The Fiamengo File - February 16, 2019


The TERF War - The Fiamengo File Episode 96

Meet The New SJW Physics - TFF Episode 95 Tonic Masculinity, Building a better world since 10,000 BC - TFF 97

Episode Stats


Length

20 minutes

Words per minute

129.46

Word count

2,688

Sentence count

62

Harmful content

Misogyny

31

sentences flagged

Toxicity

8

sentences flagged

Hate speech

6

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 In the war between the radical feminists and the radical trans activists, it's pertinent
00:00:07 to note that no matter who they're fighting, the radical feminists cannot let go of their
00:00:13 anti-male prejudice. 1.00
00:00:15 And that's my subject on today's Fiumingo File.
00:00:28 janice fumingo of the university of ottawa recently a long brewing antagonism has flared into open
00:00:36 warfare dramatically signaled by the permanent twitter ban of megan murphy the editor of
00:00:43 feminist currents online magazine and an andrea dworkin style radical feminist until fairly
00:00:51 recently murphy was best known for her unapologetic bigotry against men as expressed in articles such 1.00
00:00:59 as her october 6 2018 piece titled what will it take to have an honest conversation about the root
00:01:08 of men's sadism the first sentence of which is quote hello and welcome to this week's edition
00:01:16 of what the ever-loving is wrong with men as her supporters like to mention megan's got a
00:01:24 great sense of humor in this article she argues on the basis of a very few sensational stories
00:01:31 and a lot of fact-free conjecture that sexual sadism amongst men is rampant and is not only
00:01:40 ignored but actually condoned in our society. Such un-nuanced anti-male positions have been
00:01:48 Murphy's stock in trade for years. A few years ago, in January of 2016, Murphy wrote a modest
00:01:56 proposal titled, It's Time to Consider a Curfew for Men, referring to the Cologne New Year's Eve
00:02:04 incident, but conveniently neglecting to mention that the hundreds of men who gathered to harass
00:02:10 and assault women outside of the Cologne Cathedral in Germany on New Year's Eve were Muslim men,
00:02:17 mostly recent immigrants, she asked why all men, having, quote, proven time and time again that
00:02:24 they cannot, will not leave women alone, should, quote, be permitted to move about freely in the
00:02:31 world it was all in good fun of course to make her point that genuine solutions such as more rigorous
00:02:39 prosecution of men who rape have been neglected for too long last summer murphy featured an article
00:02:47 in her magazine by british radical feminist julie bindell about valerie solanus much celebrated 0.97
00:02:55 american feminist foremother best known for her scum manifesto scum being the acronym for the 1.00
00:03:03 society for cutting up men solanus is also famous for attempting to murder andy warhol 0.99
00:03:12 bindell's article on solanus is titled scum manifesto is your perfect summer vacay read
00:03:20 and it encouraged readers to quote bone up on your righteous man-hating this summer by rereading 0.96
00:03:27 feminist classic scum manifesto applauding solanus's call to destroy the male sex bindell 0.95
00:03:36 enthused about women's rage quote what i love about this book is how it promotes straightforward 0.98
00:03:44 man hating blaming men for the ills of the world is underrated women have been under siege for
00:03:50 centuries and resistance feels exhilarating whether in the form of waving placards or
00:03:56 reading radical statements about feminist fight back yes it's hard to believe this isn't parody
00:04:04 but trust me it isn't one of the benefits of radical feminism is that you get to refer
00:04:10 constantly to your hatred of men but if anyone calls you on it you can exclaim with indignation 0.97
00:04:17 that of course feminists don't hate men even though they have every justification for doing so 0.96
00:04:26 in the past few years both julie bindell and megan murphy have been denounced as turfs or trans 0.94
00:04:34 exclusionary radical feminists and this has led to the de-platforming and social mobbing that most
00:04:42 men's issues advocates know all about murphy as i already mentioned has been banned from twitter 1.00
00:04:50 for tweeting that a man is not a woman in the wake of which she has emerged as a defender of freedom
00:04:57 of speech and hailed by many non-feminists as a champion of common sense reality i fully support
