The Fiamengo File - September 15, 2016


The Mandi Gray Rape Case - TFF Episode 43

Feminist Mass Hysteria - TFF Episode 42 This Is Feminist Justice - TFF Episode 44

Episode Stats


Length

11 minutes

Words per minute

142.38

Word count

1,640

Sentence count

34

Harmful content

Misogyny

9

sentences flagged

Toxicity

7

sentences flagged

Hate speech

6

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 Yes means yes and no means no. But what does just going along mean? According to feminist
00:00:09 advocates calling the Mandy Gray rape verdict glorious, it means a man should go to prison
00:00:15 because a woman participated in sex when she felt she didn't want to. That's the feminist 0.97
00:00:21 theory of affirmative consent in action and it's my subject on today's Fiamengo file
00:00:32 i'm Janice Fiamengo of the university of ottawa a while ago neo-masculinist
00:00:38 roosh v earned himself a lot of hate when he published an article in early 2015 proposing
00:00:45 that rape be made legal on private property if consent was automatic once the bedroom threshold
00:00:54 had been voluntarily crossed he argued women would be a lot more careful about the men they went home
00:01:01 with well the virtue signalers were after him for that a february 2016 headline in the toronto sun
00:01:11 blared roosh v plans rape should be legal meetup in toronto even though the planned meetup for
00:01:18 roosh fans had nothing to do with that particular article from a year previous six months earlier
00:01:24 when roosh himself had visited canada a petition to deny roosh v accommodation in canada for the
00:01:32 purposes of disseminating hate had garnered 46 940 irate signatures and saw the mayors of various
00:01:41 canadian cities quick to tweet their refusal to welcome him i'm confident the vast majority of
00:01:49 people who wanted to bar rouge from canada and even to prevent his followers from meeting hadn't
00:01:56 even read the article in question but they couldn't resist the opportunity to dramatically
00:02:01 denounce a man who was supposedly in favor of rape roosh defended his article by saying the
00:02:09 piece was a satirical thought experiment not a serious proposal some commentators weren't sure
00:02:15 that that had been his original intention though i think it was it does read like a thought
00:02:20 experiment. It's a deliberately provocative over-claim intended to make a point. And the
00:02:27 point is not really so shocking, and it certainly doesn't, in my opinion, qualify as hate. It's that
00:02:34 if women want to be treated as adults who are responsible for their own behavior, perhaps they 0.99
00:02:40 should think seriously about not getting blotto with men they hardly know, following them home 0.89
00:02:46 from the bar, and then crying foul. 1.00
00:02:51 Whatever one thinks about rouche vie, it's hard to deny that many women seem to do precisely
00:02:56 that, and then if the men are not convicted of rape, the women rail against the patriarchal
00:03:02 system for not believing women.
00:03:05 Now in Canada, there's a case where a man has been convicted, and it seems that far
00:03:10 from legalizing rape we're actually at the point where we're making sex itself illegal for the man
00:03:19 of course in the canadian case which is to be appealed york university graduate student mustafa
00:03:26 urar was convicted of raping fellow graduate student mandy gray the verdict has been widely
00:03:33 celebrated in politically correct circles because it is a case in which a judge has
00:03:38 seemingly gone out of his way to show that he is nothing like the trial judge in the
00:03:43 Gian Gomeschi case. Justice Zucker's verdict reads like a radical feminist textbook full
00:03:50 of statements about rape being about power, about society's unrealistic expectations of how real
00:03:57 victims behave, and about the necessity for couples to practice affirmative consent at all times.
00:04:04 He even brings in battered woman syndrome, though how that is relevant is never made clear.
00:04:10 He enthusiastically accepts Mandy Gray's version of events, despite the fact that she was not,
00:04:17 as a Huffington Post writer phrases it, a perfect rape victim. What that means is that she
00:04:24 explicitly invited a man for sex and then never told him she'd changed her mind about it.
00:04:31 According to the court documents, Mandy Gray had been carrying on a fling with Mustafa
00:04:38 Urar in the couple of weeks before the night of the alleged rape. On that evening, she was drinking
00:04:43 with some friends, and she texted Mustafa asking him to join her and her friends at the bar, 0.97
00:04:49 and promising him that afterwards they would have, quote, hot sex. At trial, she claimed not
00:04:55 to remember exactly what she had texted having erased the texts from her phone when mustafa
00:05:02 eventually took her up on her invitation she proceeded to get drunk enough to feel she had
00:05:08 to crash at his place just to sleep there although she had the opportunity to go home with her friend
00:05:15 lacy or to catch a cab to her own home or to call somebody else to help her she chose to stay with
