The Fiamengo File - April 27, 2019


Decolonizing Mars with "The Right Stuff" - The Fiamengo File episode 102

Feminists Force Renaming of Buildings - TFF Episode 101 The Ironies of Feminist History at Fordham Law School - TFF episode 103

Episode Stats


Length

22 minutes

Words per minute

136.86

Word count

3,017

Sentence count

101

Harmful content

Hate speech

10

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 When you think of living on Mars, do you think of Black Lives Matter? Are you inspired to confront 1.00
00:00:08 your ableism or to dismantle your idea of space as a frontier? If so, or if not, you've got
00:00:17 something to learn from a group of woke academics on decolonizing Mars. And that's my subject on
00:00:25 today's Fiumingo file. I'm Janice Fiumingo of the University of Ottawa. All that was missing to
00:00:42 prove the organizer's devotion to diversity was a woman in a niqab. It was a day-long public event 1.00
00:00:50 held last september called becoming interplanetary what living on earth can teach us about living on
00:00:58 mars in general it was an exercise in imagining a future different from and better than the present
00:01:05 the event was held at the prestigious library of congress kluge center in washington dc
00:01:13 the kluge center which was founded in the year 2000 by a 60 million dollar donation from its
00:01:18 benefactor john kludge offers scholars the opportunity to use the well-stocked library
00:01:25 and to interact with members of the u.s congress and the public its purpose is to quote bring
00:01:32 together the world's best thinkers to contribute to the conversation about the challenges facing
00:01:38 democracies in the 21st century and quote there's a link below to the entire becoming interplanetary
00:01:47 day-long discussion, which I think is mandatory viewing for anyone who cares about the educated
00:01:53 imagination in the United States and how thoroughly it has been colonized by identity
00:01:59 politics. I'm going to focus today on the first panel of the conference, which was called
00:02:04 The Right Stuff, obviously in allusion to the film of that name based on the Tom Wolfe book
00:02:11 about the pilots involved in aeronautical research at Edwards Air Force Base and those
00:02:16 ultimately selected for america's first manned space flight space travel has long been thought
00:02:23 to represent much that is good and even glorious about america the triumph of human ingenuity and
00:02:31 daring over the constraints of space and matter but that was emphatically not the focus of this
00:02:38 panel or even a small part of it you can hear the condescension from the very first sentence
00:02:44 of the panel description here it is quote tom wolf's book the right stuff cemented the ideal
00:02:53 of the cowboy astronaut drawing on the frontier themes that have long been used to talk about
00:02:58 space how do these narratives of space exploration inform and influence modern ideas about who can
00:03:07 explore space what does it mean to have the right stuff and how is that meaning evolving end quote
00:03:16 the implication is that the common notion of space travel must evolve because it has been until now
00:03:24 little more than a cowboy story with the white male heteronormative frontier assumptions that
00:03:31 have limited who can explore space the implication being that many who might have contributed have
00:03:38 been prevented from doing so it's a rationale for resentment from beginning to end as so often now
00:03:46 in academia the discussion is not actually about space travel or living on mars but about the
00:03:53 narrative of space travel and how it embodies white supremacism and other isms that must be
00:03:59 resisted worldwide. Thank you everyone so much for being here today. I have some brief opening
00:04:06 remarks before we get to our first wonderful panel. I wanted to begin with a territorial
00:04:12 acknowledgement which I will read from because I cannot memorize anything. We acknowledge the
00:04:20 Piscataway and Pamunkey peoples whose traditional and unceded territory we are gathered upon today.
00:04:25 Gathering here, we pay respect to the elders, both past and present.
00:04:30 We acknowledge the grave harm that colonialism brought to these lands,
00:04:33 and in particular, the erasure of both indigenous and African identities
00:04:37 under not only slavery, but racist laws that segregated all peoples
00:04:41 into the binary classification of white and black.
00:04:45 We honor those who have lived and do live now at the intersections of identity
00:04:49 and experience, which we will be exploring today.
00:04:52 We also honor and thank Piscataway Indian leader Chief Turkey Tayak, whose leadership in the
00:04:57 Indigenous social justice movement of the 20th century played a pivotal role in reclaiming
00:05:02 Indigenous identity not only here but in communities allied with the American Indian
00:05:06 movement for self-determination around the world. The session was set up so that the panelists each
