The Fiamengo File - April 07, 2016


Women's Studies Is Not Scholarship - TFF Episode 32

Women's Studies Must Die - TFF Episode 31 Interdisciplinarity, Another Word for Emptiness - TFF Episode 33

Episode Stats


Length

9 minutes

Words per minute

130.34

Word count

1,200

Sentence count

46

Harmful content

Misogyny

10

sentences flagged

Hate speech

4

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 I'm Janice Fiumengo, the University of Ottawa, and my theme today is Get Activism Out of Academia.
00:00:10 In my last video, I promised that I was going to provide some concrete, non-ideological reasons 0.98
00:00:16 why women's studies programs should be abolished at universities across North America. This is the 1.00
00:00:22 first in my three-part series outlining the reasons, which are as follows. One, these are
00:00:28 advocacy programs not academic programs and that's enough right there to declare them totally
00:00:34 illegitimate two these programs do not have a subject to teach they're what is called
00:00:40 interdisciplinary and that inevitably leads to intellectual incoherence and lack of seriousness
00:00:46 as i will show and three the literal costs associated with the programs not counting the
00:00:53 moral and social costs are significant and the money could be far better spent on research and
00:01:00 on ensuring that students leaving our post-secondary institutions are literate and numerate.
00:01:07 My first point then. Gender studies programs advocate for social justice. No surprise there. 1.00
00:01:16 Most such programs, though not all, are quite explicit about this goal in their descriptions.
00:01:23 The Simon Fraser University Gender, Sexuality and Women's Studies program
00:01:29 declares, I want a description that it, quote,
00:01:32 aspires to build networks with feminists and activists from the South 0.79
00:01:38 to organize against social and economic exploitation of women globally, end quote.
00:01:44 That's quite a departure from an academic focus.
00:01:49 And most professors, administrators, and students today will see nothing wrong with that.
00:01:55 Why shouldn't university programs organize against injustice?
00:02:01 Here's the description by the University of Alberta Women's and Gender Studies Department.
00:02:07 Quote, The Department of Women's and Gender Studies is a hub
00:02:12 for feminist knowledge production and engaged citizenship. Its hallmarks include award-winning
00:02:21 teachers and scholars, a vibrant feminist research community, a long-standing commitment to
00:02:27 interdisciplinarity, and outstanding graduates who move into their communities as critical and
00:02:34 engaged citizens with abiding commitments to social justice," end quote.
00:02:42 Notice that there's very little here about what faculty members actually research and what the
00:02:47 students are taught. What is the content of the courses? The description doesn't say,
00:02:53 doesn't say women. And in fact, women are not the focus of a lot of these courses.
00:02:59 the focus is quote feminist knowledge production knowledge production by the way is cooler than 1.00
00:03:06 just knowledge because it suggests a dynamic and anti-hierarchical process the idea is that the
00:03:13 students are producing knowledge as much as the professors in a collaborative venture with perhaps
00:03:18 a little marxist whiff of materialist struggle against oppressive forces and what is the feminist
00:03:25 knowledge that is being produced well the description doesn't specify but it emphasizes
00:03:30 a specific kind of citizen who comes out of the program an engaged citizen not a knowledgeable
00:03:39 one necessarily but an engaged one that's said twice in two sentences so it must be very important
00:03:47 a citizen with an abiding commitment to social justice so the knowledge that is being produced
00:03:54 is intended to create citizens with a commitment to activism. This is not a place, the description
00:04:02 makes clear, not a place for ideas to be considered, tested, or debated in a spirit of disinterested
00:04:10 exploration. The University of British Columbia has gone even further, changing the very name of
00:04:17 its women's and gender studies program to the institute for gender race sexuality and social
00:04:25 justice so what's wrong with that the most obvious problem with social justice is that it often has
00:04:35 very little to do with justice as traditionally understood meaning good things like equality
00:04:41 before the law non-discrimination the protection of freedom such as freedom of expression and
00:04:47 freedom of association, habeas corpus, those aren't a part of the social justice ideal.
00:04:55 Social justice has much more to do with state mandated and guaranteed equality of outcome,
00:05:00 a utopian community forged through propaganda and the suppression of dissent by force if necessary.
00:05:10 Every social utopia of this sort has produced human misery and dysfunction on a massive scale,
00:05:17 So it's the last thing that universities should be encouraging.
00:05:21 Well, many people, including many university professors, think there should be more equality
00:05:27 in our society, even if that means you manufacture it by suppressing individual liberties.
00:05:33 Fine, that's another discussion. But even if one agrees with many of the planks of a social
00:05:40 justice platform, which I don't, there's a simple reason why advocacy should never be the goal of a
00:05:47 university program, simply because any commitment that interferes with the university's core
00:05:53 mission of pursuing knowledge is a fatal corruption. A teacher can't be a social justice
00:06:00 advocate in the classroom because advocacy will always interfere with commitment to the subject
00:06:07 being taught in a multitude of small and large ways. It's like teaching math while at the same
00:06:13 time making the case that odd numbers are more worthy of our attention and sympathy than even
00:06:18 ones. The equations you're working on are going to be garbled by the desire to prioritize the odd
00:06:24 numbers every time. I'm not saying that teachers can't be advocates in their non-teaching lives,
00:06:30 obviously I am. I'm saying it's lethal if you bring that into the classroom. The more passionately
00:06:37 held the social justice commitment, the greater the temptation to organize course materials to
00:06:43 support a particular conclusion and to misconceive your classroom role. Teaching shouldn't be about
00:06:51 shaping how your students view the world, except to the extent that you want them to be serious
00:06:57 and passionate about their work. Advocacy and teaching are diametrically opposed, in fact.
00:07:04 teaching aims at objective consideration of a subject it's fashionable now to laugh at that
00:07:11 ideal to say it isn't possible to be objective and whether it's fully achievable or not the goal
00:07:18 should always be to strive for it a good teacher becomes a different self in the classroom totally
00:07:26 committed to the subject above all the teacher's personal investments cherished values of course
00:07:32 these can't be entirely escaped, but they are never to take precedence over open dialogue about
00:07:39 all intellectually legitimate aspects of the subject. The classroom should be a safe space,
00:07:45 not for anyone's feelings or for the promotion of any ideology, but for the pure and unfettered
00:07:52 search for understanding. Advocacy, on the other hand, is all about persuasion and about particular
00:08:00 social ends. It begins from assumptions and theories that must be defended, never questioned.
00:08:08 The problem with women's studies courses is they don't teach about feminism, which would be fine. 0.97
00:08:14 The problem is that they teach feminism. How we got to the point where whole programs can state 0.95
00:08:21 right up front on their website that they promote feminist engagement with the world 0.95
00:08:28 is the story of the utter takeover of the university by the fanatical enemies of knowledge.
00:08:35 The problem is much bigger even than gender studies programs because 1.00
00:08:40 feminist methodologies and dogmas are all across the university now. 1.00
00:08:45 But the first step to reforming academia would be to close these programs with a clear statement 1.00
00:08:51 by university leaders that advocacy is off-limits. That's what I would do if I were elected president
00:08:59 of a university, but you can imagine the chances of that. Tune in next week
00:09:05 for further discussion of the illegitimate nature of academic feminism. 1.00