00:00:15And it's my subject on today's Fiamengo File.
00:00:18i'm janice fiamengo of the university of ottawa a few days ago the cbc reported on a young woman who
00:00:34is giving up her anonymity as the victim of a sexual assault to come forward with her story
00:00:40the title of the article is and then he was raping me victim goes public with shocking0.56
00:00:47attack to reveal justice system flaws. And one of the main points of emphasis in the article
00:00:52is the brutality of a horrific attack. The girl involved, Sam Fazio, at age 17, attended a high
00:01:01school pre-graduation dance party at a Vancouver nightclub on February 28, 2016, and then found
00:01:09herself, quote, cornered in a bathroom stall, end quote, being sexually assaulted by a boy of 16,
00:01:15someone she knew. He raped her so violently that she sustained internal injuries, and he left her0.91
00:01:23in the bathroom stall in a pool of her own blood from where she was, quote, rushed to hospital and0.90
00:01:30into emergency surgery to stem massive bleeding from deep cuts in and around her vagina, end quote.
00:01:38The story and all its upsetting detail is told at length in the article, and the emphasis is on the
00:01:44injustice not only of what the girl endured at the dance but also of her experience before
00:01:49and during the trial. She mentioned that the investigating officers, quote, asked her what
00:01:56she was wearing that night, end quote, and the whole process, quote, left her feeling victimized
00:02:03all over again, end quote. Ms. Fazio also alleged with deep anger that her attacker has had, quote,
00:02:09pretty much no repercussions for what he did. To make matters worse, the boy was found guilty of
00:02:17a prior assault that came to light during the trial. More on this later. The overall message
00:02:23being that women are suffering terribly from sexual violence and men are getting off with
00:02:30barely a slap on the wrist. So now this survivor is coming forward to advocate for changes to the
00:02:37system. What changes exactly? The article doesn't specify beyond saying that in the wake of the
00:02:44trial, a petition circulated demanding that the judge be removed from the bench, while victims
00:02:50advocates are calling for the justice system to, quote, get in step with changing times. It's never
00:02:56spelled out what that means exactly, but the clear suggestion is that the system should remove or at
00:03:04least weaken the legal presumption of innocence. Sam Fazio is particularly incensed that the accused
00:03:12boy's defense counsel tried to claim that the attack on her was consensual. Note how the language
00:03:18itself makes the idea pretty much unthinkable. How can an attack be consensual? The strong
00:03:25implication in the article is that when a woman ends up in the hospital requiring stitches to her
00:03:31vagina, there is no question of consent, and it shouldn't even be allowed to be raised at trial.
00:03:38Fazio is quoted as saying that, quote, with my case, I don't know how many witnesses there were,
00:03:43but there was maybe like 10, and so much evidence and blood and everything, end quote.
00:03:50Why have a regular trial at all in a case like that, is the unstated question.
00:03:58Now, I'm not a doctor and I obviously know nothing about this girl's injuries, so take what I'm about
00:04:04to say with a huge grain of salt, but a quick internet search reveals many medical sites
00:04:10describing reasons for vaginal bleeding during consensual sex, including in cases where the woman
00:04:15is very nervous or she's taking contraceptive hormones or both partners are drunk. I also
00:04:21quickly found medical reports of extreme vaginal tearing following consensual sex. One report
00:04:28states that, quote, although consensual intercourse is usually associated with minor
00:04:34genital trauma, potentially serious injuries can occur. And another report states that, quote,
00:04:41consensual coital lacerations are commonly encountered in clinical practice, though not
00:04:48as common as lacerations sustained during childbirth, they account for significant morbidity
00:04:54among sexually active women. Severe coital laceration may lead to life-threatening blood
00:05:02loss." None of this is mentioned in the CBC article, which implies that only rape could lead
00:05:11to severe lacerations. Fazio and her supporters maintained that the punishment of the young man
00:05:19in this case was completely insufficient. The article notes that, quote, as a young offender,
00:05:25he was sentenced to the maximum three years, but the judge ruled only two weeks of that sentence
00:05:32be served in custody and the rest under supervision, end quote. What the article does not mention is
00:05:40that Canada has a well-established history of treating minors differently from adults under
00:05:47the law with the rationale that minors should be reformed and given another chance when they
00:05:52break the law. Canada's Youth Criminal Justice Act protects young people under the age of 17.
