The Fiamengo File - April 14, 2016


Interdisciplinarity, Another Word for Emptiness - TFF Episode 33

Women's Studies Is Not Scholarship - TFF Episode 32 Cost of Gender Studies - TFF Episode 34

Episode Stats


Length

11 minutes

Words per minute

122.72

Word count

1,387

Sentence count

54

Harmful content

Misogyny

7

sentences flagged

Toxicity

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

1

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 I'm Janice Fiumengo of the University of Ottawa. My theme today is Interdisciplinarity,
00:00:08 another word for emptiness. This is the second in my series of videos offering
00:00:14 non-ideological reasons why programs in gender and women's studies, or whatever they're called,
00:00:20 should be closed down. Last day I talked about the first and foremost reason because these
00:00:26 programs are about advocacy rather than knowledge. They're not about pursuing truth, which should be
00:00:33 the only rationale of the university. They're about graduating a certain kind of student ready
00:00:39 to become a social activist. The whole problem with these programs is that they teach feminism 1.00
00:00:46 rather than teaching about feminism. Today I will explore the second reason that these programs are 0.79
00:00:52 by nature intellectually incoherent. Last day, we looked at the website description for the Women's 0.96
00:00:59 and Gender Studies program at the University of Alberta, in which we were told that the program
00:01:04 has a long-standing commitment to interdisciplinary collaborations. The word
00:01:11 interdisciplinary is used frequently in these descriptions. The University of British Columbia's
00:01:17 Gender Studies program tells us that it incorporates research and theories, quote,
00:01:23 with an interdisciplinary understanding of global and local social justice issues, end quote. 0.51
00:01:31 As with advocacy, interdisciplinarity is often offered in the program description as a bragging
00:01:37 point, a way to promote the program, and again, many professors, administrators,
00:01:42 and students see nothing wrong with that. In fact, to be interdisciplinary in today's university
00:01:49 environment is often thought to be very good. So what does it mean? It means that taking a
00:01:56 Gender Studies degree does not involve learning an academic subject such as history, geography,
00:02:02 criminology, political science, psychology, philosophy, anthropology, environmental science,
00:02:08 health science, or law. Instead, it involves learning a smattering of perhaps all of the
00:02:15 above, usually pretty light on the sciences and pretty light on serious history, with the end
00:02:21 result being that one doesn't learn anything in a thoroughgoing way. The original meaning of
00:02:28 interdisciplinarity was that a scholar would learn one subject thoroughly and then learn another and
00:02:35 bring together the knowledge and research methods of the two disciplines so that ideally each would
00:02:41 strengthen the other, and a more capacious kind of research project would be possible.
00:02:47 And that's not easy. It takes serious study to master any one subject because each has a vast
00:02:54 body of literature and its own methodologies, assumptions, key terms, and central debates
00:03:00 to become familiar with. Even experienced scholars don't always do interdisciplinarity well.
00:03:07 To think that undergraduate students just starting their post-secondary education could possibly
00:03:14 grasp the essence of a whole range of subjects is simply not reasonable. And they don't.
00:03:23 Women's studies itself is not a discipline, and the drift away from the word women in the title
00:03:29 towards gender and sexuality and even race and social justice simply confirms its vagueness.
00:03:38 The subject is everything and nothing, as the program descriptions often make painfully clear.
00:03:46 Here's one course description from the University of Toronto's course offerings in
00:03:51 gender, and environmental injustice. Using a transnational feminist framework, 0.96
00:04:06 this course examines material and conceptual interrelations between gendered human and 0.94
00:04:12 non-human nature, ecological crises, political economies, and environmental movements in a
00:04:20 variety of geographical historical and cultural contexts." Yikes! That's an interdisciplinary
00:04:29 cornucopia. One quarter of this course might make a potentially interesting graduate seminar topic
00:04:36 for specialists in environmental geography, perhaps. But for an undergraduate course,
00:04:42 how could one begin to understand the interrelations of gender and various
00:04:48 ecological crises in different times and places without first having a basic understanding
00:04:55 of environmental science. How could one begin to understand the interrelations of gender and
00:05:00 political economies, as the description says, without first having a basic understanding of
00:05:06 economics? You get my drift. What this course pretends to offer is so advanced and intricate
00:05:13 as to guarantee that not even a highly intelligent undergraduate student could possibly make sense of
