The Fiamengo File - February 06, 2019


Meet The New SJW Physics - TFF Episode 95

Feminists Force Cancellation of Professor's Course at Brock University, TFF - 93 The TERF War - The Fiamengo File Episode 96

Episode Stats


Length

23 minutes

Words per minute

130.81

Word count

3,072

Sentence count

97

Harmful content

Misogyny

5

sentences flagged

Toxicity

4

sentences flagged

Hate speech

12

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 While people like me were consoling ourselves that the physical sciences were immune to
00:00:07 the social justice takeover of academia, guess what happened?
00:00:12 The SJWs took over the physical sciences.
00:00:16 And that's my subject on today's Phyomingo File.
00:00:21 I'm Janice Fiomingo of the University of Ottawa.
00:00:32 Last fall saw a public statement by the SJW faith group Particles for Justice, which attacked
00:00:41 Professor Alessandro Strumia because at a conference of the European Organization for
00:00:46 nuclear research, he showed with hard data that women are not discriminated against in physics.
00:00:54 Fast on its heels, another social justice petition circulated in the physics and astronomy
00:01:00 community, and although it did not personally attack an attempt to ruin a fellow scientist for
00:01:06 telling the truth, it is just as jaw-dropping, in my opinion, as the anti-Strumia diatribe.
00:01:14 And by the way, a young person working in the field of physics has set up an excellent website
00:01:20 analyzing the studies cited by the Particles for Justice, showing how very thin their claimed
00:01:28 scientific backing was. And I encourage everyone to take a look at it. The link is in the low bar.
00:01:34 Well, by now, strumia is old news and the fevered mob has moved on to other causes.
00:01:39 One of the more recent petitions includes a denunciation of the move by the Trump administration's
00:01:46 Department of Health and Human Services to define gender biologically. Such a move,
00:01:52 according to the petition's framers, is an act of erasure of transgender, non-binary, genderqueer,
00:01:58 and intersex individuals and must be opposed even by physicists not living in the United States and
00:02:04 even by those living in countries, Mexico, for example, where trans and non-binary people have
00:02:10 far fewer protections and recognition than they have in Trump's America. All scientists were
00:02:16 urged to sign a, quote, letter of solidarity with LGBTQIA plus folks, end quote.
00:02:26 The letter states in part as follows.
00:02:29 as a community of scientists we contest that defining a person's sex or gender is grounded
00:02:37 in science or is objective we affirm that both gender and sex are not determined at birth
00:02:45 not defined by genitals or genetics and not exclusively binary furthermore the institution
00:02:53 of science, particularly the field of genetics, has a long history of being used to justify the
00:03:00 infliction of violence on marginalized communities. This is an extraordinary statement, and not only 0.83
00:03:08 in its insistence that sex is not defined by genitals or genes. The statement is also surrounded
00:03:14 by dark warnings about the violence being done or about to be done to gender non-conforming people
00:03:20 in Trump's America, who are, according to the petitioners, slated for inhuman treatment by 0.97
00:03:25 Trump and his evil henchmen. It's a now typical, overheated, far-left declaration to which all
00:03:32 practicing physicists and astronomers are expected to affirm their fealty. But what is even more
00:03:38 extraordinary is the petition's willing surrender of the role of science in determining the truth
00:03:44 of nature. What is science good for if it is not at all objective and not capable of grounding
00:03:51 understanding of the phenomenal world? The petition authors give us their answer implicitly
00:03:57 in their statement about the history of science, which they claim, forget the moon landing and the
00:04:03 combustion engine and the polio vaccine, which they claim has been primarily oppressive,
00:04:08 associated, as they say, with, quote, the infliction of violence on marginalized communities,
00:04:13 End quote. By implication, therefore, the most significant objective of science today is not
00:04:19 doing science, but bringing justice to the oppressed. And if that sounds biblical,
00:04:26 that's because it is. As others have pointed out before me, this is essentially a religious 0.86
00:04:32 movement that is taking over science, and it is one gaining many converts. In the particular case
00:04:37 I just mentioned, hundreds of physics and astronomy professors and students, 694 to be
00:04:44 precise, signed a petition affirming that sex is not determined at birth and cannot be scientifically
00:04:52 known, and they suggested that only by standing in solidarity with marginalized communities can
00:04:58 scientists save science from its intolerable history of violence. So how did we get to the
00:05:05 point that scientists stopped believing in the ability of science to arrive at reliable
00:05:11 assessments of physical reality it's an extraordinary story and not one obviously
00:05:16 that can be told in a single video but i want to look at some examples specifically from the
