The Fiamengo File - February 20, 2019


Tonic Masculinity, Building a better world since 10,000 BC - TFF 97

The TERF War - The Fiamengo File Episode 96 All [hetero]Sex Is Harmful - TFF Episode 98

Episode Stats


Length

8 minutes

Words per minute

114.86

Word count

932

Sentence count

25

Harmful content

Misogyny

7

sentences flagged

Toxicity

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

2

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 Forget toxic masculinity, how about tonic masculinity? That's my subject on today's Fiamengo File.
00:00:18 I'm Janice Fiamengo of the University of Ottawa. By now, we've all heard far more than we ever
00:00:25 cared to know about toxic masculinity. According to a recent article in the online journal Think
00:00:32 by psychotherapist Diane Barth, toxic masculinity is, quote, a terrible shorthand
00:00:38 for a real problem plaguing men, end quote. Barth positions her article as pro-male, claiming that
00:00:48 as a psychotherapist she wants to rescue men from the straitjacket society imposes on them
00:00:56 quoting from the american psychological association's guidelines for psychological 0.94
00:01:01 practice with boys and men she tells us that damaging ideas about masculinity include the
00:01:08 following quote anti-femininity achievement eschewal of the appearance of weakness and
00:01:15 adventure, risk, and violence, end quote. This rather incoherent ragbag is associated, she tells 1.00
00:01:25 us, with, quote, homophobia, bullying, and sexual harassment, end quote. Well, the problem, as many
00:01:33 critics have already pointed out, is that at least some of the listed tendencies are deeply grounded
00:01:40 in male biology, particularly in testosterone, and cannot simply be reimagined. Stigmatizing
00:01:49 natural male traits such as risk-taking or stoicism will help no one. Furthermore,
00:01:56 these masculine traits are not only linked to unhealthy behaviors, as everyone agrees they
00:02:03 sometimes are, but also to many hugely positive phenomena such as hard work, creativity,
00:02:10 individuality, dedication, courage, and problem-solving. Even what is indisputably
00:02:18 undesirable in some contexts is indispensable in others. Violence, for example, is sometimes
00:02:26 necessary to stop violence. Not wanting to appear weak can take a toll on one's mental well-being,
00:02:34 but can also lead to admirable feats of fortitude and self-control. The men who died on the Titanic
00:02:43 in order that women and children could escape. The soldiers who liberated the concentration camps.
00:02:50 The 9-11 first responders who ran into the Twin Towers while everyone else was running away.
00:02:56 The SWAT team operative who killed the shooter at the Tree of Life synagogue in Pittsburgh.
00:03:01 the divers who saved the Thai boys trapped in the underwater cave, all these and more were
00:03:08 acting out some combination of innate male drive and social conditioning. Many of them
00:03:16 would likely have preferred to have stayed at home, safe and warm and alive. Was their masculinity
00:03:26 toxic? Would our societies be better off without men like them? In some way, many of these men 0.99
00:03:34 are victims of cultural expectations about male self-sacrifice that would never be demanded of
00:03:41 women, just as are, to a lesser extent, those scientists who sacrificed a social life for years
00:03:48 spent working on a cancer breakthrough, or the doctors who sacrificed their family time to help
00:03:54 their patients, the professionals who put in 80-hour weeks to be better than anybody else,
00:04:01 the businessmen who practically live on the job to make their companies a success, and so on.
00:04:08 Yeah, it's a burden that we place on men to succeed, to stand out. Yet is anyone seriously
00:04:16 expecting that that burden can or will be removed without enormous cost to everyone?
00:04:24 and yet our society shames these men for their so-called privilege and of course it's not only
00:04:31 the outstanding heroes who expose the hollowness of feminist claims about men put man dies saving
00:04:41 dot dot dot into a google search engine and see all the awe-inspiring and heartbreaking stories
00:04:48 of everyday courage that come to light such as the north carolina man who drowned at little river park
00:04:56 last july saving an eight-year-old boy from powerful river currents the boy's mother said
00:05:04 the man used his last bits of strength to hold her son up above the water as he was drowning
00:05:12 this is what men do even when it isn't required of them even in a society that at best
00:05:19 ignores their goodness look at any list of the most dangerous occupations and
00:05:25 see the percentage of men who do those jobs the loggers the commercial fishermen the
00:05:32 aircraft pilots the roofers garbage collectors iron and steel workers farmers and truck drivers
00:05:39 electrical power line workers construction workers repairmen miners and patrol officers
00:05:46 the percentage of men risking injury and death in these positions ranges from 76 at the low end up 0.84
00:05:54 to 99.9 percent that's for oil and gas mining and i can't imagine women on mass taking over these 0.99
00:06:03 jobs so what the hell are we doing pretending that the future is female do feminists envision 1.00
00:06:12 that women will control the elite managerial government academic and leadership positions 1.00
00:06:19 while men kept out of the universities and the professions by quotas and me too will slave away 1.00
00:06:26 in the dirty and dangerous work if mainstream media can use a disgusting designation like
00:06:33 toxic to smear an entire group for characteristics exhibited by only a few let's at least have a term
00:06:40 that honors that same group for characteristics exhibited by a majority i propose the phrase
00:06:49 tonic masculinity to identify the qualities and behaviors that are the opposite of harmful
00:06:57 tonic masculinity creates well-being by bringing life health freedom prosperity security efficiency
00:07:04 technological mastery and high functionality to our societies it should be celebrated regularly
00:07:13 national leaders should explicitly acknowledge and praise it government should set aside a day
00:07:20 to remember it media outlets should highlight it as male hollywood should have a category of film
00:07:27 that displays it lawyers should introduce it as a mitigating factor at trial and gender studies
00:07:34 programs should analyze and commend it of course none of that will happen anytime soon but failing 0.94
00:07:43 that let's at least promote the phrase and be grateful for hashtag tonic masculinity
00:08:04 You