00:05:59I'm sure if the CBC wanted to, it could do a whole series on terrible crimes committed by minors for
00:06:07which the punishments would seem inadequate to some, including murders of innocent people,
00:06:14violent home invasions, the gratuitous killing of pets, and so on. But the CBC wouldn't publish
00:06:22such articles because it would see that as an irresponsible whipping up of public anger with
00:06:29an uninformed sentiment far too easy to exploit. But when the uninformed sentiment being whipped
00:06:38up is against young men for sexual assault, the CBC is obviously fully on board. And that's the
00:06:45whole point of this article, to create a poster girl for the Me Too movement to tell, as the
00:06:52article puts it, quote, the human story behind the hashtag, end quote, and to generate rage,
00:07:00not only against young men, but also against the due process of law that presumably allows
00:07:09them to get away with violent rape. This would be irresponsible and dangerous, even if the specific
00:07:18story being told were true in every detail. But it turns out it isn't. If one compares the
00:07:28judge's verdict in this case, which is available online, with the CBC article, it is obvious that
00:07:34the CBC has dramatically misrepresented what actually seems to have happened on the night
00:07:41in question, and that the young man's wrongdoing is far less clear-cut than the article sets out.
00:07:49It's an example of flat-out fake news, and it certainly makes me doubt that anything one reads
00:07:55about sexual assault in the mainstream media is trustworthy. Now, there's a whole other video
00:08:02that could be made on the judgment itself, which makes for, at times, surreal reading. And as a
00:08:09a matter of fact, it's under appeal. The male judge's sympathies in this case seem to be
00:08:16entirely with the two female accusers. And whenever there is a discrepancy between what
00:08:20the two girls said at trial and what the accused boy said in his defense, the judge always believes
00:08:28the girls. His response over and over again is, I find his statement unbelievable and I find her0.53
00:08:36explanation credible. Both allegations of assault dealt with in the judgment rest on
00:08:42he said, she said testimony, and where eyewitness testimony and video evidence are brought forward
00:08:50against Ms. Fazio, the judge is, quote, unable to determine, as he says, the truth of the matter.
00:08:58In the rest of my commentary, I'm going to mainly focus on showing the extensive omissions and
00:09:04misrepresentations in the inflammatory CBC article, but I will also deal to some extent
00:09:08with the judge's reasoning or lack thereof in the verdict. So first and most basically,
00:09:15the CBC report states that Ms. Fazio was, quote, cornered in a bathroom stall, as I already said,
00:09:21and sexually assaulted. But what it doesn't say is that prior to the incident in the stall,
00:09:26Ms. Fazio had been seen by many witnesses kissing the boy on two different couches in the dance
00:09:33club. Two witnesses describing her, quote, kissing him as if she were really into it, end quote. Also
00:09:39sitting with her leg draped over his, slow dancing with her arms around him on the dance floor and
00:09:46walking arm in arm with the boy throughout the nightclub. When confronted at trial with all of
00:09:52this eyewitness and closed circuit TV video evidence, Ms. Fazio claimed that the boy was
00:10:00forcing her to do all of this against her will. Quite an extraordinary thing to claim, given that
00:10:06she was surrounded by her friends and by authority figures whom she knew would have helped her if she
00:10:14had merely asked for help. This includes a number of security guards that she passed while she was
00:10:21walking with the accused boy. It's simply impossible to believe that she was under this
00:10:27boy's control. And it was only after all this very demonstrative sexual behavior that she went with
00:10:33the boy to the bathroom cubicle to fool around. As the judge notes, there was a security guard
00:10:38standing right at the entrance to the women's bathroom, presumably to prevent precisely the
00:10:44sort of thing that she says happened to her that night, yet she neglected the opportunity
00:10:50to ask him for assistance. She told the judge that, quote, she did not attempt to reach out
00:10:56for any help because she was too scared, too embarrassed, and didn't want to make a scene,
00:11:02end quote. Although the judge doesn't actually accept that explanation, the judge never once
00:11:09indicates that Ms. Fazio's dishonesty about her behavior during this part of the evening
00:11:14seriously calls into question her reliability in general. Why should she be considered credible
00:11:21when describing what happened inside the bathroom cubicle when she told such blatant
00:11:26untruths about what happened outside? I'm not saying, of course, that because Ms. Fazio went
00:11:33willingly into the cubicle with the boy, obviously in order to make out, that she therefore consented
00:11:38to everything that came after. Of course not, but her behavior certainly puts a very different
00:11:43complexion on the CBC's very dramatic statement that she was, quote, cornered in a bathroom stall.
