The Fiamengo File - September 22, 2016


This Is Feminist Justice - TFF Episode 44

Campus Thought - "Gender" Man As Sperm Factory - TFF Episode 45

Episode Stats


Length

13 minutes

Words per minute

120.26

Word count

1,589

Sentence count

22

Harmful content

Misogyny

21

sentences flagged

Toxicity

6

sentences flagged

Hate speech

4

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 what would rape trials look like if we quote believe survivors as we're always told to do
00:00:08 well they'd look like the judgment against mustafa urar a toronto graduate student who
00:00:13 has been convicted of raping fellow graduate student mandy gray in a case in which the worst 0.85
00:00:20 thing urar did was believe that his casual girlfriend's promise of hot sex which she
00:00:27 sent to him in a text was still in force a few hours later that's my subject on today's fiamengo file
00:00:41 i'm janice fiamengo of the university of ottawa in late july of 2016 mustafa urar was convicted of
00:00:49 rape by justice marvin zucker in a toronto courthouse the conviction is now under appeal
00:00:56 and will i hope be overturned for now however it is important to look at the words of justice zucker
00:01:03 to get a picture of how feminist theory is transforming the adjudication of rape cases
00:01:09 zucker's judgment is a word perfect application of feminist thinking on rape particularly the idea
00:01:18 that male sexuality is about power rather than desire and that therefore nearly any sex even
00:01:24 involving no force no inequality and no coercion can be rape depending on the plaintiff's state of 0.97
00:01:33 mind just as zucker repeats the feminist theory of rape as being about power and control on
00:01:40 multiple occasions in his judgment three major planks underpin the theory of rape as men's way
00:01:48 of controlling women, all present in Zucker's judgment, all contributing to the likelihood
00:01:55 that in the absence of evidence, women will consistently win guilty verdicts against men.
00:02:02 First. Over the past 30 years, feminism has moved away from emphasis on stranger rape 1.00
00:02:09 to an increasing emphasis on rape between intimates, first with the idea of date rape 1.00
00:02:15 in the 1990s and now in instances like the mandy gray case where the actors have been sexually
00:02:22 involved with one another for some time what this has done of course is to vastly increase the
00:02:28 number of sexual interactions that can be seen to be rape and to make determining guilt beyond
00:02:35 a reasonable doubt far more difficult under a system presuming innocence i don't know if it
00:02:42 It is merely a coincidence that just when DNA technology was changing the nature of 0.99
00:02:48 criminal investigation, feminists began to focus ever more intensively on he said she
00:02:55 said cases in which DNA is of no help.
00:03:00 In the case of Mandy Gray and Mustafa Urar, Justice Zucker cites a 1991 British House
00:03:06 of Lords statement affirming that,
00:03:08 rape is rape whatever the relationship between the accused and the accuser even if the accuser
00:03:16 is the man's wife the woman always has the right to withhold or withdraw consent now any reasonable
00:03:24 person will agree that it is possible for a man to rape his wife however a reasonable person would 0.91
00:03:32 also, I believe, find it untenable that partners in an established sexual relationship must
00:03:39 always obtain explicit consent. In most such relationships, consent may be simply understood.
00:03:48 This is where the feminist theory of affirmative consent, which is cited many times by Justice
00:03:55 Zucker, turns all sorts of sex into rape. Quote, affirmative consent must be ongoing throughout 1.00
00:04:04 a sexual activity, end quote, according to Zucker, and on this basis, he finds Urar guilty beyond a
00:04:14 reasonable doubt. He doesn't say how Mr. Urar was to know that Ms. Gray, previously a willing
00:04:22 sexual partner and only a few hours earlier having issued an explicit invitation to hot sex how he
00:04:30 was to have known she had changed her mind about the sex if she didn't tell him according to 0.94
00:04:37 justice zucker the fact that she quote stiffened as she claimed and said nothing should have prompted
00:04:44 him to query his partner well perhaps in an ideal world but rape law should not be concerning itself
00:04:53 with a man's failure to meet an ideal of romantic conduct it's supposed to be about crime according
00:05:00 to zucker a crime definitely occurred he says quote it is the personal responsibility of each
00:05:07 person involved in the sexual activity to ensure that he or she has the affirmative consent
00:05:15 of the other end quote but anyone who thinks about it for a minute will know that one can never
00:05:23 ensure this even with constant libido quashing inquiries is this okay is this okay and on and on
00:05:32 there's always the possibility that lack of consent could occur one millisecond after 1.00
00:05:39 an affirmative and then you're in a rape situation because according to feminist dogma
00:05:43 quote silence or lack of resistance does not demonstrate consent that's another quote from 0.86
00:05:50 justice zucker is this judge for real wouldn't it make far more sense to say that it is each
