The Fiamengo File - May 04, 2019


The Ironies of Feminist History at Fordham Law School - TFF episode 103

Decolonizing Mars with "The Right Stuff" - The Fiamengo File episode 102 How Allegations Affect Our Society - TFF Episode 104

Episode Stats


Length

15 minutes

Words per minute

122.46

Word count

1,937

Sentence count

82

Harmful content

Misogyny

31

sentences flagged

Hate speech

8

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 What does a poster display about women's history tell us about women in America?
00:00:06 Not exactly what it intended, I suspect, and that's my subject on today's Fiomingo File.
00:00:14 I'm Janice Fiomingo of the University of Ottawa. One of the biggest obstacles to
00:00:29 to rational conversation about men and women today is the conviction on the part of pretty
00:00:35 well everyone that women as a whole were oppressed and men privileged throughout all of human history.
00:00:43 Because few of us know history well and because many recent histories have been written by
00:00:49 feminists, we are unable to assess oft-repeated claims about how badly women were treated in the
00:00:56 past. In this video, I will provide a brief outline of some highlights of American women's
00:01:03 history over the last century and more using as my springboard a poster display by the Fordham
00:01:10 University School of Law, a highly ranked law school in New York City. Fordham Law School
00:01:18 recently celebrated the 100th anniversary of the admission of women to the school. And although the
00:01:25 purpose of the display seems to be to highlight the struggles women have had in a society that
00:01:31 too often denied them equal opportunities. In fact, the display can't help but illustrate that
00:01:39 many decisions on women's behalf were taken a long time ago by men to remedy injustices
00:01:48 feminists say remain unaddressed today. Let's start with the event foregrounded by the display
00:01:57 that the school opened its doors to women in September of 1918. Yes, just over 100 years ago,
00:02:08 Fordham law administrators thought it appropriate for women to study to practice law in the same
00:02:14 classrooms as their male colleagues to compete with men and read the same textbooks. What the
00:02:22 display doesn't mention is that Fordham was far from the first. Women were admitted to some 0.63
00:02:29 American law schools as early as the 1870s and were allowed to practice law in federal courts 0.94
00:02:38 starting in 1878. In related professional work, women had been practicing medicine, for example, 0.99
00:02:46 for decades before this, with the first woman, Elizabeth Blackwell, graduating from a medical
00:02:52 school in 1849, and the first woman's medical college opening in Philadelphia in 1850. Women
00:03:01 had been studying at university long before that, ever since Bradford Academy in Massachusetts 0.63
00:03:08 began admitting women in 1803. And by mid-century, a number of distinguished female academics were
00:03:17 working as university professors. In 1866, Sarah Jane Woodson Early became the first African
00:03:26 American woman professor hired at Wilberforce University to teach Latin and English. Frances
00:03:34 Willard, famed temperance leader and women's activist, became the first female college president
00:03:41 at Evanston College for Ladies in 1871, the same year as Harriet Cook, became the first
00:03:49 full professor at Cornell University, a professor of German and history, earning the same salary
00:03:56 as her male colleagues. There are many other such long-ago milestones of equality that could be
00:04:04 named. And it's worth noting that many of these academic and professional opportunities were
00:04:11 opened prior to or in tandem with the first-wave feminist movement. In other words, male willingness
00:04:18 to help women, in some cases predated the organized women's movement and certainly
00:04:26 predated women's winning of the right to vote. This simply does not sound like a society that
00:04:34 confined women to the home, that doubted women's intellectual competence, or that denied them the
00:04:40 opportunity to use their gifts. Quite the opposite. If men had wanted to deny women such
00:04:48 opportunities in the 19th century, they could easily have done so but did not. In 2016, the
00:04:55 number of female students studying law outnumbered the number of male students, just as the number
00:05:03 of women at universities all across North America significantly outpaces that of male students.
00:05:10 Though there have always been men willing to listen to and attempt to address female complaints,
00:05:16 very few women today express concern about men's massive academic decline.
00:05:24 In general, the Fordham School of Law display tells the history of women at the school and
00:05:31 in society generally as if it is incontestably the history of struggle against forces that have
00:05:38 kept women down. The display says that Fordham women's, quote, achievements, along with those
00:05:45 of women from U.S. and world history form a timeline of strength and fortitude, end quote.
00:05:53 Fortitude, the virtue of enduring difficulties with courage, certainly was demonstrated by some
00:05:59 women in the U.S. and the world, but the Fordham display also demonstrates other less desirable
00:06:07 qualities such as hypersensitivity, unfounded resentment, and narcissistic entitlement.
00:06:13 For example, we are told that in 1955, the Fordham University School of Law marked its 50th anniversary, quote, with no formal acknowledgement of its woman students, end quote.
00:06:30 An absurd statement.
00:06:33 Why should it have acknowledged its woman students in any particular manner? 0.97
00:06:37 If women really do want equality of opportunity and equal treatment with men, then a special 0.61
00:06:44 acknowledgement should be the very last thing anyone would desire, especially given the
00:06:49 commonness of women in academia by the mid-1950s, when women accounted for about one-third of all
00:06:58 university students. The fact that an indignant feminist, I'm assuming, thought this allegation
00:07:05 appropriate for a public display in 2018 and that others approved it, says much about the
00:07:11 grievance-mongering compulsion amongst feminist commentators today. Far too many women in our 1.00
00:07:17 society feel a vested interest, it seems, in promoting a victimhood narrative, even when
00:07:24 that narrative is directly contradicted by available facts, a point illustrated in other
00:07:30 parts of the Fordham Law School display. One startling piece of evidence comes when we are
00:07:39 told that in 1963, well over half a century ago, President John F. Kennedy signed the Equal Pay
