The Fiamengo File - March 31, 2021


The Near-Irresistible Lure of Damseling - The Fiamengo File Episode 128

Yeah, A Curfew For Men - The Fiamengo File Episode 127 Feminism Ruins Sport - The Fiamengo File Episode 129

Episode Stats


Length

18 minutes

Words per minute

139.98

Word count

2,626

Sentence count

97

Harmful content

Misogyny

20

sentences flagged

Toxicity

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

19

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 Well, over a century ago, our ancestors debated women's demand for voting and other privileges.
00:00:07 Traditionalists argued that women faced a choice. They could either have special treatment on the
00:00:15 basis of their alleged vulnerability as a group, or they could have political equality. But they
00:00:21 they couldn't have both. Lo and behold, women got both, with peculiar results for our political 1.00
00:00:30 culture today. In our time, the performance of powerlessness has become a dominant strategy 1.00
00:00:47 of power nowhere more evident than in politics. I've been traumatized is now a more galvanizing
00:00:55 cry than I can handle it. And trembling weakness often eclipses demonstration of strength and
00:01:03 competence. New York Governor Andrew Cuomo's accusers have reproduced the standard victim
00:01:11 script with word-perfect fidelity, claiming that relatively benign or certainly minor actions such
00:01:18 as kissing on the cheek, suggestive remarks, and too long hugging left them, quote, confused and
00:01:25 shocked and embarrassed, or as one stated, feeling reduced to being, quote, just a skirt, end quote.
00:01:34 One accuser has related how Cuomo put his hand on her back and asked to kiss her at a wedding
00:01:39 two years ago. These now formulaic expressions of woundedness reminded me of Atlantic Magazine's
00:01:47 writer Tina Dupuis, who alleged in a 2017 article that Senator Al Franklin had once years before
00:01:54 squeezed her waist during a photo op at a Media Matters party and that the squeeze had left her
00:02:00 feeling, quote, no longer a person, end quote. Notwithstanding a few notable exceptions like
00:02:08 black actor Jussie Smollett, who teared up on cue for Good Morning America while discussing his
00:02:15 alleged assault by noose-wielding megamen, the performance of quivering hurt is far more likely
00:02:21 to be used with success by women, and the past few years have brought a plethora of enactments
00:02:28 of feminine fragility. We've seen demands for apologies, declarations of fear and shame, 0.94
00:02:35 and the demand that tales of trauma be believed, all appealing to the in-group empathy of women 0.64
00:02:42 and the chivalric impulses of men. What other than in-group empathy and chivalry can explain
00:02:50 a phenomenon like Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez's stubborn insistence on the implausible trauma 0.66
00:02:57 she suffered during the January 6th storming of the U.S. Capitol building? AOC has outlined
00:03:03 in detail in a video of one and a half hours painfully self-absorbed length how she was
00:03:09 convinced that quote everything was over as she hid in her office waiting for Trump supporters
00:03:16 to come for her and I just hear where is she where is she and um this was the moment where
00:03:26 I thought everything was over. It didn't matter that she was not near the epicenter of unrest and
00:03:38 that the voice she heard that so terrified her was that of a Capitol Police officer rather than
00:03:43 a rioter. One might expect her to hesitate to share her fears once it had been revealed that
00:03:49 she was never really under any threat at all. But instead, AOC doubled down, linking her Capitol
00:03:56 ordeal to her experience years before as an alleged victim of sexual assault. According to
00:04:02 her logic, what actually happened to her in the Capitol complex doesn't really matter, only what
00:04:07 she felt. And anyone who doubts what she felt or doubts her right to use that feeling for political
00:04:13 leverage is someone with contempt for the recurring trauma of survivors like her. What is perhaps most
00:04:21 striking about AOC's hour and a half long video is her very deliberate self-infantilization as she
00:04:29 plays up the non-rational elements of her response. The story is told to the camera as if for the
00:04:35 first time, though of course it was filmed weeks after the event and presumably was much rehearsed,
