The Fiamengo File - March 09, 2019


All [hetero]Sex Is Harmful - TFF Episode 98

Tonic Masculinity, Building a better world since 10,000 BC - TFF 97 Fake News: CBC Hides The Truth About Fazio Case - TFF Episode 99

Episode Stats


Length

23 minutes

Words per minute

128.99

Word count

2,998

Sentence count

92

Harmful content

Misogyny

54

sentences flagged

Toxicity

8

sentences flagged

Hate speech

9

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 In the Me Too era, nearly any expression of male heterosexual desire can be defined as
00:00:08 assault or at least harassment if the woman finds it so. How did we get to the point in an age of
00:00:15 supposed liberation where some feminists have succeeded in equating sex with harm to women? 0.98
00:00:22 That's my subject on today's Fiamengo File.
00:00:30 I'm Janice Fumingo of the University of Ottawa.
00:00:39 In the traditional view that pertained in Western culture for centuries, 0.84
00:00:44 sex was seen as destructive to social flourishing outside of love and procreation within marriage.
00:00:50 According to this view, women needed to be protected from men whose sexual drive was understood to be far more powerful than women's.
00:01:00 in traditional western society women who became pregnant outside of marriage had no socially
00:01:04 acceptable means to guarantee the well-being of their children the marital bond was meant to tame
00:01:11 male sexuality by directing it toward one woman and to guarantee support for the woman and her 1.00
00:01:17 children second wave feminism was in the 1960s a rejection of this arrangement feminists saw 1.00
00:01:26 the family as a patriarchal strategy not for the protection of women but for their confinement 1.00
00:01:34 marriage according to feminists was about the control of female not male sexuality and feminists 1.00
00:01:41 were irritated by the belief that the female sexual drive was any less powerful than the male 1.00
00:01:48 that was simply a myth they claimed to justify women's subjugation traditional sexual morality 1.00
00:01:55 according to second wave feminist pioneers was a means to deny women their sexual pleasure 0.98
00:02:03 even as late as 2010 a major architect of second wave feminism gloria steinem gave voice to this 1.00
00:02:11 idea when she said in interview that quote all the various kinds of patriarchies have one thing in 1.00
00:02:18 common, and that is controlling women's bodies as the means of reproduction. It gives a patriarch 0.99
00:02:25 ownership of children through paternity, end quote. What she didn't also mention, of course,
00:02:34 is that under patriarchy and still today, men have had the responsibility to financially support 1.00
00:02:41 women and the children they fathered in marriage, a responsibility that feminists insist men
00:02:46 maintained to this day, even in cases where the man is not married to the mother of the children
00:02:51 and even cases where he has no contact with those children or even where they are not actually his
00:02:58 children. In a typical feminist double standard, women are to be liberated from the bonds of 1.00
00:03:04 conventional morality. They're not to be shamed for being sexual outside of marriage, but men 0.57
00:03:09 are not to be liberated from their bonds as providers. In rejecting patriarchal morality,
00:03:19 Gloria Steinem and her colleagues claimed that women's liberation was inseparable from their 0.67
00:03:24 sexual liberation. They focused on the pursuit of sexual pleasure for women, which they alleged was 0.99
00:03:30 just as important to women as it was to men. Women were urged to initiate sexual advances and to
00:03:38 enjoy sex in the same way men enjoyed it. Powered by the birth control pill, which was first made 0.96
00:03:46 widely available in the 1960s, and by the feminist critique of marriage, the sexual revolution was
00:03:52 born. But early on, some feminists sounded a dark warning, alleging that it was not so easy for 1.00
00:04:00 women to liberate themselves, and that in fact heterosexuality itself, whether within or outside 0.97
00:04:07 of marriage was an arena in which male domination of women was enacted. Radical feminists such as 0.99
00:04:16 Sheila Jeffries, Andrea Dworkin, and Catherine MacKinnon developed theories in the 1970s that 0.69
00:04:22 emphasize not liberation but female subordination. And these theories, marginal at first and still
00:04:30 highly contested amongst feminists today gained widespread credence in academia and in the front 0.96
00:04:38 lines of feminist activism from that place in academia such theories spread throughout the 0.98
00:04:45 culture infiltrating journalism entertainment advertising law and social policy in ways that 0.93
00:04:54 have created a remarkable stalemate over sex that will have long-lasting repercussions. 0.98
00:05:02 Fundamentally, the radical feminist claim is that there is no measurable difference between 0.95