00:11:50And the fact that the CBC left this whole aspect of the evening out of the article shows that even
00:11:56the sympathetic reporter recognized that a girl who goes with a guy into a public toilet to make
00:12:02out is not quite the poster girl for victimized innocence that the CBC wanted her to be.
00:12:08what exactly happened inside that stall may never be known we know that at least some of it seems
00:12:16to have been consensual ms fazio claimed that the boy forcibly took off her bra for example he
00:12:23testified that she took it off herself and he was able to say exactly how she took it off turning
00:12:28the clasp around where it could more easily be undone by her which he likely couldn't have known
00:12:32if he hadn't seen her do it again that doesn't mean that therefore she consented to everything
00:12:37that came afterwards. But if she didn't consent to oral sex and sexual intercourse, I have to say0.99
00:12:43that this is the strangest sexual assault that I've ever read about. One that happened completely0.99
00:12:51within earshot of many people who could have helped. It is established as fact that there
00:12:57were girls standing at the sinks when Ms. Fazio and the boy entered the bathroom, just as there
00:13:02were girls standing at the sinks when he walked out. There were likely girls coming in and out
00:13:06of the washroom the entire time. Yet it seems no one heard anything untoward or made any move to
00:13:13alert a security guard. The victim had merely to lift her voice to cry for help. She claimed she
00:13:20was confined against her will in the stall and forced to endure an unbearably painful sexual
00:13:26attack, yet she made no effort to save herself. It isn't even made clear in the judge's description
00:13:33whether the girl said no or made it clear in any way to the boy that she didn't consent to his
00:13:39actions. In giving the verdict, the judge makes much of the affirmative consent model that is now
00:13:46Canadian law, saying, quote, there is an affirmative obligation for the man to assure
00:13:51himself that the woman is continuing consent during the whole sexual encounter. In this case,
00:13:56according to his own testimony, he just kept on trying unsuccessfully to push his penis further1.00
00:14:02into her vagina, end quote. And the judge goes on, the fact that he heard no screaming does not0.99
00:14:07allow him to infer or conclude that she was not objecting to intercourse. He had an ongoing
00:14:14obligation to actively confirm her consent, end quote. Well, from these statements, we can conclude
00:14:20that Ms. Fazio not only did not scream, but made no verbal or any other obvious objection. This is
00:14:27a long way from the violent assault referred to in the CBC article. The judge accepts Ms. Fazio's
00:14:35testimony, quite bizarre and unbelievable in my opinion, that she was in such intense pain that
00:14:41she could not cry out. She testified that she merely said no, no, no in her head. Again, I'm
00:14:49not an expert in the physiological response of human beings to intense pain, but from the little
00:14:55I know from attending a friend in childbirth, for example, screaming and shouting no are certainly
00:15:02very common involuntary responses to intense pain. The judge makes much of the damning fact
00:15:10that the accused boy walked out of the washroom stall and left a girl there bleeding, taking that
00:15:16as proof that this was a callous attack. I think there are many possible explanations for why the
00:15:24boy might have done that. Shock, shame, confusion, fear. The boy may well have been terrified seeing
00:15:31the blood that he was about to be branded a rapist, as he was when he was arrested 20 minutes
00:15:38later in the men's washroom. Though the judge is happy to give the benefit of the doubt to many
00:15:45unlikely explanations offered by Ms. Fazio, he does not extend the same empathy to the accused,
00:15:53even though it's the accused who is supposed to be presumed innocent in a court of law.