00:04:41 but there are long pauses while she seems to search for a word or is overcome by emotion
00:04:46 while remembering. This appearance of spontaneity, of in-the-moment visceral intensity is almost
00:04:52 perfectly mastered, and in that sense it is an Oscar-worthy enactment. AOC's voice frequently
00:04:58 trembles with seemingly irrepressible emotion as tears well up in her eyes. Sometimes within a very
00:05:04 short time she moves from near tears to smiles and laughter. At moments she appears lost in thought,
00:05:10 unconscious of the camera, gazing out of the frame as if consumed by feeling, and at other moments
00:05:15 her glances directly to the camera lens inviting soul-to-soul intimacy. The performance is about
00:05:22 as far as could be imagined from the rationality and self-control, and above all the calm strength
00:05:29 that one would traditionally have expected from a politician, from someone responsible for
00:05:34 conducting the nation's business. It's a performance of youth, certainly, and even more so of deep
00:05:41 feminine vulnerability and emotional volatility far more appropriate to a 16-year-old high school
00:05:48 girl than a 31-year-old congressional representative who proposes and votes on federal 0.85
00:05:54 legislation. Such a self-performance, which is certainly not confined to AOC, raises troubling
00:06:02 questions about the impact on public life of women and men to a lesser extent who define themselves
00:06:09 by their experience of trauma and claim authenticity on the basis of powerful feelings allegedly
00:06:16 beyond their control. If AOC can't be counted upon to respond rationally in a moment of minimal or
00:06:26 merely imagined danger, how can she be counted upon to do the people's business at all? Being a member
00:06:33 of the House of Representatives requires tough-mindedness and resilience. Accusations
00:06:38 and personal attacks, though not physical attacks, are a normal part of the job. Hysteria and
00:06:46 overreaction, like accusing Ted Cruz publicly of trying to kill her, these interfere with the focus
00:06:52 and maturity necessary for the work of government. AOC's justification of her fear is quite damning.
00:07:01 She says, quote, when we encounter such a terrifying moment, we respond with the entirety
00:07:07 of our life experience, end quote. In other words, AOC admits that the moment was terrifying
00:07:15 because she couldn't separate her previous experience of alleged assault from her current
00:07:21 perception. And note how glibly she speaks of herself, not as a rational individual in control
00:07:28 of her own responses, but as a member of a predetermined collectivity, in this case,
00:07:34 the identity group Female Survivor. She admits that as a female survivor, she can't help how
00:07:41 she responds to an unsettling situation. This embrace of the hysterical feminine, 0.99
00:07:48 not as a moment of weakness overcome, but as a deliberate strategy, should be a profoundly 0.99
00:07:54 alarming revelation to all who care about the future of Western democracies, because it's
00:08:00 always easy enough for rationality to be lost inadvertently in the midst of heated political
00:08:06 debate. But it's a calamity when it is deliberately rejected. And that's where we're at now,
00:08:13 at a time when women's public tears and professions of fragility have been granted 0.94
00:08:20 unprecedented political power. There have always been women who understood the equivocal power of 0.99
00:08:30 feminine weakness and warned against it. Canadian journalist Sarah Jeanette Duncan, a skeptical
00:08:36 supporter of the women's movement, wrote in the Toronto Globe newspaper as long ago as 1885 about
00:08:43 the double-edged sword of a woman's public tears. They got results, certainly, but they detracted
00:08:50 from the intellectual self-discipline necessary for productive political engagement.
00:08:57 Quote, nothing is more unconsciously dramatic than a woman's outcry against a suffering which
00:09:04 is often hers through no fault of her own, Duncan wrote. But if she asks the ballot by virtue of her
00:09:12 ability to sorrow eloquently, it seems to me that she will be sorely puzzled to know what to do with
00:09:18 it when it is hers. If women wish to be treated as political equals, Duncan advised, they would
00:09:26 have to overcome their reliance on postures of eloquent sorrow. Many of Duncan's feminist 0.98