00:05:05 megan murphy's free speech rights and i believe the idea that she should be banned from twitter
00:05:11 for harassing trans activists and engaging in so-called hate speech is ludicrous but i must
00:05:19 admit that my heart does not bleed for murphy and her feminist friends at the base of the radical
00:05:26 feminist insistence that men can never be women is not concern for biological truth which feminists
00:05:33 have denied for years, but an unquenchable anti-male prejudice. The story of the war
00:05:42 between the radical feminists and the trans activists is a story of erstwhile allies who
00:05:48 now find themselves at loggerheads over the category woman. On one side are those who believe
00:05:54 that women born as women constitute a distinct oppressed class that is rightly the exclusive
00:06:00 focus of feminist activism and to include in the category woman those who merely identify as women
00:06:07 no matter how sincerely felt weakens they believe the moral coherence and political efficacy of 0.85
00:06:15 feminism. On the other side of the divide are those some who consider themselves feminists
00:06:20 others specifically identifying as trans activists who reject the idea of sex as a
00:06:26 biological category and believe that gender identity, what one feels deeply about one's
00:06:32 gendered self, should take precedence in all contexts and that the exclusion of trans women 0.61
00:06:37 from the category of women in feminist activism is an act of oppression as an unjust as any
00:06:44 oppression exercised by men over women. Right now, it may be fair to say that the trans activists
00:06:51 are winning the battle. In recent months, a number of trans woman athletes have achieved success in
00:06:58 high-level sports competitions, beating out born female competitors. A notorious case 1.00
00:07:05 involved Rachel McKinnon, a trans woman and an assistant professor of philosophy at Charleston
00:07:11 College in South Carolina, who won the gold medal at the World Championship of Women's
00:07:16 Track Bicycling. The female athlete who came third in the race went public about the injustice,
00:07:24 but most of the articles I've found on the subject have made the claim that it is fair
00:07:28 for trans women to compete against women born as women and that trans women do not have an
00:07:33 advantage because hormone treatments neutralize men's larger muscle mass, bone density, and oxygen
00:07:39 intake abilities. In legal terms, the trans movement has made significant advances recently.
00:07:48 Most Western nations now recognize trans women as women. Canada has made gender identity a
00:07:54 prohibited ground of discrimination. Many nations are considering or have already removed sex from
00:08:02 identity cards such as birth certificates. Many schools have made admission to toilets, 0.93
00:08:07 change rooms, sports teams, etc. entirely dictated by gender self-identification,
00:08:14 and those who object to these various practices are routinely dismissed as transphobic.
00:08:21 It may well be that the trans movement is the first social movement of the late 20th and early
00:08:28 21st centuries that the feminist movement has not relatively seamlessly accommodated or even
00:08:35 co-opted. Gay liberation, Black Lives Matter, Indigenous resistance, and Islam, all of these
00:08:43 have presented challenges, some of them fundamental to feminist ideology, but all have been absorbed
00:08:48 under the intersectional feminist umbrella as white heterosexual feminists at first grudgingly, 1.00
00:08:55 then pretty enthusiastically, made room for other categories of oppression, even when these forced 1.00
00:09:03 them to confess their privilege or to surrender some portion of their outraged authority it may
00:09:11 be that the trans movement will also ultimately be accommodated at the present time however
00:09:17 the trans insistence that womanhood is an identity some men can claim is causing seismic convulsions
00:09:27 Even the most seemingly reasonable feminists tend to betray their dislike of men. And to 0.76
00:09:36 make this case, I want to focus here on an article published recently in the magazine
00:09:41 Quillette by an author named Helen Joyce. Now, Quillette, as most of you know, is a high-quality
00:09:49 centrist journal dedicated to exploring ideas that most progressive or leftist magazines won't touch.
00:09:55 So it is especially interesting that even here and in an otherwise excellent article,
00:10:02 feminist bigotry is given free reign.
00:10:06 The article has the provocative title, The New Patriarchy,