00:05:13 made an opening statement and then spoke generally in response to questions from the chair.
00:05:18 the first panelist was Brenda Child a professor of American Indian history at the University of
00:05:25 Minnesota and you can bet it was no accident that she was placed first just as it was no accident
00:05:33 that the session began with a territorial acknowledgement and an apology for colonialism
00:05:38 it was also no accident I suspect that there were no white men on the panel or in the entire
00:05:47 three-panel conference. The shaming and exclusion of white men is now an explicit part of the
00:05:53 decolonizing academy. Black, indigenous, and Muslim men are allowed a place if they ally
00:06:00 themselves with feminists in attacking so-called white male privilege, but in general, the academy
00:06:06 today, and certainly the discussion on this panel, is about replacing male excellence and rationality
00:06:13 with intersectional feminist moral posturing.
00:06:19 So Native people have been travelers for quite a long time,
00:06:24 and we have had, of course, some famous Native people who've been travelers.
00:06:29 You probably know, thinking about this part of the world,
00:06:32 that Pocahontas traveled from the Chesapeake to London.
00:06:37 She's probably one of the most famous of Native travelers,
00:06:40 And if you head over to the NMEI and you see the Americans exhibit, there is a large story
00:06:48 about Pocahontas and how she's kind of played into American history and even American imaginings
00:06:56 of Native people.
00:06:58 There's another famous traveler that I often think about, a man named Black Elk, who was
00:07:02 a Lakota, who traveled to Europe to perform in the Wild West shows.
00:07:06 And this was a fairly common experience.
00:07:09 I have a friend who's just written a book about indigenous London, about the early Inuit
00:07:13 and other travelers from the Americas who came, sometimes involuntarily, sometimes at
00:07:19 their own will, to parts of Europe.
00:07:24 Professor Child's presentation was not explicitly concerned with space exploration or Mars,
00:07:30 which is not surprising since her area of expertise is indigenous education and history.
00:07:36 told us that indigenous people have traveled extensively specifically by canoe and mentioned
00:07:42 some indigenous people who traveled to europe in earlier eras though not by canoe her main point
00:07:49 was that we need to shift the paradigm of how we understand exploration in particular we need to
00:07:56 stop seeing native peoples as the objects of exploration and see them instead as active agents
00:08:03 By extension, the point seemed to be that those who have not been involved in any manner in space travel should be seen as just as important to it as those who have, which is perhaps the main reason why Professor Child was on the panel in the first place.
00:08:20 The second panelist was Professor Brian Nord,
00:08:24 senior member of the Kavli Institute for Cosmological Physics
00:08:28 and leader of a team of researchers at the University of Chicago
00:08:31 applying artificial intelligence to questions in cosmology.
00:08:36 Unlike the first speaker, it would seem that Professor Nord
00:08:39 would have a great deal of knowledge about the panel topic,
00:08:42 but we never found out what it was.
00:08:45 if we are going to
00:08:49 if we're going to consider
00:08:53 if we're going to think carefully about how we're going to go out there
00:08:56 if we're going to refocus who we center
00:08:59 we need to ask how we've been doing it here
00:09:04 and if we're ready for that change
00:09:06 and if we're ready for
00:09:07 if we're ready to say we're going to go out there
00:09:12 and try to be something different out there
00:09:14 what makes us think we can do that
00:09:16 if we weren't ready to be something different here
00:09:18 I think we're here
00:09:22 right now on earth with this
00:09:24 with these new technologies we're at an inflection point
00:09:26 and we have a decision to make
00:09:28 about
00:09:29 whether we're going to continue
00:09:32 to allow power to accumulate
00:09:34 through these technologies
00:09:36 or if we're going to find a way
00:09:38 to shift that power
00:09:40 to folks who haven't had it before
00:09:44 Professor Nord's main focus, if he can even be said to have had one, was the lack of social
00:10:00 justice on Earth, which has led, it seems, to a disinclination on his part to imagine
00:10:05 any expedition to Mars. He spoke of our failure to refocus who we center. The main philosophical
00:10:13 question related to a possible Mars mission seemed to be for him, quote, will we allow power to
00:10:19 continue to accumulate or will we shift it to folks who haven't had it yet? End quote. The
00:10:25 implication being that until we can shift power to other folks, the time has not yet come to imagine
00:10:31 living on Mars, though it was not made clear how shifting power to folks who haven't had it would
