The Fiamengo File - September 29, 2016


Man As Sperm Factory - TFF Episode 45

This Is Feminist Justice - TFF Episode 44 The Unisex University - TFF Episode 46

Episode Stats


Length

9 minutes

Words per minute

151.8

Word count

1,497

Sentence count

—

Harmful content

Misogyny

14

sentences flagged

Toxicity

2

sentences flagged

Hate speech

11

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 Should a woman be able to mutilate a man's dead body in order to fulfill her desire to 1.00
00:00:06 have a child with his sperm? That's my subject on today's Fiumengo File. 0.97
00:00:16 I'm Janice Fiumengo of the University of Ottawa. Recently my Facebook friend Observing Libertarian
00:00:23 drew my attention to a newspaper story he thought deserved a lot more media attention.
00:00:28 the story reveals with striking clarity our society's sense of male lives in this case
00:00:35 literally the male body as having a primarily instrumental value mattering for what they can
00:00:43 provide for women the story out of southern queensland in australia is about a woman leith
00:00:50 pattison whose boyfriend tony dean died quite suddenly last april 2016 of an unrevealed cause 0.97
00:00:58 within a day the woman had gone to the supreme court to request that her boyfriend's testicles
00:01:04 be removed and stored at an ivf facility so that she could use his sperm at some future point 0.68
00:01:10 to get pregnant she claimed that she and her boyfriend had wanted to have a child together so 0.96
00:01:16 that in having his testes removed she was not only pursuing her own interests but fulfilling a shared
00:01:23 dream friends of the couple provided sworn affidavits that indeed the couple had spoken
00:01:28 about having a child and that they'd been planning to get married they had met online six months
00:01:34 prior to mr dean's death initially the dead man's parents made no objection to the request before
00:01:40 the court one can imagine that they were likely stunned by their son's sudden death and weren't
00:01:46 even thinking about anything else but that tragic loss but after the court granted the woman's
00:01:52 request the parents had a change of heart and a follow-up news story reports that they are going
00:01:57 to oppose any attempt by the woman to use their son's sperm it turns out they had never met this
00:02:04 girl before their visit to their son's hospital bed and they have no relationship with her so the
00:02:10 whole thing is a shock and one can imagine that the idea of this woman using their son's body
00:02:16 probably seems like a desecration that's where the story ended and i couldn't find anything more
00:02:22 about it the lawyer for the parents said that it was a fairly unusual case and that he hadn't heard
00:02:28 of many like it which suggests that it actually may be somewhat precedent setting if not legally
00:02:34 than perhaps socially and probably deserving of more discussion by men's rights advocates at the
00:02:41 present time the law is conflicted on this matter in general it does allow women to use their dead
00:02:48 partner's sperm for pregnancy but only where explicit consent has been provided usually in
00:02:55 writing now whether a woman should be able to apply to use her dead partner's sperm without
00:03:01 having obtained consent strikes at the heart of the issue of male bodily autonomy and self-determination
00:03:10 what discussion i could find on the matter didn't consider that aspect at all not surprisingly the
00:03:16 consideration was focused on the desires of the woman and the fate of the unconceived child dr 0.64
00:03:24 Dr. Rebecca Collins has argued that consent laws tend to be too restrictive.
00:03:30 She writes that, quote, presumption against consent in the case of deaths caused by sudden
00:03:37 trauma is not justified by the argument that most people would not have consented to posthumous
00:03:44 reproduction.
00:03:46 She claims, quote, there are at least as good reasons, if not better, for supposing that
00:03:50 in many cases consent would have been given end quote well i'm no ethicist but this seems wonky
00:03:59 reason reasoning surely the issue is not whether in the majority of cases consent would or would
00:04:06 not have been given but that in this case consent was not given now let's consider a different but
00:04:13 not unrelated set of arguments where the issue is women's bodily autonomy we know that the primary
00:04:22 argument in favor of non-medically necessary abortion has for decades been that abortion is
00:04:29 a question of individual female self-determination now here's a quotation taken from an article
00:04:36 called why abortion is a feminist issue on the university of queensland feminist web page
00:04:42 it came up on top in an internet search on that subject the author rosie cupidge puts it this way 0.97