00:09:34 contemporaries, however, embraced claims of female emotional superiority, alleging that 1.00
00:09:40 maleness was responsible for war, cruelty, and inequality. Widely admired Canadian feminist
00:09:47 Nellie McClung, addressed the question of what she called the new chivalry in her 1915 book
00:09:55 In Times Like These. Quote, people tell us now that chivalry is dead and women have killed it, 1.00
00:10:02 she quipped at the start. She was referring to the idea quite common at the time she wrote that
00:10:07 women's entry into public life would destroy their special status as a protected class.
00:10:13 When the British vessel Titanic sank in April 1912, with enormous loss of life, 74% of the
00:10:23 women on board were rescued as compared to only 20% of the men. Men deliberately stood back,
00:10:30 giving up places on lifeboats and accepting their own deaths so that women could be saved.
00:10:36 They did so in part because they knew that to survive a disaster like the Titanic sinking while
00:10:41 leaving women to drown was to be permanently disgraced. Such was the power of chivalry as a
00:10:47 concept and a living reality in British and North American society. McClung makes no reference to
00:10:54 the Titanic sinking in her discussion of chivalry, though the disaster was very much a recent memory.
00:11:00 She dismissed chivalry as a romantic notion far more honored as an idea than as an actual practice.
00:11:07 Yes, beautiful women have always had an easy time of it, she admitted, but the notion that
00:11:12 women are protected in general was little more than a pretty theory.
00:11:18 And she asserted this at the very time that young men were being maimed and killed by
00:11:23 the hundreds of thousands in the trenches of Europe while some of their female counterparts 0.57
00:11:28 discussed voting rights.
00:11:30 McClung actually had the gall to argue that when women had the right to vote, war itself
00:11:36 would become a thing of the past because war was, in her words, quote, a crime committed by men
00:11:42 that would end when women are allowed to say what they think of war, end quote. Up until now, 0.51
00:11:49 she alleged with a sarcastic dig at chivalry, quote, women have had nothing to say about war 1.00
00:11:55 except to pay the price of it, end quote. According to McClung, what women wanted was justice, 0.99
00:12:02 not chivalry, not men's gallantry, not men's sympathy, but the right to represent their
00:12:08 interests and pursue professional careers in the same way men did. That would be, she said,
00:12:13 a fair deal. Significantly, though, she didn't reject chivalry altogether, saying that, quote,
00:12:20 chivalry is a poor substitute for justice if one cannot have both, end quote. So in the fair
00:12:28 society of McClung's vision, women should have equal rights, but should also have special rights
00:12:34 as women when appropriate. And it turns out that special rights are often deemed appropriate,
00:12:43 perhaps more now, a hundred years after McClung wrote than ever before. The temptation to act
00:12:50 the damsel in distress appears near irresistible. When women occupy positions of political 1.00
00:12:58 power, the media is always ablaze with stories about the feminine qualities they allegedly bring 1.00
00:13:04 to their positions. Their empathy, ability to work collaboratively, communication skills, 1.00
00:13:09 openness, and inclusivity. But one quality conspicuously lacking might be said to be the
00:13:15 ability to resist playing the damsel. Just a couple of examples. In my home province of British
00:13:23 Columbia, the chief health officer is a woman named Bonnie Henry, an unelected official who
00:13:28 has exercised extraordinary and often devastating power during the COVID pandemic, deciding whether
00:13:34 schools could open, which businesses were essential, how many people could gather, and
00:13:39 whether protests were legitimate, all with a soft, quavering voice and endless promises of just a few
00:13:45 more weeks as the axe fell regularly on citizens' freedoms and livelihoods. She has generally been
00:13:53 very popular, her saintly image memorialized in a public mural and a musical ode. But at the first
00:14:01 sign of criticism, the vulnerable damsel emerged onto the public scene. In the middle of the
00:14:08 pandemic last summer, when most people on her advice were isolating in their bubbles,
