The Fiamengo File - October 11, 2018


Avital Ronell - TFF Episode 91

Why Can't We Hate Men - TFF episode 84 Feminists Force Cancellation of Professor's Course at Brock University, TFF - 93

Episode Stats


Length

16 minutes

Words per minute

124.04

Word count

2,031

Sentence count

55

Harmful content

Misogyny

3

sentences flagged

Toxicity

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

4

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 What happens when a male former graduate student launches a lawsuit against the
00:00:07 female professor he claims sexually harassed him for years? It isn't pretty,
00:00:14 and it's my subject on today's Fiamengo File.
00:00:18 I'm Janice Fumengo of the University of Ottawa.
00:00:30 The complaint against Professor Avital Ranel offers a case study in female sexual bullying,
00:00:38 academic feminist double standards, and the difficulties for men seeking equal treatment
00:00:44 as victims.
00:00:46 Avital Ronel is a professor of German literature and comparative literature at New York University.
00:00:53 She is a specialist in the post-structuralist and psychoanalytically inflected cultural theory that
00:00:59 literature departments have become known for over the past few decades, which claims to oppose
00:01:05 fascism through verbal obscurity and meaninglessness. In a 2009 interview posted on YouTube,
00:01:14 For example, Ronnell can be found explaining that meaning, quote, has often had very fascisoid, non-progressivist edges, end quote.
00:01:25 I'm very suspicious historically and intellectually of the promise of meaning because meaning has often had very fascisoid, non-progressivist edges, if not a core of that sort of thing.
00:01:43 she claims to disapprove of the quote quick grasp for the transcendental signifier and she claims
00:01:52 to prefer instead the quote arbitrary eruption of something that can't be grasped or explicated
00:01:59 but is just there in this kind of absolute contingency of being it's been very devastating
00:02:07 this um this craving for meaning though it's something with which we are in constant negotiation
00:02:16 everyone wants something like meaning but when you see these dogs play why reduce it to meaning
00:02:25 rather than just see the arbitrary eruption of something that can't be grasped or explicated
00:02:33 but it's just there in this kind of absolute contingency of being.
00:03:03 Since approximately June of 2017, I, along with two other concerned academics, Peter
00:03:10 Boghossian and Helen Pluckrose, have been writing intentionally broken academic papers
00:03:16 and submitting them to highly respected journals in fields that study gender, race, sexuality,
00:03:21 and similar topics.
00:03:22 We did this to expose a political corruption that has taken hold of the university.
00:03:27 By this point, several of these papers have been accepted in highly respected journals,
00:03:31 one that claims that dog humping incidents can be taken as evidence of rape culture
00:03:36 has been officially honored as excellent scholarship. I'm not going to lie to you,
00:03:41 we had a lot of fun with this project. But don't let that lead you to believe that we're not
00:03:54 addressing a serious problem. If you have a few minutes, I'll try to explain.
00:03:58 She also advocates a, quote, politics of refusing that gratification, end quote, meaning the
00:04:07 gratification of meaning. Though, as we will see, her demands for gratification of other sorts
00:04:14 seem to have been unceasing and remorseless. Earlier this year, in May of 2018, Professor
00:04:22 ronnell was found by new york university in a title ix investigation to have sexually harassed
00:04:29 her former phd student nimrod reitman for that she received a one-year suspension the former
00:04:37 student reitman is now launching a civil action against ronnell and new york university in which
00:04:44 he alleges with many supporting documents that for three years Ronell pursued and bullied him
00:04:53 like a pathologically possessive lover, insisting on speaking to him at least every day in lavish
00:05:00 terms of endearment and sexual implication, while also threatening that if he failed to reciprocate
00:05:08 and failed to allow her access to his body and control over his time she would make sure he
00:05:15 never got the career he wanted he claimed she groped and fondled him forced him to touch her
00:05:24 and insisted at times on sleeping in his bed unless ronnell can mount an extremely convincing
00:05:32 defense, the evidence Reitman has provided in the form of email and other messages shows his