00:15:59Now, one last point about something briefly mentioned in the CBC article and explained in
00:16:04more detail in the judge's verdict, the second assault conviction against the accused boy.
00:16:10This assault was testified to by a friend of Ms. Fazio, who came forward in the middle of the
00:16:17trial to say that the boy in question had assaulted her too in the previous autumn.
00:16:22This is a startling story, though not in the way it is made to seem in the CBC article where it is mentioned as a proof of a pattern of violence on the boy's part.
00:16:33The friend had had a flirtation in what seems a casual sexual relationship with the accused boy in the autumn prior to the pre-grad party.
00:16:42She never went to the police at the time, and although she told her friends, including
00:16:48Ms. Fazio, that the boy had forced her to perform oral sex, her own friends didn't seem
00:16:55to believe her at the time, or at least didn't seem bothered by the fact.
00:17:00Text evidence brought forward at trial showed that Ms. Fazio kept on texting in a friendly
00:17:08way with the boy, obviously not disturbed enough by the thought that he was a sexual abuser to
00:17:15stop being friendly. Her friend also admitted that she continued to have feelings for the boy
00:17:21and continued to text with him. The CBC doesn't mention any of these details, perhaps because of
00:17:28the rather sordid picture they create of a teenage culture in which claims about consent or non-consent
00:17:35are treated with casual indifference by both girls and boys, and in which an assault is
00:17:42considered criminal only when it is useful that it be so. One has to ask if a friend doesn't care
00:17:52enough about her girlfriend's claimed sexual assault to stop communicating with the claimed
00:18:00assailant, how is the boy to know that it matters? Yes, I realize this sounds like victim blaming,
00:18:09but it's a genuine question about how it's possible to believe what we're told to believe
00:18:15by feminist pundits. On the one hand, we're supposed to believe that sexual assaults are0.98
00:18:22deeply traumatizing experiences that take years, perhaps a lifetime to recover from and must be
00:18:31seriously punished. On the other hand, we're given evidence that a girl in this case
00:18:36never seems to have given her sexual assault another thought until it was convenient
00:18:44to remember it in order to corroborate her friend's testimony. The conclusion that I reach
00:18:53from reading the article and comparing it to the judge's verdict is that this was emphatically
00:18:59not the clear-cut sexual crime or crimes that the CBC portrayed. It was a murky case in which a
00:19:08judge chose to believe two female complainants despite significant implausibilities in both
00:19:17their testimonies and which is now being used by judicial activists to push for the undermining of
00:19:24the presumption of innocence. Now when I first started reading about this case I thought to
00:19:29myself don't even try to defend this guy just stick to looking at the way the CBC twisted the
00:19:35facts. But the more I read the excuses and justifications offered by the accusers and
00:19:42accepted by the judge, the more it seemed that this young man may well have been falsely convicted as
00:19:48I simply don't see how the evidence proved his guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. But whether I'm
00:19:55right or wrong about that, and I fully admit my opinion has no legal substance, still it is
00:20:01outrageous that Canada's state-funded news agency is spreading an incomplete story
00:20:10to help feminist activists make it more likely that men will be falsely convicted in the future.