The Fiamengo File - April 26, 2021


Feminism Ruins Sport - The Fiamengo File Episode 129

The Near-Irresistible Lure of Damseling - The Fiamengo File Episode 128 All The Dissident Men - The Fiamengo File Episode 130

Episode Stats


Length

17 minutes

Words per minute

119.99

Word count

2,073

Sentence count

88

Harmful content

Misogyny

35

sentences flagged

Toxicity

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

7

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 Feminist advocates tell us that female athletes are just as fast and strong as 0.99
00:00:08 men, or even stronger, held back only by sexist attitudes. Ironically, their 1.00
00:00:15 version of social constructionism opens the door for trans women to annihilate 1.00
00:00:21 female athletes almost completely.
00:00:30 sport was until recently mainly free of social justice ideology skill accuracy speed and strength 1.00
00:00:44 needed no apology but now sport too like the rest of the culture must flex its woke muscles must
00:00:52 champion Black Lives Matter, denounce capitalism, and protest trans-exclusionary bathroom policies.
00:01:01 A deeply unpleasant self-promoter like Megan Rapinoe, co-captain of the perennially aggrieved
00:01:09 U.S. women's soccer team, has spent a good part of her career whining about pay discrimination
00:01:16 and lecturing Americans on their alleged bigotry. As is often the case, the ideological tenets of
00:01:25 woke sport originated in academia, where feminists have claimed for years that only 1.00
00:01:32 sexism has prevented female athletes from performing to male levels, being paid at least 1.00
00:01:39 as much as men and receiving equal media coverage for a glimpse into academia's through the looking
00:01:47 glass world i recommend a fascinating essay called the socially constructed body which was published
00:01:55 as a chapter in a college textbook and is available online as a pdf it was written by two university
00:02:03 professors of sociology judith lorber and patricia yancey martin both hold that sex differences are
00:02:12 primarily imposed by an oppressive patriarchy they go so far as to predict that within 50 years
00:02:21 women may well outrun men in the marathon because they are at last beginning to believe 0.92
00:02:29 that they can. Here is the standard social constructionist line offered by these two 0.72
00:02:36 highly decorated PhDs. Girls learn from a young age, according to Lorber and Martin, 0.99
00:02:43 that they should move differently from boys in order to gain approval. They're told that they
00:02:50 throw like a girl, and as a result they do. They don't perform to male levels because they're not 0.99
00:02:57 expected to do so, and in some cases are even prevented from doing so. Women's tennis grand 0.99
00:03:04 slams, for example, are structured differently from men's because, according to Lorber and Martin,
00:03:11 quote, women's ability to match men's endurance alarmed the U.S. Tennis Association officials,
00:03:19 all of whom were men, and they downgraded women's abilities by reducing the number of games they had
00:03:25 to play to win a match, end quote. Lorber and Martin even make the astonishing claim that,
00:03:33 quote, women and men are not allowed to compete against each other, so actual comparisons of men's
00:03:41 and women's prowess are rarely made, end quote. This is the gender voodoo that passes for insight 0.99
00:03:49 at elite colleges across North America. For Lorber and Martin, nearly everything in our society 0.93
00:03:56 conspires to hide the fact that women's bodies are, or at least could be, just as powerful and
00:04:04 agile as men's. Whether they really are, or merely could be, is never settled in the chapter,
00:04:12 a useful confusion to hedge against countervailing evidence. When in 2017, the aforementioned
00:04:21 U.S. women's soccer team lost in an embarrassing revelation of inferior skill to an under-15
00:04:30 boys academy team, feminist-compliant news reports of the 5-2 defeat were quick to offer
00:04:39 excuses. Writing for CBS, soccer reporter Roger Gonzalez reassured readers that, quote,
00:04:48 of course, this match against the academy team was very informal and should not be a major cause for
00:04:54 alarm. The U.S. surely wasn't going all out, end quote. Gonzalez carefully avoided as much as
00:05:02 possible even mentioning the women's team name in his report of their defeat. And for many years now,
00:05:11 the pressure has been on sports media to implement Lorber and Martin's gender-equal utopia
00:05:18 under the pretense that women's sports are just as exciting to watch as men's. Recently,
00:05:25 the Australian Broadcasting Corporation announced that it would be aggressively stepping up
00:05:31 what it calls its 50-50 project to, quote, improve the representation of women across our programming