00:05:39 former supervisor to have acted like an emotional terrorist, unable to control herself or to act
00:05:46 professionally. Of course, self-control and professionalism are just fascist-oid bourgeois 0.70
00:05:52 ideas based in a non-progressivist transcendental signifying system and lacking arbitrary eruptions.
00:05:59 But seriously, the evidence Reitman has brought forward in his lawsuit is enough to suggest that
00:06:06 Professor Ronell should never supervise a graduate student again. Another former teaching assistant
00:06:12 of Ronell's, Andrea Long Chu, has published an article in the Times Higher Ed magazine to say
00:06:19 that the described behavior is commonplace for Ronell, well known among graduate students at NYU,
00:06:26 and, in fact, not very remarkable in academia as a whole.
00:06:32 In addition, Bernd Hupoff, the former chair of German at NYU,
00:06:37 has written a scathing account of Ronell's totalitarian takeover of the department that hired her,
00:06:43 which he claims she transformed from a respectable literature department into her own bullying fiefdom,
00:06:51 in which anyone who disagreed with her theoretical approach or even failed to show the requisite 1.00
00:06:57 enthusiasm would be rebuked, excluded, and humiliated. Perhaps Ronell's penchant for
00:07:05 power plays explains the response of some of Avital's friends and colleagues, including
00:07:11 gender studies superstar Judith Butler, a group of whom wrote a letter to NYU not only defending
00:07:20 Ronell without knowing the nature of the charges, but also attacking Ronell's accuser, Reitman,
00:07:27 whom they alleged was waging what they called a, quote, malicious campaign. Furthermore,
00:07:32 they argued with predictable but still outrageous elitism that Ronell should be treated differently
00:07:39 from other accused professionals in this kind of situation because she is a, basically, a wonderful
00:07:46 woman with an international reputation they wrote quote we testify to the grace the keen wit and
00:07:51 the intellectual commitment of professor ronnell and ask that she be accorded the dignity rightly
00:07:58 deserved by someone of her international standing and reputation end quote their victim blaming and
00:08:07 perpetrator excusing arguments break every rule in the feminist playbook except the one rule that 0.99
00:08:13 we know governs all. That men are always guilty if accused, but feminist women only very rarely.
00:08:22 A writer for Salon Magazine basically made the same case, claiming laughably that Ronel's real
00:08:28 problem was that she came of age in Paris during the 1970s when sleeping with younger men was a
00:08:34 bohemian thing to do, not an abuse. Ronel is reported to have had an affair with Jacques
00:08:40 Derrida's 16-year-old son when she was a student of Derrida's. The Salon writer actually goes so
00:08:47 far as to declare it a profound sexist injustice that Ronel will now be known not for her
00:08:54 supposedly brilliant writing, but for preying on a young man. The double standards are, of course,
00:09:00 very evident. If a man had done to a young woman what Ronel certainly seems to have done to Nimrod
00:09:06 Reitman, his career would be over. So, so far, so predictable. Unfortunately, the lawsuit also
00:09:15 makes for dismaying reading because of what it reveals about the behavior of Ronel's accuser,
00:09:21 Nimrod Reitman, whom it is difficult to champion as an innocent victim of Ronel. On his very first
00:09:30 meeting with her just after his acceptance as a PhD candidate, but months before he moved to New
00:09:35 York City, Reitman experienced her inappropriate attentions and did next to nothing about it.
00:09:43 The lawsuit states that after they first met at a conference in Israel held in Ronell's honor,
00:09:49 quote, Ronell began calling Reitman on his cell phone and on his parents' home phone in Israel,
00:09:55 often insisting that Reitman speak with her for hours. Though the calls made him uncomfortable,
00:10:01 Reitman did not want to alienate his famous and powerful new doctoral advisor and therefore
00:10:08 participated in them. When Reitman returned to his residence in Berlin, he continued to receive
00:10:15 telephone calls and requests for video calls from Ronell on a near daily basis. The calls would
00:10:22 occur at all times of the day and night with Ronell demanding that Reitman remain on them
00:10:27 for hours, end quote. And it went on and on. Here, we're asked to believe that a 26-year-old man
00:10:38 was so intimidated by this woman's unwanted come-ons that he couldn't extricate himself.
