The Fiamengo File - June 02, 2016


Sons of Feminism - TFF Episode 40

Women Overvalue Themselves - TFF Episode 39 The Stanford Rape Case - TFF Special Edition, Episode 41

Episode Stats


Length

15 minutes

Words per minute

142.27

Word count

2,201

Sentence count

79

Harmful content

Misogyny

7

sentences flagged

Toxicity

8

sentences flagged

Hate speech

5

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 Are men's problems mainly personal and self-created, while women's problems are caused by men
00:00:08 and male-dominated culture?
00:00:10 And is it worse to be propositioned at a mathematics conference than to be told by your entire 0.99
00:00:17 culture that your sexuality is sick and violent? 0.98
00:00:21 And how did we get to the point where the relatively trivial problems of one sex can 0.99
00:00:25 entirely obliterate the problems of another?
00:00:29 That's my subject on today's Fiamengo File.
00:00:37 I'm Janice Fiamengo of the University of Ottawa.
00:00:40 This is the last video of our second season.
00:00:43 Steve and I are going to be taking a short break and will resume later in the summer.
00:00:48 A while back, one of my Facebook friends alerted me to a December 2014 blog post by an MIT
00:00:55 computer science professor named Scott Aronson.
00:00:59 It described the loneliness, confusion, and self-hatred Aronson had experienced as a self-described
00:01:06 young math nerd, and the bitterness of being told by a feminist culture over and over again
00:01:11 about his privilege as a man. 0.52
00:01:15 The post is a must-read for anybody who cares about the male half of society and the lack
00:01:20 of fit between feminist theory and so many men's lives.
00:01:25 other things, Aronson explains, his experience of his sexuality was a source of unceasing humiliation
00:01:31 and torment. Quote, he says, I spent my formative years, basically from the age of 12 until my mid
00:01:39 20s, feeling not entitled, not privileged, but terrified. I was terrified that one of my female
00:01:47 classmates would somehow find out that I sexually desired her and that the instant she did, I would 0.94
00:01:53 be scorned, laughed at, called a creep and a weirdo, maybe even expelled from school or sent 0.95
00:01:59 to prison. And furthermore, that the people who did these things to me would somehow be morally
00:02:06 right to do them, even if I couldn't understand how. He goes on, you can call that my personal
00:02:14 psychological problem if you want, but it was strongly reinforced by everything I picked up
00:02:20 from my environment. To take one example, the sexual assault prevention workshops we had to
00:02:25 attend regularly as undergrads with their endless lists of all the forms of human interaction that
00:02:32 might be sexual harassment or assault and their refusal ever to specify anything that definitely
00:02:39 wouldn't be sexual harassment or assault. I left each of those workshops with enough fresh paranoia
00:02:46 and self-hatred to last me through another year." The whole post is insightful and funny and sad,
00:02:56 not only describing Aronson's pain in feeling ugly and unwanted, but also the depressing
00:03:02 conviction that he deserved to be unwanted. And nobody cared about his experience. There were no
00:03:10 professors researching it or activists protesting it, no panels convened to discuss it, no government
00:03:16 committees reporting on measures to alleviate it, no task forces to prevent further suffering,
00:03:22 no poster campaigns to alert the public, no government money spent on helping victims.
00:03:28 He was alone. He described in compelling detail how as a young man he begged a doctor to give him
00:03:36 some kind of medication to have his sexual drive eliminated, how he thought often about suicide
00:03:41 and how the only thing that saved him was his love of mathematics eventually success in mathematics
00:03:47 enabled him to gain the confidence to be different in the world to meet women and eventually to marry
00:03:54 and have a child which transformed his life but in the course of his struggle it was understandably
00:03:59 difficult for him to keep believing in feminist claims about the system of male power and female
00:04:07 powerlessness. He tells us this, quote, now the whole time I was struggling with this I was also
00:04:14 fighting a second battle to maintain the liberal enlightened feminist ideals that I had held since
00:04:21 childhood against a powerful current pulling me away from them. I reminded myself every day that
00:04:27 there's no conspiracy to make the world a hell for shy male nerds. There are only individual women and 1.00
00:04:34 men trying to play the cards they're dealt and the confluence of their interests sometimes leads
