The Fiamengo File - September 08, 2016


Feminist Mass Hysteria - TFF Episode 42

The Stanford Rape Case - TFF Special Edition, Episode 41 The Mandi Gray Rape Case - TFF Episode 43

Episode Stats


Length

18 minutes

Words per minute

133.97

Word count

2,419

Sentence count

—

Harmful content

Misogyny

13

sentences flagged

Toxicity

4

sentences flagged

Hate speech

3

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 Reading news stories about our culture of rape, misogyny, objectification, and sexual harassment,
00:00:07 I often feel that either I am crazy or some significant portion of our society is.
00:00:15 Is it possible that feminism is actually a form of mass hysteria?
00:00:21 That's my subject on today's Fiamengo File.
00:00:24 I'm Janice Fiamengo of the University of Ottawa, and welcome to Season 3 of The Fiamengo File,
00:00:34 where we'll continue to explore our current bizarre and often horrifying cultural moment
00:00:41 in which the very foundations of our civilization are in peril. This is a time when the National
00:00:48 organization for women which bills itself as the largest grassroots women's organization in america
00:00:55 can give its woman of courage award to emma solkowitz a messed up young woman who has made
00:01:03 rape claims rape falsehoods and rape fantasies her life's work this is a time when thousands
00:01:12 of women and men in Canada can claim to know that media personality Gian Gomeschi, accused of sexual 0.64
00:01:19 assault, deserved to rot in prison despite irrefutable evidence that his three accusers
00:01:26 had lied repeatedly in court and to the police. It's a time when over a million people in the
00:01:34 United States signed a petition to recall the supposedly too lenient Stanford rape trial judge
00:01:42 in a case about which most commentators knew nothing beside a few inaccurate headlines.
00:01:49 It's a time when a wealthy British actress can accuse a commuter of sexually assaulting her in
00:01:55 a busy London underground station in the split second in which he walked past, not even breaking
00:02:03 stride a literally unimaginable crime but the police and prosecutors pursued the case to the
00:02:11 bitter end thank god mark pearson was at last acquitted meanwhile sexual harassment now a major
00:02:20 concern of university and workplace policy has been defined so broadly by the american equal
00:02:27 Employment Opportunity Commission that it can literally include anything a man says or does
00:02:34 if the woman claims it made her feel uncomfortable. Surely this is far more than a rational political
00:02:42 movement that is occasionally taken too far, as some say. Surely this movement is irrational to
00:02:50 its core such will be our subject over the next episodes with a special focus on university
00:02:57 campuses because we know that what happens at the university doesn't stay at the university
00:03:05 recently i was re-reading jessica valenti's new york times article titled what does a history of 0.95
00:03:12 leers do to us and i was trying to figure out what is wrong with a woman as successful and
00:03:20 influential as valenti that she views her entire life through a lens of undeserved sexualized 1.00
00:03:28 suffering valenti acknowledges in the article that feminism has made many gains for women
00:03:34 but she rejects the possibility or even the desirability of moving past what sexism has 0.92
00:03:41 as she says done to us in her opinion feminists need to dwell a lot longer on the misery of being
00:03:49 female valenti claims to be speaking for all women not just herself in a characterization
00:03:56 that's not at all unusual in contemporary feminism to be female is to be dehumanized she asserts
00:04:04 she describes how she used to take the subway to school in queens new york when she was growing up
00:04:08 and was frequently groped and saw men exposing themselves but it didn't end then she assures us
00:04:16 it goes on and on and it's never just one incident or one threatening man it's a continuous panorama
00:04:25 of full-on misogyny decades of what she calls quote gendered trauma constantly chipping away
00:04:33 at her quote sense of safety and sense of self end quote merely to exist as a full human being
00:04:40 in such a hateful culture is a perilous struggle it's typical that none of the experiences that
00:04:48 valente names even the explicit ones can ever be verified we are simply to accept her word that
00:04:55 she was groped at least a dozen times that her high school teacher tried to date her that an 0.71
00:05:01 ex-boyfriend wrote whore on her dorm room door that she is daily threatened with rape on twitter 0.68
00:05:08 and so on and we are to accept that such are other women's experiences too if this is a con job 0.92
00:05:17 it's a successful one for these stories of victimhood leave most critics speechless with
00:05:22 discomfort how dare we question a woman's experience every time i've given a talk at a
00:05:29 university i've been assailed afterwards by university age girls telling me of the intolerable 0.78
00:05:35 reality of their trauma how they can't walk from their front door to the bus stop without being 0.99
00:05:41 cat called their constant exposure to male sexual attention what can i say more than that one rape
