The Fiamengo File - March 31, 2016


Women's Studies Must Die - TFF Episode 31

Women In Astronomy - TFF Episode 30 Women's Studies Is Not Scholarship - TFF Episode 32

Episode Stats


Length

15 minutes

Words per minute

129.68

Word count

1,958

Sentence count

74

Harmful content

Misogyny

11

sentences flagged

Toxicity

2

sentences flagged

Hate speech

9

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 I'm Janice Fiomingo of the University of Ottawa. My theme today is Women's Studies Must Die. 1.00
00:00:10 In a recent video, I stated that all women's and gender studies programs should be closed 1.00
00:00:15 down as quickly as possible. It's a provocative assertion, I guess. In Canada alone, there are 66 0.88
00:00:23 gender and women's studies departments, programs, course offerings, and institutes,
00:00:29 according to a list compiled by the Association for Academic Women's Studies in 2013.
00:00:37 Gender Studies courses are offered in all ten provinces and one Canadian territory,
00:00:43 and the programs employ hundreds of professors in both part-time and full-time positions
00:00:49 and grant thousands of degrees and certificates. They range from small one-year certificate
00:00:56 programs all the way up to master's degrees and PhDs. That's a lot of programs to slash,
00:01:03 a lot of students who won't get their degrees, and a profusion of professors to put out of work.
00:01:10 Still, I am serious in my statement that these programs have no more place at a university than
00:01:16 voodoo or yogic flying. And I'm sure most of you know why I think so, 0.88
00:01:23 because these courses are not about knowledge. They're about theories of oppression and resistance,
00:01:31 often a range of different kinds of feminist, Marxist, queer, post-colonial, eco-critical,
00:01:37 and other theories. Of course, theories are used all the time in academic research and writing,
00:01:45 but their purpose in legitimate disciplines is to be tested. Feminist theories are not tested 1.00
00:01:52 in that sense except by other feminist or related theories. They're almost never compared with 1.00
00:01:59 non-feminist theories. The fundamental tenets of feminism are not up for debate. They are simply
00:02:06 presented as truth to be learned and applied. I know this from first-hand experience. I spent
00:02:14 years studying feminist theory as an undergraduate and then graduate student, years I could have spent
00:02:20 studying something real. I learned things that are untrue about gender as a social construct and
00:02:26 about the deep-rooted misogyny of patriarchal culture, and it took years to unlearn them.
00:02:34 That hundreds of thousands of students across North America still learn these untruths,
00:02:40 that they will likely continue learning them well into the future, is staggering.
00:02:46 For a good example of what I mean, let's take a quick glance at the reading material
00:02:52 for the foundational first-year course in the prestigious Gender Studies Program at the
00:02:58 University of British Columbia in Vancouver. It's staffed by 10 full-time professors and
00:03:05 a number of part-timers, and the course is called Gender, Race, Sex, and Power, and it
00:03:12 bills itself as an introduction to quote intersectional feminist scholarship and debate
00:03:19 the required reading on the subject of gender is a chapter called introduction to gender from a
00:03:26 textbook language and gender by penelope eckert and sally mcconnell genet the book is now published
00:03:35 but the link in the course syllabus is to a pre-publication version of the chapter it's
00:03:40 about 35 pages long. Well, you'll likely not be surprised to learn that the authors of this text
00:03:48 adhere to the theory that gender is a social construct, telling us in the opening pages of
00:03:53 the chapter that, quote, the very definition of the biological categories male and female
00:04:01 is ultimately social. Well, given that anything humans do in language is ultimately dependent on
00:04:10 society, of course, the labels male and female are, in that sense, social. But Eckert and McConnell
00:04:17 Genet mean far more than that. The authors mean that gender is something we perform. This is a
00:04:26 very popular word in gender discourse today. And they assert that, quote, labeling someone a man
00:04:33 or a woman is a social decision. In other words, it has no natural basis that pre-exists language.
00:04:41 And everything in the chapter follows from this key tenet of feminist thought,