00:04:40 to crappy outcomes no woman owes male nerds anything no woman deserves blame if she prefers
00:04:48 the neanderthals everyone's free choice demands respect end quote in the end according to aronson
00:04:55 he did manage to maintain his feminist ideals he states now his commitment to encouraging girls to
00:05:02 go into science his support for affirmative action hiring and his horror at the supposedly typical
00:05:09 and widespread female experience of sexual assault and harassment but aronson continues to bristle
00:05:17 at the generally accepted idea of male privilege it simply isn't so he argued in the post men too
00:05:25 can be victims of sexism and the vast majority of ordinary non-alpha men are not privileged at all.
00:05:34 Well, not surprisingly, his post stirred up a hornet's nest of opposition and angry denunciation.
00:05:43 Feminists objected not only that a man would put his pain in words in order to contradict
00:05:49 the theory of male privilege, how dare he, but also that he would seem to put at least part of
00:05:55 the blame on feminism itself, the sacred not-to-be-contradicted equality movement,
00:06:03 for some of the difficulties he had experienced. The general opinion was, well, maybe he'd been
00:06:10 miserable, but he had only himself to blame. He couldn't legitimately blame a larger society in
00:06:17 the way women always can. So what if he had to attend some sexual assault prevention programs? 0.99
00:06:24 Well, women have to get raped. I have to admit I didn't read most of the feminist attacks on 1.00
00:06:31 Aronson. I just couldn't bear it. But I did read Arthur Chu's nominally sympathetic piece in Salon 0.87
00:06:38 magazine called The Plight of the Bitter Nerd, in which a self-proclaimed fellow nerd comes forward
00:06:46 to teach Scott Aronson all about women's suffering that he hadn't apparently understood.
00:06:53 According to Chu, although Scott's suffering was real, it was a self-imposed suffering,
00:07:00 almost entirely caused by ideas inside his own head. While women's suffering, on the other hand,
00:07:07 is not only real, but also externally imposed, as we see demonstrated in the claims of a woman named
00:07:15 Amy who responded to Scott's blog, telling him how she'd been sexually harassed and ultimately
00:07:22 assaulted by shy nerds. So there, shy nerds couldn't be let off the hook. The salon writer's
00:07:30 main point in the article is that men had better get used to the fact that there is a qualitative
00:07:36 difference between their pain and that of women. He sums it up as follows, quote,
00:07:43 Scott's story is about things that happened inside his brain. Amy's story is about actual
00:07:50 things that were done to her by other people against her will without her control."
00:07:58 Well, that's a rhetorically neat opposition, even if it is obviously wrong. It leaves out the fact
00:08:05 that men are harassed and sexually assaulted too, that men are the victims of violence far
00:08:11 more often than women are, that men's depression is real enough to cause disproportionately higher 0.99
00:08:18 incidents of male suicide, and that feminist culture telling Scott he's dirty and disgusting 0.69
00:08:24 is palpably real, not something he made up in his head. But none of that matters to Mr. Chu,
00:08:32 whose feminist blinkers were firmly in place. It's not at all surprising that Aronson's lament
00:08:40 would fall on the deaf ears of ideologues who refused to acknowledge the male victims of our
00:08:47 gynocentric culture. But some non-ideologues did hear Aronson's story and were moved by it.
00:08:53 And perhaps more importantly, other men read his post and were comforted and could believe that
00:08:59 they might live through their personal hells and come out the other side. Stories like Scott's have
00:09:06 had a huge impact on me too.
00:09:09 When I gave my first public lecture
00:09:11 at the University of Toronto three years ago,
00:09:13 I had a pretty good idea about the, in my opinion,
00:09:16 belligerent SJW opposition that would cry foul.
00:09:21 And true to form, they staged a protest
00:09:24 of hysterical dimensions and pulled the fire alarm
00:09:27 to try to prevent my evil words
00:09:29 from polluting the minds of the young. 1.00
00:09:31 Academic feminism, as it is practiced and disseminated in our universities, is overwhelmingly 1.00
00:09:41 intellectually empty, incoherent, and dishonest. 1.00
00:09:46 This whole reason for being depends on an activist orientation towards women's position 1.00
00:09:54 in society.
00:09:55 But at that time, I had little idea who I was speaking for.
00:10:00 The young men and the not-so-young men who had come to recognize that their society cared