00:05:48 is too many right now what more can i say that you are devaluing people's experience here by
00:05:55 calling that maybe what they have experience of rape that took away their personal ability and
00:06:00 their personal i mean like their pride and their dignity away from them such stories are as
00:06:12 predictable as they are frankly completely unbelievable i've looked for it believe me
00:06:21 and i can't find it i have never witnessed the behavior described on anything like the scale
00:06:27 asserted i've never had a friend who had to run a gauntlet of male leers and the account bears
00:06:35 no relation to my own experience from the time i was a young girl until now
00:06:40 walking down the street riding public transit attending school working at various secretarial
00:06:45 jobs i knew there was no generalized sexual threat if i felt someone looking at me it didn't
00:06:52 feel like a violation if i was complimented it didn't feel demeaning yeah i was sometimes
00:06:59 embarrassed or irritated by certain comments but i didn't feel diminished in my very soul
00:07:06 and i hasten to say that i didn't lead a particularly sheltered life i went to an ordinary
00:07:12 public school in a working class area i hung out for years at a roller skating rink frequented by
00:07:18 rebellious kids and i got into more than my share of trouble and took way too many risks
00:07:25 so i had some bad experiences as most people do but none of them determined who i am in a society
00:07:31 where women have never been so free or so protected so why do so many girls and women feel compelled
00:07:40 to tell sad stories like valentes and to make that the definitive reality of their lives
00:07:48 there are a few possible explanations one perhaps my experience was unusual maybe it just happened
00:07:57 that men exempted me and all my friends from their cat calling and their harassment they took out
00:08:04 their sexual aggression on others and always when i was out of range this is a possibility but it
00:08:09 seems highly unlikely two perhaps the women who tell their victim stories are simply exaggerating
00:08:17 overplaying a few minor incidents in order to reap the rewards that come to victims in our culture
00:08:23 all that sympathy this may account for some of the victim obsession that i've encountered but
00:08:29 it doesn't seem to account for it all so many of these women valenti included don't seem to be
00:08:36 enjoying themselves despite living lives that by any measure are incredibly safe and prosperous
00:08:42 thanks largely to the brilliance and generosity of men of course but these women's pain and their
00:08:48 anger especially their anger they seem too genuine to be a mere conscious exaggeration which brings
00:08:56 me to the third explanation which is the possibility that a significant portion of
00:09:02 these women especially those who obsess over their injuries so unrelentingly are actually
00:09:09 experiencing a form of low-level hysteria spread across the western world through social media
00:09:17 i'm not a psychologist obviously but it seems that our current preoccupation with all manner of
00:09:23 sexual abuse shares some characteristics of other episodes of mass hysteria except that feminist
00:09:31 hysteria is longer lasting and much more diffuse in its effects historically in mass hysteria we
00:09:40 see a relatively short-lived collective delusion characterized by anxiety irrational behavior
00:09:48 and beliefs and by baseless symptoms of illness as in for example leroy new york where 14 teenage
00:09:57 girls and one boy suddenly began exhibiting Tourette's-like symptoms in 2012. Or a 1944
00:10:05 case in a small Illinois town in which female residents thought they were being poisoned by a
00:10:10 gas that caused their throat and lips to burn, though no gas was ever found and their symptoms
00:10:16 went away when they talked to police. Or a case in Martinsville, Saskatchewan in which dozens of
00:10:22 children claim to have been abused in satanic rituals at a daycare center resulting in over
00:10:28 a hundred charges made against more than a dozen people including a number of police officers all
00:10:33 of it ultimately found to be groundless any google search will turn up many fascinating historical
00:10:40 examples medical doctor andrew wilner has put together an overview of episodes of hysteria on
00:10:46 a website called Medscape. He makes clear that although much remains unknown about the causes,
00:10:53 mass hysteria is a phenomenon in which the power of suggestion is key. Witnessing others,
00:11:01 even a single other, can cause the behaviour to spread. Now think of Anita Hill's accusations
00:11:10 in 1991 against supreme court nominee clarence thomas in which a brilliant lawyer thomas was
00:11:18 nearly denied a place on the supreme court because a single woman alleged that he had many years
00:11:25 before spoken of an interest in pornography to her and said famously now who has put pubic hair
00:11:34 on my coke this alleged harassment was flat out difficult to believe not least because hill kept
00:11:42 in close contact with thomas for years after the incidents were supposed to have taken place but
00:11:49 even if true they were remarkably trivial issues entirely unworthy to have held the attention of
