00:00:00The mob is coming for a dissident professor near you, as academic cancel culture heats up.
00:00:19Last June, in the racially charged days following the death of George Floyd,
00:00:24psychology professor Charles Negge of the University of Central Florida triggered his
00:00:30excommunication by tweeting, black privilege is real. He explained, quote, besides affirmative
00:00:39action, special scholarships, and other set asides, being shielded from legitimate criticism
00:00:47is a privilege, but as a group, they're missing out on much needed feedback, end quote.
00:00:54It wasn't unreasonable, and it certainly wasn't hate, but it was the beginning of the end for
00:01:01the tenured prof who had dared to break consensus on Black American victimhood.
00:01:07Almost immediately, hashtag UCFfirehim began trending on Twitter, a ragtag group of protesters
00:01:15gathered on Negi's campus, and a full-on mobbing had begun.1.00
00:01:20academia has become ground zero for this typically feminine form of relational aggression1.00
00:01:28which seeks as a recent article in ariel magazine put it quote reputation destruction and social0.69
00:01:35exclusion end quote negi's mo was in contrast typically masculine intended not to shame and
00:01:44exclude, but to confront and argue rationally. Another naggy tweet from the same time reads like0.82
00:01:51exasperated but well-intentioned practical advice about how to defeat alleged oppression0.97
00:01:57through common sense measures like staying in school and avoiding gangs and drugs.
00:02:04The woke mob, however, doesn't care about intentions or common sense. It cares only
00:02:11that you have failed to offer your allegiance, failed to join the two minutes hate. In this case,
00:02:18failed to affirm white privilege and anti-black racism as mandated by critical race orthodoxy.
00:02:25From the mob's perspective, the refusal of allegiance makes the dissident abhorrent,
00:02:32contemptible, without redeeming qualities, and deserving only of social and professional
00:02:38elimination. Canadian sociologist Kenneth Westhuse has made the study of mobbing his life's work.
00:02:47He has demonstrated the remarkable viciousness of many otherwise conscientious decent people
00:02:54who have ardently participated in destroying their colleagues' lives without compunction,
00:03:00convinced that their victim deserves nothing else. Amidst the firestorm around Negi,
00:03:07His school, the University of Central Florida, predictably failed to support him and even worse,
00:03:13openly sided with the mob, condemning his rather mild if provocative tweets as
00:03:20racist and, quote, completely counter to UCF's values, end quote. While admitting that a tenured
00:03:28prof couldn't be fired for constitutionally protected speech, university personnel set out
00:03:35to find a rationale to purge him. They requested that any students with complaints about Negi
00:03:43should come forward, and not surprisingly, students came forward in droves with various
00:03:49stories of offense mostly having to do with statements Negi allegedly made either in the
00:03:55classroom or in private conversations, some of the alleged statements dating back years,
00:04:00All of them, of course, distorted through recontextualization in the witch-hunt atmosphere of accusation and moral grandstanding.
00:04:11In a sane world, such thin gruel wouldn't even have whetted the appetite of a disciplinary body with better things to do than spend dozens of hours listening to hearsay.
00:04:23But in woke 2020, it was more than sufficient for an administration falling all over itself
00:04:31to prove its social justice credentials, and according to news reports, the university
00:04:36fired Negi in late January for academic misconduct, having produced a 244-page report on the equal
00:04:45opportunity offenders' various transgressions, which ranged from telling students that God0.84
00:04:51wasn't real, to informing them that all men were a little bit gay and that penis size varied with0.98
00:04:58race. For those of us following what has come to be called cancel culture at North American0.97
00:05:05universities, the sheer number and variety of professors hounded for politically incorrect
00:05:10statements or alleged harassment is now well past reckoning. From the well-known to the relatively
00:05:18obscure. From Yale's Nicholas Christakis and Evergreen's Brett Weinstein to NYU's Michael
00:05:26Rechtenwald and New Brunswick's Ricardo Duchenne, reported cases now come too thick and fast to
00:05:33track. At Studio Brule, we've covered a large number of profs who have run afoul of the
00:05:38intersectional thought police, including but not limited to Larry Summers, Sir Timothy Hunt,
00:05:45Jordan Peterson, of course, Alan Franson, Rick Mehta, Paul Griffiths, Francesco Ayala, Rebecca
00:05:54Tuvel, Dennis Gaus, Alessandro Strumia, Rachel Fulton Brown, and Mark Selinsky, and they're the
00:06:01proverbial tip of the iceberg. The real number of the persecuted will never be known. Many professors
00:06:08having been shamed and bullied past endurance and finding no support amongst their colleagues
00:06:14allow themselves to be quietly terminated, preferring their names be kept out of the public
00:06:20domain in hopes of retaining some shred of dignity or possibility of starting their lives again.
