The Fiamengo File - March 24, 2016


Women In Astronomy - TFF Episode 30

Feminism, A Victim Mentality Disorder - TFF Episode 29 Women's Studies Must Die - TFF Episode 31

Episode Stats


Length

17 minutes

Words per minute

136.13

Word count

2,402

Sentence count

74

Harmful content

Misogyny

26

sentences flagged

Hate speech

9

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 I'm Janice Fumengo from the University of Ottawa. My theme today is Women in Astronomy.
00:00:08 Eight years ago, astronomers found a new gas giant exoplanet named 2MASS J2126-8140. It was
00:00:18 believed to be a rogue planet floating freely through space, but it has now been determined
00:00:23 that 2MASS is actually part of the largest solar system ever discovered.
00:00:29 This historic discovery was made by astronomical teams headed by Dr. Neil Deacon of the University
00:00:35 of Herefordshire in the UK, Dr. Simon Murphy of the Australian National University, and Dr.
00:00:42 Joshua Sleater from the NASA Ames Research Centre in California. The collaborators believe that this
00:00:49 new solar system did not originate as ours did from a disk of dust and gas but was formed
00:00:56 in some way not yet fully understood and in a recent press conference the researchers announced
00:01:03 that they were bringing some female astronomers onto the team to help them theorize about the
00:01:09 origins of the system it was felt that a woman's perspective a perspective operating outside the 1.00
00:01:17 rigid exclusionary binarisms and linear logic of masculist conceptual structures would be more 0.99
00:01:24 likely to solve this astronomical enigma. Not… Okay, that last statement isn't true. It is true
00:01:34 that a team of male researchers has discovered a new solar system, but the researchers are not,
00:01:40 to my knowledge, incorporating female perspectives in the way I described, perhaps because they're
00:01:46 phallocentric misogynists who require gender sensitivity training. Because, unfortunately, 0.80
00:01:53 that's the kind of discourse you hear in astronomy these days.
00:01:58 For years, I have consoled myself for the corruption of higher education with the thought
00:02:03 that, at least in the natural sciences, victimology had not derailed rational inquiry.
00:02:09 In his book, The Closing of the American Mind, the philosopher Alan Bloom actually accused
00:02:17 scientists of colluding in the ruination of the liberal university because they were not 0.94
00:02:22 particularly unhappy to allow feminist and SJW energies to focus on disciplines that the 0.93
00:02:30 scientists had always considered soft and therefore expendable, thus leaving the scientists
00:02:35 to do their real work without distraction. As a professor of English, I had always envied those
00:02:43 in the natural sciences, their oasis of academic sanity. It turns out I was naive. Feminists
00:02:52 conquered many humanities departments and much of the social sciences with almost no resistance at 1.00
00:02:58 all. Within a few decades from the founding of the first women's studies program in 1970,
00:03:03 every university had one, and feminist theories and methodologies became a central part of most
00:03:10 teaching and research outside of the natural sciences. But why did we think social justice 1.00
00:03:17 activists would be satisfied with leaving the natural sciences alone? Evidence is accumulating
00:03:24 that the bastion of scientific rationality is already in the process of being invaded and may
00:03:32 even already have toppled in some places. Recently, William Collins, a physicist,
00:03:40 posted an article on Jonathan Taylor's site, Boys and Men in Education, reporting on the manner in
00:03:45 which the teaching of physics is being reformed in order to make it more friendly to girls.
00:03:52 The idea that we need girls to like physics is a taken-for-granted axiom of modern education.
00:04:00 collins tells us about a report that was commissioned in 2006 to explore why more
00:04:06 girls don't study physics at a levels this is the program generally required for university
00:04:11 entrance in britain the report authors recommended that physics be made more attractive to girls by
00:04:18 bringing in more social context which is what girls tend to like in a subject as opposed to
00:04:23 boy's greater interest in the subject itself the neutrons and the electrons and all that
00:04:29 the proposed reforms were sweeping to say the least according to collins the curriculum should
00:04:36 be context-based or humanistic it should use a variety of social situations and context to
00:04:42 organize and determine the scientific content of the course represent science as something that
00:04:48 people do influenced by historical political cultural and personal factors not just as a body
00:04:55 of knowledge now collins remarks on this report identify how deeply at odds with the nature of
00:05:03 scientific research the reform proposal really is he says there's no social context in physics at all
00:05:11 it's about electrons it's about the motion of planets which is not noticeably influenced by
00:05:17 the existence of homo sapiens it's about the primordial fireball in the first fraction of a
00:05:24 second of the universe's existence it's about pure mathematical constructs of awesome elegance
