The Fiamengo File - May 26, 2016


Women Overvalue Themselves - TFF Episode 39

Climate Of Fear - TFF Episode 38 Sons of Feminism - TFF Episode 40

Episode Stats


Length

19 minutes

Words per minute

145.11

Word count

2,782

Sentence count

82

Harmful content

Misogyny

31

sentences flagged

Hate speech

17

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 Do women undervalue themselves? This is a story we hear frequently in the media, 1.00
00:00:06 that women fail to take proper credit for their workplace performance.
00:00:10 Men supposedly suffer from the opposite problem, being overconvinced of their worth,
00:00:16 and this discrepancy leads to many inequities. Can this possibly be true?
00:00:22 That's my subject on today's Fiamengo File.
00:00:30 I'm Janice Fiumengo of the University of Ottawa.
00:00:33 If you like this video, or even if you don't, please subscribe to Studio Brulee. 0.77
00:00:38 If you put the phrase, women undervalue themselves into Google, you'll find an abundance of 0.98
00:00:44 studies about how women underrate their overall job performance.
00:00:50 If you put the phrase, men undervalue themselves into Google, the same studies about women
00:00:56 come up.
00:00:57 Obviously, no researchers of any stature are exploring whether men suffer from lack of
00:01:02 confidence in the workplace.
00:01:04 Let's look at the kinds of claims that are being made.
00:01:08 A 2015 study in London's Daily Mail asserted that women generally ask for lower pay than
00:01:16 men do.
00:01:17 According to the report, women applying for jobs asked on average for 4,000 British pounds
00:01:26 less per year than men did for the same job, and the gender gap widened at the senior level.
00:01:34 For the more prestigious positions, it seems women's undervaluing of their worth was even
00:01:39 more marked with as much as a £10,000 or $15,000 discrepancy. The Daily Mail tells us that
00:01:47 quote, expected salaries varied by industry with women asking for 29% less than men in accountancy,
00:01:56 22% less in banking, 21% less in the energy sector and 18% lower in education, end quote.
00:02:05 So, what do we make of such findings? Well, as you know, I'm not a social
00:02:10 scientist so I invite you to tell me where I'm wrong here. What strikes me is that the report
00:02:15 provided almost no context for the numbers. We're told that women had, quote, the same experience
00:02:22 and qualifications as the men in the various fields, so we're supposed to conclude that the
00:02:26 women simply don't recognize what they're worth. That's the only conclusion suggested by the report. 0.97
00:02:34 The fact is, though, that there is no such thing as the same when we're measuring a worker's
00:02:40 quality each person's experience skills motivation self-discipline drive focus and work ethic are
00:02:47 unique we weren't told and i don't know it could be ascertained whether the women had performed
00:02:53 equally well as their male counterparts in previous positions or whether they were equally
00:02:59 intelligent hard-working ambitious and capable as the men what the study doesn't tell us is that
00:03:05 it's quite possible and even likely that some of the women applying for positions in accounting or
00:03:12 banking were looking for a job that allowed them greater flexibility in hours or more time off or
00:03:18 a less high pressure environment in return for the more modest salary that they sought in which case
00:03:24 they wouldn't be undervaluing themselves but recognizing realistically what they were worth
00:03:30 to their employer and to what extent they were willing to commit to the job.
00:03:35 On the other hand, perhaps money was just not a major factor in their lives because they were
00:03:40 financially supported by their current or former husbands. Perhaps men tend to seek a higher salary
00:03:47 because men have for centuries been the ones who bore the primary responsibility for supporting
00:03:52 their families. None of that was, or could be I guess, a part of the report and the clear
00:03:58 implication was simply the usual one that most industries are happy to take advantage of women's
00:04:06 uncertainty about what they deserve to be paid and that this is unfair there is an obvious 0.99
00:04:13 counter claim that wasn't considered in the article which is that if women are really 0.98
00:04:18 consistently willing to accept less pay dramatically less pay it seems for the same 1.00
00:04:23 job performance for bringing the exact same skills and dedication and ability to the job then why
00:04:30 would accountancy firms and banks and energy companies ever hire men if they have to overpay