00:07:47 Act, quote, making it illegal for employers to pay a woman less than what a man would receive
00:07:54 for the same job, end quote. Come again? But aren't women paid 75 cents to every male dollar? 0.97
00:08:03 No, of course not. Paying a woman less for doing the same job as a man became illegal in 1963, 1.00
00:08:11 the year before I was born. Here is a bit of history rarely mentioned by feminists who 0.96
00:08:18 continually complain about the wage gap, a zombie fact debunked time and time again, 0.99
00:08:25 but apparently unkillable. As many reputable commentators have explained, and the links are
00:08:31 below, women as a group do make less overall than men, but that's because they tend to choose
00:08:38 different types of work to do, tend to work fewer hours, take less overtime than men do,
00:08:45 and make other choices that lead to lower income.
00:08:49 The situation has nothing to do with sex discrimination. 1.00
00:08:53 Though many loyal feminists continue to believe 1.00
00:08:56 that a woman standing next to a man 0.98
00:08:59 performing exactly the same job
00:09:00 is being paid less for her work 1.00
00:09:02 simply because she's female, it isn't so. 1.00
00:09:07 And governments have gone even further 1.00
00:09:09 to assuage feminist anger.
00:09:12 in later decades, quote, equal pay for work of equal value became the new Orwellian rallying cry.
00:09:21 It became fashionable and was in some cases built into legislation that men and women doing
00:09:27 different jobs should be paid the same for them if the jobs were deemed similar enough,
00:09:35 according to estimates of the skill, effort, responsibility, and working conditions associated
00:09:40 with them, though quite independent of their market value. Is a librarian worth the same
00:09:48 as an archivist? Yes, say feminists, because librarians tend to be women and archivists 1.00
00:09:54 more often men. No, say employers who discover that it's far easier to hire a competent librarian 0.99
00:10:02 than a skilled archivist. And through it all, we continue to hear about the mythical wage gap.
00:10:09 As the Fordham Law poster inadvertently shows us, feminists have so seriously hoodwinked huge segments of the public that few of us know the facts about male legislators' willingness to accede to women's demands.
00:10:27 On the front of employment, the Fordham display shows us other major gains for feminism that we don't often hear about today.
00:10:37 In 1968, we learn, still more than half a century ago, President Lyndon Johnson prohibited sex discrimination by government contractors and required affirmative action plans for hiring women.
00:10:55 This is quite staggering to contemplate. Government-mandated affirmative action hiring,
00:11:04 the targeted hiring of women because they are women, has been in place for close to 50 years.
00:11:13 Feminists are quiet about this fact. I remember being told when I first learned about affirmative 1.00
00:11:19 action hiring in the late 1980s that it was a temporary measure to help women and certain
00:11:25 minority groups overcome historical barriers and to enable them to see people like themselves in
00:11:31 public positions so that they would feel comfortable striving for such positions.
00:11:36 But could any reasonable person say that we now live in a society where women can't see women in 1.00
00:11:43 positions of authority and influence. Yet affirmative action hiring has become, it seems,
00:11:49 a permanent feature of many workplaces involving the deliberate sidelining of qualified white men
00:11:57 for about two generations and the shoehorning of mainly women into positions by virtue of the fact
00:12:04 that they were born female. Do women never get tired of having things handed to them? 1.00
00:12:12 not most of them, not so far. Today, feminists are bolder than ever about demanding gender quotas 1.00
00:12:20 or radical measures for fields and positions in which women remain a minority. They don't in 1.00
00:12:26 general care about fields and positions in which men are a minority. And as if in evidence that
00:12:34 there hasn't been a need for affirmative action hiring, if there ever was, for a long time, 0.92
00:12:40 but that this hasn't stopped women from playing the victim card we learn from the Fordham display 0.64
00:12:46 that in 1984 that's 35 years ago a graduate of Fordham law school Geraldine Ferraro was the first
00:12:55 female vice presidential candidate with presidential candidate Walter Mondale to
00:13:00 attempt to unseat incumbent Ronald Reagan and his running mate George Bush senior. During the 1.00
00:13:08 campaign, Ferraro, reading straight out of the feminist playbook, accused her vice presidential 0.96
00:13:13 opponent, George Bush, of taking a, quote, patronizing tone with her in their debate. 1.00
00:13:21 Bush routinely used the rhetorical device of, let me help you to understand, with all opponents,
00:13:29 but the story became that he was being condescending with a woman. It's clear that
00:13:36 being a woman in politics has, since at least 1984, brought with it the right to accuse one's
00:13:44 political opponents of sexism, a cheap shot for which the opponent has little recourse.
00:13:51 1984 was also the year that a landmark Supreme Court case opened up male-only private clubs
00:13:59 to women. Men have not been able to gather in private clubs for over 35 years. Female-only
00:14:08 private clubs and spaces are, of course, fine. These stories of female firsts and feminist 0.88
00:14:16 legal victories give us a flavor of the Fordham Law School display. It's all about women showing 1.00
00:14:23 they're just as good as men fighting for equal rights. At least that's the story we're supposed 0.97
00:14:29 to take from it. A more objective appraisal should lead to the conclusion that it's been
00:14:35 a very long time since anyone could legitimately say that women have been legally disadvantaged
00:14:41 in American society and that in actuality, the historical record has been one of male
00:14:47 authored decisions and legal initiatives to advantage women and to aid their success,
00:14:54 often at male expense. On the fronts of pay equity, affirmative action hiring, and political
00:15:01 advantage, women have been given special privileges for many decades. It's a result of the genius 1.00
00:15:09 of feminism and the gynocentric gullibility of the rest of us that feminists can continue to insist 1.00
00:15:17 on how long-suffering women are.
00:15:22 Please consider supporting us on Subscribestar
00:15:26 to help us keep producing male-positive, anti-feminist, and anti-SJW content.
00:15:47 You