The Fiamengo File - January 28, 2016


Feminist Terminology 1: Gender - The Fiamengo File Episode 22

Feminist Terminology 2: Lived Experience - TFF Episode 23

Episode Stats


Length

14 minutes

Words per minute

127.7

Word count

1,903

Sentence count

61

Harmful content

Misogyny

32

sentences flagged

Toxicity

4

sentences flagged

Hate speech

4

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 I'm Janice Fiomingo from the University of Ottawa.
00:00:19 My theme today is five pernicious academic terms that have shaped mainstream feminism.
00:00:27 For a while I've had an idea to do an episode on the hyper-Orwellian language of the modern
00:00:32 university.
00:00:34 You know the kind of thing, the safe space, which is really a pretty scary conformist
00:00:39 space, where hate speech is outlawed except of course against those heterosexual white
00:00:46 men one is permitted to hate, and where diversity is celebrated and monitored in a rigidly uniform
00:00:54 way through trigger warnings and so on. The whole discussion would be carried out with my trademark
00:01:01 laugh-out-loud wit. Well, maybe not the latter part. Seriously, that was the idea, but it
00:01:08 developed in its own direction and I found myself exploring certain key feminist terms that began
00:01:15 in academia and have moved out into the wider society with ever greater mainstream acceptance.
00:01:21 I will argue that these terms, to a large extent, are responsible for the specific shape
00:01:28 of debate about men and women in our society.
00:01:31 And the more I thought about the terms, the more I saw that understanding their origins
00:01:37 and their underlying assumptions was an important part of understanding the modern feminist
00:01:42 worldview, especially its particular resistance to logical debate.
00:01:50 matters uniquely in this context, because much as we'd like to shrug it off as a place where 0.99
00:01:56 highly intelligent, stupid people engage in mostly trivial pursuits, and I don't disagree with that 0.98
00:02:04 assessment, sadly, but we know that the university is the key arena of indoctrination of our youth 1.00
00:02:11 today, who then make careers in journalism, law, politics, business, policing, social work, media,
00:02:17 the civil service and the judiciary where they carry utopian ideology and the immunity to logic
00:02:25 into all the main facets of our society with pernicious effect i don't know that this process
00:02:33 can be stopped anytime soon the network of these revolutionary agents is very firmly entrenched
00:02:39 but i do think that understanding the origins of some of the terms can help us call out the
00:02:45 ideology's biases and conceptual errors more effectively. The first term that's going to be
00:02:53 the subject of today's video is gender. Recently I've tried to stop using the term gender,
00:02:59 kind of as a political protest substituting the good old-fashioned word sex as much as possible,
00:03:05 but it's hard to remember a time before gender was the standard word used to refer to men or women
00:03:11 as a group. The problem with gender is that its current meaning comes loaded with feminist
00:03:17 assumptions about sex differences that have had a profound impact on fact-based public discussion
00:03:23 about equality. From the time of Simone de Beauvoir's rather unextraordinary but pithy statement that
00:03:31 quote one is not born but rather becomes a woman, the tendency within feminism has been to claim
00:03:39 ever more dogmatically and in the absence of proof that there is no such thing as femaleness
00:03:46 outside of the idea of femaleness. This is a kind of feminist version of Descartes's 0.99
00:03:53 I think, therefore I am. In this case, patriarchy thinks, therefore woman is. 0.99
00:04:02 In other words, women's perceived differences from men are entirely the result of social
00:04:08 conditioning, and any reference to hardwired sex differences is by definition offensive
00:04:14 and sexist.
00:04:16 Just last summer, to take one example, Sky News aired a short exchange between anti-feminist
00:04:23 provocateur Milo Yiannopoulos and feminist journalist Rennie Edo-Lodge over the question
00:04:29 of whether male brains are better at chess. 0.53
00:04:34 And all the feminist journalist could say was that such was sexist thinking. 0.99
00:04:39 She declared it, quote, biological determinism, stereotypical, and 1950s thinking. 0.80
00:04:47 She was no match for Milo logically, who cited Simon Baron Cohen's research into sex differences
00:04:55 in male and female brains, but she didn't seem to think she had to be. 0.99
00:05:00 simply had to hold to the feminist position. The extraordinary thing is that the feminist 1.00
00:05:06 case has been advanced with marked success by social science professors, psychoanalysts,
00:05:12 legal theorists, and even literary scholars with no credible scientific backing at all.
00:05:21 When Kate Millett published her landmark work of literary criticism entitled Sexual Politics 1.00
00:05:28 in 1970, she simply declared her belief, without arguing for it in any way, that women's nature
00:05:36 was, quote, essentially cultural rather than biological. Social conditioning makes women 1.00
00:05:43 what they are, and social conditioning can be undone. Anthropology professor Gail Rubin, 0.95
00:05:51 in her 1975 discussion of what she called the sex-slash-gender system, at least acknowledged
00:05:59 the, quote, raw material of biological sex, which is shaped to become gender, according to Rubin. 0.97
00:06:06 But later theorists, including psychoanalyst Nancy Chotaro with her influential feminist
00:06:12 theory of gender-differentiated mothering, or passionate anti-pornographer crusader
00:06:19 Catherine MacKinnon with her emphasis on femininity as almost purely an expression of submission to
00:06:25 male sexual domination, these later theorists were less and less willing to acknowledge biological
00:06:34 sex at all, focusing instead on what they called the social practices that produce a sexed self,
00:06:42 basically everything that happens to us in the home and in society at large.
00:06:47 So by the time we get to Judith Butler and her 1990 magnum opus,
00:06:52 Gender Trouble, that focused on gender as performance, we encounter the argument that
00:06:58 the sex-gender distinction is completely unintelligible. That's her word. In other words,
00:07:04 that sex does not pre-exist gender and cannot be distinguished from it. Though I suspect few
00:07:13 outside of academia and actually kind of few inside it have really waded through butler's