00:04:37 them for the same level of commitment and professionalism in fact it turns out that the
00:04:43 story isn't even what its first few paragraphs lead us to believe because further into the story
00:04:48 we learn that, for example, quote, a qualified male accountant expected to earn £47,000 in their
00:04:56 next role compared to just £36,400 for women with the same experience. But the gender gap
00:05:05 narrowed in the manufacturing industry and the legal sector to just 9%, and in the IT and security
00:05:12 industry, women actually asked for higher pay, albeit just 2% more." Now wait a moment,
00:05:20 isn't that quite significant? In a report stating in its headline and opening statements that women 0.99
00:05:26 always ask for less than their male counterparts, that now it turns out that in the IT and security
00:05:32 industries, women are asking for more than men. Doesn't that suggest that the story is not about
00:05:38 women's lower self-esteem but about complex industry-specific variables and men's and women's
00:05:45 differing histories within them but that's not as interesting a conclusion as what we are offered
00:05:51 in the article which tells us at the end that according to feminist activist fiona hathorne
00:05:57 quote stereotypical unconscious biases are alive and kicking in the uk end quote there are a lot of
00:06:07 these kinds of studies around to promote the wage gap myth and to encourage people to take a
00:06:12 parody pledge to value women's and men's achievements equally. To me, they often seem
00:06:19 like reports from Life on Mars in their claim that women don't think highly enough of themselves.
00:06:26 That's never been my experience of women. In 2013, there was a study whose results were
00:06:33 published in Wired magazine that found that women consistently underrate their on-the-job
00:06:38 performance when working in a successful group alongside a man. The subjects of the study were
00:06:43 told that they were working on a team project with a male colleague, though they never met
00:06:47 or interacted with that colleague. At the end, when the results were pooled, they were told the
00:06:52 project was a success and they were asked to rate their contribution. We're told that the women
00:06:58 intended to give more credit to their male co-workers than they took for themselves.
00:07:03 So this seems incontrovertible evidence again of low self-esteem.
00:07:08 But there are problems with how the study was set up.
00:07:10 Specifically, the women were told they were working on a project that men have consistently
00:07:17 excelled at.
00:07:18 They were told that 86% of those working in the field were male. 0.93
00:07:22 So the women were in a sense primed to underrate their performance.
00:07:26 they would have rated it if they'd been told that they were working on a task in which women 1.00
00:07:30 generally excel. Well, that's another question. But ultimately, the real issue, as in the previous
00:07:36 study, is that we know nothing about the actual performances of the women in the study, whether
00:07:42 they deserved equal credit for the team's work. And this is the elephant in the room with so many
00:07:49 of these studies and assertions about how women feel about their treatment in the workplace. 0.97
00:07:54 What are women worth in the job market? Let's say for argument's sake that the results of the
00:08:02 studies are generally true, which I'm not sure there are, but never mind. Let's say that women 1.00
00:08:07 are inclined to rate their work-related achievements lower than men rate theirs,
00:08:12 especially in traditionally male-dominated fields. If that is true, what might it mean?
00:08:19 Where does women's perception of their own performance come from? 0.99
00:08:23 We know the feminist answer to this question. Women's lower self-evaluation comes from the 1.00
00:08:28 messages all around women in the culture, which is apparently a woman undervaluing culture that 0.95
00:08:34 doesn't believe women can do certain kinds of jobs as well as men. 0.98
00:08:38 This is the perfect feminist answer, of course, because it doesn't have to be 0.96
00:08:42 proved, simply asserted. Feminists will point to images of women in the media that supposedly 1.00
00:08:48 objectify them as sexual objects and diminish their other capacities. They never mention, 1.00
00:08:53 of course, that one can find similar images of men and that much of the so-called
00:08:58 objectification can also be perceived as a celebration of female beauty.
00:09:03 Critics dwell at length on trivial incidents such as Tim Hunt's joke about women in science labs,
