The Fiamengo File - January 20, 2019


Feminists Force Cancellation of Professor's Course at Brock University, TFF - 93

Avital Ronell - TFF Episode 91 Meet The New SJW Physics - TFF Episode 95

Episode Stats


Length

10 minutes

Words per minute

131.54

Word count

1,324

Sentence count

39

Harmful content

Misogyny

4

sentences flagged

Toxicity

2

sentences flagged

Hate speech

1

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 Ontario professor who sexually assaulted his student will no longer be teaching again this
00:00:07 term and students are overjoyed. That's what the headline read in the Narsity, a Toronto area
00:00:15 newspaper for millennials. The story behind the false headline shows how fully universities have
00:00:23 come under the sway of feminist hysteria, and it's my subject on today's Fiumengo File.
00:00:39 I'm Janice Fiumengo of the University of Ottawa. For those of us with short memories,
00:00:44 it might seem like Me Too ushered in a new era, but in fact Me Too-style accusations against men
00:00:52 have been commonplace for years leading to reputations and careers destroyed for the most
00:00:58 minor of perceived offenses against sexual propriety now i say propriety not harassment
00:01:06 or sexual assault because of the extremely trivial nature of the alleged wrongdoing in this
00:01:13 and other cases now in this particular case the man's life as a university professor has been
00:01:20 irrevocably damaged and fanatical students and politically correct media are having a field day
00:01:27 with his public humiliation the professor in question david schimmelpenick is a professor
00:01:35 of history at brock university in saint catherine's ontario and a member of the royal society of
00:01:41 canada before being hired at brock in 1997 professor schimmelpenick worked as a reconnaissance
00:01:47 troop officer for the royal canadian armor corps reserve and as a government financial analyst
00:01:54 as an academic he earned many awards for his internationally respected research he hasn't
00:02:01 taught since 2016 having been found guilty of sexual harassment following an incident in 2014
00:02:09 he was supposed to be allowed back into his classroom for the first time this january 2019
00:02:16 to teach a history class called War and Peace in the Modern Age. But that didn't happen. A few
00:02:24 weeks ago, it was announced that his course would be cancelled as a result of the uproar created
00:02:29 by his announced return to campus. Students at Brock launched a petition and inundated the
00:02:37 university administration with angry letters. They were also planning a campus protest and
00:02:43 even with the news that the class has been canceled, they were still reportedly hoping
00:02:48 to mount some kind of demonstration against Professor Schimmelpenick. These students,
00:02:54 descended it seems from George Orwell's junior anti-sex league, none of whom presumably know
00:03:00 the alleged victim or even many details about what happened on the fateful night in question,
00:03:06 are certain about one thing. This professor should be forced to resign from his position
00:03:13 and should never teach again because his wrongdoing can never be overcome.
00:03:20 One of them is quoted in a news report as saying, quote, when you overstep your boundaries of power,
00:03:27 it's very difficult to step back from that, end quote. Indeed, as we know, in the SJW religion,
00:03:35 there is no atonement possible for the sin of being a man with sexual feelings for women.
00:03:43 And as it happens, Schimelpenick has expressed deep remorse in a detailed, even groveling apology,
00:03:50 saying that he, quote, regrets his past behavior and would undo it and the harm he caused if he
00:03:56 could. As part of his discipline, he has had to take coaching on respectful workplace practices,
00:04:03 and he's had to agree to a set of strict conditions about his on-campus conduct.
00:04:11 But unsurprisingly, none of that has helped him.
00:04:14 He might as well have behaved with the insouciant defiance of J.M. Kutze's main character
00:04:19 in his brilliant novel, Disgrace.
00:04:22 And the same student who told us there was no way back for Schimmelpenick
00:04:26 also felt entitled to comment on the inadequacies of his apology,
00:04:31 saying that, quote, because his statement very heavily focused on his dealings with alcoholism
00:04:38 and maybe having a problem, he wasn't as open to actually admitting the fact that he was found to
00:04:44 have perpetrated sexual violence against a student, end quote. The implication, of course, is that
