The Fiamengo File - May 19, 2016


Climate Of Fear - TFF Episode 38

Professors in Love - TFF Episode 37 r Women Overvalue Themselves - TFF Episode 39

Episode Stats


Length

13 minutes

Words per minute

131.07

Word count

1,806

Sentence count

65

Harmful content

Misogyny

9

sentences flagged

Toxicity

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

7

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 There's been talk on YouTube lately about closing down university social
00:00:05 justice courses, a much-needed reform, but would that be enough to heal the
00:00:10 North American university system? Not by a long shot, unfortunately, because
00:00:15 politically correct orthodoxy on university campuses has spread far
00:00:21 beyond the confines of specific classes, creating a repressive environment of
00:00:27 totalitarian dimensions. That's my subject on today's Fiamengo File.
00:00:37 I'm Janice Fiamengo of the University of Ottawa. In this video I will argue that there are troubling
00:00:42 parallels between the communist regimes of the Eastern Bloc countries during the Cold War period 0.90
00:00:48 and the politically correct hegemony on North American campuses, the purpose of both being to
00:00:54 produce obedient soldiers for the New World Order. The differences are pertinent too, of course.
00:01:01 Enemies of the official ideology in North America are not treated as harshly as they were in, let's
00:01:07 say, the German Democratic Republic, and the surveillance reach of the feminist regime is not
00:01:14 yet near total, as it was in the Soviet bloc. What we are experiencing today is soft totalitarianism,
00:01:23 But it is totalitarianism, make no mistake, a system that, in the name of safety and respect
00:01:30 for women, is creating a climate of fear in which men know that even the most innocent of words or
00:01:38 gestures or nothing at all can bring down the disciplinary power of the authorities.
00:01:45 I'm speaking today specifically about sexual harassment legislation, but the repression
00:01:50 extends into many other realms as well. Recently, it was reported that the United States Justice
00:01:57 Department is forcing universities to investigate any and all reported cases of sexual harassment,
00:02:05 including what it calls, quote, unwelcome conduct or speech of a sexual nature, quote,
00:02:11 regardless of whether it creates a hostile environment, end quote. As critics point out,
00:02:17 this means that a huge amount of everyday interaction could be, and likely will be,
00:02:24 investigated as sexual harassment. A much publicized case occurred last year when
00:02:30 Professor Laura Kipnis of Northwestern University was investigated for a Title IX violation
00:02:36 after she wrote an essay for the Chronicle of Higher Education on what she called the sexual
00:02:41 paranoia on university campuses. Some students complained, saying that her criticism of the
00:02:47 persecution of male professors created an environment in which female students were
00:02:51 afraid to come forward to instigate more persecution. Kipnis was ultimately cleared,
00:02:58 but the unpleasant process she endured will certainly have a chilling effect on open discussion
00:03:04 of campus policy. Now, I admire Kipnis' courage in standing by her position, but she is, after all,
00:03:12 a university professor protected by her union and her public profile, and of course she's a woman. 0.89
00:03:20 Most such cases never see the light of day. They're resolved quietly and secretly behind
00:03:25 closed doors and the mostly men whose lives are ruined or at least severely disrupted
00:03:31 never get to tell their stories. Moreover, such investigations have been going on
00:03:37 for a very long time. At my university, for example, policy 67 on sexual harassment has
00:03:44 been in effect since 1998, nearly two decades. So how is this related to the situation in the
00:03:52 German Democratic Republic? Well, as under communism, the feminist anti-harassment regime 0.96
00:03:59 is all about control of the populace through surveillance and punishment. In East Germany, 1.00
00:04:05 it is estimated that up to half a million Germans, or one in 30 of the population,
00:04:10 were employed as spies for the Stasi in what one scholar has called a widespread
00:04:16 culture of denunciation. The terror of being accused acted as a kind of wall in the mind,
00:04:24 according to one commentator, spreading anticipatory obedience throughout the nation.
00:04:30 From kindergarten on up, East German citizens were trained to monitor one another for incorrect
00:04:38 attitudes and to share the information they gathered with authorities. Millions of ordinary
00:04:44 people acted as informal collaborators with the state, on the lookout for minor failures of
00:04:51 orthodoxy such as, quote, skipping a Russian language class, making an ill-considered comment
00:04:57 at the student union or exhibiting a lack of the proletarian point of view." The keynote of the
00:05:05 whole system was fear. One never knew when one might say or do the wrong thing and thus find
00:05:12 oneself under investigation. And this is now the situation at universities across North America,
00:05:18 where any evidence of male sexual thought crime is carefully monitored. In my country, Dalhousie
00:05:26 university's sexual harassment policy defines harassment and i'm not quoting the entire
00:05:31 paragraph just the most ridiculous bits they're defined to include quote sounds or gestures
00:05:39 emphasizing sex or sexual orientation suggestive staring inappropriate displays or distribution of 0.87
00:05:48 sexually suggestive pictures and unnecessary or unwanted physical contact of a sexual nature such
00:05:55 as patting, touching, pinching, or brushing against." Can you imagine investigating someone
00:06:04 for suggestive staring? There's a wonderful Diana Davison video on this point where the
00:06:11 police officer asks, did he look at you like this? Or like this? Or like this?
00:06:18 Do you look at you like this? Do you look at you like this? Or do you look at you like this?
00:06:31 Imagine the poor fellow expelled from his university studies for brushing against someone.
00:06:38 My university doesn't go into as much laugh out loud detail defining sexual harassment broadly
00:06:44 to include any quote unwanted sexual attention or any quote sexually oriented remark or behavior