00:11:56 the whole nation during the confirmation hearings yet they did and the impact of that scandal on
00:12:03 north american culture is i believe incalculable according to a university website reporting on
00:12:10 this incident in the five years that followed hill's accusation against thomas sexual harassment
00:12:17 cases more than doubled in the united states from 6 127 in 1991 to 15 342 in 1996 and over that same
00:12:28 period awards to victims under federal law nearly quadrupled from 7.7 million to 27.8 million dollars
00:12:38 now feminists would say of course that anita hill's courage inspired other women who were 1.00
00:12:44 previously suffering in silence another explanation of course would be that the affair inspired women
00:12:51 to see what had formerly been understood as innocuous banter or normal expressions of
00:12:59 sexual interest as intolerable harassment and this is how it goes one case leads to many others all
00:13:08 manifesting the same irrational symptoms the tearful accusations he touched me he propositioned me
00:13:17 he said things i couldn't sleep i was never comfortable in that office again i could feel
00:13:22 him watching me he made me so afraid as the national organization for women knows in giving
00:13:31 its award to emma sulkowicz the more alleged victims are celebrated for their supposed courage
00:13:38 in dwelling on the alleged abuse the more other women will be inclined to view their experiences
00:13:45 through that lens of sexual trauma for which they will require a long long perhaps lifelong
00:13:53 period of healing it is surely significant that girls and women are especially vulnerable to mass
00:14:01 hysteria historical episodes have often included only or predominantly female hysterics like most 0.98
00:14:10 hysterics of course feminist hysterics are true believers no matter what evidence is presented to 0.98
00:14:16 contradict their irrational fear the evidence can't shake their bedrock belief and they experience 0.79
00:14:23 depressive or anxious behaviors such as weeping trouble getting out of bed fear of public spaces
00:14:30 and obsessive compulsive behaviors i've noticed this in news reports of harassment cases in which
00:14:36 the woman reports being unable to get out of bed for months in response to what to any reasonable
00:14:42 person would be only the most minor of incidents such as a university teacher allegedly expressing
00:14:48 some kind of sexual or romantic interest the utter lack of resiliency the prolonged indulgence
00:14:57 in the probing of imagined wounds it betrays a severely disordered mindset 0.99
00:15:05 yet in our time feminist hysteria has gained so many adherents that attempts to point out
00:15:11 its irrationality are considered further evidence of the so-called threat denial of rape culture is
00:15:19 proof of rape culture and and so on just recently ms magazine a mainstream women's magazine with
00:15:26 millions of readers tweeted out a claim about the moral equivalence between the actions of
00:15:31 isis and those of american college administrations it said quote while isis endorses rape american
00:15:40 college administrations similarly facilitate the rape of women on campuses end quote that word
00:15:50 similarly is a breathtaking admission of insanity the suggestion that there is any kind of moral or
00:15:58 any other parallel between a u.s college administration and a barbaric death cult
00:16:04 that uses sexual torture to terrorize whole populations is crazy especially given the
00:16:10 extent to which college administrations are actually under the thumb of government mandated 1.00
00:16:14 feminist policy but ms can make the allegation with no appreciable blowback and many women will 1.00
00:16:21 believe that there is an essential truth to the comparison even as those women are living lives
00:16:28 of unprecedented security one of the great unknowns about hysteria is how it is cured
00:16:37 i'm not aware that there has ever been a case where the cure involved validating the delusion
00:16:44 you don't tell a person who's worried about gremlins releasing poisonous gas into their home
00:16:49 that the government is going to outlaw such gremlin activity that just confirms the hysteric
00:16:55 in her delusion wilner suggests that the most effective treatment involves separating hysterics
00:17:02 from others who have the same symptoms and rationally persuading them out of their delusion
00:17:09 but we're now in a situation where that form of cure is nearly impossible because entire media 1.00
00:17:14 organizations and government bodies exist to support and affirm feminist delusions about
00:17:20 rape culture patriarchy and women's oppression and naysayer voices no matter how evidence-based 1.00
00:17:26 are either drowned out or completely silenced feminist hysterics actually want to change the law 1.00
00:17:33 so that it's easier to convict men of sexual assault on a woman's word they want every school 1.00
00:17:39 and workplace to have a vast punitive machinery to punish men for anything a woman doesn't like
00:17:46 and generally authorities are inclined to give in to their insane demands so this is where we are
00:17:55 Don't expect the hysteria to go away anytime soon, but don't stay silent while it spreads.