The Fiamengo File - June 16, 2016


The Stanford Rape Case - TFF Special Edition, Episode 41

Sons of Feminism - TFF Episode 40 Feminist Mass Hysteria - TFF Episode 42

Episode Stats


Length

18 minutes

Words per minute

137.59

Word count

2,554

Sentence count

82

Harmful content

Misogyny

6

sentences flagged

Toxicity

10

sentences flagged

Hate speech

3

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 Was Brock Turner's six-month sentence in the Stanford rape case really such a
00:00:05 travesty of justice that the judge deserves to be recalled? That's my
00:00:11 subject on today's special edition Fiamengo File.
00:00:18 I'm Janice Fiamengo of the University of Ottawa and if you like this video, or
00:00:23 even if you don't, please consider making a donation towards my producer Steve
00:00:27 Brule's plan to attend the International Conference on Men's Issues in London, England next month.
00:00:36 Amidst the outrage that has greeted the sentence given to Brock Turner in the Stanford rape case,
00:00:42 we can expect feminist activists, politicians, and an angry public to once again demand changes to
00:00:49 the law and to college programs to punish men more harshly for sexual assault. I can only
00:00:57 hope that cooler heads will prevail. I'll argue here that Brock Turner's sentence is quite harsh
00:01:04 enough, and that his case, supposedly so clear-cut, reminds us that drunken sex and so-called rape are
00:01:13 often very hard to distinguish. And a society that no longer allows honest public conversations about
00:01:22 such matters, supposedly in the name of combating rape culture, is a society that doesn't protect
00:01:30 women and, even more seriously, sets men up for false convictions. Brock Turner is a now 20-year-old
00:01:40 ex-Stanford University student and a gifted competitive swimmer who was found guilty
00:01:47 on June 6, 2016, of sexually assaulting a woman three years his senior who had been drinking so
00:01:55 heavily on the night in question that she claims no recollection of the events. Turner was discovered
00:02:02 on top of her unconscious body outside the frat house where both had been partying. She didn't
00:02:10 wake up for about another three hours according to the vast majority of commentators the kit 1.00
00:02:17 the case fits perfectly the feminist paradigm of campus rape we have a supposedly dehumanizing 1.00
00:02:26 assault behind a dumpster no less by a privileged jock who still thinks he should get away with it 0.99
00:02:34 We have a valiant woman survivor re-victimized at the trial. And we have a white male judge who 0.90
00:02:43 let the rapist off easy. Galvanized by anger and with very little real knowledge of the case, 0.76
00:02:50 more than one million people to date have signed a petition to have the judge, Aaron Persky,
00:02:57 recalled for giving Turner such a supposedly light sentence. And the indie band Good English
00:03:05 has had performance dates cancelled and a wave of outrage coming their way after their drummer
00:03:11 declared her support for Turner, who is a friend from high school. No wonder that Turner's high
00:03:18 school guidance counsellor, who committed the thought crime of alleging that Turner was a
00:03:23 quote, outstanding student, has since apologized publicly for seeming to humanize him.
00:03:33 Even Turner's parents have come in for all-out condemnation because they don't believe in their
00:03:40 son's guilt. Special Venom has focused on the father because he has asked for leniency in the
00:03:46 case and belittled the severity of his son's actions. On the other side, sympathy galore has
00:03:54 poured out for the unnamed woman whose lengthy victim impact statement has been widely published
00:04:01 and pretty much universally celebrated for its alleged eloquence and power. It will be read out
00:04:08 in full in the US Congress as part of a legislative push to prevent rape and punish accused men more
00:04:14 severely in future. A number of talkbackers to the impact statement at BuzzFeed have expressed
00:04:22 their satisfaction at the thought of Turner being raped while in jail. The headline of an article
00:04:29 published in Reason magazine pretty much summed up the public mood. Quote, Brock Turner is a rapist, 0.99
00:04:37 his father is wrong and justice is elusive." Actually, Turner was not convicted of rape. He 0.93
00:04:47 was acquitted of the rape charges in the case. He was actually convicted of sexual assault
00:04:54 for penetrating the woman with his finger. That's all? My husband said when I told him about it.
00:05:03 well it isn't really all and it's bad enough depending on how one believes the whole incident
00:05:09 unfolded but no one knows how the whole incident unfolded and even at the worst it isn't the
00:05:19 unimaginably violent and hideous atrocity that commentators keep insisting it is you won't find
00:05:28 much other than outrage in any of the mainstream commentary, and when the normally prudent Reason
00:05:36 magazine is plugging the same line as BuzzFeed, we know we're dealing with an unusually clear
00:05:43 cultural consensus. The author of the Reason article goes so far as to declare that there
00:05:49 is nothing, quote, ambiguous about this assault. The victim was passed out, the assailant has
00:05:57 failed to accept responsibility or express appropriate remorse, and he has received
00:06:03 essentially a slap on the wrist. Describing how Turner fled the scene and was chased down by two