00:06:27And not all professors are fired. Some are made so uncomfortable that they choose to leave their
00:06:33universities. A few fight and win a Pyrrhic victory in a soul-wearying battle with cowardly
00:06:41officials and SJW fanatics that may drag on for months or years, ruining their health and
00:06:49relationships. Kenneth Westhouse found in his research that mobbing victims often experience
00:06:55cardiovascular diseases like hypertension, heart attack, or stroke, while marital breakdown and
00:07:01isolation are also common. Women are certainly not immune to mob attack, especially women with
00:07:09incorrect views on trans issues, but most of the fired or publicly pilloried have been men,
00:07:17probably because it is far easier for a male dissident to be framed as a threat.
00:07:23In the case of Professor Negi, it's likely that certain administrators and or colleagues
00:07:29working behind the scenes had been preparing his ousting for some time. In 2019, he had published
00:07:38a prescient book, as it turned out, with the title, White Shaming, Bullying, Based on Prejudice,
00:07:46Virtue Signaling, and Ignorance, and it would certainly have made him a marked man on campus.
00:07:53The book argued that white Americans are experiencing an unprecedented attack on their
00:07:59rights and personhood, at a time when 60% of black Americans are middle class or higher,
00:08:06with 35,000 black millionaires in the U.S., and when Asian Americans earn more annually as a group0.68
00:08:14than all other groups, including whites, it has become acceptable and even profitable in many
00:08:20circles to racially stereotype all whites as privileged oppressors. A new double standard0.57
00:08:28has become structuralized in society, Nagy wrote in the first chapter. We must revere and show
00:08:35deference to non-whites, while whites are to be shamed for all the real, exaggerated, or even0.97
00:08:42manufactured transgressions committed by white people historically or currently. Little or no0.94
00:08:50stigma at all attaches to people who berate and racially bully whites, and Negi gives many examples,
00:08:57singling out activist professors as especially culpable. Negi's book was prescient because it
00:09:04perfectly forecast the anti-white mania that would convulse North America during the summer
00:09:11of Black Lives Matter, as every major institution in the country, from universities to law enforcement,0.57
00:09:19from public libraries to political parties, and from art galleries to large corporations,0.96
00:09:26promise to become less white as quickly as possible. In his book, Nagy demonstrated how0.96
00:09:33the media hides violent hate crime when the perpetrators are non-white, while flogging it
00:09:40endlessly when it fits an anti-white agenda. And he gave many examples of the remarkable manner in0.53
00:09:47which whites are expected to tolerate and even applaud harsh denunciations of their race as
00:09:54uniquely evil, while they themselves are held to an impossibly pure standard of racially sensitive
00:10:00conduct toward others. I highly recommend the book, which is filled with noteworthy examples
00:10:06of racial double standards and hyper-charged political correctness. The book was also
00:10:11prescient, alas, for Negi's own life, as over the autumn and winter, he was forced to attempt
00:10:18to defend statements he may or may not have made so long ago in many cases as to be past
00:10:24accurate recall. During this time, he was denied due process, told very little about the substance
00:10:30of the complaints against him until forced to address them under prolonged questioning,
00:10:36and then blamed when he didn't remember or denied specific instances.
00:10:42Nagy's experience is also notable for the stunning swiftness with which his fortunes
00:10:47have turned. He had been a respected tenured professor of 22 years, consistently receiving
00:10:54very high performance ratings. For the past four years, in fact, he was evaluated as
00:10:59outstanding. Then suddenly it was as if none of that had ever been.
00:11:07For all professors who find themselves in the mob's crosshairs, the experience is deeply
00:11:13unpleasant, in some cases actually fatal. In his study of circumstances surrounding suicides in
00:11:20Sweden, psychologist Heinz Lehman estimated that, quote, about 12% of people who take their own
00:11:27lives had recently been mobbed at work. This was the case for Professor Mike Adams, a tenured
00:11:33criminology prof at the University of North Carolina, Wilmington, who died by his own hand
00:11:39in late July of 2020 after a mob pile-on. Adams had been hated for years for his outspoken
00:11:47opposition to social justice ideology and academia. He found himself under attack once again
00:11:53after he tweeted against COVID restrictions last spring, addressing North Carolina Governor Roy
00:12:01Cooper in the manner of a slave addressing a slave owner, ironically pleading with him,
00:12:07Massa Cooper, let my people go. Naturally, this parody was denounced as racist for its
00:12:14appropriation of black experience. According to reports by those who knew him, Adams then endured
00:12:21a sustained barrage of hate-filled and threatening phone calls, emails, and tweets with no support
00:12:28whatsoever from his university, which was keen to do the mob's bidding. Just weeks before Adams was
00:12:35set to take the early retirement he had negotiated under pressure with his employer, he was found
00:12:41dead in his home many on twitter expressed their delighted satisfaction with this outcome1.00
00:12:49with one smug sjw hoping that his family quote buried his ass in a mask end quote1.00
00:12:59the willingness to eliminate non-conformists with extreme prejudice has never been more fervid and0.99
00:13:05unashamed than in our era when swift retribution follows even the most minor of politically
00:13:13incorrect statements. Let me offer just a few examples. At the University of North Texas,
00:13:20professor of mathematics Nathaniel Hears was fired in late 2019 for the simple act of writing
00:13:28on a chalkboard in the faculty lounge, please don't leave garbage lying around with an arrow
00:13:33pointing to a stack of flyers about microaggressions. He was later told by his
00:13:39department head that what he had written was threatening and incompatible with the values
00:13:45of the math department, and his teaching contract was not renewed when he refused to apologize.
