The Fiamengo File - April 11, 2019


Feminists Force Renaming of Buildings - TFF Episode 101

The Fiamengo File 100 - All Anti-Feminism, All The Time Decolonizing Mars with "The Right Stuff" - The Fiamengo File episode 102

Episode Stats


Length

14 minutes

Words per minute

129.85

Word count

1,884

Sentence count

46

Harmful content

Misogyny

18

sentences flagged

Toxicity

3

sentences flagged

Hate speech

8

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 after a number of scandals involving men accused of sexual misconduct universities across north
00:00:08 america have approved the female renaming of campus buildings scholarships and academic
00:00:15 programs. And that's my subject on today's Fiamengo File. 0.93
00:00:30 I'm Janice Fiamengo of the University of Ottawa. The practice of building renaming began last
00:00:36 summer at the University of California at Irvine and has spread rapidly as many colleges are
00:00:43 reacting to an outpouring of me too style allegations of impropriety against men some
00:00:51 universities have chosen not only to force resignations on accused men men accused of a
00:00:58 variety of alleged infractions but also to remove the men's names from the edifices or the programs
00:01:06 they financially endowed and in an astounding move some colleges have even decided to preemptively
00:01:13 remove all male names from campus one university official who drafted the new naming guidelines
00:01:21 for a california university spoke to us on condition of anonymity saying quote the sexual
00:01:28 harassment charges have come so thick and fast that it seemed wise to get ahead of the curve
00:01:33 that way we save ourselves considerable bad pr and financial outlay in the future he added as female
00:01:41 numbers on campus continue to increase, we expect that the level of anti-male hatred and anti-male
00:01:48 allegations will also increase, end quote. The VP academic of a respected Midwestern university
00:01:56 currently contemplating a similar renaming concurred. He said, quote, no one objects to a
00:02:04 woman's name on a building. Male names, unfortunately, especially those associated
00:02:09 with male achievement invention and discovery make many women angry and angry women don't perform as 0.72
00:02:17 well on tests and assignments as we all want them to perform end quote the head of the student union
00:02:24 at a prestigious east coast college also approved the renaming quote the message is clear said
00:02:34 tyler whose pronouns are me me and me administrators recognize the need for a positive
00:02:43 female and non-binary gendered space on campus tyler said the more quickly the university can 1.00
00:02:49 appease feminist demands sometimes by making confessions feminists haven't even thought up yet 0.95
00:02:56 the more likely the universities may be able to avoid the protests we've seen lately some of those 1.00
00:03:02 protests involved mass feintins women exposing one breast in imitation of the ancient amazons
00:03:11 and the pummeling of college spokespersons with sanitary products end quote okay no not really
00:03:21 everything i've said thus far is a joke i was going to do this whole video as a parody but my
00:03:29 husband said it was too difficult to distinguish the parodic from the real the problem is that the
00:03:35 previous scenario is not that far beyond the realm of possibility a realm in which we are seeing men
00:03:41 punished for so-called crimes whose harm exists entirely in the minds of the shrinking violets
00:03:49 who find cause for offense and deep wounding in even the most ordinary of human interactions
00:03:55 This is actually not funny at all. It's a vivid illustration of what happens when
00:04:03 irrational demands to protect women's feelings are allowed to override common sense and basic
00:04:11 fairness. So let me start over basing everything from this point on in the facts as we know them.
00:04:18 the real controversy about building names did emerge at uc irvine last june 2018 when professor
00:04:29 of biology and university benefactor francisco ayala a spanish-born man who donated 10 million
00:04:36 dollars to his university was forced to retire at age 84 and was barred from participating in
00:04:44 any future university events after four women reported that he had sexually harassed him
00:04:51 harassed them most often by giving them compliments and sexually tinged expressions
00:04:58 of admiration and secondarily through minor physical touching in one of the most remarkable
00:05:04 examples of his so-called misconduct he said to a woman quote i just learned that women don't like
00:05:11 to be told they're beautiful but i know you don't mind end quote to which apparently the victim was
00:05:19 too intimidated to respond the alleged helplessness of the female complainants in this case
00:05:26 is remarkable according to an investigation carried out by ayala's university the professor
00:05:33 on one occasion jokingly offered a colleague the opportunity to sit in his lap while she gave a
00:05:40 presentation on another occasion he allegedly told a female professor that she had been so lively 0.69
00:05:48 while making a certain presentation that he thought she would quote have an orgasm end quote 0.55
00:05:54 on another occasion he allegedly remarked to a pregnant woman you're huge even if all the
00:06:02 allegations were true it is staggering to think that such such harsh action was required in response
00:06:10 professor ayala in turn denied many of the allegations and in his own defense he insisted
00:06:16 that old world courtesy lay at the heart of many of his remarks and actions we might also assume
00:06:23 that his advanced age not to mention the different more effusive cultural context out of which he
00:06:31 emerged would be mitigating factors to lessen the harm he was said to have caused could these
00:06:38 women not simply have avoided him if they found his compliment so disturbing or simply ignored his
00:06:45 remarks but apparently that's too much to ask of the modern woman the investigation found that 0.95
00:06:53 female colleagues and students quote felt professionally undermined end quote by ayala's
00:07:00 words and his habit of kissing women on both cheeks was unwelcome and some students and staff
00:07:07 felt quote unable to complain end quote that's all it took for professor ayala's lifetime of