00:06:11 witnesses, the author of the reasoned piece asserts, quote, and yet Turner did get away
00:06:18 in a sense. He was given a mere six months in prison and will likely serve only three, end quote.
00:06:26 come on months in jail a lifetime ban from competitive swimming having to register as
00:06:34 a sex offender which will have serious long-term consequences and a black cloud of community
00:06:42 hatred and suspicion that will follow him long after he has served his sentence all seem pretty
00:06:49 harsh to me. Turner's comments, contrary to what everyone is saying, do express regret for his
00:06:57 actions. He wrote, quote, I can't believe I imposed such suffering on her, and I'm so sorry, end quote.
00:07:09 True, this is not the absolute self-castigating I-deserve-it-all mortification that his critics
00:07:15 demand of course but even that wouldn't be nearly enough for them and it's not surprising that a
00:07:22 young man who until this event had led pretty much a charmed life and whose downfall came it seems
00:07:28 not from conscious intent but from alcohol-fueled lust well it's just not that surprising that he
00:07:35 would fail to see himself as the monster everyone else has decided he is and the fact that he doesn't
00:07:44 see himself as a monster is not as has been suggested further proof that he is one as a 0.97
00:07:52 white man he has of course become the convenient stand-in for the evil entitlement of all white men 0.71
00:07:59 who supposedly suffer from what nema clark refers to in an article for the chronicle of higher 0.64
00:08:05 education as a quote deficit or quote chasm in their natures caused by systemic privilege
00:08:15 and the fact is that this sexual assault case is ambiguous as so many are so ambiguous that
00:08:24 the jury erred in my opinion in finding turner guilty beyond a reasonable doubt in my opinion
00:08:31 this jury was operating according to the preponderance of evidence model employed in
00:08:36 civil cases and in campus tribunal investigations. In other words, the accused is found guilty
00:08:43 if it was merely, quote, more likely than not that he committed the crime.
00:08:49 This is the direction, certainly, that juries have been primed to move by decades of concerted
00:08:55 feminist propaganda about the claimed prevalence of sexual assault on campus 1.00
00:09:01 and the heinousness of all types of sexual assault.
00:09:06 But this case is not clear. Both Turner and the woman were drinking heavily on the night in
00:09:13 question. Turner's blood alcohol level was 0.17%, twice the legal driving limit, and the
00:09:20 victims was 0.22%, three times the legal driving limit. It's likely that both experienced severely
00:09:29 impaired judgment. In the case of the woman, apparently the alcohol means that she wasn't
00:09:34 responsible for anything she did or said. And in the case of the man, it means that he was
00:09:40 responsible for everything. So how is it that alcohol can be thought to have such different
00:09:46 impacts on two young people on the basis of gender alone? Well, it's because we've bought
00:09:51 the feminist argument that nearly all sex is a form of male violence against women,
00:09:57 and that men who have sex with drunken women are using the alcohol as a weapon in their campaign
00:10:04 of sexual terror. Now, it is possible that this is what Brock Turner was doing, but it is certainly
00:10:12 not proven. It seems to me far more likely that he was a young man very much wanting to have sex,
00:10:20 who thought he had found a willing partner. Nearly all the reports I've read describe
00:10:26 Turner as having assaulted a, quote, unconscious woman, and this is the point that supposedly
00:10:35 makes the case so atrocious and so clear-cut. But it is far from clear whether the woman was
00:10:43 unconscious throughout. Only a few minutes earlier, about 20 or 25 minutes, she had been standing at
00:10:51 the back of the frat house laughing and talking, seemingly at least somewhat coherent. She had been
00:10:57 coherent enough, shortly after midnight a few minutes earlier, for her sister to have left
00:11:03 her at the party thinking that she was fine. Now we don't know whether soon after this she totally
00:11:09 lost control of herself and was taken advantage of by Turner or whether she passed out while they
00:11:16 were, as he said to the police, making out. It makes a huge difference to our understanding of
00:11:24 Turner's intent and of the extent of his wrongdoing whether he walked with a giddy girl outside the
00:11:31 the frat house and made out with a seemingly willing partner who then passed out, something
00:11:38 I suspect is very common in consensual drunken encounters, or whether he dragged an unresisting,
00:11:47 nearly unconscious victim outside the frat house and proceeded to take advantage of her
00:11:54 incapacity. I've seen almost no discussion in the mainstream news reporting of this hugely
00:12:01 important distinction, and as far as I can tell, nobody except Turner himself, and perhaps not even
00:12:08 he, knows for sure which it was. As far as I've been able to ascertain from the police report and
00:12:16 trial documents, no witnesses contradicted Turner's claim that he and the girl
00:12:21 danced together and kissed and everybody seems to have been too drunk to notice whether Turner and
00:12:27 the woman left the frat house hand in hand as he claimed and whether she was behaving relatively