00:10:06 a lot more about women than it did about them.
00:10:09 In the months that followed the talk, I received a lot of emails from these men telling me
00:10:14 about their lives, especially their sense of being blamed for everything and the concrete
00:10:20 injustices they had experienced.
00:10:23 are just a few examples. The first is from an email from a man who wrote me after my
00:10:28 talk at Queen's University in 2014 about being a male student. This is what he says,
00:10:35 quote, I was born in 1988 and my experience at school was that at every level of education
00:10:41 there was outreach for girls and both explicit and implicit understandings that girls were to
00:10:48 be treated with respect and sensitivity. This doctrine was never extended to the boys.
00:10:55 The impression that this gave me—and all boys, I'm sure—was that girls were the victims of
00:11:00 some form of bias or prejudice that we, the boys, were not to encourage or repeat.
00:11:05 I think it is all but impossible for a child to realize the way he internalizes that message and
00:11:12 assumes that his own problems and inadequacies are his own fault and unimportant, especially since we
00:11:19 were never aware what misdeed against girls we were supposed to ameliorate. The grievances of
00:11:27 past generations never answered the question of why we were to give our female peers more respect 0.65
00:11:35 than we were allowed to give ourselves." And he goes on to describe what he calls the
00:11:41 toxic and shame-inducing experience of having female teachers make it clear that they preferred
00:11:47 female students to male students and that they had contempt for the male part of humanity.
00:11:52 Here's a story from somebody at the other end of the life spectrum looking back on divorce
00:11:58 and losing contact with his son. Quote, he tells us, 45 years ago, I had to sit in a police
00:12:06 counselor's office while she and my ex-wife told me that my son was being taken out of the state
00:12:11 where I could never see him without great difficulty and hardship against my wishes
00:12:17 and that there was nothing I could do about it. I've seen him twice since then. He didn't look
00:12:24 good either time now i don't know where he is how he is or even if he's still alive every day i burn
00:12:33 with a furious passion about the injustice that's been done to my son to me and to millions of men
00:12:41 and their children under the oppression of feminism because i know how i feel i know how those other
00:12:48 men feel. Just under the surface in every one of them burns that same furious passion and it's
00:12:55 past the point of negotiating away or counselling away." A third example involves someone I came
00:13:05 to know in Ottawa who returned home from a trip abroad to discover that his wife had thrown a
00:13:12 bunch of his clothes and belongings into his car, telling him she was divorcing him. When he tried
00:13:19 to enter their home, she called the police, saying she feared for her life because her husband was a
00:13:24 controlling man and a gun enthusiast. In fact, he was a collector of heirloom non-functional firearms.
00:13:31 But following the feminist script, the police informed my friend that he had to stay away from
00:13:37 his wife and their children that if he went into his own home he would be charged with trespassing.
00:13:43 Through the long divorce proceedings which led my friend deeply into debt and caused such stress
00:13:49 that he lost his job, his ex-wife told lies about her fear of him and deliberately alienated his
00:13:56 children whom he has now not seen for over 10 years. Nearly half a million dollars in debt and
00:14:03 unable to work due to physical and emotional disabilities, my friend is convinced that his
00:14:07 life will never recover. But his story, as I've learned, is absolutely ordinary.
00:14:16 Over the years, I realized that these stories weren't just for me, that they deserved to be
00:14:23 read by a wider public. And so I got the idea for a book. I decided to call the book Sons of
00:14:30 feminism in order to emphasize the centrality of the feminist revolution in changing the lives of
00:14:36 men today in negative ways. If you have a story you want to tell, please consider contributing a
00:14:44 3,000 to 5,000 word personal essay to this book. I want readers to understand what it means to grow
00:14:52 up male in a post-feminist world that actively denies the reality or significance of male
00:14:59 suffering. Details about the book will be posted on the Studio Brulee site.
00:15:06 Male pain isn't only about things guys make up in their heads, as the Salon Magazine article
00:15:12 outrageously declared. Male pain is real and it's totally unacceptable.