00:09:09 neglecting to mention that his joke was followed up by an emphatic declaration of support for
00:09:15 women in science. But basically, if one man anywhere says something that can be perceived
00:09:21 as less than 100% over the moon about a woman, that supposedly strikes a shattering blow
00:09:28 to all women's self-esteem. At the same time, these critics have to gloss over the many
00:09:34 positive messages about women that our culture pumps out daily. Does anyone really believe that
00:09:40 a majority or even a minority of mothers are telling their daughters that they're inferior
00:09:46 or that the predominantly female teachers in a pro-feminist pedagogical environment are telling 0.98
00:09:52 female students that they're inferior or that team coaches or drama instructors or 0.97
00:09:58 phys ed instructors or dance teachers or counselors or politicians or news commentators 0.95
00:10:02 or journalists or judges or judeo-christian religious leaders are giving them that message
00:10:08 The fact is that our culture is saturated with adoring messages telling girls not only that they
00:10:14 can do anything they set their mind to. I was told this explicitly in the early 1970s when
00:10:21 I started school. Not only that, but girls are told that they are superior to the violence-prone
00:10:27 and sexually depraved males with whom they share their society. If it were really true that our
00:10:33 culture is misogynist we would expect to find a consistent pattern of negative messages with very
00:10:40 little on the positive side wouldn't we and in a society that did not value women would we really
00:10:47 have so many studies worrying about the fact that women don't properly value themselves
00:10:54 other critics will say well it's not so much the messages that women receive it's the fact
00:10:59 that we don't have 50 percent parity in parliament in the boardrooms on the supreme court and so on 0.57
00:11:07 so in other words women recognize the discrepancy between the messages they receive and the reality
00:11:13 on the ground but this doesn't really explain things either because the fact is that the
00:11:18 reality on the ground has changed dramatically over the last half century so much so that one
00:11:23 would expect women, if they were judging on that basis, to feel euphoria about women's possibilities. 0.84
00:11:29 We've had a steady increase in women's participation in formerly masculine spheres at all 1.00
00:11:35 levels of politics, running companies, completing graduate degrees, practicing law and medicine, 1.00
00:11:41 and so on. So an objective analysis of the advantageous placement of women in business
00:11:48 in the professions should create ever-increasing confidence in women. So, why then would some
00:11:56 women's self-perception of ability be so seemingly out of whack with the modern world? 1.00
00:12:02 Well, what if it isn't out of whack? What if the women's self-judgment is a result of years 1.00
00:12:08 of knowingly letting men do a majority share of the work? The studies we've looked at don't
00:12:14 inquire into what actually happens on a variety of jobs where women and men work together and if
00:12:21 they did they might well find that yes there are inequalities but not the kind the studies
00:12:27 seek in road construction work for example we've all seen women holding the stop sign
00:12:33 while the men shovel the hot asphalt in building construction as a friend of mine reports measures
00:12:38 to increase women's participation have consistently meant inefficiencies and accidents on farms as my
00:12:46 husband remembers from his youth the men did the truly back-breaking work in the chemical industry
00:12:51 as steve tells me from first-hand experience women watch the control board in warmth and comfort
00:12:57 while men work in the freezing rain with dangerous heavy equipment on high scaffolding in the
00:13:02 military, as I'm told by a friend with decades of experience, the pretense of equality covers over
00:13:09 the reality that women simply cannot and do not do many of the combat-related drills and daily
00:13:16 tasks of the men, and that there is a massive cover-up involved so that the women themselves
00:13:22 are protected from having to confront their own inability. In high-level scientific research and
00:13:28 academia as a friend in the field reports men simply tend to be more intensely focused than
00:13:33 women he's noticed that as he and all his friends age most of the women are wanting to step back
00:13:40 from their careers in order to do other things while the men are focusing even more energetically