00:07:18 impressively convoluted prose our social elite have generally accepted with very few of them
00:07:25 having any understanding of biology that most of gender is not based in biological sex but is a
00:07:33 result of social categories and upbringing now why is this stress on the social construction of gender
00:07:41 so major? Well, it's simple because it means that anything is possible. If you have a utopian theory
00:07:50 of what the world should be like, the belief that men and women can be reshaped at will
00:07:55 is a very attractive idea. Though many feminists, if really pressed, might admit that we don't
00:08:03 know that there isn't a biological basis to sex, even a pretty significant one, they'll usually 0.85
00:08:10 say that it's useful and productive to move ahead as if there isn't. The theory of gender as a
00:08:16 social construct is extremely important to feminists because it means that women need 1.00
00:08:22 never accept or take responsibility for anything they don't like about women's position in society. 1.00
00:08:28 In any instance in which women fall short of a standard or fail to perform as well as men,
00:08:34 external factors, even amorphous ones, can always be blamed since powerful men have ostensibly
00:08:42 been in charge of creating the social conditions under which women's identities have developed.
00:08:48 Even body size and strength, the one natural bedrock you would think, you know, that would 0.94
00:08:56 have to be conceited, even that can be explained with reference to social conditioning. 1.00
00:09:03 yeah feminists will bring up nutritional differences between boys and girls access 1.00
00:09:09 to weight training equipment different levels of social encouragement and so on 1.00
00:09:14 for example a 2011 chapter by professors judith lorber and patricia martin called the socially
00:09:23 constructed body published in a collection called illuminating social life that chapter actually
00:09:31 argues that the primary difference between women and men's performance in sports is caused entirely
00:09:39 by a social preference to see women as weak and slender, in contradistinction to men's being
00:09:46 perceived as strong and muscular. The authors of this chapter are two well-published, highly
00:09:53 decorated professors of sociology and women's studies at American colleges, and here's a
00:09:58 quotation from the chapter to give you a flavor of their acid-tripping fantasy. 0.96
00:10:07 Today, when girls and women are professional and amateur players in all kinds of sports,
00:10:13 women and men are not allowed to compete against each other, so actual comparisons of men's and
00:10:21 women's and boys and girls' physical prowess are rarely made. So, in other words, the professors
00:10:30 argue that our society prevents women and men from competing in sports together because that
00:10:36 would show that there is no difference in skill level or strength between women and men. They go 0.99
00:10:42 on to use an example from one of their students. They claim, one student in one of our introductory
00:10:49 sociology classes noted that he and the other boys were glad that they did not have to play
00:10:55 against the best athlete in their elementary school a girl sex segregation kept her from
00:11:02 playing with the boys and probably from showing them up they conclude that gender is a mass
00:11:10 conspiracy they don't use that term to fool everyone to convince us that women are not 0.58
00:11:16 actually as strong as men." Just in case we missed it, they repeat the point. Here it is. 0.82
00:11:23 If members of society are told repeatedly that women's bodily limitations prevent them from
00:11:29 doing sports as well as men, they come to believe it, and the belief is reinforced by the media.
00:11:37 The result is that even women's championship teams falter and fail. End of the quote.
00:11:45 You see, when a woman fails to perform as well as a man, the fault is society's because society
00:11:52 didn't believe that female athletes are as strong as male athletes. This is the kind of scholarship
00:12:00 that students read as fact in their university classrooms, are tested on, rewarded for parroting
00:12:08 back and from which no dissent is allowed it is surely a kind of madness it is social
00:12:16 constructionism that authorizes the call for ever greater measures to undo the negative effects of 1.00
00:12:23 patriarchy no matter how many times such policies fail feminists simply claim that more are needed 1.00
00:12:31 that patriarchal bias is still there preventing women from achieving what they're capable of 1.00
00:12:36 achieving. Because no rational argument about women's capabilities is ever allowed into the 0.87
00:12:42 discussion, the madness only increases from year to year. Social constructionism likewise justifies 0.99
00:12:49 countless public campaigns, social policies and laws aimed at changing men, retooling their
00:12:57 behaviour to make it more acceptable for a feminist world. Ever more punitive harassment
00:13:03 policies, ever wider definitions of sexual assault, ever more aggressive gender programming
00:13:08 workshops at universities, ever more elaborate workplace respect codes and equity hiring
00:13:14 policies for offices and boardrooms and shop floors. In cases where men are seen to be suffering
00:13:21 or falling behind women, that too is essentially men's fault since they are as they are, not because
00:13:27 they evolved that way, not because their nature is at odds with feminist dictates, but because
00:13:33 they were made as they are by male culture and can be undone and remade. The theory of gender 0.98
00:13:40 as a social construction thus offers feminists a blank check for transforming men and women 0.99
00:13:46 without any parameters. And if it destroys our society in the process, you can bet feminists 1.00
00:13:54 will find a way to blame the patriarchy for that too. But of course, feminists are vulnerable 1.00
00:14:01 on the front of biology. Just because they try to taint every reference to sex differences with the 1.00
00:14:08 charge of biological determinism doesn't mean that those who understand biology shouldn't attack
00:14:15 them. Surely this is where feminism is truly vulnerable. And the point is that it doesn't 1.00
00:14:20 take a rocket scientist to understand feminist positions. Vice versa, however, most feminists 1.00
00:14:28 do not understand biology at all, so let's start attacking feminist positions using evidence-based 1.00
00:14:35 science. Stay tuned for four more fundamental academic terms that have had a pernicious effect 1.00
00:14:43 on mainstream discourse.