00:05:21 history of physics which is one of the disciplines one might have thought most immune to social
00:05:28 justice fanaticism. Now, there have been calls, at least since the 1990s, to change the nature
00:05:35 of physics teaching in order to make it more socially just by attracting more women and
00:05:42 racial minorities. In a 2003 article published in the feminist journal Signs called Has Feminism 1.00
00:05:49 Changed Physics, Professor Amy Graves of Swarthmore College approved the introduction of various 0.99
00:05:57 collaborative learning and student-led teaching methods to make physics more female friendly
00:06:04 these included peer instruction in which students interact in small groups and either
00:06:09 agree on an answer or agree to disagree and something called inquiry based physics in
00:06:17 which students construct their own knowledge in small groups according to professor graves
00:06:23 these were a promising beginning, though far from adequate in themselves, to move physics in a 0.99
00:06:30 feminist direction. Interestingly, the author of the article was not concerned that these kinds
00:06:37 of initiatives revealed a notable willingness to water down the content of physics instruction
00:06:43 through enormously time-wasting and often counterproductive group efforts, nor did she
00:06:48 consider that the changes to physics education that she was advocating almost certainly made
00:06:54 the subject less attractive to the brainy, introverted male nerds who loved physics
00:07:00 precisely because it had nothing to do with feminine activities like agreeing to disagree,
00:07:07 but too bad for them. For Professor Graves, involving more women and non-whites in physics 1.00
00:07:13 would transform the discipline in a positive way, no rationale provided, and this has remained the
00:07:21 uncontested axiom of all social justice activism in physics since then. If we fast forward a few
00:07:30 years, we can see how the social justice agenda became more aggressive and more explicitly
00:07:37 anti-scientific as the faith spread and its apostles became bolder. Back in 2003, Amy Graves
00:07:47 wanted physics teaching to be changed to attract people otherwise not very interested in doing
00:07:53 physics, but at least she assumed that what would be taught would be some version of physics,
00:07:59 even if a far less rigorous one. Not so a later pedagogical reformer named Moses Rifkin, a physics
00:08:07 teacher at an elite school called University Prep High School in Seattle, Washington.
00:08:13 Some years ago, Rifkin put together a six-day program to introduce social justice into the
00:08:19 teaching of physics, and it has proven attractive to progressive schools across the United States.
00:08:25 I was contacted a few years ago by a parent at a Chicago high school whose son was being taught a
00:08:31 week-long social justice physics curriculum in the ninth grade based on Rifkin's outline and a
00:08:38 detailed synopsis of that outline can be found online so i strongly encourage everyone to
00:08:43 consult it and see for yourself what is being taught as physics in some progressive schools
00:08:50 now the creator of this social justice unit for physics is pretty upfront that the material he
00:08:57 is presenting in his physics classroom has nothing to do with physics and that it sprang from his
00:09:03 personal frustration that as a science teacher he was not as able as he imagined his colleagues in
00:09:10 english or history were to bring what he calls moral issues i.e ideology into the classroom but
00:09:17 he overcame this limitation by affirming that in his words as science teachers we have to take an
00:09:25 active role in undoing the bias in our society. I'm not sure how Rifkin would defend his assertion
00:09:33 that it is not only desirable but even necessary, morally necessary, for someone like himself with
00:09:42 no proven competence in history or moral philosophy or anything else to impose his
00:09:47 personal views on a captive audience of young people and in the meantime neglect the teaching
00:09:52 he was hired to do, but it's obvious from reading the curriculum that Rifkin feels no need to
00:09:58 justify himself. Why bother to teach about Newton's laws of motion when it's a lot more exhilarating
00:10:05 to denounce them as white supremacist heteropatriarchal constructs? Rifkin uses the
00:10:11 lack of well-known black physicists in the United States as his launching point for teaching about
00:10:19 systemic discrimination, and he makes it clear that his analysis can be applied to other
00:10:24 underrepresented groups in physics, such as Muslims or women, for example. His project is
00:10:31 to have students, quote, reflect on how racism affects achievement in science. The answer,
00:10:38 already determined in advance by Rifkin, of course, is that Blacks don't do physics because 0.93
00:10:43 in various ways they are excluded or denied the opportunity or made to feel it isn't for them. 0.65
00:10:51 Whites, on the other hand, are overrepresented in physics because of their social privilege 0.76
00:10:56 and race-based measures are necessary to address the inequality. Now, Rifkin uses the word
00:11:03 discussion when he describes his unit, but it's pretty clear from his outline that the students
