00:00:00100 videos in and I'm more anti-feminist than ever before and that's my subject on today's Fiamengo file.
00:00:20I'm Janice Fiamengo of the University of Ottawa.
00:00:23This is the 100th Fiamengo file. When I started recording these videos in Steve's basement in
00:00:29Kingston, Ontario, I was nervous, unable to relax. Now, close to four years later, I'm recording the
00:00:36videos in my own basement and still pretty much unable to relax. For those who've watched
00:00:43regularly, you've seen hundreds of minutes of anti-feminist analysis, some bad hair days,
00:00:50at least one video that made a lot of people angry, and one that went viral. With my retirement
00:00:56from academia just a few months away, Steve and I plan to keep on contributing anti-feminist content
00:01:03to YouTube, and in the next few minutes I want to suggest the direction we'll be going.
00:01:09When Steve first suggested the idea of a video series four years ago, I think we both figured
00:01:15it might consist of a dozen or so short videos critiquing feminism i'd been disgusted by feminist
00:01:22advocacy with its endless poor me claims and demands for a long time starting with my experience
00:01:29of the affirmative action or equity hiring that i witnessed when i was a new professor in which i
00:01:35saw with my own eyes something that is still going on 20 years later even more blatantly highly
00:01:43qualified men mostly white being passed over in favor of less qualified others mostly white women
00:01:51in the name of social justice with the result that thousands perhaps even tens of thousands of women
00:01:58and some non-whites in north america have been given highly paid and influential university0.69
00:02:04positions not exclusively on the basis of merit but because of their membership in underachieving
00:02:10identity groups. Recently, Ireland announced that it will advertise dozens of female-only
00:02:17university positions over the next few years. These affirmative action professors, instead of1.00
00:02:24feeling embarrassed or grateful for what they've been given, tend to vigorously proclaim their0.72
00:02:32victimhood over and over again as a way of justifying and at the same time covering up
00:02:38their own unfair advantage it's a dangerous farcical injustice against high achieving men
00:02:46that has been practiced for decades and shows no sign of letting up and it's now invading fields
00:02:52like the natural sciences and engineering that one would have hoped might remain immune and yes
00:03:00i myself benefited from that outrageous discrimination in my early years as a professor
00:03:07i was shocked by the number of my colleagues who were overtly anti-male and more broadly anti-western
00:03:15and who made harsh criticism of their own countries and their country's best achievers the
00:03:21primary focus of their teaching and research so that young men in the classroom were repeatedly
00:03:28given the message that the only thing good about western societies were the angry blaming voices
00:03:35who advocated the tearing down and transformation of the whole culture according to intersectional feminist priorities.
00:03:43Already then, back in the 1990s, the Victim Olympics contest was in full swing,
00:03:48with people everywhere eager to affirm what in a truly unjust and discriminatory society
00:03:54they would try to hide their female, queer, black, or Muslim identities,
00:03:59and everyone else bowing down before their presumed suffering.
00:04:03It was my first taste of the upside-down world of academia in which countless special accommodations and privileges, advantages, and perks were made available to certain favored groups of people, while all the while we heard constantly what a terrible time they were having and how much more needed to be done for them.
00:04:24academia became one of the primary subjects in my video series as a result and i i think it is my not
00:04:31completely original but perhaps most intellectually significant contribution to online discussion
00:04:37the way that the extreme ideas and social justice mania first developed by academic feminists back1.00
00:04:44in the 1980s and 90s eventually became mainstream affecting all areas of higher education including1.00
00:04:52even the hard sciences and also our legal system our public schools policing journalism hollywood
00:04:59high tech and many other areas gender as a social construct privilege emotional labor0.97
00:05:07critical race theory microaggressions intersectionality orientalism feminist
00:05:13science indigenous science and so on all these began in the echo chamber of academia where
00:05:20radicalism is a marker of chic and where academics compete with one another to propound the most
00:05:26ingenious forms of transgression. I've made videos about feminist theories of the male gaze.0.73
00:05:34Even when a woman is not looking at a man, he knows she might be looking somewhere sometime.