00:10:11 How Trans Radicalism Hurts Children, Women, and Trans People Themselves.
00:10:18 Notice that men aren't mentioned as subjects deserving of concern.
00:10:22 they just don't count much with Ms. Joyce. Much of the article consists of a rational discussion
00:10:29 of legitimate issues, but it also vividly puts on display the two fatal flaws of feminist ideology, 0.99
00:10:39 its reflex hostility to men and its inability to take responsibility for its own errors and 0.99
00:10:47 inconsistencies the author does a great job of discussing how relatively quickly the idea of
00:10:55 gender identity which she defines as a kind of quasi-mystical inner essence has become more
00:11:01 important than any other factor including genitals and chromosomes in determining sex this has as she
00:11:09 argues worrying implications for public health policy especially in cases where children at
00:11:16 very young ages are being encouraged by their teachers to question their gender identity and
00:11:22 parents and doctors are being pressured to provide affirmation body-altering hormone treatments and
00:11:30 even surgery to very young people the author raises good questions not only about the long-term
00:11:36 effects of such medical interventions but also about the moral implications of allowing children
00:11:41 to make such radical and often irreversible decisions about their lives.
00:11:47 But when the author comes to the specific harms to women of the transgender movement,
00:11:54 her evidence is much thinner and her feminist paranoia, as I see it, quite unmistakable.
00:12:03 She looks at various instances of aggressive trans women who have invaded female-only spaces 0.98
00:12:11 and use the power of the state or the threat of lawsuits to demand their admittance over
00:12:16 the objections of some women. 0.57
00:12:18 And here she raises valid concerns.
00:12:20 I don't happen to agree that they're as clear-cut as she suggests, but I don't have time to
00:12:24 discuss all of the details.
00:12:27 But what is most relevant for my argument is the author's peculiar insistence that
00:12:33 all of these are examples of women being oppressed by a male-dominated society.
00:12:40 So wedded is Helen Joyce to this feminist framework, in which all social relations are
00:12:47 male-dominated, that she cannot let go of that model, even when it bears really no relation
00:12:53 to the conditions she's describing. 0.95
00:12:56 The last thing most trans women want to do is oppress other women.
00:13:01 Trans women want, in general, to be women, and this has nothing whatsoever to do with
00:13:07 patriarchy. If anything, one could argue that the present situation that disturbs Helen Joyce
00:13:15 would have been impossible if not for feminist theory and activism, which long ago asserted
00:13:22 that gender was socially determined and that even biological sex itself couldn't be conceived 1.00
00:13:29 outside of the social realm. Feminists have for decades argued that most or even all differences 1.00
00:13:37 between men and women, certainly any that might be used to justify traditional gender arrangements or
00:13:43 keep women out of male-only spheres, were patriarchal constructs and could be explained
00:13:48 away by some social factors. Anyone who objected to the feminist demand that firefighting, just for 1.00
00:13:56 one example, be open to women was told in no uncertain terms that claims about men's superior
00:14:01 your strength were unsupported by scientific evidence. Therefore, it is ironic, to say the
00:14:08 least, to see a feminist developing a new respect for what science and common sense tell us about
00:14:16 male-female differences. Helen Joyce in the article now wants to defend the biological basis 1.00
00:14:24 of women's oppression, which is why she states that, quote, defining womanhood as based on a 0.99
00:14:30 feeling rather than anatomy is incompatible with a feminist position that women are oppressed
00:14:37 because they are physically weaker than men and bear the entire burden of reproduction, end quote. 1.00
00:14:44 Well, we'll leave aside the patently ridiculous assertion that women bear the entire burden of
00:14:50 reproduction in a culture where a man can find himself compelled by the state on penalty of 0.75
00:14:56 imprisonment to provide financial support over decades to children he may have never wanted to
00:15:03 father and with whom he may have no relationship at all, depending on the inclination of the mother.