00:12:34 normally at this point. It is not beyond the realm of possibility that in an inebriated state
00:12:41 the woman did consent to Turner's advances that he had reason to believe he was making out with
00:12:48 willing partner and that drunk himself he was in no condition to notice that she had passed out.
00:12:54 I don't see what's so unlikely about this scenario and without evidence that it was not the case,
00:13:00 he certainly does not deserve the six years in prison recommended by the prosecution or the
00:13:08 nine years or 14 years that other commentators have felt themselves qualified to pronounce.
00:13:16 In my opinion, he doesn't deserve any time in jail, and the judge who gave him six months,
00:13:22 of which he will serve three, doesn't deserve to be recalled as a privileged white man giving 0.99
00:13:27 his co-whitey a privileged pass. In my opinion, both Turner and the young woman should have been 0.75
00:13:33 given a stern lecture by the police about their irresponsible sexual behavior and drunkenness,
00:13:39 should have been made to feel ashamed and should have been encouraged to exercise self-restraint
00:13:46 in the future. Both would have benefited from counseling after the event. But we live in a
00:13:53 culture where both men and women are tacitly encouraged to drink heavily and be indiscriminately
00:14:00 sexual and only the man held responsible when it goes wrong. It's considered prudish or victim
00:14:08 blaming to tell women not to drink themselves into a stupor at frat parties. In this case,
00:14:14 the victim's mother actually drove her two daughters to this party despite the fact that,
00:14:20 according to the police report, both girls had already been drinking heavily enough to
00:14:25 be inebriated by the time the mother dropped them off. According to the woman's own statement to
00:14:30 the police, she'd had at least four shots of whiskey, which had given her a buzz. 0.99
00:14:36 now in a culture that says a woman consuming alcohol cannot be held responsible for her 0.78
00:14:42 sexual conduct is this not a case of a mother knowingly putting her daughter in harm's way
00:14:48 is she not then an accessory to the crime if there was a crime well that's a rhetorical rather
00:14:55 than a real question i don't expect we'll see a lot of condemnation of the girl's mother in
00:15:01 all of this discussion and certainly we'll see few quibbles over the much stressed quote
00:15:07 courage of the quote victim it may indeed have taken courage to go through the trial process 0.90
00:15:15 but it is a courage compromised by earlier stupidity and recklessness neither of which 0.97
00:15:22 the woman acknowledges in her victim impact statement in fact at one point in her statement 0.97
00:15:28 The woman asks Turner how he was planning to guarantee her safety at the end of the evening.
00:15:34 This is meant to drive home her point about his indifference to her as a human being.
00:15:41 But it was never reasonable for a grown woman to expect a drunk 19-year-old stranger to ensure
00:15:49 her safety. She also claims in her statement that if Turner hadn't picked on her,
00:15:54 he would have picked on somebody else. She writes, quote, sometimes I think if I hadn't gone then this
00:16:00 would never have happened, but then I realized it would have happened just to somebody else,
00:16:07 end quote. In other words, she's saying Brock Turner was a predator looking for an innocent
00:16:14 victim and she just happened to be the one. But no, whatever Brock Turner is or isn't,
00:16:21 If she hadn't been as drunk as she was he couldn't have picked on her in the way she claims he did
00:16:27 and when it comes right down to it by her own account she doesn't know what he did.
00:16:33 Getting a blood alcohol content of 0.22 doesn't happen by accident. It doesn't come by thoughtlessly
00:16:40 taking a few too many sips of beer or by drinking liquor quote too fast as she claims because her
00:16:46 quote, tolerance had lowered. Getting this drunk happens after a very determined hours-long process
00:16:53 of serious alcohol consumption. This young woman reached a point at which she couldn't take
00:16:59 responsibility for her actions. She's adamant about that, and nobody disagrees. But she reached that
00:17:06 point through several hours of choices made while she was still a rational agent. Those choices
00:17:13 definitely contributed to what happened that night, including that a young man with an exciting life
00:17:20 of competitive swimming ahead of him is now going to jail and will likely never compete again,
00:17:26 perhaps never be able to pursue a respectable profession or hold his head up in his community.
00:17:33 She will go on with her life, traumatized, as she says, but with a tremendous outpouring of
00:17:39 love, exoneration, and praise to help her in the months and years ahead.
00:17:44 Turner's life, by contrast, is ruined, and even his own father isn't allowed to publicly wish it
00:17:53 otherwise. We'll probably hear a lot more about rape culture and the need to more harshly punish
00:18:02 young men as a result of this supposedly unambiguous case, which, judging from all the information
00:18:09 available, is nothing but ambiguous. And all that's really clear are the mixed messages our
00:18:19 culture promotes about men, women, and alcohol, and our society's determination that only 0.61
00:18:25 female suffering is worthy of public empathy. I won't drink to that.