and inclusion
00:06:20 is not a simple matter, end quote. It isn't. This is a fancy way of saying that the university
00:06:29 isn't about freedom of speech anymore, because if other values such as diversity and inclusion,
00:06:37 If those are equally or more important, then speech will inevitably be restrained.
00:06:44 It will inevitably depend on the feelings of potentially offended persons,
00:06:49 and it's hard to imagine any serious subject not being likely to wound and threaten somebody
00:06:56 in today's very victim-conscious climate.
00:07:01 The President McClatches of the world know this all too well,
00:07:04 and to be fair, know that the human rights tribunals and such are watching them. So freedom
00:07:10 of speech is dead on many university campuses, and a majority of professors are okay with that.
00:07:18 In some cases, in fact, professors make very complicated arguments about what freedom of
00:07:23 expression means, trying to claim that the principles of freedom of speech were never
00:07:31 meant to apply to certain types of expression. In March of 2017, for example, in advance of a talk
00:07:37 by Jordan Peterson at McMaster University in Hamilton, Ontario, a group called the President's
00:07:44 Advisory Committee on Building an Inclusive Community. This is a very large SJW group that
00:07:51 advises the president. That group issued an extraordinary statement in which they argued
00:07:56 that Professor Peterson's speech shouldn't fall under the category of protected speech at all,
00:08:01 even though they didn't even know yet what he was going to say. This is what they claimed,
00:08:06 quote, freedom of speech doesn't now and hasn't ever meant that we can or should be able to say
00:08:13 whatever we like in public spaces, regardless of the impact of our speech on others. Remember,
00:08:19 this is a professor of psychology speaking. And go on. Instead, the concept of freedom of speech
00:08:25 has most often been mobilized to protect specifically counter hegemonic ideas ideas
00:08:31 that actually challenge rather than reiterate the status quo end quote this bizarre baffle gab is a
00:08:40 now fairly standard position taken by those who believe those elites that only speech that passes
00:08:48 their political purity test deserves a hearing if your discourse can be said to quote reiterate
00:08:56 the status quo whatever that means it doesn't deserve protection from goons and hooligans and 0.93
00:09:02 of course from people like the heretic hunters on the president's advisory committee at mcmaster u
00:09:10 that's what gets taught as elite opinion at universities today in classroom after classroom
00:09:15 and it's no wonder that their students use illegal tactics intimidation and violence to shut down
00:09:22 talks by speakers they've been coached to hate there's actually been a fair bit of argument
00:09:28 online lately about whether the threat to freedom of speech on campus is a real issue or not and
00:09:34 if it is real whether it comes equally from the left or the right so i would encourage everyone
00:09:40 to judge for yourself take a look at the database compiled by the foundation for individual rights
00:09:46 in education or fire for short fire has created what it calls a disinvitation database which is
00:09:53 a listing by year since 2000 of the censoring of hot button topics and speakers on university
00:09:59 campuses so look carefully at that list and see who's doing the shutting down and what kind of
00:10:06 of strategies they typically use. Out of 35 incidents recorded by fire for the year 2017,
00:10:14 30 of the censorship efforts came from the left, about 85, 86 percent or so. The database includes
00:10:22 many well-known names, Milo Yiannopoulos, Ben Shapiro, Gavin McInnes, Bessie DeVos, Donald Trump
00:10:28 Jr., Tommy Robinson, Dennis Prager. Many of these people are not academics, so of course that's no
00:10:36 reason why their ideas shouldn't be discussed on a college campus others though are highly
00:10:41 respected scholars and researchers authorities in their fields like political scientist charles
00:10:48 murray author of the bell curve and heather mcdonald fellow of the manhattan institute
00:10:53 and author of the war on cops it would be an enormous privilege to be able to hear
00:10:59 such people speak but they too have been violently disrupted in march of 2017 students at the elite
00:11:08 middlebury college in vermont disrupted an event featuring charles murray forcing the talk to be
00:11:15 moved to a private location where only murray and the professor who had invited him a political
00:11:21 scientist named allison stanger where only those two would be able to discuss his ideas by remote
00:11:28 feed. But protesters, sorry, protesters became aware of the new location and attacked Murray
00:11:35 and Stanger, surrounding their car, pounding on it, rocking it, throwing a stop sign at the
00:11:41 windshield and grabbing the hair and twisting the neck of Professor Stanger, who ended up in
00:11:47 hospital as a result. It was a surreal encounter, all because a world authority on IQ was prepared
00:11:55 to share his knowledge and entertain questions from his audience. In April of 2017 at Claremont
00:12:02 McKenna College in California, Heather MacDonald faced an angry mob of Black Lives Matter protesters 0.97
00:12:08 who harassed students and faculty attempting to attend the event and blocked the entrance
00:12:14 ways to the building where the talk was to take place while the police stood by mainly watching
00:12:20 as they so often do at such events. And as had happened with Charles Murray, MacDonald was taken
00:12:26 to a different venue so that she could give her talk to essentially an empty room via live stream,
00:12:34 but protesters still pounded on the windows and yelled obscenities and the talk had to be cut 0.98
00:12:39 short at the instructions of the police. MacDonald is a diminutive, impassioned, incredibly smart
00:12:47 and well-informed thinker whose arguments about the threat to black communities posed by Black 0.72
00:12:53 Lives Matter are of enormous importance to our society, yet they provoke hysteria. In my own
00:13:01 country, there have been shutdowns and disruptions aplenty of everyone from journalist Christy
00:13:06 Blatchford and bioethicist Margaret Somerville to men's advocate Warren Farrell and conservative
00:13:15 pundit Ann Coulter. Most recently, Queen's University protesters disrupted a talk by
00:13:21 Professor Jordan Peterson, and Wilfred Laurier protesters were successful in preventing a talk
00:13:26 by journalist Faith Goldie. Skeptics will point out, they have pointed out, that a few handfuls
00:13:34 of cancelled speaking events isn't that many in a large country like the United States with some
00:13:40 4,700 colleges and universities and this is true to a certain extent though the database makes no
00:13:47 claim to being comprehensive and there are likely more cancelled events that we never hear about and
00:13:52 of course these events are just the tip of an iceberg that includes manifold types of censorship
00:14:00 from the indoctrination of undergraduates and the training up of graduate students all the way up to
00:14:05 the hiring of professors, the granting of tenure, the funding of professors' projects, and the
00:14:11 penalizing of dissent at all levels. We know that for every Heather MacDonald who has shut down,
00:14:17 there are hundreds of speakers who are never even considered at all, whose ideas are dismissed as
00:14:23 right-wing, fringe ideas, and are never discussed at the university to begin with.
