00:12:20chivalry is a poor substitute for justice if one cannot have both, end quote. So in the fair
00:12:28society of McClung's vision, women should have equal rights, but should also have special rights
00:12:34as women when appropriate. And it turns out that special rights are often deemed appropriate,
00:12:43perhaps more now, a hundred years after McClung wrote than ever before. The temptation to act
00:12:50the damsel in distress appears near irresistible. When women occupy positions of political1.00
00:12:58power, the media is always ablaze with stories about the feminine qualities they allegedly bring1.00
00:13:04to their positions. Their empathy, ability to work collaboratively, communication skills,1.00
00:13:09openness, and inclusivity. But one quality conspicuously lacking might be said to be the
00:13:15ability to resist playing the damsel. Just a couple of examples. In my home province of British
00:13:23Columbia, the chief health officer is a woman named Bonnie Henry, an unelected official who
00:13:28has exercised extraordinary and often devastating power during the COVID pandemic, deciding whether
00:13:34schools could open, which businesses were essential, how many people could gather, and
00:13:39whether protests were legitimate, all with a soft, quavering voice and endless promises of just a few
00:13:45more weeks as the axe fell regularly on citizens' freedoms and livelihoods. She has generally been
00:13:53very popular, her saintly image memorialized in a public mural and a musical ode. But at the first
00:14:01sign of criticism, the vulnerable damsel emerged onto the public scene. In the middle of the
00:14:08pandemic last summer, when most people on her advice were isolating in their bubbles,
00:14:13Henry took part in a panel discussion about women in leadership and made much of her own
00:14:19suffering, singling out the, quote, death threats, quote, nasty notes, quote, phone calls, and, quote,
00:14:24harassment she had allegedly received, and suggesting that, quote, people find that it's
00:14:29okay to do that for a woman who's up front more so than some of our male leaders, though she
00:14:35followed that with, but I could be wrong. Fortunately for Henry, it doesn't matter whether
00:14:40female leaders are attacked more often or more viciously than male leaders, actually they're not,
00:14:45a chorus of chivalric experts are always happy to chime in about women's special suffering,0.99
00:14:50and Bonnie Henry, suffering to the tune of $360,000 a year while peons lost their businesses,0.59
00:14:58stoked public sympathy even while wasting precious pandemic time appearing on a panel0.96
00:15:03to damsel about how hard it is to be her. That's a now standard part of gender politics. Endless1.00
00:15:11claims and controversies about sexism, endless rounds of demands for apology, apologies offered,
00:15:17apologies refused, apologies accepted but criticized as inadequate, and so on. Just a few
00:15:23weeks ago, Canadian newspapers ignited with inflammatory headlines such as, quote, Ford owes
00:15:29apology to every woman in Ontario after hurling sexist comment, Horvath says. Readers could be
00:15:35forgiven for assuming that the Conservative leader of Ontario, Doug Ford, must have said, or rather0.92
00:15:41hurled, something outrageous if it required not only an apology to Horvath, the feminist leader
00:15:47of the Ontario New Democratic Party, but to every one of the millions of women in the province.
00:15:53It turned out that during a back and forth in the provincial parliament, Ford had said,
00:15:57it's like listening to nails on a chalkboard listening to you. An extraordinary number of
00:16:03journalistic words were spent hyperventilating about the alleged misogyny of that outburst and
00:16:09Horvath couldn't resist the halo it offered her as a deeply wounded but valiant champion of
00:16:15womankind. Later that day she tweeted out a message to all women advising them, quote,
00:16:21don't let anyone try to tell you you don't belong at Queen's Park, though there'd been no
00:16:26suggestion that she didn't belong. Quote, I'm going to continue making positive proposals to
00:16:32give people the help and hope they need to get through this pandemic. End quote. If she were
00:16:38really so deeply concerned about constituents affected by the pandemic, she might have thought
00:16:44it frivolous to waste an entire day fussing about alleged hurt feelings. But that is the nature of
00:16:53the female politician too often these days, consumed with thoughts of self-narcissistic1.00
00:16:58displays, allegations of harm, and demands that others recognize the uniqueness of female1.00
00:17:05suffering. The notable confusion in our societies is highlighted every time an allegation of
00:17:13gendered trauma or a necessity for gendered apology is raised. Do women require kid gloves0.50
00:17:19treatment in the public sphere or not? Are their feelings more delicate than men's when it comes to
00:17:25personal remarks and perception of threat or not? If the answer to these questions is no,
00:17:31then why do female politicians not say so loud and clear? If the answer is yes, women do require1.00
00:17:38kid gloves treatment, then why do we continue to pretend that women today seek equality?0.99
00:17:43The fact is that women's ability to demand equality when it suits them, and special treatment when that suits them, is a ridiculous and corrosive distraction.0.97
00:17:55Women's claims of victimhood take a great deal of time and energy away from many pressing issues and they create an uneven political playing field in which every man knows he can be wrong-footed and every woman knows she can power-trip if she wants to.0.93
00:18:11The damsel option disinclines some women from wholeheartedly pursuing competence because they know they can deflect criticism or gain advancement by sorrowing eloquently, as Sarah Jeanette Duncan said, and it creates bad faith in many women, suspicion and resentment in many men.0.65
00:18:32And until it becomes an actual political disability to claim weakness and demand apologies,
00:18:40our public culture will continue to be held hostage by the damsels among us.