00:10:35 aid space travel or would make for a more just and inclusive society. Judging from the members of
00:10:42 this panel, it will lead to overt bigotry and race-based discrimination. The third panelist
00:10:50 was Dr. Chanda Prescott-Weinstein, now of the University of New Hampshire, also an astrophysicist
00:10:57 and the one with the most to say about herself as a scientist, specifically as a light-skinned
00:11:04 black woman and one of only a very few black physicists working in the United States Academy.
00:11:10 Brian Nord, it turns out, also identifies as black.
00:11:14 But again, she had little to say about her actual research in relation to space exploration.
00:11:21 So because I am a black and Caribbean American descended from slaves,
00:11:25 I'm more familiar with the great law of the Iroquois than I am with any moral rules that my African ancestors lived by,
00:11:32 because I'm actually not sure who my African ancestors were.
00:11:35 And my basic understanding of this law is that it teaches that we must consider the
00:11:39 impact of our actions on those who will live seven generations from now.
00:11:43 And I know that when colonial processes begin, no one is really thinking of the
00:11:48 next seven generations. It's just not how colonialism works. And so because of this,
00:11:52 the list of anxieties that I experience when thinking about the right stuff is
00:11:57 really about whether we are, have the right stuff. When I think about humans
00:12:01 arriving on another planet like Mars, you know, questions I'm asking myself could,
00:12:06 and when we go to the moon, which is actually one of the first destinations,
00:12:10 I think, is could mining on the moon forever alter how a future generation see
00:12:14 this majestic and natural satellite of Earth? Who will profit? Who will perish
00:12:20 in the expedition? Will such missions ultimately exacerbate inequalities that
00:12:25 already exist on Earth? And in fact, will missions to Mars make life on Earth
00:12:30 worse? How can we have these conversations with a language that 1.00
00:12:34 refuses to entwine itself with the lingua franca of settler colonialism? So
00:12:39 discovery, exploration, settlement, colonizing. You dig a little bit deep
00:12:44 and these words come back to settler colonialism. Mars for Professor Prescott
00:12:49 Weinstein is best approached through the lens not of a high-powered telescope but
00:12:55 through the grievance highlighting lens of post-colonial theory where the framing
00:13:00 questions are always pretty much the same ones. Will space research exacerbate existing inequalities
00:13:08 on Earth? She made much of how the very words discovery, exploration, and settlement have a
00:13:15 deep history of violence and therefore how problematic it is to use them. Academics like
00:13:20 Chanda do love to reveal their deeply sensitive moral natures. Prescott Weinstein told us that 1.00
00:13:29 whites visited colonial apocalypse on the indigenous and speculated that the mars mission
00:13:34 might be merely another form of white colonial exploitation she didn't mention whether the
00:13:40 indigenous visited indigenous apocalypse on their neighbors or whether blacks have
00:13:46 any significant history of violence that might diminish their imputed moral preeminence
00:13:52 what meaning dr prescott weinstein asked does a mission to mars have for making black lives
00:13:58 matter or for idle no more. The implication, as with Professor Nord before her, is that we should
00:14:04 not think about going to Mars or about much of anything else until Black and Indigenous peoples
00:14:10 are equitably represented in any scientific project. The final panelist, Professor Ashley
00:14:18 Hsu from Virginia Tech University, spoke about disability. Astronauts in space are themselves
00:14:26 disabled, she asserted, suggesting that people who live with disabilities have much to teach
00:14:32 astronauts, an intriguing idea that she didn't develop, and an idea somewhat in contradiction
00:14:37 to her other claim that it is incorrect to assume that there is anything wrong with people who are
00:14:45 disabled. So I work on disability narratives, so what would I be doing here? The assumption with
00:14:51 the right stuff is that disabled people aren't. 1.00
00:14:56 They don't. 1.00
00:14:57 They don't have the right stuff.
00:14:59 My particular work is on techno-ableism,
00:15:02 meaning I think a lot about how the narratives of technology
00:15:05 that we have often reinforce ableism,
00:15:08 and sometimes do this by using the language of empowerment
00:15:15 to cover up an ableist narrative about disabled lives.
00:15:18 That would see us as defective and needing to be fixed,
00:15:21 but, oh, yay, technology.
00:15:23 So a lot of the ways in which I think about
00:15:25 how disabled people have or have not been included
00:15:28 in what counts as having the right stuff, 0.96
00:15:31 it takes three different veins.
00:15:33 Xu mentioned that deaf people were used in research
00:15:37 into motion sickness in space,
