The Fiamengo File - April 03, 2018


#MeToo Comes For Doctors - TFF episode 76

Are Universities About Truth Or The Protection of Approved Ideas? TFF-75 Then They Came For The Poets - TFF episode 77

Episode Stats


Length

15 minutes

Words per minute

130.91

Word count

2,072

Sentence count

57

Harmful content

Misogyny

17

sentences flagged

Toxicity

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

1

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 If you like your doctor, you can keep your doctor, at least until Me Too comes for him.
00:00:06 That's my subject on today's Fiumingo File.
00:00:18 I'm Janice Fiumingo of the University of Ottawa.
00:00:22 The sentencing hearing of former Olympics team doctor Larry Nassar, who was given 40 to 175 years in prison,
00:00:30 for molesting female gymnasts and other athletes is important of things to come, in my opinion.
00:00:36 The hearing was notable for the manner in which Judge Rosemary Aquilina made no attempt to control 0.95
00:00:42 her vaunting hatred. I've just signed your death warrant, she gloated, in what I found an unseemly
00:00:51 display of rage. She had been listening to testimony by Nassar's victims, and she spoke to
00:00:57 Nassar not as a judge to a convicted criminal, but as a woman to a despicable man.
00:01:05 Putting aside the particular subject of Larry Nassar, I want to focus here on the peril
00:01:10 of male doctors in general in this time of mass accusation.
00:01:16 Doctors are, of course, particularly vulnerable to the feminist mob. 1.00
00:01:21 Many have spent thousands of hours examining female patients behind closed doors, doing 1.00
00:01:27 the pap smears and the breast exams that they're required to do. They probably won't be doing that 0.99
00:01:33 much longer. I suspect they'll soon have female nurses present whenever a patient has to disrobe 1.00
00:01:40 and imagine the increased expense of that. But given that there is no statute of limitations
00:01:46 on sexual assault charges and given that the police and the courts are zealous to pursue
00:01:52 alleged abuse, many male doctors have reason to be breaking a sweat. Angry women have traditionally 1.00
00:02:01 had a special dislike of male doctors who are often depicted as symbols of the most hated form 1.00
00:02:08 of patriarchal power. According to Professor Mary Daly in her book Gynecology, The Metaethics of
00:02:16 radical feminism, the rise of the male medical profession necessitated the massacre of wise 0.99
00:02:23 women during the witch craze in medieval Europe. Would-be medical men, according to Daly, needed to 0.54
00:02:30 kill off the female healers in their villages in order to take their places. The notion that only 0.97
00:02:37 women were killed as witches in medieval Europe has been thoroughly discredited by historians,
00:02:42 but the myth remains potent. And in general, many feminist accounts describe the practice of
00:02:49 medicine as the ultimate patriarchal system, with the male doctor as the locus of knowledge and 0.97
00:02:55 power, and the woman a passive object, her body controlled, objectified, and abused.
00:03:03 As the authors of the study Social Theory, Health and Healthcare make clear, quote, 1.00
00:03:08 Foucault's notion of the clinical gaze has been taken up by feminist sociologists and health
00:03:14 activists to critique the medical appropriation of women's bodies, end quote. Fast forward to the
00:03:22 Me Too moment beginning in the fall of 2017, in which women empowered themselves by calling out
00:03:29 men's predatory behavior, whether criminal or not, and in which how the woman felt is at least as
00:03:36 important as what she objectively experienced, with, for example, Tina Dupuy in the Atlantic
00:03:42 Monthly going so far as to say that Al Franken's squeeze of her waist during a photo op made her
00:03:50 feel, quote, no longer a person. In this climate of finger-pointing melodrama, it is no surprise
00:03:59 that male doctors are now in the crosshairs of accusing women. Many of us have felt apprehensive,
00:04:07 queasy, and embarrassed in a doctor's office at some point, but Me Too has given a large number
00:04:14 of women permission to translate such feelings into criminal allegations that can ruin a man's 1.00
00:04:20 life. The title of an October 2017 article by Alison Knopp in an online magazine makes the
00:04:28 connection clear. Quote, my me too moments happened in the doctor's office, she writes.