00:07:18 achievements to be sent down the memory hole a few colleagues of professor ayala found his treatment
00:07:26 excessive professor elizabeth loftus a famed cognitive psychologist at uc irvine is reported
00:07:33 as saying that she was, quote, shocked that this man's life was ruined over this collection of
00:07:39 reactions to his behavior, end quote. She found the allegations thin and, quote, far from the
00:07:46 obviously bad behaviors that we want to be punishing, end quote. But most of those consulted
00:07:53 were satisfied with Ayala's punishment and felt he had it coming. After all, he'd been warned and
00:08:01 he hadn't stopped his complimenting. One woman, Professor Jane Zelakova, an ecologist from the
00:08:09 University of Wyoming, said that sexual harassment of all kinds deserves to be punished, not only the
00:08:15 most severe. No form of harassment is okay, she asserted. I hope Professor Zelakova will remember
00:08:23 that if a small group of vindictive students ever comes forward to say that she gave them
00:08:29 unwanted compliments that made them feel professionally undermined. So the elderly 0.55
00:08:36 professor Ayala, recipient of many awards and distinctions for his pioneering work
00:08:41 in drossophila speciation, is now barred from campus and formally disowned by the university.
00:08:50 He will not receive the emeritus status that bestows honor on retired professors. Most remarkably,
00:08:58 he was symbolically banished by having his name removed from two buildings constructed through
00:09:06 the 10 million dollars he had given after he grew rich from a wine grape growing business
00:09:13 according to the university his name will be taken off the school of biological sciences
00:09:18 and the science library as well as from certain graduate fellowships endowed chairs and other
00:09:25 programs many of them started or supported as a result of his generosity. One of the women who
00:09:31 complained about him, in fact, had been awarded a research chair position with his funds. I don't
00:09:38 suppose she feels strongly enough to give the money back. The feminist message couldn't have 0.99
00:09:44 been clearer. Being a first-rate scientist with an international reputation and having given out 1.00
00:09:51 of one's own money to support the university's teaching and research mandate are not enough
00:09:56 to save one from the ignominy of women's accusations, no matter how non-threatening 0.99
00:10:03 one's behavior. Though convicted of no crime and though his main transgression seems to have been
00:10:09 an inability to stay silent about his admiration for female beauty, this elderly man is now a
00:10:17 non-person at UC Irvine. I wonder if his accusers will ever contribute even a tiny fraction of what
00:10:24 he did to science. But not content with its punitive actions, the school's chancellor,
00:10:31 Howard Gilman, even unctuously thanked Ayala's accusers calling their action,
00:10:39 quote, extremely courageous, end quote. I'm sure you'll also be glad to know that Irvine's
00:10:44 diversity advisors reached out to offer counseling to the university community just in case any other 0.66
00:10:52 women had the vapors about all those compliments. It may be too early to say that the Ayala scandal
00:11:00 is part of a trend, but it is not a one-off. And my prediction for what it's worth is that we'll
00:11:07 see a lot more calls for the removal of the names of men who offend. After all, why should women 0.95
00:11:13 have to see the names of men they don't like anywhere. A few months after Ayala's disgrace,
00:11:21 students at the Savannah College of Art and Design in the state of Georgia made the news with a
00:11:28 petition to have the name of Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas removed from the Clarence Thomas
00:11:35 Center for Historic Preservation. A graduate of the school, Sage Lucero, began the petition
00:11:42 citing women's feelings of safety after the Judge Kavanaugh hearings. She said, quote,
00:11:49 I don't want any other female who has hopes and dreams to have to walk through the doors of that 1.00
00:11:54 building. They shouldn't have to be subjugated, I think she meant subjected, to that toxic feeling, 1.00
00:12:01 end quote. Some other students concurred saying how dangerous it is for sexual assault to be
00:12:07 condoned, though it never is condoned and though Clarence Thomas was never even accused, let alone
00:12:13 convicted, of sexual assault. That didn't deter the petitioners. Quote, by naming a building after
00:12:20 Clarence Thomas makes it feel as though sexual assault in the workplace isn't taken seriously,
00:12:28 said Sarah Brassie, a senior at the school. Some wanted the name of the building changed to the
00:12:34 Anita Hill Center. An article on the controversy noted that, quote, attorney Anita Hill claimed that 0.99
00:12:40 Thomas sexually harassed her in an FBI investigation followed, end quote. It did not mention that the
00:12:47 FBI found insufficient evidence to proceed with the criminal charge, but no matter, in an era in
00:12:55 which claims alone are thought sufficient to smear a man's reputation forever. Sage Lucero summed up
00:13:03 the Believe the Women position thus. She said, quote, when will we learn that a victim's trauma
00:13:11 should outweigh politics, end quote. More than 2,400 people signed her petition, though many
00:13:20 students couldn't say when asked what Thomas had done that justified his name being removed from
00:13:26 the building, and some didn't even know who he was. Eventually, the petition was taken down after
00:13:31 Lucero was criticized in turn as a white woman seeking to disgrace a black man. So I'm sure 1.00
00:13:38 next time she'll make certain that her target is the right color for elimination. 1.00
00:13:46 Feminists have long claimed that men control women by controlling language and that a true 1.00
00:13:52 feminist revolution can only come about when women take the tools of their oppression, in this case, 0.98
00:13:58 the power to name into their own hands i expect that for the foreseeable future universities 1.00
00:14:06 will be a lot more careful how they designate their buildings and will find that female names
00:14:13 have a much fresher safer ring to them though i presume that male money will remain attractive 0.90
00:14:20 for some time yet 1.00
00:14:28 You