00:04:51 Schimmel Panik is not only a violent abuser, but a liar who won't admit his culpability, 0.54
00:04:57 who can argue with keeping violent perpetrators out of the classroom but nobody really knows 0.92
00:05:05 aside from shimmel pennock himself his accuser and those people immediately involved in the
00:05:10 investigation what exactly he did that caused his public disgrace and suspension from the classroom
00:05:16 five years ago and it definitely wasn't sexual violence in any sane use of the term newspaper
00:05:25 reports tell us the following. In October of 2014, Shimmel Pennick went drinking at a campus bar with
00:05:33 his students after class. All were of drinking age. After the bar closed, a female student and a male
00:05:41 student went back with him to his office to continue drinking. The male student eventually
00:05:45 left the office and the female stayed on. I assume they were deep into discussion of international
00:05:52 relations or 21st century warfare. Then Professor Schimelpennick ruined the moment by moving to sit
00:06:00 next to the student, likely breaking into an analysis of, I don't know, why the French generals
00:06:06 in 1914 had mistakenly placed so much faith in the Maginot line. At that point, according to the
00:06:11 lawyer who investigated the case, the professor made, quote, an unwelcome sexual advance that
00:06:19 involved, quote, inappropriate and unwelcome physical touching, comments of a sexual nature
00:06:25 and a provocative comment attempting to arrange ongoing intimacy, end quote. Presumably at this
00:06:32 point the student left the office. So that's it. Comments of a sexual nature, an attempt to arrange
00:06:40 ongoing intimacy and, quote, inappropriate and unwelcome physical touching, end quote.
00:06:47 Note that it's physical touching, not sexual touching, a very important distinction here.
00:06:55 Physical touching means that Professor Schimelpenick did something minor enough that neither the
00:07:01 aggrieved student nor the supine university administration nor the lawyer brought in to
00:07:06 adjudicate the case, found it serious enough to be considered and pursued legally as sexual
00:07:12 assault, which in Canadian law can include almost any kind of sexual touching. Professor
00:07:19 Schimelpenick, in other words, did not sexually assault this girl. He made the mistake of thinking
00:07:26 that a young woman who liked him enough to come to his office after bar closing time and to stay
00:07:32 even after her male friend left was interested in him which i dare say she must have been otherwise
00:07:38 her behavior makes no sense at all there is no suggestion that after she rejected his advance he
00:07:46 kept on trying or was in any way aggressive or threatening or even ungentlemanly
00:07:54 the incident shows how completely divorced from reality the public discussion about female
00:08:01 safety on university campuses has become and how extreme the punishments are for men who put even
00:08:08 a toe over the line numerous reports and op-eds about this incident use the words sexual violence
00:08:18 and survivors over and over again with one commentator the support services coordinator
00:08:24 at the university claiming that quote there is a desperate need for more funding and resources
00:08:30 at brock to prevent violence and support survivors end quote this was not a case of sexual violence
00:08:39 this was a case of an older man infatuated with a younger woman he thought with some reason liked
00:08:46 him he didn't target and pursue her without believing he had been encouraged and to pretend
00:08:53 that his mild advance constituted an act of violence or represents a threat to other female
00:09:00 students is to vastly overstate the case. Moreover, the viciousness of Schimmel-Pennock's
00:09:08 persecutors and the manner in which the university administration and other commentators give them
00:09:15 cover by pretending that safety is at issue are frankly nauseating and make it impossible for me 0.74
00:09:22 to say, as I'm supposed to say at this point, that feminism harms women by infantilizing them. 1.00
00:09:29 Let's dispense with that politically correct claptrap. This is not infantilization. This is 1.00
00:09:39 deification, the making of women into goddesses whom no male mortal can approach without their
00:09:46 permission upon pain of essentially reputational death. And yes, it does damage women, not by
00:09:55 robbing them of their power, but by bloating them with it, turning them grotesque and cruel. 0.99