The Fiamengo File - April 13, 2018


Then They Came For The Poets - TFF episode 77

#MeToo Comes For Doctors - TFF episode 76 Why Can't We Hate Men - TFF episode 84

Episode Stats


Length

9 minutes

Words per minute

142.25

Word count

1,387

Sentence count

41

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

1

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 Is calling someone hot at a poetry reading now an unforgivable sin?
00:00:06 That's my subject on today's Fiumengo File.
00:00:19 I'm Janice Fiumengo from the University of Ottawa. Poetry readings used to be spaces of erotic
00:00:25 energy in which the poets on the stage the purveyors of beautiful words had power and
00:00:31 we in the audience wanted to bask in the glow now that's all forbidden an organization called
00:00:39 vida women in literary arts is inviting its members to take the safer lit pledge to make
00:00:47 poetry readings as safe and stayed as a meeting of the committee to prevent public vice the pledge
00:00:55 wants to outlaw what it calls quote non-consensual sexual advances and it lists do's and don'ts for
00:01:04 those who pledge such as stepping in if you see something that doesn't look consensual in other
00:01:09 words consent police and although the website declares that quote these actions are not about
00:01:16 punishing the perpetrator they're about protecting current and future victims and quote we know
00:01:22 there's punishment aplenty in store recently the new york times published an article called
00:01:29 cancelled deals and pulped books as the publishing industry confronts sexual harassment
00:01:36 the title should have read as the publishing industry caves in to sexual harassment hysteria
00:01:43 in which deluded vicious or otherwise dangerous women use allegations of misconduct to destroy
00:01:49 men's literary careers the article tells of the many authors some well known who have had their
00:01:56 books deferred or their publishing contracts cancelled because quote publishing companies
00:02:02 are facing painful trade-offs as they cut ties with accused men in hopes of minimizing any
00:02:09 collateral damage end quote note that accused men not men convicted of anything and many of them
00:02:17 accused of what we use to consider harmless flirting. Jamie Thomas, manager of a bookstore
00:02:24 called Women and Children First in Chicago, has removed books by accused authors from her store
00:02:32 shelves. She states, quote, I don't want to have our customers having to come in here and ask why
00:02:37 we're supporting someone accused of sexual misconduct, end quote. She doesn't mind explaining
00:02:44 obviously, why she is removing a book that never did anybody any harm solely because of an unfounded
00:02:52 accusation. In the 15th century in England, there used to be a practice called the bonfire of the
00:02:59 vanities in which a bonfire would be made of objects that were thought by religious authorities
00:03:05 to cause sin. These were objects like mirrors, cosmetics, and of course, immoral books. They
00:03:13 would be burned up in a public act of renunciation. Now we're metaphorically of course burning books
00:03:22 not because the books cause sin, in fact the subject of the books doesn't matter at all,
00:03:27 but because they are the products of purportedly sinful men. 300 odd years after the bonfire of the
00:03:35 vanities, the British poet Lord Byron, the bad boy of the early 19th century, caused outrage with his
00:03:41 sexually irreverent poetry and rumors that he had had multiple love affairs including with men
00:03:47 and it was said an incestuous relationship with his half-sister augusta his most famous poem don
00:03:54 juan based on the legend of don juan but with the main character an innocent seduced by women was
00:04:02 considered so shocking and immoral that various publishers refused to be associated with it
00:04:07 if the censors of early 19th century england had carried the day we might have lost one of the
00:04:13 greatest and most memorable long poems in the entire history of the english language
00:04:20 today's censors claim to care about safety rather than morals but they're every bit as punitive as
00:04:28 those who hounded byron out of england recently the american poet joseph massey woke up one morning
00:04:36 and found himself famous, to quote Byron, but of course not famous in a good way. A scurrilous
00:04:42 website titled The Poet Joseph Massey is an Abuser was posted by anonymous accusers and links to it