00:05:42French theorist Michel Foucault talked about the panopticon, a disciplinary regime in which
00:05:48prisoners are aware of themselves as potentially watchable at all times and thus learn to discipline0.73
00:05:54themselves to monitor their own behavior and that's what the feminist regime wants to put in
00:06:01place for men the feminist panopticon an awareness by men that doing pretty much anything a woman
00:06:08doesn't like can get them in serious life-altering trouble of patriarchal power of how all men
00:06:17supposedly benefit from sexual violence of women's inability to truly consent to sex of the all
00:06:24pervasiveness of sexual harassment if i ask you out on a date and you say you're busy then i ask
00:06:32you again a few weeks later and again a week after that not understanding that busy meant busy
00:06:38forever then according to the definition used in the study i've harassed you but a full 86
00:06:45percent of respondents in the study indicated that what they experienced never went beyond the verbal
00:06:53in other words it involved such assaults as jokes suggestive comments even compliments hey julie
00:07:02that's a gorgeous outfit wow madge i love your hair that way or to cite the famous quip supposedly
00:07:09uttered by supreme court nominee clarence thomas that ignited a public furor when revealed by his
00:07:15assistant Anita Hill, who put pubic hair in my coke. Moving now into the realm of public theatre,
00:07:24we have also seen a variety of anti-cat-calling videos purporting to demonstrate what a misogynistic0.54
00:07:31environment sidewalks are for women. A number of these videos turned out to be staged by actors
00:07:37rather than the candid windows onto reality they pretended to be, a fact that has not lessened
00:07:43their popularity among those who believe in their deeper truth. In one Peruvian video that went viral,
00:07:50street harassers are tricked into catcalling their own mothers who are done up in makeup and wig
00:07:55disguises. When their sons make sexual remarks, the angry mamas reveal their true identities and1.00
00:08:02berate their sons for their lack of respect. It's all fake, but many viewers loved the message.0.90
00:08:09If you wouldn't do it to your mother, why would you do it to any other woman?
00:08:14It's a question with a very obvious answer. Men tend to feel and express sexual interest in women
00:08:20who are not their mothers. But this is a fact seemingly lost on many of those
00:08:24applauding the video's Don't You Dare message.
00:08:31In general, it's clear that the MeToo movement involves a dramatic
00:08:35walk back of what feminist leaders have said for years about yes means yes and no means no
00:08:43now yes does not necessarily mean yes anymore it doesn't mean yes if the woman has been drinking0.99
00:08:49and has been deemed unable to consent it doesn't mean yes if there's any kind of power differential
00:08:56in the relationship it doesn't mean yes if the woman regrets her decision to be sexual
00:09:00Now the net of unhappy and degrading and damaging sex is being cast ever more widely to include
00:09:09the nominally consensual, with the result that, as Catherine McKinnon hoped, much normal sex
00:09:16is being redefined as abuse. In my opinion, this is the terrifying direction in which
00:09:24Me Too is heading to define more and more categories of unhappy female experience as
00:09:32male sexual abuse. A key plank of the feminist agenda has always been to give women the power1.00
00:09:39backed by social, state, and legal sanction to determine the nature of every interaction,0.95
00:09:47sexual and non-sexual, between men and women. The power to define reality is the greatest0.71
00:09:54power it is possible to have. And feminism's endgame, not that far from being realized,1.00
00:10:01will render men near voiceless in both the public and private spheres.
00:10:08And I've talked about the powerful impact these ideas have had on judges' verdicts in rape trials,
00:10:15on police procedure in cases of domestic violence, and on feminist disciplining of the male body
00:10:22and male behavior. When Steve and I first started documenting feminism, and still now,
00:10:29university campuses were gripped by a rape culture fever. No matter how many times1.00
00:10:36responsible people demonstrated with facts that rape is rare on college campuses and that it is1.00
00:10:43universally condemned when it occurs, not condoned, feminist advocates and university officials0.98
00:10:50continue to collude in the idea that women are in grave peril on campus today. These people never0.95
00:10:58explain how such peril can exist at the same time that women's numbers at university continue to
00:11:04increase all across the Western world. Why would women keep attending schools if their lives there0.98
00:11:10are filled with sexual terror? Still, the hysteria is stoked and universities are constantly vowing
00:11:18to take action to prevent sexual violence. What this has meant is a plethora of anti-male
00:11:28initiatives and messaging, including policies in which university officials are instructed to
00:11:34start by believing when a woman makes a complaint, and the never-ending lecturing of men about all
00:11:43the harm they supposedly cause. My own university was rocked by the allegation that members of the
00:11:50University of Ottawa varsity hockey team had participated in a gang rape. The entire team
00:11:57was suspended and publicly shamed. The university president and chancellor talked about rape culture
00:12:04as a campus and social disease needing to be purged. An expensive task force was struck that
00:12:12issued a report recommending basically that the entire university organized courses around the