00:04:51 she says quote widely available abortion is essential so that women can determine what to 0.99
00:04:58 do with their own bodies end quote she goes on to say that there are many reasons why women may want
00:05:04 to have an abortion but that's not the issue that's nobody's business the content of their
00:05:09 reasons doesn't matter it is the woman's right and nobody else's to make decisions about her
00:05:15 own body i think it's fair to say that that argument has been so persuasive that it has
00:05:23 often enabled pro-abortion advocates to not only supersede morally powerful arguments about the
00:05:30 rights of the unborn child but even ironically to totally elide the fact that another life is 0.97
00:05:35 involved at all rosie cupidge for example doesn't even bother to argue about why the woman's right
00:05:43 to control her body is more important than the child's right to have a life at all she simply 0.93
00:05:48 says that quote the right to life she puts that in quotation marks to show she's treating it with 0.99
00:05:54 skepticism she says the right to life is thrown around way too often as a reason to deprive women
00:06:02 of their capacity to self-determination this has to stop so she won't even deal with the issue 0.98
00:06:11 logically she simply rules it out of order claiming that quote when abortion is not available 1.00
00:06:17 it centers a woman's life on her reproductive system her reproductive system then becomes
00:06:24 the determinant of her life." I think Cupidge's argument is representative of the main focus of 0.72
00:06:32 most pro-abortion arguments, and it seems to me that the framing of the argument in this manner
00:06:37 is entirely relevant to the case of Tony Dean, whose testes are now in cold storage, potentially
00:06:45 to be harvested by a woman seeking to conceive a child. I couldn't help but think that in one 0.99
00:06:51 sense the case is an ironic answer to the feminist position that abortion is about a woman's control 0.53
00:06:57 over her body in which no man is allowed any say at all it doesn't matter that the man co-created
00:07:05 the child with the woman it doesn't matter if the man wants to have the child it doesn't matter even
00:07:10 if he promises the woman that he'll take over the entire care and financial burden of the child once 1.00
00:07:17 the child is born the feminist insistence is always that he should have no say in the matter
00:07:23 at all and that to all intents and purposes the child belongs solely to the mother well here's a
00:07:29 case where the significance of the man to the creation of the child is front and center and
00:07:35 suddenly all the arguments about self-determination about how a person's reproductive system should
00:07:42 not become the sole determinant of their life's value and about how nobody else should be able to
00:07:48 have any say in what that person does with their body all of a sudden those arguments fade away
00:07:54 and we get a lot of hypothetical talk about whether tony dean or the majority of men would
00:08:01 have consented to posthumous reproduction the fact is that we don't even know for sure that this man
00:08:09 really wanted to have a child friends of the couple say he did but perhaps he was simply
00:08:15 going along with an insistent girlfriend not wanting to have a row in front of their friends
00:08:21 perhaps he had secret reservations about whether the woman would make a good mother or not
00:08:26 perhaps he started out enthusiastic but changed his mind as the relationship progressed regardless
00:08:33 he's dead now and the woman shouldn't be able to decide for him she shouldn't have any access or 0.99
00:08:41 control over his reproductive tissue she shouldn't be able to take his sperm out of his body and the
00:08:48 court should have protected his bodily integrity against her invasive plan i think this is a
00:08:55 frontier for men's advocacy men's right to reproductive self-determination even after
00:09:02 death men have always had fewer reproductive rights than women they've rarely had any say
00:09:10 over the lives of their unborn children women have always been able to decide whether the child 0.68
00:09:15 lives or dies men have had some control about whether sex leads to an unborn life or not but 0.78
00:09:22 in cases where the woman tricks them into producing a life by poking holes in a condom 0.71
00:09:27 for example, men have had no recourse. Until now, though, as far as I know, women have not had the 0.74
00:09:35 right without the man's prior consent to extract sperm from men's dead bodies in order to produce 0.90
00:09:41 the life that they will then shout and demonstrate about their right to control. And they should not
00:09:48 have that control granted to them.