00:05:39 and offer more content for female audiences, end quote. Just how ambitious a goal this is wasn't
00:05:47 directly spelled out in the story, but according to the website Neiman reports, women's coverage
00:05:53 currently accounts for only about three to four percent of all sports media. So increasing to
00:06:01 50 percent or even 20 percent is daunting to say the least. As the Neiman Report's author admits,
00:06:09 quote, if women's pro soccer matches or women's pro hockey games barely draw crowds, then it's
00:06:18 hard to justify sending a senior reporter or columnist to cover them, especially for newspapers
00:06:24 fighting for survival, end quote. But unbothered by the bottom line, feminist activists have been 1.00
00:06:33 badgering networks for years to frog march the sporting world into the feminist future.
00:06:39 And in response, Nieman reports offers, quote, seven ways to improve coverage of women's sports, in an article that once again takes a social constructionist view.
00:06:53 Refusing to consider that female athletes get less coverage overall because they are overall less impressive as athletes, the article accepts that merely offering more coverage will lead to greater public interest.
00:07:10 In one case of rather circular reasoning, the article laments that, quote, most sports journalists, male and female, want to cover men's sports, end quote.
00:07:22 Why is that? The article provides a typical feminist non-answer from a professor Cheryl Kuki
00:07:31 of Purdue University who says, quote, because that's what the culture values. But why does 1.00
00:07:40 the culture value it? One can't expect a real explanation from the ideologue Professor Kuki.
00:07:48 I kid you not, that's her name. She teaches courses on feminism and American sport, 1.00
00:07:53 and I'll have more on Dr. Kuki in a few minutes. The primary solution offered for the dearth of 0.99
00:08:01 interest in women's sports is to cover the issues and athletes in a more female-friendly way in 1.00
00:08:08 order to draw in a female audience. Neiman Reports promotes more, quote, storytelling, 0.73
00:08:15 more giving voice to women. And the ABC article previously cited likewise highlights storytelling,
00:08:25 mentioning such issues as, quote, eating disorders, quote, domestic violence in sports,
00:08:32 whatever that means, quote, harassment when going on a run, quote, challenges for women of different
00:08:39 abilities along with, quote, fertility struggles, cultural barriers, body image issues, transgender
00:08:46 participation, and maternity protections, end quote. In other words, women may be convinced 0.98
00:08:54 to consume more sports programming if it's not really about sport at all. The article also
00:09:01 encourages a de-emphasis on, quote, elite or professional sports women in favor of, quote, 1.00
00:09:07 everyday people because these are more, quote, relatable. As an example of a relatable approach, 1.00
00:09:16 Neiman Reports recommends a 2018 opinion piece by marathoner and feminist sports journalist 1.00
00:09:24 Lindsay Krauss that showcases what a female-centered approach to sports storytelling 0.98
00:09:31 looks like. And it's a striking one. The idea for this story came to Krauss when she looked at the
00:09:39 results from the Boston Marathon of 2018, a year when temperatures were unusually cold, and she
00:09:45 noticed that women that year finished the race at a higher rate than men. She then wrote a New York
00:09:52 Times op-ed with the almost parodically triumphalist title, Why Men Quit and Women Don't.
00:10:04 Krauss is quoted in Nieman Reports, patting herself on the back for the idea. Quote,
00:10:10 Part of why I even thought of this angle in the first place was because I'm a woman, 0.98
00:10:16 she boasted. In the article, Krauss notes that women have more body fat than men, 0.82
00:10:21 which may have played a role in their greater resistance to the hypothermia that forced some
00:10:27 men from the race that day. But her article gives free reign to speculation about other factors,
00:10:34 physiological, emotional, and even moral, that reputedly give women a sporting edge.
00:10:42 Women have greater pain tolerance than men, according to Krauss, and tend to pace themselves
00:10:47 more effectively. And she quotes alleged experts weighing in with biased and anecdotal assertions.
00:10:55 Distance coach Steve Magnus was willing to go on record with the absurd generalization that
00:11:01 quote, women generally seem better able to adjust their goals in the moment, whereas men will see
00:11:09 their race as more black or white, succeed or fail, end quote. One might argue that it makes 0.53
00:11:16 a lot more sense for an elite athlete to drop out of a race rather than risk harm through