00:12:18theme of sexual violence the careers were ruined of even hockey team members who hadn't been in
00:12:25thunder bay when the incident allegedly occurred and a long drawn out four-year trial was set in
00:12:32motion in the end only two men were charged and they were ultimately acquitted but no matter
00:12:40their reputations are still in tatters the judge still rebuked them for their ungentlemanly
00:12:46behavior and nobody walked back any of the inflammatory statements and feminist agendas
00:12:53that had been promoted in the wake of the initial unfounded accusation0.99
00:13:02every time we see a high-profile sexual assault trial result in acquittal it sends women back
00:13:07every time not just in cases where the proof of the man's guilt seems unquestionable not just in
00:13:14cases where the woman clearly suffered from a brutal violation no from the feminist point of
00:13:20view any case that goes to trial should result in a conviction so that women can rest assured0.99
00:13:27their word is law julie lalon's disappointment at the verdict it's not surprising because she0.96
00:13:35has a lot invested in men being found guilty of sexual assault she's made male sexual violence
00:13:43her career back in 2014 i tried to speak on campus about the injustice of the anti-male
00:13:53bigotry surrounding the allegation but a group of students called the revolutionary student movement
00:13:59prevented my talk by singing horn blowing and drum pounding it's my hope that as a result
00:14:07of my talk a few of you may decide to okay you know it's the signature
00:14:15it's a signature of a totalitarian ideology to attempt to squash dissent so every time you
00:14:22interrupt you're merely showing your repressive tendencies you're not showing anything about your
00:14:29four years later these students morphed into antifa and prevented me from giving another talk
00:14:57this one on free speech at the ottawa public library showing up in their little black outfits
00:15:04and face masks to block the entrance ways to the library harassing and intimidating library patrons
00:15:11as well as those wanting to attend my talk canada's built on the genocide of indigenous
00:15:16people it's built on the exploitation of like chinese immigrants who came and built on railroads
00:15:21it's built on the exploitation of black immigrants, it's built on exploitation and capitalism,0.96
00:15:26and capitalism is inherently exploiting. It inherently exploits those who are marginalized,0.97
00:15:32like women and gay people and like people of color. I come from a very poor family.
00:19:47Young men from that woman's classes stood up to confess their white male heterosexuality,
00:19:54falling all over themselves in a pitiful display
00:19:58to agree that men shouldn't be allowed to discuss men's issues if they weren't feminist.
00:20:06I am a white heterosexual male, so I personally feel that I enjoy a lot of the privilege that a lot of people in this room and this country and this world do not.
00:20:13I live on a conscious and self-conscious level that I have benefited from being a white male.
00:20:17I'm white, I'm male, straight, I'm temporarily able-bodied, and I'm socially acceptable body size, so I just like to check my privilege first.
00:20:26the year before that in 2013 i had spoken at the university of toronto about women's and gender
00:20:33studies courses criticizing them as ideologically driven fake scholarship there the fire alarm was0.57
00:20:42pulled in order to prevent such a sacrilege from being uttered academic feminism as it is practiced0.99
00:21:08and disseminated in our universities is overwhelmingly intellectually empty incoherent
00:21:17and dishonest this whole reason for being depends on an activist orientation towards1.00
00:21:24women's position in society so it must always find new wars to fight new sources of inequality0.99
00:21:46to decry and that also means therefore that the discipline can't really be at base about the0.74
00:21:55pursuit of truth it must always be advancing its ideological agenda maintaining its world view
00:22:04whatever means by whatever means necessary i mentioned these various protested talks
00:22:12Not to toot my own horn, though I do consider it a badge of honor to join the ranks of the great and
00:22:19the good who have been shouted down or prevented from speaking by the fascist left all across North
00:22:24America. I mention them merely to affirm the outrageous situation on university campuses where
00:22:31speech hasn't been free for a long time and where leftist professors and administrators have
00:22:38smugly tolerated and explicitly encouraged the shutting down of any event challenging their
00:22:46ideological supremacy always of course in the name of the safety and rights of women and minorities0.81
00:22:54of course a speaker who wanted to make damning clit statements about white men or about western
00:23:01civilization that speaker is rapturously received since that time my videos have highlighted the
00:23:09large number of professors who either make the ludicrous claim that free speech was never meant
00:23:14to include what they call right-wing speech or who are too indifferent or naive or careerist or
00:23:21afraid to say anything at all a number of my videos have focused on individual students and
00:23:28professors principled people like kevin areola sage gerard alan franson paul griffiths jordan
00:23:37peterson rick meta rachel fulton brown alessandro strumia and others who have broken with the
00:23:45intersectional feminist orthodoxy and have been viciously persecuted by their holier-than-thou
00:24:22Free speech is the alternative to violence, and there's lots of people who like violence
00:24:49and who are waiting for the opportunity to use it.