00:13:52At the University of Louisville, Professor of Child Psychiatry and Psychology Dr. Alan Josephson
00:13:59was first demoted and then effectively fired, his contract not renewed, merely for participating in
00:14:06a panel discussion on gender dysphoria at the Heritage Foundation, where he expressed his
00:14:12view that the vast majority of children with gender dysphoria eventually reconcile to their
00:14:17biological sex and should be treated for the underlying psychological issues creating their
00:14:23distress rather than be rushed into radical life-altering interventions. His medically
00:14:30sane and compassionate departure from the consensus on trans-affirmation spelled the
00:14:37end of his career at Lewisville. At the University of California in Los Angeles,
00:14:44professor of management Gordon Klein was put on leave and publicly denounced by his dean
00:14:52after he responded to a student email with just a touch of sarcasm.
00:14:57The student had written him following the death of George Floyd,
00:15:00requesting or demanding that he give black students special accommodations for a scheduled exam.
00:15:07Klein responded by querying the student how he was to know in an online course
00:15:13which students were black and whether he was to offer half accommodation for mixed-race students
00:15:20and so on, in a series of half-ironic questions.
00:15:2520,000 people signed a petition to have him fired for his alleged abuse of power.
00:15:32Though he wasn't in the end fired, he has never received an apology for his very public humiliation.
00:15:40Each of these stories, and many more, all of which deserve a fuller telling,
00:15:44illuminate the depth of self-righteous rage and the determination to destroy1.00
00:15:51unleashed against the non-conforming in our day.
00:15:56Kenneth West, who says, concluded that mobbing is a form of savagery
00:16:01with roots deep in the primitive human psyche.
00:16:04It is not only a way of excluding the non-cooperative,
00:16:08but also of achieving, at least temporarily, unity in the group
00:16:12by gathering the dark energies of the collective and focusing them outward.
00:16:18These dark energies aren't easily curtailed,
00:16:21and when given institutional encouragement in the name of anti-racism
00:16:26or protection of women, for example, they become monstrous.
00:16:31Unfortunately, recent evidence suggests that younger academics are more
00:16:37rather than less supportive of the practice of cancelling.
00:16:40A survey last month by the Center for the Study of Partisanship and Ideology found that, quote,
00:16:47with other factors held constant, a 30-year-old far-left academic has a 50% chance of endorsing
00:16:56at least one of four hypothetical dismissal campaigns involving politically incorrect
00:17:02research findings, whereas a 70-year-old far-leftist has only a 35% chance of doing so, end quote.
00:17:10The survey's author went on to report that PhD students are 10 to 20 points more in favor of
00:17:17cancelling than staff. And unless these trends are capturing a life cycle effect that people
00:17:23mature out of over time, the study portends, quote, rising support for illiberalism, end quote.
00:17:31And it's fascinating to note the kind of politically incorrect research findings
00:17:35leftist academics were willing to cancel. The survey found that, quote, among American doctoral
00:17:40students, 43% would endorse a campaign to dismiss a hypothetical scholar who found that racial and
00:17:48gender diversity reduces the effectiveness of an organization, end quote. That is, in my opinion,
00:17:55a remarkably low bar for alleged harm. The study's author, Eric Kaufman, thus cast serious doubt on
00:18:05the somewhat comforting notion that there's a silent majority in academia who oppose cancelling.
00:18:12On the contrary, he argues, there's quite strong support. And even if there is a silent majority
00:18:18on some campuses, very few are willing or feel able to stand up to the mob's annihilating energy.
00:18:26The fear, intimidation, and hatred ripple out in ever-widening circles.
00:18:33Charles Nagy introduced his excellent book on white shaming with a reflection on the profound
00:18:42strangeness of our present moment as the alleged pursuit of equality and inclusion has authorized
00:18:49race and gender-based persecution campaigns and remarkable group savagery. Quote,
00:18:57quote, it seems that the arc of justice sometimes takes a detour, he stated, rephrasing Martin
00:19:04Luther King's claim about the arc of the moral universe bending toward justice. Let
00:19:11us hope that what we are experiencing is really a detour only, rather than what I sometimes
00:19:18fear it is, a dead end from which there is no exit and no return.