00:06:52 which may reasonably be perceived to create a negative psychological and emotional environment
00:06:58 end quote i am blown away by the irony of that word reasonably in the description of the kinds
00:07:06 of remarks it could create a negative psychological or emotional environment
00:07:12 Come on, sexually oriented attraction between young people is not a matter of reasonableness.
00:07:19 And I have zero faith that the ideologues who framed these policies or who sit on these
00:07:26 investigative committees are governed by reason. On the contrary, I have to ask what ridiculously
00:07:33 prudish Victorian fantasy world they're living in to write a sentence like that into policy
00:07:40 and not expect that it will be consistently misapplied and will make men's lives a nightmare
00:07:47 of false allegations. Don't these censorious busybodies understand that male-female relations 0.77
00:07:54 in all aspects of life, but especially amongst young people, often involve erotic feelings
00:08:00 expressed clumsily and crudely as a result of roiling emotions and desires, and are often
00:08:07 structured by the age-old pattern of pursuit and retreat. For a range of biological and cultural
00:08:14 reasons, it is still usually the young man who pursues the woman, who makes the first move,
00:08:20 expresses his interest with looks, actions, and words, and invites the young woman out on dates.
00:08:27 That the recipients of, quote, unwanted sexual attention may sometimes feel uncomfortable,
00:08:34 maybe even deeply uncomfortable, well, that's a fact of life, regrettable at times, but not
00:08:41 something a university investigative committee should be involved in at all. It is something
00:08:48 for adult students to deal with on their own, perhaps in consultation with a counselor if
00:08:54 necessary, but not in consultation with a disciplinary board with the power to expel
00:09:00 a young man for pursuing a woman who didn't happen to find him attractive i'm not talking of course
00:09:08 about criminal behavior such as sexual assault that should be dealt with by the police and the
00:09:13 courts i'm talking about the complex emotional and psychological dynamics of human sexual
00:09:20 interaction the fact is that such interaction is rife with the possibility of hurt misunderstanding
00:09:27 manipulativeness, covert aggression, and yes, downright nastiness, frequently actually on the
00:09:34 part of young women. Do these disciplinary boards care about the hurt feelings of the young man who
00:09:40 thought the girl he had been flirting with was really interested in him only to find out that
00:09:46 she already had a boyfriend and was just using him for help with their science project only to
00:09:51 discard him later, that can be awful and may well involve sleepless nights, anxiety, insecurity,
00:09:58 lowered self-esteem, and difficulty concentrating on schoolwork. So are we going to strike committees
00:10:03 to deal with that too? Perhaps to expel young women who repeat the offense as so many do? 0.73
00:10:09 Of course not, because feminist ideologues aren't interested in these often male forms of 1.00
00:10:16 woundedness. Feminist ideologues are not interested in the various emotional and psychological abuses 0.96
00:10:22 that young women routinely inflict on young men and that create real distress that actively
00:10:27 interferes with male students' ability to participate in university learning. Feminist 1.00
00:10:33 authorities are only interested in what they can class amongst the ever-expanding category 0.81
00:10:38 of sexual trauma for women, even if the trauma is of the objectively trivial sort that any
00:10:45 mature human being should be able to deal with. Nobody who impartially examines these sexual
00:10:53 harassment policies could doubt that they are not mainly about protecting women from abuse.
00:10:59 They're far too broadly conceived for that. They're about monitoring, stigmatizing, and
00:11:06 controlling male sexuality, making it a punishable wrongdoing for an adult male merely to express
00:11:13 sexual interest in an adult female, especially an adult male who is, for whatever reason,
00:11:19 deemed creepy or unattractive by the woman he approaches. This is an outrageous incursion on
00:11:27 individual freedom and testifies to a deeply heterophobic and man-hating culture.
00:11:33 Because the vast majority of the records related to sexual harassment investigations are confidential,
00:11:39 We simply can't know how many male students have been disciplined or what range of sanctions has
00:11:46 been applied to them. I've received many emails from men whose lives have been turned upside down
00:11:52 by investigations of words or actions they can barely remember. Defenders of these committees
00:11:59 will point out that the men aren't always found guilty or always harshly punished. Accusations may
00:12:06 be deemed unfounded or the issue between the complainant and the respondent may be resolved
00:12:11 relatively easily with a mediated discussion and a simple apology. Well, I don't care. The
00:12:17 humiliation and the degradation are still massive, no matter the outcome. The environment of fear
00:12:25 created by these secretive tribunals cannot be underestimated. Such policies state openly,
00:12:33 often in their introductory remarks, that their purpose is not only to punish misbehavior but to
00:12:39 quote, be educational, as the Dalhousie University statement maintains. In other words, the very
00:12:47 existence of the policy will quote, increase awareness and sensitivity to the negative impact
00:12:54 of sexual harassment. It's clever, isn't it? Actually, the existence of the policy does much
00:13:01 more than that, it increases awareness of the special protected status of women on university 0.95
00:13:07 campuses, of the power of their words to destroy men's lives, and of the general loathing and
00:13:14 contempt for the sexual expression of, mainly as it happens, low-status men. These policies are
00:13:22 designed to put men on notice that they can continue studying at university only so long as
00:13:27 an informant for the Feminist Thought Police doesn't report them to a disciplinary committee. 0.97
00:13:34 Welcome to the soft totalitarianism of the Democratic Republic of University North America. 1.00