00:05:32 which turn out amazingly ineffably numinously to align with the behavior of inanimate matter
00:05:40 it is gloriously austere and deeply mysterious well the articulate objections of people like
00:05:50 william collins fell on deaf ears the curriculum has duly been changed and now we have a curriculum
00:05:57 that quote shows the usefulness of the subject and illustrates the impact the discoveries in
00:06:03 physics have had on the way people live." In other words, it's not physics anymore,
00:06:10 it's now the social history of physics. Now there are opportunities for candidates
00:06:18 to use their imaginations and place physics in a social or historical context and argue
00:06:24 about the issues that arise. In other words, there has been a drastic
00:06:31 watering down of physics content and a new emphasis on peripheral aspects of the subject. 0.95
00:06:38 The irony is, as Collins reports, that physics has changed for the worse, but girls have not
00:06:44 become noticeably more interested in it. At the school where Collins teaches sixth form,
00:06:50 A-level physics, only four out of his 40 students are girls, with the result that, quote,
00:06:55 90% of the candidates, the boys, are being taught a curriculum which has been optimized
00:07:00 for the remaining 10% the girls. So our politically correct preoccupation with making 0.92
00:07:07 every subject safe for girls has had the consequence of making no subject safe for boys,
00:07:13 especially those boys, as Collins points out, who are not strong in language skills and who
00:07:19 prefer subjects that have traditionally favoured numeracy. Now those boys have nowhere academic to
00:07:26 go at all. It's also getting increasingly uncomfortable to be a male researcher in astronomy,
00:07:34 even for top-tier academics in the university system. Recently, an American astronomer named
00:07:40 Jeff Marcy, highly regarded for decades and rumored to be a Nobel Prize contender,
00:07:47 was forced to resign from his position at the University of California, Berkeley after having
00:07:51 been found to have violated his university's Title IX policies against sexual harassment.
00:07:58 What this means, according to a statement by the chair of the American Astronomical Society's
00:08:06 Committee on the Status of Women, is that he made what in a sane age would have been considered
00:08:13 minor sexual advances to female students involving touches or kisses advances never pursued if the 0.96
00:08:23 women objected forgive me for finding his behavior less than heinous but an inflam inflammatory 0.59
00:08:32 article recently in the atlantic spins his case and a few unnamed others into a widespread sexual
00:08:40 harassment scandal, for which aggressive, proactive measures in astronomy departments
00:08:46 all across the Western world are claimed to be necessary. Referring to harassers and their
00:08:53 prey as if the alleged harassers were predatory animals rather than male human beings who just
00:08:59 happened to ask female students out on dates or offered them rides home from university,
00:09:05 The article also makes its sky is falling case with survey results in which 82% of respondents
00:09:14 claim to have heard sexist remarks in their workplace and 57% claim to have been verbally
00:09:22 harassed. Well, when nearly anything a man in authority says about or to a woman can now be
00:09:28 perceived as sexist or even harassing, I liked your hair better long, your perfume is lovely,
00:09:34 well, I'm surprised the figure for those harassed is actually as low as it is.
00:09:41 Despite such remarkably thin evidence, the article ends with the typical woman-as-victim appeal.
00:09:48 While acknowledging that not everyone in astronomy is convinced that a huge anti-harassment campaign
00:09:55 is a good idea, the article notes that that's just too bad. Quote,
00:10:00 it's been a tough forever for women in astronomy and women in science and also just women who have
00:10:09 been dealing with harassment and discrimination since always end quote well who could argue
00:10:17 with such sentimental bloviation the result of the manufactured scandal as a friend in Australia
00:10:24 who works in astronomy has informed me has been a behind-the-scenes effort to encourage the lodging
00:10:32 of complaints as well as a naming and shaming campaign on social media in which alleged
00:10:37 harassers are outed by feminist vigilantes who couldn't care less if innocent men's reputations
00:10:44 or careers are ruined. To get a flavour of the feminist perspective on so-called harassment in 1.00
00:10:51 science one need only look at a website called women in astronomy to note the typical feminist 0.89
00:10:57 obsession with barriers to women's advancement and the insistence that the practice of astronomy 1.00
00:11:04 must change to accommodate women's preferences and habits rather than the other way around
00:11:10 there's even a special post about matt taylor the brilliant astrophysicist you'll remember
00:11:16 forced to apologize in tears for wearing an inappropriate shirt when appearing on television
00:11:21 to discuss the space probe he and his team had landed on a comet. 0.84
00:11:25 If you want a sense of what female grievance looks like in the discipline of astronomy, 1.00