00:11:08 are not so much to discuss as to be led by Rifkin to his politically correct conclusions.
00:11:15 His discussion questions include such question-begging howlers as, quote, 0.86
00:11:21 how can it be white people's fault that black people don't want to do physics?
00:11:27 And in what ways have we been the recipients of unearned advantage? End quote. In order to help 0.91
00:11:35 his students arrive at the conclusion that, quote, many of them have been given advantages
00:11:41 that they didn't earn themselves. Yes, he is going to take it that far in the blaming direction.
00:11:48 In order to get there, Rifkin provides the students with some programmatic sociological 0.56
00:11:54 material, such as professor of sociology Peggy McIntosh's now somewhat famous outline of white
00:12:01 privilege, which she defines as, quote, an invisible package of unearned assets that whites
00:12:10 can conveniently remain oblivious to. And because they're oblivious, that's why denying that one has
00:12:17 white privilege is actually proof that one has it. Rifkin also uses something called the Speak Up
00:12:24 Pledge by the Southern Poverty Law Center, which, as many of you know, is a smear organization that
00:12:31 applies the label of hate to any ideas that deviate from its far-left platform. It's clear
00:12:39 from Rifkin's description that he does not teach his students how to question the methodologies
00:12:45 and assumptions of the sources. He simply gives the students anti-white propaganda and pressures
00:12:52 them to accept it in the name of making physics and society as a whole more inclusive. At a few
00:13:00 points in the syllabus outline, Rifkin admits that at times he forces conclusions on the students,
00:13:07 but he sees this as a matter of technique, something he can learn to do more adeptly.
00:13:13 He mentions, for example, that on the day he tries to move them from seeing racism as
00:13:17 individual acts of meanness to seeing it as a systemic phenomenon. He says, quote,
00:13:23 I often just end up telling students that their definitions are incomplete and that they need to
00:13:30 broaden them out i'm still trying to find a way to help them see that for themselves end quote
00:13:38 yeah it's tough when one can't simply control how one's students think altogether but rifkin
00:13:44 is committed to sharpening his methods of ideological coercion the fact that rifkin has
00:13:52 his students sign a pledge designed by the southern poverty law center which he then
00:13:58 posts outside the classroom, makes very clear that this teaching unit has everything to do with 0.51
00:14:05 shaming white students to accept that they have an unfair advantage in life. And Rifkin tells us
00:14:15 outright that by the end of the unit, he hopes to convince his students that, quote, not taking
00:14:20 action as an ally is to perpetuate the problem, end quote. So unless his white male students
00:14:28 agree to promote underrepresented minorities and women ahead of themselves,
00:14:35 they will know that their teacher considers them, quote,
00:14:38 part of the problem of unjust discrimination.
00:14:41 It's quite a trip to lay on a group of young people
00:14:44 who thought they were signing on to learn about the nature of the physical world.
00:14:49 Now, I don't know whether any parent has ever objected
00:14:54 to Rifkin's use of the physics classroom to brainwash his students. A quick glance at his
00:14:59 Twitter output suggests that some four years after posting about his unit online, he's still a
00:15:05 happy warrior, far more interested in allyship than in physics. And of course, he's not alone,
00:15:13 as cases such as the Strumia affair suggest Moses Rifkin is one committed soldier in a mass army
00:15:21 marching to save the world, with the rest of us mostly standing to the side, rightly afraid of
00:15:27 getting run over. Another example. In the same year that Rifkin posted his social justice physics
00:15:35 curriculum, scientists at the 2015 annual conference of the International Centre for
00:15:41 Radio Astronomy Research, held in Western Australia, were treated to a range of social
00:15:47 justice acknowledgments and exhortations that would have warmed Mr. Rifkin's heart. First came
00:15:55 an acknowledgement at the very start of proceedings of Indigenous sovereignty over the land where the
00:16:02 conference was taking place, and of the respect owed to Indigenous ways of knowing. After that
00:16:10 came an opening plenary talk by one Malcolm Fialho, the Senior Diversity Officer of the
00:16:17 University of Western Australia. The subject of Fialho's talk before this gathering of
00:16:23 high-level astronomy researchers was not just the unbearable whiteness, but the entire
00:16:29 quote, white, heterosexual, Anglo-Christian, cisgender, male privilege of astronomy.
00:16:34 me. Here was a fully orthodox statement of the intersectional feminist creed. One eyewitness
00:16:42 reported on Fialho's teaching as follows, quote, after reminding us how we male astronomers cannot
00:16:50 even begin to understand the constant state of fear felt by women and people of color in astronomy
00:16:56 departments every day, the diversity officer instructed the audience to pair up in male-female