00:15:08 Let's look at that first assertion about women being oppressed because they are physically 0.64
00:15:14 weaker than men. Seems pretty simple. And I agree that on average, women are physically weaker than 1.00
00:15:19 men. And I would in fact argue that much of what is now seen as oppression from the past was
00:15:24 actually an attempt to protect women because they were weaker than men but one would be hard pressed
00:15:31 to find many feminists today who would state blatantly that women are weaker rather feminists 1.00
00:15:38 today tend to argue that the category woman is socially created through the oppression of some 0.99
00:15:45 beings who are perceived as weaker and that women's weakness is the result not the cause
00:15:54 of patriarchal domination. So, in other words, feminists created a way of describing gender 1.00
00:16:02 relations predicated on denying the reality of biology, and they're now outraged when denial 1.00
00:16:10 of biology works against some feminist positions. The related point in the article that's hard not
00:16:19 to notice is its clear anti-male animus from the title on down helen joyce identifies as a woman
00:16:30 possessed of an ingrained dislike of men and much of her discomfort with trans women comes from the
00:16:37 fact that she sees them as the enemy for whom she has spent a lifetime feeling no empathy her
00:16:45 repressed hostility is made obvious when she quotes one of her sources to the effect that quote
00:16:53 trans activism is also unusual in that it gives men a chance to claim they are oppressed compared
00:17:02 with women and plenty of opportunity to tell women to shut up end quote ah there we have it
00:17:11 that's what is so intolerable about the trans movement that it's no longer women claiming to
00:17:19 be oppressed and telling men to shut up which women have been doing for decades and it sure 0.72
00:17:25 felt good until the same strategy was turned on them that's why the article is called the new
00:17:33 patriarchy because this author cannot relinquish the idea that our society is set up to disempower
00:17:41 women even though this article is about people who don't want to be men and want to join women
00:17:48 and live as women which is the opposite of what radical feminists have always said of patriarchal
00:17:55 men whom feminists argued hated and feared women. For Helen Joyce, anything hurtful or wrong in
00:18:05 society must be patriarchal because patriarchy has become a shorthand for anything a woman doesn't 0.99
00:18:13 like in the world. Helen Joyce is also outraged that some women have been silenced, banned from 0.97
00:18:21 platforms are prevented from gathering to discuss their concerns about trans activism. Now, I agree
00:18:27 with her that this is wrong, but she is seemingly oblivious to the fact, or maybe she's simply
00:18:34 unconcerned, that men and some women have been silenced, banned from platforms, or prevented
00:18:40 from gathering to discuss their concerns about feminist activism for decades. And with the same
00:18:47 rationale, now being used to exclude TERFs, that their words supposedly are violence.
00:18:55 Helen Joyce even has the gall to quote one of her sources that, quote, I can't think of any
00:19:02 genuine human rights activism that demands attacks on the rights and protections of other
00:19:07 civil society groups or advocates hateful language against them, end quote. Is she kidding?
00:19:15 Has she not read the dozens and dozens of mainstream feminist articles just in the last 0.58
00:19:24 five years that explicitly declare their hatred of men, such as those written by Megan Murphy
00:19:32 and Julie Bindel? Or perhaps men don't count as part of a civil society group,
00:19:38 since they are oppressors who neither require nor deserve protection from hatred.
00:19:45 Thus, yes, the chickens come home to roost. The moral of the story, I guess, is that you can't
00:19:54 build a movement based on hatred without those you train to hate occasionally turning the hatred
00:20:01 back on you. You can't train your side to feel no empathy for an entire category of human being
00:20:08 without creating a momentum by which you will also eventually be excluded from empathy.
00:20:14 For the record, I don't really have a side in this squabble. But the spectacle of these turf wars
00:20:21 should remind us that it's long past time to call an end to victim identity games we have
00:20:27 too long injured so that everyone, even men, can live free of sanctioned hatred.
00:20:43 You