00:05:09 normal sex and sexual violence, and that in fact normal sex is violent. The result in 2019 is the
00:05:18 massive expansion of the definition of sexual assault, which can now include nearly any kind
00:05:24 of unwanted touching, even on a woman's clothed body, and of sexual harassment, which can now
00:05:30 include nearly any unwelcome attention on the part of a man toward a woman. In 1989, Harvard
00:05:38 professor of law Catherine McKinnon encapsulated the theory in an article published in the journal
00:05:45 Ethics with the title, Sexuality Pornography Method, Pleasure Under Patriarchy. In this
00:05:53 definitive article, McKinnon summed up her argument as follows, quote, compare victims reports of rape
00:06:02 with women's reports of sex. They look a lot alike, end quote. She concluded, in this light,
00:06:11 the major distinction between intercourse, normal, and rape, abnormal, is that the normal happens so
00:06:19 often that one cannot get anyone to see anything wrong with it end quote outrageous bizarre but
00:06:28 mckinnon was not a crackpot raving on a street corner she was a highly articulate credentialed
00:06:35 legal theorist who framed her ideas in sophisticated seeming arguments her thesis statement was notable
00:06:43 amongst other reasons for admitting that getting people to see something wrong with normal sex 0.96
00:06:50 was a feminist goal in 1990 lesbian feminist sheila jeffries published her book anti-climax 0.55
00:06:59 a feminist perspective on the sexual revolution in which she argued that the sexual revolution was in 1.00
00:07:05 fact directly contrary to women's liberation designed to eroticize female subordination and 0.59
00:07:13 that's to diffuse the potential threat to male power created by women's economic emancipation 0.99
00:07:19 in the 60s she said quote behind the baloney of liberation the naked power politics of male 0.98
00:07:28 supremacy were being acted out, end quote. For Jeffreys, the entire basis of heterosexual desire
00:07:36 is the eroticization of inequality. In her words, quote, in heterosexual desire,
00:07:43 our subordination becomes sexy, end quote. I don't think it would be too much of a simplification
00:07:52 to say that the Me Too movement is the popular realization of McKinnon's and Jeffrey's once-outlier theories
00:08:02 in their focus on sex itself as a harm to women.
00:08:07 To elide the distinction between sex and violence, the Me Too movement redefines consent as non-consent in all sorts of ways
00:08:17 and argues that even consensual sex hurts at least some and perhaps all women.
00:08:24 One striking popular example of the redefining of consent can be seen in Monica Lewinsky's claim 0.93
00:08:31 in the February 2018 issue of Vanity Fair that she has rethought her involvement with Bill Clinton.
00:08:39 Now, as everyone knows, Lewinsky was the White House intern who found herself
00:08:44 at the center of a political firestorm when President Clinton lied about their sexual
00:08:49 affair in the White House. Up until 2018, to my knowledge, Lewinsky never claimed that the affair
00:08:56 was anything but consensual. But in the wake of Me Too, she has recast her involvement with the
00:09:03 president using the familiar language of feminist victimology. She says, quote, I now see how
00:09:10 problematic it was that the two of us even got to a place where there was a question of consent.
00:09:19 This was her statement in the Vanity Fair interview. She went on, quote, instead,
00:09:24 the road that led there was littered with inappropriate abuse of authority, station,
00:09:30 and privilege, end quote. Well, obviously, the inappropriate abuse that she refers to is not
00:09:39 hers, but Bill Clinton's alone. This is a fairly remarkable turnaround for the woman who admitted
00:09:47 in interview with Barbara Walters to feeling flattered by Clinton's interest and to actually
00:09:53 showing the president her thong underwear as an explicit sexual invitation. But the turnaround
00:10:00 isn't all that surprising for anyone who has followed even one-tenth of the MeToo movement,
00:10:05 which is incapable of seeing women as anything but helpless victims of male power. And by the way,
00:10:13 I'm not unsympathetic to Lewinsky. I think her public exposure at that time was cruel. But her
00:10:21 born-again feminism offers an all-too-predictable script into which we now watch her trying to 1.00
00:10:28 force her experience. In general, it's clear that the Me Too movement involves a dramatic 1.00
00:10:35 walk back of what feminist leaders have said for years about yes means yes and no means no.
00:10:43 Now, yes does not necessarily mean yes anymore. It doesn't mean yes if the woman has been drinking 1.00
00:10:49 and has been deemed unable to consent. It doesn't mean yes if there's any kind of power differential
00:10:56 in the relationship, it doesn't mean yes if the woman regrets her decision to be sexual.
00:11:01 Now the net of unhappy and degrading and damaging sex is being cast ever more widely to include