00:10:46 We're asked to believe that he was entirely in her power, even though he was living thousands
00:10:52 of miles away at this point and bound by no legal contract or personal obligation.
00:10:58 It seems he considered only once switching schools but gave up the idea because the person
00:11:04 he would have had to apply to at Yale University was purportedly a close friend of Ronel's.
00:11:10 But Ronel is not close friends with every graduate admissions chairperson in every literature
00:11:17 program in the United States, and there are dozens of reputable schools that Reitman could
00:11:23 have chosen from. He could have made up a family excuse not to come to New York University with
00:11:29 no irreparable damage to his career prospects. Instead, knowing that he was about to embark on
00:11:36 a close relationship with a woman whose behavior was so far out of line as to constitute pathological
00:11:42 obsession. Still, he placed himself entirely in her hands. Throughout the complaint, many excuses
00:11:52 are made for why Reitman continually complied with Ronell's near-daily demands for three long years.
00:12:02 We can only imagine that his friends and family must have begged him to save himself. Once again,
00:12:08 we see the sickness of me too culture in the total abdication of responsibility on the part of the
00:12:17 usually female but in this case male victim the truth is that avital ronnell never had the absolute
00:12:24 power reitman claimed she had but even if she did he always had power to the power to say no
00:12:32 clearly reitman's complaint reveals as we've known all along that women can be at least as abusive
00:12:38 obsessive selfish lacking in empathy and unethical as men are traditionally said to be
00:12:46 but it also reveals in my opinion anyway what happens to men in a feminized and
00:12:53 feministic culture who live by that culture's terms they end up entrapped by the victim myth
00:13:01 and reduced by it one of the most striking aspects of the lawsuit from my perspective
00:13:07 is its observation that the Title IX investigation carried out by New York University did not
00:13:13 use its usual lax standards of evidence when considering whether Ronel sexually assaulted
00:13:21 Reitman. And here's the section in the lawsuit, quote, NYU also determined that because Reitman
00:13:30 did not have corroborating witnesses, there was insufficient evidence to find that Ronel had
00:13:37 engaged in sexual assault by employing such reasoning for its determination and requiring
00:13:43 that sexual assault allegations be corroborated by a third-party witness nyu applied an evidentiary
00:13:49 standard to the complaint of a male victim that has not been employed by the law in new york for
00:13:56 more than 40 years and has never been applied by nyu to the complaints of a female victim end quote
00:14:05 so surprise surprise the title ix investigation employed a higher standard than usual to judge
00:14:13 reitman's complaint because reitman is a man and his alleged abuser was a woman
00:14:18 in most cases no corroboration for a claim of sexual assault is necessary but rather than
00:14:25 objecting to the low standard of evidence the reitman lawsuit wants it lowered for reitman
00:14:32 also. Why should he have to show evidence of sexual assault when women don't have to show evidence?
00:14:38 It's logical enough. But this aspect of the civil action stands as a metaphor for Reitman's case 0.98
00:14:46 as a whole, which is, in my opinion, not really about justice or leveling the playing field. 0.82
00:14:53 It's about lowering the playing field, admitting men into the victim game that women have been 0.77
00:14:59 winning for such a long time but the victim game is a contest for public sympathy that plays into 0.71
00:15:06 women's particular strengths and weaknesses and it's a game that men as a group can only
00:15:12 lose even if individual men may win some of their cases some of the time if reitman wins this case
00:15:20 against ronnell which it seems to me from what i know about the case he should his victory will not
00:15:26 restore sanity maturity personal responsibility or high standards of evidence to universities or
00:15:33 workplaces it will only extend to some men the illusory vindication and seduction of victim
00:15:41 politics we need to say no to the victim game altogether to victim identity and victim assumptions
00:15:50 a massive cultural and personal refusal. Anything less will only lead to more abuse and more lawsuits. 0.63
00:16:20 You