00:17:03 couples. Each couple was told to read, acknowledge, and discuss a list of 29 white male privileges.
00:17:12 A few male astronomers, randomly chosen from the audience, were then asked to stand up and
00:17:17 publicly confess instances of their privilege. It all looks straight out of a Maoist textbook.
00:17:25 And yet, the attendee noted, some male astronomers enjoyed being shamed.
00:17:33 Nothing gives more pleasure to committed leftist academics than to openly proclaim their shame
00:17:40 for their gender, social class, religion, skin color, and nationality,
00:17:45 because feeling ashamed is a sign of moral superiority.
00:17:49 End quote.
00:17:51 Mr. Fialo, obviously a Peggy McIntosh of white privilege fame, obviously a Peggy McIntosh disciple,
00:18:00 also pointed out that those who couldn't think of any examples of their privilege were likely the
00:18:06 most privileged with their privilege so entrenched they couldn't even see it.
00:18:11 So there we have it. Indoctrination of the youth, rituals of conformity for the professoriate,
00:18:18 and the mob-shaming of anyone who fails to conform, such as a Strumia or a James Damore.
00:18:27 And in case these are insufficient, a new gatekeeping mechanism has recently been introduced,
00:18:33 the diversity statement now required of academic job applicants designed to probe applicants'
00:18:41 ideological allegiances. The University of Wisconsin-Madison, for example,
00:18:46 is advertising a position in astronomy astrophysics, and it contains the usual
00:18:52 rubric strongly encouraging, quote, women and candidates from member groups traditionally
00:18:59 underrepresented in the field of astronomy. But in addition to that, and in addition to providing
00:19:05 their CV, bibliography, and statement of research interests, applicants must now include, quote,
00:19:12 a one-page statement describing how the applicant plans to foster an inclusive and diverse
00:19:21 research and learning environment. A friend of mine who inquired about this job was told that
00:19:29 such diversity statements are now being requested at all top-tier academic institutions, and believe
00:19:37 you me, simply stating that one judges all people solely on the quality of their work will not be
00:19:45 sufficient. One will be required to profess one's faith in the new theology, white heteronormative 0.79
00:19:50 cisgendered male privilege, female disadvantage, unconscious bias, systemic discrimination,
00:19:57 the violent history of science, the scourge of sexual harassment, the need for safe spaces,
00:20:02 and the path to restitution. Anyone who thought it might still be possible to keep one's head down
00:20:09 and avoid the politics will soon realize that being apolitical is no longer an option. The SJW
00:20:18 priest caste has grown tired of irritating debates about merit, that dog whistle of the far right,
00:20:27 and this is the next stage in the great purge of heretics. Now I've used religious language 0.52
00:20:35 throughout this video, not as a slur on religious believers, but to signal that the deep enthusiasm
00:20:42 with which SJW terminology and practice have been welcomed into physics and related disciplines
00:20:51 represents the routing of the Enlightenment philosophy by a new dogmatic belief system
00:20:57 complete with its own mystical faith and its own concepts of original sin and necessary
00:21:04 self-sacrifice. The triumph of this new worldview suggests that the scientific atheists who attacked
00:21:12 Christian evangelicalism with glee, and who still do, weren't quite as comfortable with the rejection
00:21:20 of faith, as they often claimed. The great God of equality and the virtue of, quote,
00:21:26 conspicuous compassion, as Alan Bloom called it, proved far more seductive than many could
00:21:33 have imagined. In a few short years, all facets of academic physics have been transformed under
00:21:41 the new aegis. There have been masses of taxpayer-funded diversity initiatives, including
00:21:47 conferences and workshops and mentorship programs and female-only panels, fellowships, research
00:21:54 opportunities, and even female-only academic positions. There have been constant surveys of 0.99
00:22:00 the climate for women and racial minorities, always with the discovery that gender and racial 1.00
00:22:06 harassment and discrimination are much worse than previously understood or admitted, always with the
00:22:12 conclusion that more needs to be done to diversify the field and to attract women and racial
00:22:19 minorities. There have been stellar careers cut short by non-criminal allegations of so-called
00:22:26 harassment, and there have been scientific mediocrities elevated to positions of influence
00:22:32 who make their careers out of promoting the diversity doctrine rather than actually doing
00:22:37 science. And through it all, there has been and will continue to be the remorseless hounding
00:22:43 of anyone who objects or expresses less than enthusiastic adherence to every and all of the
00:22:50 priorities, policies, and protocols of the project to make physics SJW compliant.
00:22:57 And meanwhile, in China, Japan, South Korea, and India, physicists are doing physics, leaving the West behind.
00:23:27 You 0.60