The Fiamengo File - March 17, 2016


Feminism, A Victim Mentality Disorder - TFF Episode 29

Persecution at KSU - TFF Episode 28 Women In Astronomy - TFF Episode 30

Episode Stats


Length

17 minutes

Words per minute

125.77

Word count

2,246

Sentence count

85

Harmful content

Misogyny

54

sentences flagged

Toxicity

8

sentences flagged

Hate speech

16

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 I'm Janice Fiamengo of the University of Ottawa. My theme today is feminist psychology.
00:00:09 I've been asked occasionally to comment on how white Western feminists typically focus 0.98
00:00:16 intensively on what would seem to a reasonable person the most trivial cases of sexism, 1.00
00:00:22 such as so-called workplace sexual harassment, while remaining silent about or even justifying
00:00:29 overt abuses if the accused are not white men, a case in point being the
00:00:35 years-long complicity of many feminist officials and journalists in the cover
00:00:40 up of the sex abuse scandal in Rotherham, England between 1997 and 2013, in which
00:00:48 an estimated 1,400 children were sexually abused, often with extreme
00:00:53 violence by gangs of British Pakistani men, an abuse ignored and denied for years in the
00:01:00 interests of multicultural harmony. I'm not an expert on that or other similar incidents,
00:01:06 but I do consider myself an expert on the white feminist mindset that such incidents illuminate. 0.99
00:01:14 So that's my subject today, a mindset that blends self-justifying claims of moral purity
00:01:22 with anxious deflections of irrational guilt. I know this mindset from the inside. When I was
00:01:29 a student at university, I spent years studying feminist theory, conversing with other feminists,
00:01:36 and believing in feminist ideology. I worked for a year at a rape crisis and women's center in 0.93
00:01:41 Vancouver. I marched in Take Back the Night marches, and I cut my hair short on my head and
00:01:47 grew it long on my legs as a symbol of my feminist convictions. It took getting my first job and
00:01:55 seeing affirmative action hiring in practice that turned me off feminism forever. So in this video
00:02:02 I want to reconstruct the typical story of how an individual white woman becomes a modern feminist
00:02:08 which is also a mini psycho history of modern feminism. I will begin by saying that I'm not
00:02:14 alone in having come to see modern feminism as a social movement that attracts adherents who are
00:02:20 vulnerable to or already possess certain severe emotional problems in other words that the 0.53
00:02:27 feminist way of perceiving the world is both an expression of and an encouragement to disordered 1.00
00:02:34 and irrational thinking in particular feminism manifests many elements of a victim mentality 1.00
00:02:42 disorder . A victim mentality is a learned personality trait 0.97
00:02:49 in which one believes oneself to have been harmed in a manner that is entirely undeserved and for
00:02:55 which one bears no responsibility. Typical characteristics of the victim mentality
00:03:02 include the following. These are summarized basically straight off the internet.
00:03:06 typical characteristics. Blaming others, particularly men of course, for a situation
00:03:14 that one has contributed to. Being unwilling to take responsibility for one's own actions.
00:03:22 Ascribing non-existent negative intentions to other people, particularly to men.
00:03:29 Believing that other people, particularly men, are generally luckier and happier.
00:03:35 And, perhaps most importantly gaining pleasure from feeling sorry for oneself and
00:03:45 eliciting pity from others, and therefore telling exaggerated stories about one's victimization,
00:03:52 in some cases even harming oneself, to support the story. When I was a graduate student in
00:03:58 Vancouver, for example, I knew a girl who beat herself up and then claimed she had been attacked
00:04:04 by two young men because they're a feminist. People with VMD often develop elaborate arguments
00:04:12 in support of their theory. For an example, try reading the jargon-laden Judith Butler.
00:04:18 But they're often not above rather more earthy analyses. I often think of the professor of
00:04:23 philosophy who responded to me with the eloquent, I don't know what the hell you're talking about. 1.00
00:04:29 Feminists with VMD tend to be self-absorbed, unable or unwilling to consider a situation 1.00
00:04:37 from others' point of view. They are hyper-defensive, often reacting with accusations of abuse if 1.00
00:04:45 anyone doubts their story, and tending to see any kind of skepticism or counter-argument as evidence
00:04:51 of further unjust victimization. Obviously, individuals who exhibit these behaviors are
00:04:59 difficult to deal with, creating a great deal of conflict and emotional heartache in their roles as
00:05:05 friends, family members, co-workers or, heaven forbid, bosses. But when they make up a significant
00:05:13 interest group in society with power to influence laws and public policy, they are catastrophically
00:05:20 dangerous. Here's my thumbnail sketch of feminist psychosocial development. 1.00
00:05:27 The average young white woman grows up in a culture that tells her her feelings about
00:05:33 herself and her experiences matter very much, and this has been the case for the past 40 years at 0.57