00:05:21 him very late into the night and quite a few drinks later she and mustafa went into his bedroom 0.97
00:05:29 where she didn't resist but claims she did not consent to oral sex and sexual intercourse 0.67
00:05:37 she stated at trial that her self-esteem was so low after yarar's vicious tirade on the way to 0.93
00:05:43 his home that she just withdrew into herself and couldn't resist him now obviously someone who
00:05:51 deletes texts and then is allegedly surprised when their compromising contents are revealed
00:05:58 doesn't make the most confidence-inspiring advocate for her case. But even if everything
00:06:04 she stated at trial is true, and even if everything she described is the typical behavior of a
00:06:10 traumatized survivor this is now the standard feminist excuse for anything that might create 1.00
00:06:15 doubt about a victim story well even if mandy is telling the truth it's a strange kind of rape 1.00
00:06:23 non-consensual only in the feminist sense of lacking an explicit yes at every stage of the 0.61
00:06:30 proceedings mandy's own text to her friend on the morning after sums it up quote i don't know
00:06:40 what it is she wrote to her friend quote i didn't consent but i didn't not consent end quote
00:06:50 i agree with a commentator on reddit if you invite a man for sex get drunk with him go back
00:06:55 to his house and do not object when he begins having sex with you it's hard for him to know 1.00
00:07:01 he's assaulting you feminists seem to have no problem with men being put in jail for
00:07:08 failing to secure an appropriate number of affirmatives, but I would hope that reasonable 1.00
00:07:14 people would find that outrageous. To complicate matters further, the defendant said at trial that
00:07:20 it didn't happen as Ms. Gray has claimed at all. In his version, Mandy's anger and hurt arose not
00:07:27 from the fact that he purportedly raped her, but from the fact that he told her he didn't want to
00:07:32 see her anymore roosh v's thought experiment has never seemed more relevant i would modify his
00:07:41 proposal for real rape should never be legal but it should be legally impossible to prosecute a man
00:07:51 for rape when there is not only no evidence that an assault took place but also plenty of evidence
00:07:58 that the woman never said no if it weren't for her eagerness to send a man to prison for her own bad
00:08:06 choices i would actually feel sorry for mandy gray because i don't think she's a very happy girl
00:08:13 on the morning after her encounter with mustafa she texted to her friend quote ah why do i meet
00:08:20 abusive psychos end quote note that she didn't say why did i meet an abusive psycho it is stated
00:08:31 in the present tense and it is stated in the plural in other words it's a general statement
00:08:37 about her life her patterns the men she habitually finds herself involved with whom she allows to
00:08:45 treat her not so well. And her friend's return text shows her recognition of the pattern Mandy
00:08:52 is referring to. Surely it is significant that the friend's first words focus on Mandy's behavior
00:08:59 and mindset. The friend doesn't say, oh my god, you've been raped, go to the police right away.
00:09:06 She says essentially, you should stop doing this to yourself. It's not good for you.
00:09:11 Here are her exact words, quote, I think you need to stay away from him and remember you
00:09:19 deserve better or you'll be walking down a dark path that doesn't change, end quote.
00:09:26 And Mandy's response accepts the implied blame, quote, I know it's true.
00:09:33 It just sucks because that means not going out with a lot of people, end quote.
00:09:39 In other words, Mandy's gone out with men like Mustafa before, and she thinks she likely will
00:09:45 again, though she knows she probably shouldn't. But if the alternative is to be alone, that's hard.
00:09:52 And yes, dating a man who already has a girlfriend, as in the case of Mustafa,
00:09:58 is often a recipe for feeling used. Going home with him when he's made it pretty clear he's
00:10:04 not that interested and is actually annoyed by your behavior well that's probably going to make 1.00
00:10:10 you feel even worse maybe you are was a jerk as some guys are totally focused on getting laid as 0.99
00:10:18 much as possible and not giving a damn about the full personhood of mandy gray but there's no law 1.00
00:10:25 against that at least not yet this is the whole problem with feminism as it is now affecting 1.00
00:10:33 discussions about sexual violence that it has nothing to do with equal rights and responsibilities 1.00
00:10:40 it makes a mockery of any notion of equality before the law and it has everything to do
00:10:47 with using the coercive power of the state to prosecute a man anytime a woman fails to 0.52
00:10:53 feel good about herself even when the man is a stand-in for a whole series of men this woman
00:11:01 has chosen who happened to have made her feel cheap. Roosh V nailed it in the article everybody
00:11:08 loved to hate. If you treat women like children, there's a strong likelihood they'll act like 1.00
00:11:15 children, and the consequences, for men and for the law, sure aren't pretty. 0.97