00:15:39 but that these same people were not considered
00:15:42 for recruitment as astronauts,
00:15:45 presenting this latter point as if it were
00:15:47 an example of unjust exclusion.
00:15:51 Actually, she suggested that there is something unjustly exclusionary
00:15:55 built into the very idea of having the right stuff for going into space
00:16:02 because that suggests that we know what the right stuff is
00:16:06 and that we value that rather than valuing, as she suggested we should,
00:16:11 a variety of people who might have, quote, all kinds of stuff, as she put it.
00:16:17 here we came to a truly radical and bizarre affirmation that as we think about space
00:16:24 exploration we should unlearn the ableist idea that specific abilities should be valued as if
00:16:32 there could ever be any successful project that was not highly discriminatory and purposefully
00:16:39 so discriminatory of the inept the malicious the self-aggrandizing the destructive the lazy
00:16:45 and so on. Professor Xu didn't exactly say that it is unethical to value anything over anything
00:16:55 else, since obviously she valued her own analysis, but she certainly did indicate with quite
00:17:02 remarkable assurance that the traditional qualities prized in space missions have been
00:17:08 a product of able-bodied bigotry. Following these opening remarks, there was a more general
00:17:16 discussion in which the panelists elaborated their positions, and I won't go into detail
00:17:20 because mainly they spoke more along the holier-than-thou lines already indicated,
00:17:26 implying that everything American scientific research has ever prized has had an element
00:17:32 of the oppressive. There was much abstract talk of transforming academic institutions.
00:17:40 The only material aspect of space exploration that the panelists were interested to talk about
00:17:47 was the difficulty of, as they called it, pooping in space. Pooping excited them and caused much
00:17:57 hilarity because it de-romanticized the ablest white male narrative of the astronaut. The
00:18:04 conventional story of intense training, hard-won knowledge, dedication, self-sacrifice, true grit
00:18:10 and commitment elements they never once praised or even acknowledged. The focus on poop showed
00:18:19 the astronaut in a humiliating light brought him down to earth, so to speak, made him or her no
00:18:25 more special than anybody else, and that seemed at least partially the undeclared agenda of this
00:18:32 panel. Near the end of the general discussion, Professor Child, the professor of American Indian
00:18:38 History, mentioned that Native Americans are forever having to remind those they call settlers
00:18:45 that, quote, we are the ones from here. You are all from someplace else, end quote, end quote.
00:18:53 Very inclusive of her. She mentioned that her people like to joke amongst themselves about the
00:19:00 settlers leaving. Perhaps they'll create a joke, she said, in which the settlers will go to Mars
00:19:06 and leave the indigenous people with their ancestors. The clear implication being that 0.86
00:19:11 that would be a glad day, with lots of appreciative chuckles from the panel and the audience about 1.00
00:19:18 the disappearance of all the non-Indigenous from North America. It's impossible to imagine 1.00
00:19:25 white professors joking about the disappearance of Indigenous peoples as part of an elite panel
00:19:32 on the philosophy of exploration. Professor Child's lack of embarrassment, as she told her
00:19:40 crude joke, summed up for me the moral and intellectual shallowness of many of those who
00:19:47 are held up as leaders in the academy today, as resentment and blame take the place of useful
00:19:56 analysis. What such academics will accomplish in their quest for social justice remains an open
00:20:03 question, apart from the utter ruin of the university as a merit-based and truth-seeking
00:20:10 enterprise. That's for certain. But if they ever do mount any kind of Mars mission, or actually
00:20:18 any mission at all where excellence matters, I know I'd feel a whole lot better with the Cowboys.
00:20:33 Time for one last question.
00:20:56 So assuming that we do indeed want to colonize Mars, we want to give the first colony every
00:21:02 chance of success, and it could still fail even if we do everything right.
00:21:08 So it takes resources to put people into space, and picking the people most likely to succeed
00:21:14 is critical to reducing the risk.
00:21:16 So I think that it's been a point well made that it's a very prickly question to ask,
00:21:22 but what are the characteristics of the optimal first colonist?
00:21:28 How do we pick those people?
00:21:30 It depends on whether your goal is actually colonization, right?
00:21:36 I think, like, I think I probably want someone who doesn't think about it as colonization.
00:21:43 I'm sure that Donald Trump disagrees with me about that.
00:21:47 Anyone else?
00:21:52 All right.
00:21:55 Well, let's thank our panelists again.
00:22:00 You