00:00:00I hear at least once a week from men who are being investigated at work for sexual harassment
00:00:07allegations, and the fallout from the culture of fear and resentment that has been created
00:00:13for men in all professions and walks of life is even more profound than I think has yet
00:00:19been generally acknowledged, and that's my subject on today's Fiamengo File.
00:00:33I'm Janice Fiamengo at the University of Ottawa. For four or five months now, I've been in
00:00:40correspondence with a cancer surgeon who's been accused by two subordinates of low-level
00:00:46sexual harassment and is now under investigation by a panel of doctors with power to discipline him
00:00:52or even recommend his suspension. This surgeon, whom I'll call Dr. Smith, has always made his
00:00:59patients his first priority and he has devoted his life to creating a professional learning
00:01:05environment at his medical practice. Therefore, he was stunned when two junior colleagues, both
00:01:13women complained about him and i won't go into the details about the allegations because i want
00:01:18to protect his identity but i will say this none of the allegations concerns sexual acts or sexual
00:01:26touching both accusers allege inappropriate comments about their bodies and their sex lives
00:01:34one claims that the surgeon looked at her inappropriately and made her uncomfortable
00:01:39from any objective point of view the allegations are minor and given that they allegedly occurred
00:01:47when no one else was around they are impossible to substantiate but the accusations are being
00:01:54taken very seriously and they have been passed to this three-person panel to investigate and as a
00:01:59result this surgeon's life has been put in a horrific limbo for months with no end in sight
00:02:06Of course, he's had to hire a lawyer, and the lawyer has told him he has about a 5% risk of suspension and a 30% risk of being disciplined on a finding of sexual harassment.
00:02:19The proceeding is a nightmare of ongoing stress during which Dr. Smith has to fight his anger and a sense of helplessness while attempting to maintain the stoic professionalism necessary for his work.
00:02:35He also must remain a devoted husband, loving father, and high-performing surgeon, managing a wide spectrum of complex cases while going through a humiliating process that's expected to last at least another year, perhaps longer.
00:02:51He says that he now understands how cancer patients lose hope and concentration when they first hear the word cancer.
00:02:58that's how he felt when he learned he was under investigation for sexual harassment charges that
00:03:04could result in his termination the man has been told that his best defense is to demonstrate that
00:03:10he takes the accusation seriously and is willing to engage in self-reflection about his own
00:03:15responsibility a galling suggestion when he knows that things either simply didn't happen as alleged
00:03:22or didn't happen at all, but he has no way of proving his innocence and he must merely hope
00:03:28for a sane conclusion to his ordeal. He estimates that hundreds of thousands of dollars
00:03:36will be allegated to investigate the bogus harassment charges. Unfortunately, like many
00:03:43injustices in life, he also knows that the accusers will not face any retribution if the
00:03:48panel determines that the accusations are false or at least don't stand up to scrutiny.0.98
00:03:53So it's a no-lose gamble for the women. Dr. Smith finds it remarkable the ease with which his
00:04:02accusers can make their allegations with no risk to themselves and the seeming ease with which,
00:04:07if the allegations are found credible, he could lose everything, his practice, his livelihood,
00:04:12his reputation, his identity. Even without the allegations being confirmed, he could lose his
00:04:17license to practice if he allows the stress to get to him. This is a man who removes tumors
00:04:24from people's eyes and other organs and reconstructs damaged tissue. His accusers,
00:04:32in contrast, need fear nothing. Moreover, he doubts that either of them will ever become
00:04:37skillful or knowledgeable enough to achieve his level of expertise. This man has a record of
00:04:43outstanding surgical ability in patient care over years.
00:04:49Yet the system seems not to care about that as a factor in his favor and not to appreciate
00:04:55how much the entire community stands to lose if he is to be incapacitated.
00:05:01He feels a profound sense of despair and a loss of faith in the entire patient care structure
00:05:09that he once dedicated himself to maintaining. He feels that he has spent his life giving to
00:05:16humankind in humility, going the extra mile for his colleagues and patients, taking on extra work
00:05:21on scheduled days off, sometimes at the expense of his own health, certainly at the expense of
00:05:26the time he could have spent with his wife and children. Yet he stands to lose it all over
00:05:31nothing, and there's no way he can protect himself. Other allegations could come in
00:05:35at any time. Some of his friends and associates have had similar experiences or they've seen
00:05:42other men accused and they've told him their coping strategy, which is essentially to stop
00:05:49caring. They say they do the least that is necessary to fulfill their contractual obligations
00:05:55and no more. They no longer do voluntary service or teaching. They spend the minimal time necessary
00:06:01with patients. They don't go out of their way to help junior colleagues, especially women.
00:06:06They're far more stressed, far more defensive, far less generous than they were in the past.0.90
00:06:12Why throw your heart and soul into something that could be taken away on a crazy woman's whim?
00:06:19Repressed anger is now a near constant part of their work lives.0.82
00:06:24this is the unseen but enormous cost of me too not only men's legitimate wariness around female
00:06:33colleagues that we've heard quite a bit about but the general loss to the whole society of
00:06:39expertise and dedication of the men who now withdraw into themselves after a false allegation
00:06:44the men who decide not to sacrifice themselves anymore in an environment that won't protect them
00:06:51and goes out of its way to protect their accusers.
00:06:56So imagine the case of this one exemplary man
00:07:00multiplied by a factor of X across the entire Western world.
00:07:07Can we really afford to give up so much knowledge, ability, and goodwill?
00:07:13Are so many highly competent men really so expendable?
00:07:18In the feminist West, we seem more than willing to take the risk.0.96
00:07:24Thanks again, feminism, for making life worse for us all.
00:07:30Please consider supporting us on Subscribestar to help us keep producing male positive, anti-feminist, and anti-SJW content.0.78