00:24:51And I'm hoping that we can talk our way out of it.1.00
00:24:55I started speaking out in the first place because I was appalled by the feminist insistence
00:25:01on men's guilt in the wake of any woman's complaint.0.72
00:25:06This was the era of the Duke lacrosse scandal, mattress girl, the UVA rape hoax.1.00
00:25:14Feminists were always searching for the ultimate symbol of male sexual brutality.0.99
00:25:20matter how many times their vivid illustrations were shown to be fake they continued to insist
00:25:27that false allegations are extremely rare this was the case long before the fall of 2017 and i made
00:25:36videos highlighting some high-profile sexual assault allegations in both canada and the united
00:25:42States arguing that academic feminist ideas about affirmative consent and the rejection of so-called
00:25:50victim stereotypes have had a profound influence on judges and on lawmakers,
00:25:57leading to increasing restrictions on men's ability to defend themselves at trial.
00:26:04then things got much worse in 2017 with the me too movement as women pushed even harder
00:26:12for their voices alone to be able to end careers and destroy reputations and a tsunami of
00:26:20allegations and social media mobbings followed believing women became an article of faith
00:26:27and anyone who dissented was sought out for a heretic's social death. In the year and a half
00:26:33since Me Too started, despite frequent predictions of its imminent demise, it shows no sign of
00:26:42slowing down. Indeed, claims about harassment continue, and worried leaders in the domains of
00:26:49law, medicine, academia, business, high tech, and engineering are busily making the right noises
00:26:55about promoting women, making the workplace safe, punishing perpetrators, and so on.
00:27:03Men now know that if they are accused, very few will step forward to defend them.
00:27:09A few accused men survive the horror, many do not.
00:27:14I have made and will continue to make videos chronicling the complete breakdown of due process
00:27:21and basic fairness brought about by the Me Too movement.
00:27:25Unlike some others who are hopeful that feminism will eventually run out of steam or that rational dialogue will win out, I don't actually see the madness of our time abating.
00:27:41On the contrary, I believe it will worsen. Sanctioned hatreds have no mechanism for
00:27:48self-regulation. Even the prospect of societal breakdown has no damping effect. In fact,
00:27:53societal breakdown is the conscious or unconscious goal of many who drive these movements. Such people
00:28:00cannot be negotiated with, only defeated. And I fear that the forces of reason and truth are
00:28:09far too scattered, too timid, too internally divided, and too uncertain of their own rightness
00:28:17to be able to quash the destructive energies that feminism and other social justice movements0.74
00:28:22have released. Of course, I hope to be wrong, and that's why we want to keep on making videos.
00:28:30There will certainly continue to be plenty of things to talk about, principally the academic
00:28:36source of the ideas that threaten our culture, the persecution of individuals who object,
00:28:42and this persecution is ramping up, I believe, and of course, the devastating consequences
00:28:48for accused men. I know not everybody likes my approach. Some think I'm too right-wing. Sorry.
00:28:57Some think I'm a tradcon. Some think I'm not enough of a tradcon. Some think I shouldn't talk
00:29:04about race. Some think I should show feminism to be merely one symptom of a much larger movement.0.99
00:29:10Some think I'm unfair to certain feminists or too keen to defend accused men. Some think I could
00:29:16make my message more persuasive or palatable by not calling myself an anti-feminist. Well,
00:29:23I do welcome your criticisms and I'm happy to have errors pointed out. And I know I do
00:29:28sometimes make errors even though i try very hard to avoid them but i have to admit i'm not likely
00:29:35to change my perspective i've been observing the social justice mania in academia for over 20 years
00:29:43close up it's the one thing i know with a fairly high degree of certainty and my main aim in these
00:29:51videos is to chronicle it as and its damage to chronicle it as precisely as i can for those
00:29:59who have supported us over the past four years steve and i extend a hearty thanks
00:30:05and we hope to bring you good content in the future