00:13:45 on their research work perhaps it is the case that women's feeling that the man on the team
00:13:52 contributed more may be due to their general experience of men contributing more.
00:13:59 What if the fact is that a lot of women recognize that they haven't earned the professional
00:14:05 positions they've been given, either individually or as a group, and that despite all the kudos
00:14:12 women regularly receive, overall men often do outperform women, especially in the technical
00:14:19 and scientific fields, even with the game rigged against men as it now is in terms of preferential
00:14:26 recruitment, hiring, and promotions. In fact, the preferential recruitment, hiring, and promotions
00:14:33 probably increase the number of superior performers among men because it guarantees that men must earn 0.54
00:14:40 their positions by having to be significantly better than the women they compete against.
00:14:45 I saw this in hiring competitions in my workplace during the late 1990s and early 2000s 0.92
00:14:52 over and over again. What if the fact is that a lot of women can't help but see all around them 0.99
00:15:00 that men in significantly higher numbers continue to do the most demanding and difficult work as
00:15:06 well as the most prized work from the standpoint of cultural flourishing, the work of invention,
00:15:13 the work of high-level research that wins Nobel Prizes and other forms of recognition,
00:15:18 the work involving the longest hours and the greatest dedication. If women look to the past, 1.00
00:15:25 to that long roll call of greatness in the areas of scientific discovery, medical research, 0.89
00:15:30 technological invention, and artistic greatness, it's an overwhelmingly male roll call. But they
00:15:37 can tell themselves that was because women were held back then well what about now where are the
00:15:44 great female composers where the great female visual artists where the great female inventors
00:15:50 where the great pioneers in medical research or pure science research there are some brilliant 0.76
00:15:56 women certainly but they remain a small minority despite at least a half century in which women
00:16:01 were entirely free and enthusiastically encouraged to pursue greatness just to be clear i'm not
00:16:09 saying that women are inferior to men in their overall contribution to society not at all but
00:16:15 i am saying that in certain areas of creativity and intellectual attainment in those areas that
00:16:21 most explicitly have built and continue to build culture men seem to have an edge not only for
00:16:28 purely intellectual reasons, but, you know, that must play a role, but for evolutionarily
00:16:33 derived reasons of temperament, attitude, character, and sheer drive. And I suspect that
00:16:40 for the foreseeable future, no matter how much society encourages women and tells them they can
00:16:46 do and be whatever they want, and no matter how much artificial equality is created through 0.59
00:16:52 parity pledges for boardrooms and corporate leadership and political office, men will 0.89
00:16:57 continue to outpace women in certain areas of dazzling achievement, and women will continue
00:17:04 to recognize it, even if only grudgingly and with resentment. And if my hunch is right, 0.96
00:17:12 all the special measures in the world will not increase women's self-respect. In fact,
00:17:17 those special measures will have the opposite effect, increasing the imposter syndrome,
00:17:23 the resentment, and the need to seek out yet more false evidence of discrimination. And that's
00:17:29 really too bad because women should recognize men's historical and present achievements with
00:17:34 admiration and gratitude since those male achievements have been so generously shared. 0.96
00:17:41 Let's at least stop pretending that women wrongly undervalue themselves and that yet more money
00:17:48 needs to be wasted coaching women about how great they are and creating artificial conditions in 1.00
00:17:53 which they can feel valued. Where individual women do excel, obviously their achievements 0.99
00:17:59 should be recognized and women's special role in childbearing and child rearing deserves respect
00:18:05 when it's done well. But let's be honest about the relative contributions of men and women,
00:18:10 in those standout areas requiring special brilliance, tenacity, single-mindedness and
00:18:16 self-sacrifice. There is no shame in a society that doesn't achieve absolute parity between men
00:18:25 and women. But there is shame in forcing everyone to act as if absolute parity is desirable or necessary.
00:18:40 Thank you.