00:11:09 the nominally consensual, with the result that, as Catherine McKinnon hoped, much normal sex
00:11:16 is being redefined as abuse. Even when there isn't any power differential between the woman and the
00:11:25 man, the Me Too emphasis is on the many ways that a woman's yes can actually be interpreted as
00:11:32 non-consensual. Recently, the New York Times published an article by columnist Jessica Bennett,
00:11:40 their gender editor, called When Saying Yes Is Easier Than Saying No, in which Bennett writes
00:11:49 about what she calls the gray areas of consent which include in her words quote begrudgingly
00:11:55 consensual sex because you know you don't really want to do it but it's probably easier to just 0.85
00:12:01 get it over with lukewarm sex because you're kind of meh about it and of course bad sex where the 0.82
00:12:09 bad refers not to the perceived pleasure of it but to the way you feel in the aftermath 0.98
00:12:15 math. That's the end of that quote. At first, this statement seems like it might lead to a
00:12:23 frank discussion about what women really want from sex and relationships and the difficulty,
00:12:29 at least some women seem to have in knowing and articulating that. But then it falls back into
00:12:35 the most cliched of laments when Bennett claims that, quote, women have been taught by every
00:12:41 cultural force imaginable, that we must be nice and quiet and polite, that we must protect others'
00:12:49 feelings before our own, that we are there for others' pleasure, end quote. And we're back to
00:12:57 Feminism 101, the patriarchal conspiracy theory and women's supposed powerlessness. Now in 1958, 0.78
00:13:05 bennett's assertion might have had some truth but in 2018 it was a misrepresentation of embarrassing
00:13:13 proportions as anyone knows who has eyes to see every advertisement hashtag public service
00:13:18 announcement and educational slogan encourages women to think about their needs and desires
00:13:25 above all if some or even many women still do want to be wanted more than they want sex itself
00:13:35 and i agree that at least some some women do it's very hard to blame that on society
00:13:41 but having opened a can of worms about women who lie about their desire bennett can only move in
00:13:50 the direction McKinnon laid out, spinning justifications for yes, not really meaning yes.
00:13:56 She approves the idea that women can't consent if they've been drinking alcohol, even though
00:14:03 alcohol is what a lot of women drink when they want and intend to be sexual. And Bennett wants 0.80
00:14:09 to go even further than that. She says, quote, what about a woman who doesn't feel that she can 0.99
00:14:13 speak up because of cultural expectations? Should that woman be considered unable to consent
00:14:20 to end quote so 50 years into the modern feminist movement elite feminist opinion makers are openly 1.00
00:14:30 declaring that women cannot be responsible for knowing their desire or saying what they mean 0.98
00:14:36 a movement that supposedly began with women's quest for freedom and self-determination has
00:14:42 rather quickly become about blaming patriarchy for women's moral cowardice. Even sex within
00:14:51 marriage, or perhaps especially sex within marriage, is in the feminist crosshairs. 0.99
00:14:57 Last year, Vox magazine published a long op-ed entitled, We Need to Talk About Sexual Assault 0.98
00:15:06 in marriage too. But the subject isn't actually sexual assault. Describing years in an unhappy
00:15:16 marriage, the anonymous author who teaches, you guessed it, feminist theory at an American
00:15:22 university, claims that she was violated every time she and her husband had sex,
00:15:29 even though the sex was consensual submitting to her husband left her quote sexually traumatized
00:15:39 long after I ended that marriage she claims it certainly sounds very unpleasant and of course
00:15:45 it's all the fault of the patriarchy the author claims that quote all the feminist texts I had
00:15:52 read, could not drown out what I had absorbed from society and popular culture, that it was my
00:16:00 duty to satisfy my husband regardless of my own feelings, end quote. But she obviously didn't make
00:16:10 any real attempt to satisfy her husband. On the contrary, it seems that she went out of her way
00:16:16 to humiliate and rub his nose in the fact that sex with him repulsed her. She tells us that she 0.78
00:16:24 insisted on reading a book during sex and never allowed her husband to kiss her on the lips and
00:16:31 that this state of things went on for years. The entire piece reads far more like a overwritten
00:16:39 gender studies agitprop assignment than like any true confession and it's pretty obviously a piece 0.95
00:16:45 of feminist theater. What man could go through with such a farce? What could possibly have been 0.69
00:16:52 the source of this deep sexual disgust for a man the author claims she once loved and