00:11:22 hypothermia. Perhaps the high-level male runners who dropped out of Boston did so because they had
00:11:27 other races coming up while more women had made finishing Boston their single goal. But we won't
00:11:34 know from Krause's op-ed because she's not interested in the whole story. She quotes not
00:11:40 a single person with a male positive or even neutral perspective. One commentator, Adam Grant,
00:11:47 pushes far into the territory of female moral superiority with the gushing sentiment that, 0.98
00:11:53 quote, women are more likely to reach out to runners next to them and offer support and seek 0.98
00:12:00 support. Sharing pain and being part of a group can make it easier to withstand pain, end quote.
00:12:08 And of course, Krauss doesn't omit the classic victim doctrine, asserting against all the
00:12:14 material evidence that women are discouraged from being athletes and that therefore, quote,
00:12:20 the female runners who made it to Boston had already overcome more social obstacles than men.
00:12:29 They may simply be tougher. And this was a year when toughness worked, end quote. 0.58
00:12:35 Well, it worked if simply finishing a marathon is the benchmark. If finishing with the best time is
00:12:45 the benchmark, then the male runners, as they always do, decisively outperformed their female 0.93
00:12:51 counterparts. The top male finisher, Yuki Kuauchi from Japan, who finished with a fairly slow time
00:12:58 for him of 2 hours 15 minutes, was still significantly ahead of the top female finisher,
00:13:04 American Des Linden, who crossed the finish line at two hours, 39 minutes. In fact, the top 10
00:13:12 male marathoners at Boston were all significantly faster than America's top female Linden.
00:13:20 Even the most cursory knowledge of sports physiology shows that men have a larger heart
00:13:25 size, greater muscle mass, greater hemoglobin concentration, and consequently higher oxygen
00:13:33 uptake, all of which makes them faster runners. But none of that is mentioned by feminist journalist 0.56
00:13:39 Lindsay Krause. My point isn't to denigrate female long-distance runners. I've watched my
00:13:45 share of Boston's and always marveled at both the men's and women's extraordinary stamina and grit.
00:13:53 But Lindsay Krause's op-ed is pure anti-male female supremacist grandstanding that, if allowed 0.93
00:14:00 to become the norm will ruin sports reporting just as surely as feminism has ruined everything 0.98
00:14:07 else that matters to normal men and women. But the irony of ironies is that at the same time as
00:14:16 academics and activists like Purdue University's Cheryl Kuki have been complaining about sexism in
00:14:24 sport coverage and alleging that young women in sport, quote, can't be what they can't see,
00:14:29 which is Kuki's phrase from a TEDx talk, at the same time they have been laying the groundwork
00:14:35 for the destruction of girls' and women's real sporting opportunities. Last year, Professor 0.75
00:14:43 Kuki published an academic article with the feminist post-structuralist title,
00:14:48 quote, Policing the Boundaries of Sex, a Critical Examination of Gender Verification
00:14:54 and the Castor Semenya controversy. Semenya is a South African middle distance runner and 2016
00:15:03 Olympic gold medalist who was barred in 2019 from competing in certain running events unless
00:15:09 she takes medication to lower her testosterone levels. In the article, Kuki takes the now
00:15:17 orthodox feminist position that sex testing enforces a hegemonic sex gender system. She 1.00
00:15:27 argues that sex testing targets female athletes. In other words, it targets those competing in 1.00
00:15:34 women's events who are biologically male or intersex. And it assumes heresy of heresies
00:15:42 that sex is binary. In her words, sex testing, quote, illustrates how sport organizations,
00:15:52 scientists, athletes, and the broader society adhere to notions of categorical difference
00:15:58 and efforts to maintain sex dichotomies and sex segregation in sport, end quote.
00:16:04 And in response, Kuki calls for the abandonment of all sex testing in sporting competitions and the acceptance that any, quote, woman should be allowed to participate in female competitions.
00:16:20 So here, then, is one version of Lorber and Martin's feminist fantasy, the rejection of the traditional gender binary, the categories woman and man reimagined at will, and, at last, a woman potentially winning the marathon.
00:16:44 on. A trans woman, that is. In fact, if ideologues like Professor Kuki prevail, trans women may
00:16:52 end up winning most female athletic competitions and dominating team sports. Look out, Megan 0.97
00:17:00 Rapinoe. Thanks to feminist theory and practice, women's athletics just got a lot more interesting. 1.00
00:17:14 You 1.00