00:04:46 and what we find throughout is a consistent downplaying or outright denial of natural
00:04:52 differences in male-female development. Eckerd and McConnell Genet, for example,
00:04:58 chronicle the so-called scripting of masculine and feminine identities from the time of infancy to
00:05:05 adulthood that ungendered infants are made into boys and girls by conditioning and modeling
00:05:13 always with the implication that they could be and should be reconditioned remodeled they have a 0.59
00:05:20 section on what they call the manufacturing of heterosexual desire which is also not natural
00:05:27 they tell us, but, quote, highly structured and learned through, quote, dominant socially endorsed
00:05:35 images. Just as a sidebar, this is really a fascinating feature of contemporary feminist
00:05:41 discourse, this insistence that heterosexuality is manufactured, that there's nothing natural
00:05:48 about it, that women don't really desire men. They just learn to do so because they are bombarded
00:05:55 with images of heterosexual desire. The authors also discuss the supposed devaluing of the feminine
00:06:03 in culture. Boy activities are more highly valued, they allege, and girls are told that,
00:06:09 for example, they can't be astronauts when they grow up because they're girls. That's an example 0.97
00:06:14 they actually use. Another section in the chapter emphasizes the pervasive inequities that work
00:06:21 against women in everything from household chores to the order in which men and women tend to be
00:06:26 mentioned in sentences. And this is all standard feminist propaganda about the nefarious gender 0.98
00:06:34 order in which women always get the short end of the stick. What is especially notable about the 0.99
00:06:42 chapter, perhaps, is that it gives no indication that feminist claims about gender are in any way
00:06:49 contentious. Students aren't made aware of the hundreds of studies that have revealed hormonal
00:06:56 and physiological differences between men and women. They're not even really told that there
00:07:02 is a debate on the matter or that trained scientists might have an understanding of
00:07:07 sex difference that a person without scientific training needs at least to respect. In fact,
00:07:13 readers are given the opposite impression—that the social constructionists have the far more
00:07:20 sophisticated and compelling case. It's presented as fact that, quote,
00:07:27 gender is the process of creating a dichotomy between male and female by effacing similarity
00:07:36 and elaborating on difference. And where there are biological differences,
00:07:41 these differences are exaggerated and extended in the service of constructing gender," end quote.
00:07:51 In other words, the authors admit that there may be some biological basis to sex difference,
00:07:56 but they assert that it's significantly exaggerated by both researchers and popular commentators.
00:08:05 Now, the authors do cite some few scientific studies to support their position, but
00:08:10 no student reading the chapter and being introduced to the idea of gender would have any idea that a
00:08:17 majority of scientists have come in good faith to the opposite view of the physiological and
00:08:23 biological basis of gender. For a compendious summation of hundreds of studies of sex difference
00:08:29 supporting the natural basis of male-female difference, see for example Stephen Rhodes's
00:08:35 book, Taking Sex Differences Seriously. What is most shocking in the feminist introduction to 0.99
00:08:41 gender is the strong suggestion by Eckerd and McConnell Genet that any researcher who focuses
00:08:48 on evolutionary and hormonal differences between men and women is actually corrupt.
00:08:54 We're told, for example, that everyone from scientist to journalist to the reading public
00:09:00 has an insatiable appetite for sensationalist gender news. Silly us. The authors say, quote, 0.97
00:09:10 any results that might support physiological differences are readily snatched up and
00:09:17 combined with any variety of gender stereotypes and some often quite fantastic leaps of logic.
00:09:25 And the products of these leaps can in turn feed directly into social and particularly
00:09:33 into educational policy, with arguments that gender equity in such, quote,
00:09:38 left-brain areas as mathematics and engineering is impossible. That's the end of their quote.
00:09:45 The authors of the chapter give no examples of these so-called fantastic leaps of logic,
00:09:52 But their statement tells students in no uncertain terms that whenever they encounter a claim