00:11:31 take a look at this post alone, which is a kind of object lesson in feminist envy and bitterness.
00:11:38 At one point, the writer who chose to remain anonymous says of Matt Taylor that, quote, 0.99
00:11:45 The female scientists bringing this up have just as cool things on their CVs.
00:11:52 We're not impressed with him just for being on a mission team. 0.88
00:11:56 Well, if it's true that female astrophysicists are so cool, one has to wonder why they spend so 1.00
00:12:02 much of their time writing on this post rather than doing research. This same writer provides 1.00
00:12:09 a list of female injuries that culminates in an embarrassingly childish rant about being
00:12:15 a woman in a male scientific field.
00:12:20 Another contributor detailed at length an experience of what she called sexual harassment,
00:12:26 which consisted of a man she had been introduced to at an astronomy conference expressing sexual
00:12:32 interest at a pub gathering after the conference where she had gone with other students.
00:12:37 She dwells on her personal calvary at length, telling us that his suggestion that she come
00:12:42 back to his hotel for a threesome with his girlfriend made her feel, quote, very vulnerable
00:12:48 and alone and, quote, burning with shame.
00:12:52 In fact, the incident, as she reports it, made her doubt herself in every way.
00:12:58 Quote, he must have not been interested in my work at all, she reports, thinking, does
00:13:03 that mean I'm not really a scientist?
00:13:08 Even six years later, it seems, the outrage is still fresh. But is it in any way justified
00:13:15 or reasonable? Did this man threaten her? Did he pursue her even after her refusal?
00:13:22 Was he churlish when she refused him? No. Merely the fact that he propositioned her
00:13:28 was enough to send this adult woman into years-long trauma, only assuaged
00:13:37 through repetition she tells us quote i knew that the only thing i could do was talk about
00:13:43 it speak it out loud give it form and display it for all to see but why not just forget it
00:13:51 go talk to one of the other students you'd come to the bar with make a joke out of it or feel
00:13:56 flattered that a man found you attractive the writer seems not to realize that men proposition
00:14:02 women all the time and a fair number of women like it but following the standard feminist script
00:14:09 the writer emphasizes that what was so egregious in the incident was that the harasser was 10 years
00:14:16 older and quote in a position of power over her but in fact he wasn't he was a post-doctoral fellow
00:14:23 with no involvement in her work and with whom she never had to interact again it's also clear that
00:14:29 during the whole rest of her career. Nothing like this ever occurred again. We can be sure
00:14:35 she'd have mentioned it if it did. But it's that kind of sight, women with a monumental sense of 0.94
00:14:42 their own heroism demonstrating through their trivial complaints that they are really not
00:14:47 equipped with heroism or even common sense to function in a male space. Sites like this go on
00:14:54 and on about the need to speak out and name our oppression as if it were still the 19th century,
00:15:01 all in the name of the advancement of women in science, which the site tells us frequently is
00:15:07 important and beneficial. It never says why, and it doesn't have to, of course. Every politician
00:15:13 and opinion maker of our time praises diversity. But let's ask why. Why do we need women astronomers?
00:15:21 Why do we need to encourage girls to go into physics or chemistry or engineering? 1.00
00:15:27 Don't tell me because justice. 1.00
00:15:30 It is justice to make sure that women are not prevented from pursuing their scientific passions. 0.99
00:15:37 But it is not justice, and there is much to be lost in changing the disciplines to make them more compatible with female habits of mind.
00:15:46 There is no justice in stigmatizing men for mistakenly calling a young female PhD miss
00:15:54 or asking her out on a date. There is no justice in pretending that women face
00:16:00 massive hurdles to achievement and must be constantly affirmed and supported.
00:16:05 So let me say it. We do not need more women doing physics or astronomy, especially not if it means 1.00
00:16:13 that standards are lowered or witch hunts conducted. 1.00
00:16:17 What we need are smart people doing physics or astronomy, smart people of whatever sex
00:16:24 or race who will bring to the subject the dedication, the discipline, and the intellectual
00:16:29 chops to do the subject justice. 0.74
00:16:33 So we should stop pretending that the vast majority of scientists working in these fields
00:16:39 are less than civil and decent in their behaviour. Anything else is an insult to fair-minded women 1.00
00:16:47 and to the men who established and developed these subjects in the first place.
00:16:53 To return to the astronomical discovery with which I began, one of the interesting aspects
00:17:00 of the newfound solar system is that the planet 2 mass is so far away from its host star tyc-9486
00:17:10 approximately a trillion miles that one full orbit by the planet takes about a million years nearly 1.00
00:17:19 13 000 human lifespans so let's just hope it doesn't take that long before feminism is finally 1.00
00:17:28 discredited 1.00