00:14:30 But what is really noteworthy about the recorded events on FHIR's database is not only the level
00:14:38 of violence and disruption employed, but also the shocking manner in which university administrators
00:14:44 often go out of their way to condone the protesters, or at least to make outlandish
00:14:51 excuses for them. In nearly every one of these cases on FHIR's database, the university either
00:14:59 makes no statement at all after the protest or it makes a statement in which it expresses regret
00:15:07 for the lack of civility in general but suggests that this lack of civility applies equally to the
00:15:15 speaker as it does to those who resort to illegal disruption intimidation and violence
00:15:22 and here's a case in point professor allison stanger the political scientist who went to the
00:15:28 hospital after she was beaten by a mob for inviting Charles Murray, she wrote an opinion
00:15:34 piece in the New York Times last March 2017 entitled, Understanding the Angry Mob at Middlebury
00:15:42 that Gave Me a Concussion. Now, you would think that she would primarily talk about why the mere
00:15:48 act of giving a talk, and not just anybody giving a talk, but a distinguished political scientist,
00:15:54 why that mere act would provoke a riot. And we're not talking about the owner of a factory telling
00:16:02 his workers that they're going to lose their jobs. This is an academic making rational,
00:16:08 evidence-based arguments with which one is free to disagree or ignore altogether.
00:16:15 So what does it say about a group of privileged young people, one of the most privileged
00:16:20 generations in world history, that their first recourse, their first recourse, is to violence.
00:16:28 But that's not what Alison Stanger was really interested in addressing. Stanger wanted to
00:16:35 show off her progressivist credentials. She actually blamed Donald Trump and Trump supporters
00:16:41 for the students' actions, saying that Trump had polarized America with his violent rhetoric. 0.67
00:16:50 this is what she said quote president trump has demonized muslims as terrorists and dehumanized
00:16:57 many groups of marginalized people well that is true radical style never miss an opportunity to
00:17:04 say that the violent mobsters are really good people she went on quote much of the free speech
00:17:11 he that's trump has inspired or has refused to disavow is ugly and has already had ugly
00:17:18 real-world consequences." So, that is astounding. A political science professor refusing to make
00:17:28 a basic distinction between speech and violence. And this is what the opponents of free speech
00:17:34 always do. Talk about violent rhetoric, and that means that you can be violent,
00:17:42 you can use violence against somebody and say that you're simply responding to that speaker's
00:17:47 discursive violence in a kind of almost self-defense near the end of her article professor stanger
00:17:57 said quote i hear and understand the righteous anger of many of those who shouted us down
00:18:04 i know that many students felt they were standing up to protect marginalized people
00:18:08 who have been demeaned or even threatened under the guise of free speech end quote
00:18:14 quote, thanks, Professor Stanger. You just guaranteed that university students will be
00:18:21 emboldened to continue their campaign to give other people concussions and send other people
00:18:28 to the hospital, and maybe those others won't blame them for it either. And this sympathizing
00:18:34 with the bullies, appeasing them and attacking the speakers who were themselves attacked. This
00:18:40 is seen fairly often in such cases. After Milo Yiannopoulos was prevented from speaking at
00:18:46 DePaul University by Black Lives Matter protesters, the president of the university made a notable
00:18:51 public statement in which he essentially blamed Yiannopoulos for the whole scandal. He made clear
00:18:58 his extreme dislike of Yiannopoulos, saying of speakers like him that, quote, their shtick is to
00:19:04 shock and incite a strong emotional response they can then use to discredit the moral high ground
00:19:09 claimed by their opponents. This is unworthy of university discourse, but not unfamiliar across
00:19:16 American higher education. There will always be speakers who exploit the differences within our
00:19:22 human community to their own benefit, blissfully unconcerned with the damage they leave behind,
00:19:29 end quote. What a fascinating spectacle to see a university president verbally attacking an
00:19:36 invited speaker for quote discrediting the moral high ground end quote of black lives matter as if 0.66
00:19:42 milo or anybody else owes it to black lives matter to help them maintain their facade of moral 0.89
00:19:49 legitimacy in cases such as these one catches a glimpse into the disordered mental and moral 0.93
00:19:57 universe of academic leaders in which it is clear that their primary aim is to make common cause
00:20:05 with thugs whom they imagine to be victims some of these people of course are quite sincere
00:20:12 others are careerists still others unhinged ideologues but one thing is clear when you hate
00:20:21 what you perceive to be social injustice more than you love the principles of civil dialogue
00:20:28 you shouldn't be at university at all and unfortunately these are the ones firmly in
00:20:35 charge at the present time so i expect we will see many more violent disruptions in future what a shame
00:20:46 thank you for watching if you enjoyed this video please support us on patreon
00:20:51 if even half of our subscribers gave us one dollar per month we'd be well on our way to creating
00:20:56 more and better content. And don't forget to subscribe to us on Studio Brulee.