00:16:58 wasn't ready to leave? And why are we being told all this? The repeated refrain in the article is
00:17:06 that we need to talk about this more. Apparently we need to hear more from resentful women complaining 1.00
00:17:14 about bad sex more from women who loathe sex with their husbands because me too has become a great
00:17:23 howl of bad feelings about men and that needs to be kept going an ever expanding grievance machine 0.98
00:17:32 I wouldn't be surprised to learn that the American professor of feminist theory who wrote that Vox
00:17:39 article had read a chapter by professor of law and philosophy, Robin West, called Sex, Law and
00:17:49 Consent. Published in 2008, this chapter is available online and as part of a book called
00:17:57 The Ethics of Consent Theory and Practice. And I would recommend everyone take a look at this if
00:18:04 you want to see where Me Too and modern feminism are heading, in my opinion. Professor Robin West 1.00
00:18:11 argues that feminist theory needs to take more seriously the harms to women of what she defines 0.99
00:18:18 as consensual but unwelcome sex, which is sex where the woman has given a yes that really should 0.75
00:18:26 have been a no. She argues that, quote, consensual sex, when it is unwanted and unwelcome, often
00:18:34 carries harms to the personhood, autonomy, integrity, and identity of the person who
00:18:40 consents to it, and these harms are unreckoned by law and more or less unnoticed by the rest of us,
00:18:51 End quote. Now, according to West, not unlike the worker who does his job under stressful and
00:19:00 dangerous conditions, a woman who consents to sex she doesn't want, even if she fully consents and
00:19:06 is not subordinate or incapacitated, is alienated in the Marxian sense from her own self. Professor 0.98
00:19:14 west also states ominously in my opinion that quote legal theorists should focus more than we
00:19:21 do on consensual sexual harms and their relation to law in the intimate sphere i think that bears
00:19:32 repeating consensual sexual harms and their relation to law in the intimate sphere wow
00:19:39 Wow. West is not, perhaps not yet, arguing that unwanted consensual sex should be criminalized.
00:19:49 But she definitely wants to make it at the least a subject of extensive discussion. And indeed,
00:19:55 as we see 10 years later, it is now a subject of discussion in Vox magazine,
00:20:00 scripted to Professor West's near exact specifications. Actually, one of the scenarios
00:20:06 that West mentioned in her chapter is a woman in a marriage having unwanted sex over a period of
00:20:13 years. The clear suggestion in both West's theoretical analysis and the anonymous Vox
00:20:20 magazine article is that a case of unwelcome though consensual sex is not merely a personal
00:20:28 experience best left to individuals to deal with on their own. No, consensual but unwelcome sex
00:20:35 deserves to become a social and perhaps legal category, not unlike sexual assault,
00:20:41 a part of our public discourse, a subject of feminist analysis and grievance,
00:20:47 and, of course, another tool of male shaming and control of male sexuality.
00:20:54 Neither West nor any of the other feminists I've read ever considers the harms to men
00:21:00 of being trapped in sexless marriages in which their wives have checked out sexually and
00:21:06 emotionally, which the brilliant Bettina Arndt has spoken about in depth. I don't think feminists 1.00
00:21:12 ever seriously think about the men whose longing for sex is a fact of their lives that has nothing 0.90
00:21:18 to do with power or abuse or who themselves have unwelcome sex with women. No, feminists have come 1.00
00:21:26 to believe that most men are like the husband in the vox article a cardboard caricature without
00:21:34 any higher feeling or self-respect and women have been taught from childhood to see sex with men 0.53
00:21:41 exactly as robin west describes the experience of marx's alienated worker dirty repetitive
00:21:49 unfulfilling body and soul deforming labor. And now Me Too has sent out the call. Let's go after
00:21:58 all the bastards. The result is increased anger and resentment on the part of women and increased 1.00
00:22:07 social stigma against men for a variety of non-criminal behavior, including asking for sex
00:22:13 with their wives and girlfriends. In my opinion, this is the terrifying direction in which
00:22:21 Me Too is heading to define more and more categories of unhappy female experience as
00:22:28 male sexual abuse. A key plank of the feminist agenda has always been to give women the power 1.00
00:22:35 backed by social, state, and legal sanction to determine the nature of every interaction, 0.94
00:22:43 sexual and non-sexual between men and women. The power to define reality is the greatest power
00:22:50 it is possible to have, and feminism's endgame, not that far from being realized, 0.95
00:22:57 will render men near voiceless in both the public and private spheres. 0.99
00:23:12 You