00:05:19 all the domains of knowledge it draws from. Most students will come away from such a course with
00:05:26 little more than a bundle of buzzwords about the politics of oppositional agency, dissident
00:05:34 homo-nationalisms, Indigenous knowledge and counter-hegemonic praxis, diasporic communities
00:05:40 and dialogical pedagogies, the liberatory potential of transcultural intersectionality,
00:05:47 queer ethics, discourses of racialization, and self-reflexive non-normative trajectories of desire.
00:05:55 That's not understanding. It's elite-sounding terminology that's hollow at the core.
00:06:02 Because gender studies lacks a core subject to be learned in any depth, many of the courses have
00:06:08 no real content. A common focus of many is popular media representations.
00:06:15 You can understand why. It'd be pretty dull and not immediately relevant to feminism to examine 1.00
00:06:22 in depth, for example, the history of women in the Far East from the Ming Dynasty to the present.
00:06:28 What a lot of dry facts to be learned. Or the comparative legal status of men and women in the
00:06:33 Judaic, Christian, and Islamic traditions from 1400 to the present. It's much easier and more 0.99
00:06:40 conducive to happy classrooms to discuss Lady Gaga, The Hunger Games, and Fifty Shades of Grey,
00:06:48 to critique their discursive production of race and class, for example, or to ferret out their
00:06:54 implicit transphobia or heteronormativity or resistance to same. There simply is not the time,
00:07:02 nor are the students equipped to look at complex issues requiring sustained subject-specific reading
00:07:09 and study. Course content that can provoke lively discussion without requiring prior knowledge is
00:07:15 much more attractive in courses with titles like Gender and Popular Culture, Feminist Consciousness
00:07:22 and Community Organization, Gender and Sexuality in World Literatures, and my personal favourite,
00:07:29 ghosts and haunted houses an exploration of how theories and fictions of haunting can illuminate
00:07:37 still unfolding histories of dispossession and exploitation often the sophistication of the
00:07:46 language employed in the program descriptions betrays its fundamental unreality here's the
00:07:54 description for example of the an undergraduate program at the university of toronto's women and
00:08:01 gender studies institute this is what they say quote for the past 40 years we have trained
00:08:09 students to think deeply about how gender and sexuality operate at the individual interpersonal
00:08:16 institutional and global levels drawing from a range of disciplines such as history and literature
00:08:24 sociology and law, we enable students to answer urgent questions such as how militarization can
00:08:32 constrict men's aspirations for their lives, why there are income disparities between women and men,
00:08:40 how sexual expression is scripted and can be re-scripted, and even what Lady Gaga could have
00:08:49 in common with Shakespeare. In addition to training students to traverse the stanzas of a poem
00:08:56 and a government report with equal care and skill, we also focus attention on matters of scale,
00:09:05 when to aggregate and when to parse significant distinctions, how to think comparatively
00:09:12 across space and time end quote wow even just thinking comparatively across space and time
00:09:22 sounds like a pretty ambitious and evanescent objective not to mention all that has gone before
00:09:28 the stanzas of a poem the government report aggregating and parsing well it's kind of neat
00:09:35 actually, but in its vast over-claim it reveals a utopian unrealizability.
00:09:43 No one will come out of that program, I guarantee, with a working knowledge of history, literature,
00:09:50 sociology, and law, let alone any of the other glittering rubrics evoked. Actually, it's no easy
00:09:57 thing to traverse the stanzas of poems. That alone is an achievement requiring sustained practice and
00:10:04 a heck of a lot of reading. You don't just pick it up in a class or two before moving on to other
00:10:10 areas of expertise. If you're going to really understand what Lady Gaga has in common, or
00:10:17 doesn't, with Shakespeare, you're going to have to read a lot of Shakespeare and some other
00:10:22 Renaissance dramatists and understand something about the culture that produced Shakespeare.
00:10:28 otherwise it's all just superficial baffle gab but it seems clear that really knowing shakespeare
00:10:37 or anything for that matter isn't the concern of the women's and gender studies program
00:10:44 this is about knowledge production in the department's own words about learning a
00:10:50 collective orientation towards the world some of the courses look interesting many look pretentious 0.95
00:10:56 and silly. But are these university-worthy programs that taxpayers should be funding to the tune of
00:11:04 millions of dollars every year? Certainly not, in my opinion. And the question of cost
00:11:11 will be the subject of my next video, the last in this series.