00:10:00 about natural differences between male and female, they can reliably shut their minds to it.
00:10:06 They can be sure that gender stereotypes and fantastic leaps of logic are at work in biased,
00:10:14 ideologically driven individuals, probably misogynists, who want to prevent women from
00:10:21 achieving what they're capable of in mathematics and engineering. It is never admitted that the
00:10:28 authors of this chapter, who are not scientists, in fact they're both linguists, might themselves
00:10:34 be choosing their examples and studies with a predetermined end in view. Every page in this
00:10:43 tendentious feminist chapter contains a plethora of misdirection, oversimplification, suppression 0.91
00:10:50 of contrary evidence and overgeneralization, if not outright falsification. The focus is always
00:10:58 on the hardships and sufferings of girls and women to the exclusion of equal and often far
00:11:04 greater hardships and sufferings of boys and men. The chapter spends, for example, some space
00:11:10 discussing the pre-adolescent crisis of confidence that is commonly assumed to manifest in girls
00:11:17 at school, making the point that the crisis itself may be a social construct based on ideas
00:11:24 about normative femininity. And it makes this point by contrasting studies of white girls with 0.89
00:11:31 evidence for the greater self-assertion and autonomy apparently shown by black girls at
00:11:36 the same point in their lives. But nothing at all is said about boys' problems, black or white,
00:11:43 with a school system staffed mainly by women who see natural boy behavior as a problem,
00:11:49 even though a major feminist scholar, Christina Hoff Summers, has written extensively
00:11:53 about this pressing issue. Eckert and McConnell Genet also point us to evidence of built-in 0.99
00:12:00 cultural bias in the phrase husband and wife, but it's not wife and husband. This is supposedly
00:12:07 proof of the patriarchal prioritizing of the male but they don't mention the rampant prioritizing
00:12:14 of the female in news reporting for example such that when boys and men are killed or injured they
00:12:20 are referred to as people generically while when girls and women are killed their sex is identified
00:12:26 to focus public compassion and horror obviously a discussion of the boy crisis in education or
00:12:35 linguistic evidence of the valuing of female life over male life would complicate
00:12:41 the neat story of female grievance these scholars are elaborating. 0.82
00:12:46 On every major facet of gender knowledge, then, this chapter opts for feminist orthodoxy over
00:12:53 honest discussion, and there is nothing to offset its misleading emphasis in the whole rest of the
00:12:58 course syllabus which consists mainly of pop culture texts and other theoretical statements
00:13:07 as the most substantial reading on gender in the course the chapter is entirely inadequate
00:13:14 distorting students understanding by telling them not only that feminist gender fantasies are true
00:13:20 but also that scientific facts about sex difference are false again i have to say that
00:13:26 although I've known for a long time that this material is being taught in Gender Studies
00:13:31 courses, looking closely at it again leaves me flabbergasted. I don't deny that there are some
00:13:39 smart people teaching in these programs and doing valuable work. Some of it isn't about
00:13:45 man-hatred. But in the main, the programs teach a totally warped view of the world.
00:13:51 Now, someone might say, ah, Fiamengo, you're an anti-feminist, so of course, of course, 0.58
00:13:57 you don't like what is being taught in these courses. Your ideological opposition is no more 0.99
00:14:03 legitimate than their ideological advocacy. So, in my next three videos, I want to provide
00:14:09 more specifics about why the vast majority of feminist courses can't be defended on any grounds, 0.97
00:14:17 even if you happen to think that some of the content is justified.
00:14:21 As I said, I've had friends and people I admire teach courses for women's studies programs,
00:14:25 but nonetheless, there are non-ideological reasons why these programs should not exist. 0.62
00:14:32 The money being spent on them, on programs that miseducate our youth and contribute to the rot
00:14:39 that pervades our justice system, our social services, and our media.
00:14:44 That's money that could be far better spent on real academic subjects that do not harm
00:14:49 and actually benefit society. Please stay tuned.