00:04:36 Knopp claims to have experienced, quote, multiple sexual traumas at the hands of male doctors
00:04:41 beginning when I was nine years old. It's significant that the writer calls what happened
00:04:47 to her trauma, an elastic term referring not to a specific external reality, but to an intense
00:04:54 psychological and emotional response. Knopp doesn't tell us what caused the trauma, as is her right,
00:05:01 but she doesn't hesitate to describe it as assault, even while admitting the difficulty
00:05:07 of determining what is and is not abuse in cases where an incident is being recalled
00:05:13 many years after the fact, and in which the feeling of shame or humiliation is the primary
00:05:22 defining criterion knopp writes that quote in many cases of sexual trauma and abuse the victim may
00:05:30 doubt herself as her in shock brain tries to process what happened and it can be especially
00:05:36 difficult in the case of a patient who may question whether the clinician who did something
00:05:41 to her that felt wrong actually did something wrong or whether what happened was medically
00:05:48 necessary, end quote. This is a revealing sentence. At first glance, it may seem to be saying that it's
00:05:56 difficult to determine in the context of medical procedures whether what feels wrong actually is
00:06:02 wrong. In other words, women should be careful about what they name as abuse. But that's not 0.96
00:06:08 what this writer is saying. When we return to the first clause of the sentence, we're reminded that
00:06:13 she begins, quote, in many cases of sexual trauma and abuse, the victim may doubt herself. In other
00:06:20 words, there is no existential doubt about the fact of abuse. There's only the victim's felt
00:06:27 doubt within herself. And because trauma creates doubt, according to feminist theory, by definition, 1.00
00:06:34 self-doubt is part of trauma, even proof of trauma. And indeed, commentators on Knopf's article
00:06:42 are similarly enthusiastic about naming discomfort as abuse even when it isn't sexual. One commentator
00:06:52 speaks of the humiliation of having to walk in front of doctors and medical students after hip
00:06:57 surgery as a young girl feeling herself the victim of the collective male gaze. This is what she says
00:07:04 quote when I entered the exam room I was required to strip down to my underwear no gown because they
00:07:10 needed to see my gait as I walked and see how my hips moved. I was asked to walk across the room,
00:07:15 turn, stand on one leg, lift my arms up. It was humiliating. After the demonstrations,
00:07:20 the students would gather around me with all sorts of questions that were so demeaning
00:07:24 and devoid of any empathy as to what a young girl would possibly be feeling,
00:07:28 standing there in her underwear, exposed to them. They would bend my arms, move my legs up and down
00:07:33 while feeling my hips. It was traumatizing. Was it sexual in nature? No. I never felt sexually
00:07:39 violated however a line was very much crossed end quote but what line was crossed and how
00:07:51 nothing that she describes is objectively abusive at least in my opinion she even notes that her
00:07:56 mother was always present in the room well likely the exams were unpleasant and perhaps could have
00:08:02 been handled better i'm not of course suggesting that abuse doesn't happen or that the feelings of
00:08:08 these women aren't worth attending to but i am struck by their unwillingness to admit that
00:08:14 feeling humiliated doesn't equate to abuse now the psycho-biological roots of these feelings 1.00
00:08:23 are undoubtedly complex and surely exacerbated during a physical exam in which the female body 1.00
00:08:30 is exposed to the medical gaze and medical touch and surely decades of feminist theorizing about
00:08:38 the damage of the male gaze have buttressed and encouraged outraged claims of malpractice
00:08:47 i don't think i am exaggerating in predicting a me too attack on male doctors in which one of the
00:08:56 overt features of the mobbing will be the doctor's exposure to the pitiless
00:09:03 and dehumanizing gaze of journalists and the wider public
00:09:11 consider the case of dr vincent naidong an ottawa doctor with a decades-long practice
00:09:18 at the university of ottawa health clinic naidong was my doctor for 10 years when i lived in ottawa
00:09:24 and i always found him to be extremely competent professional knowledgeable obviously i'm not in