00:04:50 were sent to Massey's publishers and his employer, the University of Pennsylvania. The website authors
00:04:56 claimed that he was an abuser, that he used his depression and anxiety as excuses to prey on women,
00:05:03 that he gaslighted his victims, and that he threatened to harm their reputations.
00:05:10 What is actually posted on the website, though, is long on portentous declaration and very short
00:05:18 on substance. Here's the main part of it. Quote, the first time I met him, he was the star poet
00:05:25 at a reading. He was extremely drunk and told me several times in front of a large crowd of
00:05:30 published writers, and my partner, that he thought I was hot. I ignored it because every time he said
00:05:36 it, he would then loudly cite depression and anxiety as reasons for acting out. It seemed
00:05:42 that this was his public persona. Everyone's attitude was, it's just Joseph being Joseph.
00:05:47 I became friends with him. Years later, though I should have known better, someone had even warned
00:05:52 me about him and his grooming behavior. He ended up having an outburst at me in a manner that was
00:05:59 extremely inappropriate and that mirrored many of the stories I have since heard. I have reason to
00:06:04 believe it was because he felt entitled to be romantic and or sexual with me, even though I
00:06:10 never remotely showed interest, end quote. Well, even within this presumably carefully crafted
00:06:18 text, which is obviously designed to inflict maximum damage on Joseph Massey, the self-contradictions
00:06:26 and special pleading are hard to ignore. If Joseph Massey's behavior at the poetry reading was really
00:06:33 so off-putting, if it was so disturbing to be called hot, why would the author go on to become
00:06:40 friends with him later? And how can we square the statement that most of those around Massey
00:06:47 found his behavior entirely excusable, it's just Joseph being Joseph, if in fact someone was also
00:06:52 warning about his grooming behavior i mean which was it and what exactly was so inappropriate
00:07:00 about his so-called outburst the whole post goes on like this it's vague full of sound and fury
00:07:09 signifying only that joseph massey is like most people capable of saying mean things occasionally
00:07:18 Massey has publicly admitted that years ago when he was in his 20s and early 30s
00:07:23 he had a drinking problem and was at times verbally abusive on social media. He once grabbed
00:07:30 a friend's breast at a poetry event when he was drunk and he quarreled with a girlfriend while
00:07:36 he was drunk. But this was all a decade ago. Since then he's changed his life, joined AA,
00:07:43 and apologize to the people he hurt are the missteps from his past really bad enough that
00:07:50 he should be drummed out of the creative writing community and have his career and reputation
00:07:54 ruined it seems the answer is yes ruin has befallen joseph massey his accusers have
00:08:04 as i said inundated the offices of his publishers and his employer with their claims they contacted
00:08:10 various newspapers and have had at least one story published based on their accusations.
00:08:16 The head of the writing program at the University of Pennsylvania, where Massey worked in the past
00:08:21 and where he was supposed to work this summer, he wrote him a letter cancelling the contract saying
00:08:26 he had received what he called, quote, credible statements about your inappropriate behavior, end
00:08:32 quote. Wesleyan University Press has deferred publication of an upcoming book of poetry of
00:08:38 Massey's, and other presses say they will no longer publish his work. There has been a pile-on
00:08:43 of slander and character assassination on social media. Massey has experienced a mobbing of classic
00:08:51 proportions, all in the name of making the literary world safe for women. I suspect that 1.00
00:09:01 these women and their male allies who pour so much time and energy into ruining their male rivals
00:09:08 and working to stamp out any whiff of male sexuality from literary events are as short on 1.00
00:09:16 talent as they are long on nastiness. They can't help that, I suppose, but it's shocking
00:09:23 that they're being given the power to ruin literature for us all.
00:09:28 Thank you for watching. If you enjoyed this video, please support us on Patreon. If even
00:09:36 half of our subscribers gave us $1 per month, we'd be well on our way to creating more
00:09:40 and better content. And don't forget to subscribe to us on Studio Brulee.