00:05:59 person's responsibility in a sexual interaction to clearly communicate non-consent if that's what
00:06:06 they feel that's far more straightforward you just say no but zucker isn't interested in the woman's
00:06:15 simple responsibility to say no only in the man's impossible responsibility to affirm yes at every
00:06:22 stage this means essentially that every man is always already a rapist unless his partner decides 0.94
00:06:29 that he is not to strengthen women's power over men we have the second plank in the feminist 1.00
00:06:37 platform feminists have applied trauma theory to their understanding of rape such theory explains 0.99
00:06:45 any inconsistencies outright contradictions or general implausibilities in the rape accuser's 0.96
00:06:50 story as arising out of her trauma therefore nothing the woman says or does can be seen to
00:06:57 weaken her credibility this is a perfect circle of illogic because it means that anything that
00:07:05 might be brought forward as contextual evidence that the woman was not raped for example that
00:07:10 she herself didn't think she was raped that her story changed over time or that she lied to the
00:07:16 police well now those very things are not only not evidence that she's lying about the rape
00:07:24 they are actually evidence for her rape trauma and justice zucker buys this completely and uses it to
00:07:32 excuse memory slips and other doubt inducing behaviors on mandy gray's part such as the fact 0.92
00:07:39 that she deleted the text inviting mr urar for hot sex and didn't mention it to police that's okay
00:07:47 according to zucker it's an example of what he calls quote counterintuitive victim responses to
00:07:53 trauma," and he duly cites trauma theorists to support his position.
00:07:59 So it's a double whammy.
00:08:01 Any sex is potentially rape, according to feminist theory, and any complainant, no matter 1.00
00:08:06 how implausible, is a survivor of trauma, precisely because she is implausible.
00:08:14 Finally, the third major plank. 1.00
00:08:18 Feminist theorists have been working for the past 30 years to develop their theory of 0.56
00:08:22 patriarchal power as something so far-reaching so amorphous yet ever-present that even a highly 1.00
00:08:30 educated presumably confident and mentally capable certainly successful sexually liberated white 0.95
00:08:38 woman like mandy gray is supposedly helpless before it this is why mandy gray couldn't say 1.00
00:08:47 no to mr urar couldn't have changed her mind about going into his bedroom and getting into his bed 0.99
00:08:54 couldn't have said please don't when he initiated oral sex she just went along because she was so 0.98
00:09:02 helpless justice zucker has no problem with that either and in fact in relation to this aspect of 0.97
00:09:10 the so-called rape he wrote what is perhaps the most bizarre and outrageous paragraph of his entire
00:09:18 177 page judgment in which he suggests that the law itself needs to change to treat women
00:09:27 differently from men because women are so crushed by patriarchal power that they are not actually
00:09:34 autonomous agents take a deep breath here it is quote the question why didn't she leave
00:09:45 is actually an objectifying statement that asserts that the woman did not leave
00:09:51 Asking this question often makes actual separations disappear. Law assumes,
00:10:02 pretends, the autonomy of women. Why didn't she leave implies the woman could have left. 1.00
00:10:12 left, we need to challenge the coercion of choices, reveal the complexity of experience
00:10:21 and struggle, and recast the entire discussion of separations in terms of violent attempts
00:10:31 at control."
00:10:38 The statement, like much feminist theory, doesn't really make any sense, and Judge
00:10:44 Zucker seems to have forgotten entirely about the specific case of Mandy Gray and Mustafa
00:10:49 Urar as he floats off into some kind of impassioned cry for battered women.
00:10:56 But still, the import is clear.
00:10:59 According to Judge Zucker, women have been so oppressed by patriarchy that they can't
00:11:05 actually say what they mean or act with integrity, and the law can and should be warped by a
00:11:15 judge in order to accommodate any woman's story of victimhood, that a judge can actually
00:11:23 criticize the law for assuming the autonomy of women as he says that he can say that is to say
00:11:32 the least startling what would it actually mean for the law not to assume female autonomy would
00:11:40 it mean women couldn't be held responsible for crimes would it mean women's words and
00:11:46 actions couldn't be understood as reflecting rational agency if taken seriously justice 1.00
00:11:52 zucker's feminist proposition would surely mean a woman couldn't enter into any binding 1.00
00:11:58 legal agreements couldn't sign contracts and couldn't assume positions of legal responsibility
00:12:04 or power i don't know precisely what justice zucker meant but it is shocking that such
00:12:12 abstruse pseudo-academic reasoning can be used to convict a man of a serious crime based entirely
00:12:22 on a woman's word, even though supposedly women are so powerless that they can't be expected to 0.58
00:12:29 say what they mean when it really matters. So, this is what feminist law looks like. Hideous. 1.00
00:12:42 Thank you.