00:05:40 least under the reign of second wave feminism. The average young woman is typically the
00:05:47 beneficiary of school programs to help girls succeed all the way from primary school to
00:05:53 post-secondary level, and she is typically taught almost entirely by pro-feminist teachers, many of
00:05:59 them women, who praise her for her insights, her social interactions, and her verbal skills. She's
00:06:06 told from an early age that she should assert herself, that girls and women's contribution
00:06:12 to society are worthy of special praise, and that boys and men have no right to make her feel
00:06:19 uncomfortable in any way. At some point, she is also introduced to feminist ideas of blame. She
00:06:26 learns that the history of humanity is a history of women fighting for their rights in a male-dominated 0.56
00:06:31 society. She is also told that women still have a long way to go, that many women face discrimination,
00:06:40 harassment, and objectification. If she is explicitly introduced to feminist theory,
00:06:46 these ideas are intensified tenfold, but even if she never learns feminist theory explicitly,
00:06:53 the ideas of such second-wave feminists as Gloria Steinem and Catherine McKinnon about women's 0.96
00:06:59 subordination are now so widespread in our culture that the average young woman simply 0.74
00:07:05 absorbs them as uncontested facts about the world. For many girls, the years-long immersion in 0.95
00:07:13 mainstream feminist thought has a two-fold effect. First, it channels any feelings of 1.00
00:07:20 dissatisfaction, anxiety, resentment, or self-dislike into anger
00:07:29 at male-dominated society, which is seen as actively and eternally biased against women.
00:07:37 And second, it creates a powerful, heady and exhilarating rush of euphoria, deeply pleasurable,
00:07:46 at perceiving oneself an innocent victim of social forces beyond one's control.
00:07:54 We live in a culture in which victim status confers authenticity, moral innocence,
00:08:01 and an aura of admirable courage for surviving. It wasn't always this way, of course.
00:08:09 There were times in the past, and there are still cultures, in which being a victim is shameful,
00:08:15 equated with loss of status, perceived weakness. But at least since the late 18th century in the
00:08:22 West, a movement to elevate victims as objects of sympathy and interest has gained ever greater
00:08:29 attraction and is now in full flower. In our day, the combination of the two effects I've named—the
00:08:37 creation of a legitimized target for anger and the outpouring of sympathy for female victims—contributes 0.99
00:08:45 to the development of the feminist victim mentality, especially the belief that any 1.00
00:08:50 difficulty in a woman's life—from disliking one's big bum to a failing grade in math—is
00:08:58 caused by a single malevolent source beyond her control and that she is owed public sympathy 0.72
00:09:05 and compensation. Under the feminist VMD, sources of dissatisfaction, rather than being accepted as
00:09:14 part of every life or seen as balanced out by sources of happiness, are eagerly identified, 0.84
00:09:22 remembered, and magnified. The use of the word survivor by feminists 0.93
00:09:29 is a good example of how the two aspects of VMD are expressed in feminist discussions.
00:09:37 Survivor is a term that was once used to distinguish those often Jewish victims of
00:09:42 genocidal attacks who survived the camps or pogroms, but it is used now almost invariably
00:09:49 to refer to women who claim to have been sexually assaulted. The word was chosen
00:09:55 ostensibly to rebut the charge that women revel in their victimization. But in effect,
00:10:02 it intensifies the emphasis on heroic female suffering. The idea of victimization, of course,
00:10:09 remains part of the word survivor. What is one surviving if not one's victimization?
00:10:15 and to that is added a dimension of noble resistance. Survivors claim all the sympathy
00:10:22 due to innocent victims for an assault for which they were not responsible, while also claiming
00:10:28 public admiration and deference for their alleged moral strength and courage in speaking out about
00:10:35 the assault, in alerting society to the problem, and helping other women in similar overcoming.
00:10:42 No wonder that a website devoted to outlining the stages of healing from sexual assault makes it
00:10:49 clear that it can take years, even a whole lifetime, to fully recover from a sexual assault. 0.58
00:10:57 With so many powerful public rewards for victim status, it is surprising not that women emphasize
00:11:04 their victimhood, but that even more women do not do so. But a big problem developed.
00:11:12 for the white feminist along the way. All of these powerfully positive feelings 1.00
00:11:19 are vulnerable to claims made by women in other identity categories, especially lesbians,
00:11:25 black women, aboriginal women, and disabled women. Not only that their suffering is far
00:11:32 more severe than that experienced by white heterosexual women, but even worse that the 0.71
00:11:38 white heterosexual cisgender woman actually participates in the oppression of these others 0.53
00:11:44 through her whiteness, her heterosexuality, her able-bodiedness, etc. This psychological stage 0.86