00:14:13 Henry took part in a panel discussion about women in leadership and made much of her own
00:14:19 suffering, singling out the, quote, death threats, quote, nasty notes, quote, phone calls, and, quote,
00:14:24 harassment she had allegedly received, and suggesting that, quote, people find that it's
00:14:29 okay to do that for a woman who's up front more so than some of our male leaders, though she
00:14:35 followed that with, but I could be wrong. Fortunately for Henry, it doesn't matter whether
00:14:40 female leaders are attacked more often or more viciously than male leaders, actually they're not,
00:14:45 a chorus of chivalric experts are always happy to chime in about women's special suffering, 0.99
00:14:50 and Bonnie Henry, suffering to the tune of $360,000 a year while peons lost their businesses, 0.59
00:14:58 stoked public sympathy even while wasting precious pandemic time appearing on a panel 0.96
00:15:03 to damsel about how hard it is to be her. That's a now standard part of gender politics. Endless 1.00
00:15:11 claims and controversies about sexism, endless rounds of demands for apology, apologies offered,
00:15:17 apologies refused, apologies accepted but criticized as inadequate, and so on. Just a few
00:15:23 weeks ago, Canadian newspapers ignited with inflammatory headlines such as, quote, Ford owes
00:15:29 apology to every woman in Ontario after hurling sexist comment, Horvath says. Readers could be
00:15:35 forgiven for assuming that the Conservative leader of Ontario, Doug Ford, must have said, or rather 0.92
00:15:41 hurled, something outrageous if it required not only an apology to Horvath, the feminist leader
00:15:47 of the Ontario New Democratic Party, but to every one of the millions of women in the province.
00:15:53 It turned out that during a back and forth in the provincial parliament, Ford had said,
00:15:57 it's like listening to nails on a chalkboard listening to you. An extraordinary number of
00:16:03 journalistic words were spent hyperventilating about the alleged misogyny of that outburst and
00:16:09 Horvath couldn't resist the halo it offered her as a deeply wounded but valiant champion of
00:16:15 womankind. Later that day she tweeted out a message to all women advising them, quote,
00:16:21 don't let anyone try to tell you you don't belong at Queen's Park, though there'd been no
00:16:26 suggestion that she didn't belong. Quote, I'm going to continue making positive proposals to
00:16:32 give people the help and hope they need to get through this pandemic. End quote. If she were
00:16:38 really so deeply concerned about constituents affected by the pandemic, she might have thought
00:16:44 it frivolous to waste an entire day fussing about alleged hurt feelings. But that is the nature of
00:16:53 the female politician too often these days, consumed with thoughts of self-narcissistic 1.00
00:16:58 displays, allegations of harm, and demands that others recognize the uniqueness of female 1.00
00:17:05 suffering. The notable confusion in our societies is highlighted every time an allegation of
00:17:13 gendered trauma or a necessity for gendered apology is raised. Do women require kid gloves 0.50
00:17:19 treatment in the public sphere or not? Are their feelings more delicate than men's when it comes to
00:17:25 personal remarks and perception of threat or not? If the answer to these questions is no,
00:17:31 then why do female politicians not say so loud and clear? If the answer is yes, women do require 1.00
00:17:38 kid gloves treatment, then why do we continue to pretend that women today seek equality? 0.99
00:17:43 The fact is that women's ability to demand equality when it suits them, and special treatment when that suits them, is a ridiculous and corrosive distraction. 0.97
00:17:55 Women's claims of victimhood take a great deal of time and energy away from many pressing issues and they create an uneven political playing field in which every man knows he can be wrong-footed and every woman knows she can power-trip if she wants to. 0.93
00:18:11 The damsel option disinclines some women from wholeheartedly pursuing competence because they know they can deflect criticism or gain advancement by sorrowing eloquently, as Sarah Jeanette Duncan said, and it creates bad faith in many women, suspicion and resentment in many men. 0.65
00:18:32 And until it becomes an actual political disability to claim weakness and demand apologies,
00:18:40 our public culture will continue to be held hostage by the damsels among us.