00:09:31 any position to pronounce on his guilt or his innocence but i can note the spectacular manner
00:09:39 in which he has been criminalized before trial in january of 2018 dr nadon was arrested and charged
00:09:48 with sexual assault and voyeurism after a female patient said that she had quote become suspicious
00:09:55 that she was being recorded during a medical examination by nadon at the university of
00:10:00 ottawa health services clinic the basis for the suspicion has never been explained and we don't
00:10:06 know whether any recording was actually found it's also not clear whether the charge of voyeurism
00:10:13 and the charge of sexual assault relate to one in the same incident i'm assuming that they do
00:10:18 As a result of changes to the Canadian Criminal Code in 1985, sexual assault can be defined extremely broadly, which it would need to be, as it's hard to imagine in this case anything approaching a conventional assault happening at the busy clinic where Nédant worked, where there were always at least half a dozen doctors and nurses and many more patients in the corridors that connect to the examining rooms.
00:10:45 following his arrest dr nadon's name and face were splashed all over the news and he was treated
00:10:54 like a highly dangerous sex criminal a threat to society he was jailed he was placed under 30 day
00:11:03 30 day house arrest upon his release he was forced to surrender his passport and he was prohibited
00:11:09 from using any recording devices or even from accessing the internet unless in the presence
00:11:17 of his wife or brother who posted bail for him. Moreover, the Ottawa police made a plea
00:11:24 for help, declaring their near certainty that there were more victims out there and asking
00:11:33 anyone with information about Nédon to come forward. And come forward they did. Within a month
00:11:42 there were 10 additional counts of sexual assault against the doctor from 10 different quote
00:11:49 victims reaching as far back as 1995. And even in the most recent reports about the additional
00:11:57 charges, the police are still expressing concern that there are likely more victims they hope will
00:12:06 come forward. They're sending a clear message. It couldn't be any clearer that Vincent Nédon is
00:12:13 guilty. Now, Nédon is no longer under house arrest, but he is essentially a prisoner in his own home.
00:12:21 his position at the clinic has been terminated not suspended his reputation has been destroyed his
00:12:29 face has been burned into the memories of hundreds of thousands of members of the reading public
00:12:35 he has nothing left to do in his life but wait for his trial which will likely not take place for
00:12:42 years and of course contemplate the crushing of every professional dream he ever had
00:12:50 he'll spend hundreds of thousands of dollars perhaps half a million dollars on a lawyer
00:12:55 to defend him against charges that are essentially impossible to defend against
00:13:02 how prove that a claimed assault from 1995 never took place for that matter how prove
00:13:10 a claimed assault from yesterday never took place even if nadal is found not guilty he will almost
00:13:17 certainly never work as a doctor again and the life he had can never be recovered his accusers
00:13:26 of course whether bogus or not will remain shielded from public view their dignity must
00:13:34 be protected but nobody gives a bloody damn about the dignity of a man who has not yet even been
00:13:41 tried what nadon's case shows most clearly in my opinion is the extent to which our society is
00:13:51 already what me too hashtaggers envision in which men are pilloried from the moment someone accuses
00:14:00 them what a barbarous practice it is to publish the name of the accused and to call for more
00:14:10 accusers why publish his name and picture before trial if not to ruin his life how is it how does 0.65
00:14:18 it help justice why plea for more accusers if not to load up a trial with women already coached
00:14:27 about what to say simply by reading the newspaper if we don't permit jury members to serve who have 0.99
00:14:35 read too much about a case and already made up their mind why would we permit that in accusers
00:14:42 even if they don't is guilty which i admit it possible he is the manner in which his case has
00:14:49 been set up is completely tainted in my opinion. And if he's innocent, the depth of betrayal
00:14:59 is beyond words.
00:15:19 Thank you.