00:11:52 corresponds to the advent of the third wave of feminism when prominent feminists such as Angela 0.98
00:11:58 Davis, Kimberly Crenshaw, Bell Hooks, and Gayatri Spivak confronted white feminists with their
00:12:05 blindness to the impact of racism, classism, ableism, and heterosexism in women's experience.
00:12:12 Psychologically, this is a shattering accusation, threatening all that the white feminist holds dear
00:12:20 in her self-conception. Most fundamentally, it takes away her moral innocence and the intense
00:12:27 pleasure she has derived from her victimhood. The threat has to be defended against in some manner,
00:12:36 but because the structure of the victim claim made by these other women is so closely related
00:12:41 it's actually identical in outline it's another binary model of innocent victim and privileged 0.87
00:12:47 oppressor, so because the structure of the claim is identical to that made by the white feminist 0.97
00:12:54 herself, it cannot be rebutted without at the same time threatening the grounding of 0.98
00:13:00 the white feminist's own identity, and that identity is far too precious to be surrendered. 0.94
00:13:08 So an accommodation has to be arrived at, and in the history of feminism it was, quite 0.99
00:13:14 simply in theory, it's become the theory of intersectionality, though in practice
00:13:20 it has involved myriad, fairly complicated and sometimes incoherent calculations of
00:13:25 degrees of victimization and complicity. In practice, essentially, white feminist guilt 0.99
00:13:33 for white privilege or hetero privilege is acknowledged, even embraced. Since the deflection 1.00
00:13:40 of blame is always the end goal of the feminist psychosis, that is achieved in this case by 0.95
00:13:47 accepting and then renouncing privilege through confession and contrition. Confession involves, 0.99
00:13:55 as we have often seen, public acknowledgement, the ritual announcement of one's sources of privilege,
00:14:02 and contrition involves attacks on the externalized source of that privilege, whether it be
00:14:08 racist patriarchy, heteropatriarchy, western colonial patriarchy, or what have you. 0.98
00:14:14 Thus, the white feminist reclaims her temporarily lost moral innocence by focusing with ever 1.00
00:14:22 greater fury on white, heterosexual, able-bodied, cisgender male villainy and declaring her 0.99
00:14:28 allegiance with its various victims—the non-Western other, the sexually marginalized, 0.91
00:14:35 and so on. 0.54
00:14:37 She becomes innocent again by becoming a victim advocate for her brown and lesbian sisters,
00:14:44 and even in some cases, brothers. 1.00
00:14:47 This may involve the white feminist in blatant contradictions, but that's fine. 1.00
00:14:53 In recent debates in Canada, for example, about the wearing of the Muslim niqab, the 1.00
00:14:59 white feminist position in support of the niqab involves accepting ideas about female 0.65
00:15:05 sexual purity under Islam that contradict the core principles of Western feminism. 0.97
00:15:12 But such acceptance is eagerly proffered in quest of the moral innocence required by the 0.96
00:15:18 white feminist victim mentality disorder. You see, Islam is by definition in the intersectional 0.80
00:15:25 feminist schema othered by the colonial West and therefore cannot be the main target of feminist
00:15:32 criticism, no matter how repugnant elements of it might be. It is always more important, 0.99
00:15:40 whatever the real issue, to maintain anger at white Western patriarchy and, above all, 1.00
00:15:47 to maintain the white feminist identity as a blameless victim or victim advocate. 0.96
00:15:53 In its simplest outlines, this schema of white feminist VMD can be applied in every situation 0.92
00:16:02 we encounter today. White feminists march in the slut walk one day and want all white women to 1.00
00:16:09 wear a hijab in Muslim solidarity on another day, and you can bet they don't try to shame 1.00
00:16:15 Muslim women into walking talkless in the slut walk. White feminists fuss and fuss about a male 1.00
00:16:23 astrophysicist who wears an inappropriate shirt, seeing his transgression as symbolic of discrimination 1.00
00:16:30 against women in STEM, but stay silent out of multicultural deference when Swedish girls are
00:16:37 systematically attacked by male migrants at a music festival. Though one might have expected
00:16:43 to find disagreement amongst white feminists over such issues, in practice the degree of uniformity
00:16:50 among them is striking. Though we are accustomed to saying that feminism is about female supremacism, 0.64
00:16:59 events such as the Rotherham scandal and recent Muslim attacks on women in various European cities 0.72
00:17:05 about which feminists have been silent or conflicted demonstrate that what feminism is
00:17:11 primarily about is the feminist victim fantasy, a fantasy that has not that much to do with
00:17:19 ordinary women's lives at all. It is about a psychology, an orientation towards the world
00:17:26 having to do with claimed innocence. As a mental disorder, it cannot be argued with,
00:17:32 only defeated. But given its hold on Western society today,
00:17:37 I fear that feminism can only be dislodged by a crisis of massive proportions. 0.93
00:17:49 You 1.00