The Fiamengo File - February 04, 2016


Feminist Terminology 2: Lived Experience - TFF Episode 23

Feminist Terminology 1: Gender - The Fiamengo File Episode 22 Feminist Terminology 3: Privilege - TFF Episode 24

Episode Stats


Length

11 minutes

Words per minute

134.08

Word count

1,602

Sentence count

52

Harmful content

Misogyny

38

sentences flagged

Hate speech

11

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 I'm Janice Fiumengo of the University of Ottawa and my theme today is lived experience. This
00:00:20 is the second in my five-part primer on feminist terms that have entered mainstream discussions
00:00:26 with pernicious effect. Last week I discussed the academic theory of gender as a social construct,
00:00:33 showing that the mainstreaming of gender has been fundamental to modern feminism, 0.55
00:00:38 giving feminists a metaphorical blank check for their policies. 1.00
00:00:46 The feminist reasoning is that since there is no biological basis to sex differences and therefore 1.00
00:00:51 everything is socially determined, there's no limit to how our society can be transformed to 1.00
00:00:57 at last achieve after so many centuries of oppression what they call equality for women,
00:01:04 which translates to powerful positions in all the major sectors of our society 0.92
00:01:09 they don't care about janitorial services or garbage collection of course, 1.00
00:01:13 and legal measures to protect women's feelings and status in these powerful white-collar sectors. 1.00
00:01:21 I think it's fair to say that this is the foundational idea of second-wave feminism and everything that came after. 1.00
00:01:29 If women are not equally represented, as in STEM, for example, it's always because they are oppressed by social forces.
00:01:40 My second term, then, is closely related to the first, and it is lived experience.
00:01:46 A lot of my intellectual energy when I was a feminist graduate student was, sadly in retrospect,
00:01:53 focused on the relationship between the social construction of gender and those rebellious women
00:01:59 who throughout history and in the present have defied that social construction. There's a
00:02:05 problem with the feminist theory of social construction. If everything, including women's 1.00
00:02:11 very selves the way they think and act and how well they do at sports for example if all that 0.95
00:02:18 is determined by social forces how can women come to reject their conditioning that must mean that
00:02:26 the conditioning wasn't very successful but if it wasn't very successful then how come even 50 years 0.99
00:02:33 after second wave feminists started telling women to be all they can be when it became socially 1.00
00:02:39 acceptable for a woman to have a career and to define herself outside of the categories of wife
00:02:44 and mother, how come patriarchal society is still being blamed for inhibiting and limiting women's 0.82
00:02:52 achievements? Patriarchal society is either all-powerful or it isn't. If it isn't all-powerful, 0.80
00:03:00 then you can't continue to blame it for everything as feminists do. But if it is all-powerful, 1.00
00:03:07 then, how come so many women successfully resist it? This is one of the many tensions 0.90
00:03:13 within feminist theory that academics love to use their taxpayer-funded sinecures to explore 0.99
00:03:19 at length. On the relationship between social conditioning and the individual woman, 0.71
00:03:25 the phrase lived experience is a common term in feminist scholarship, allowing feminists to have 0.99
00:03:32 it both ways to claim ever-present highly repressive social power but also to celebrate 0.99
00:03:40 women's resistance to it and the authority of their experience open up google and you'll find
00:03:48 a cornucopia of scholarly articles on women's lived experience their lived experience of violence for
00:03:55 example, or their lived experience of childbirth and so on. Something of the term's academic
00:04:02 bloatedness is suggested by its redundancy. Experience alone could do just as well since
00:04:10 it is impossible to conceive an experience that is not also in some sense lived. You might think
00:04:17 in its defense that the term distinguishes between actual and imagined experience, but that isn't the 0.94
00:04:23 case since emotions and perceptions are regularly included in feminist research as part of what 0.88
00:04:29 counts as lived experience. See, for example, Google entries on women's, quote, lived experience 0.97
00:04:36 of fear of childbirth or women's, quote, lived experience of conceptualizing the self.
00:04:42 It's typical academic jargon. Why not just women's fear of childbirth or women's conceptions of the
00:04:49 self. It's because lived experience is an academic code term for a set of assumptions about women's 1.00
00:04:56 core of authentic experience. The idea is that this core of experience is, though not unaffected
00:05:04 by social conditioning, also not entirely controlled by it. And if we can get at this
00:05:10 core of lived experience, according to feminist researchers, we can find out women's truth, 0.97
00:05:17 which is the truth about their oppression and their desires to live freely, 1.00
00:05:22 and we can transform society in accordance because, of course, why wouldn't we want to 0.88
00:05:28 at last achieve justice for women? Feminism has always made a big deal out of, quote, 1.00
00:05:35 listening to women's words and building knowledge around that, presumably in opposition to the male 1.00
00:05:42 habits of abstraction and empty theorizing. Actually, the term lived experience was first
00:05:49 formulated by a male German philosopher, Wilhelm Dithy, who argued that it was necessary for
00:05:56 philosophy to take seriously the full range of human subjective perception.
00:06:03 What is most significant about the term, as it has been adopted by feminists, different
00:06:08 from Dilthi's usage is the underlying assumption, which is a bedrock of feminist belief that
00:06:14 women's lived experiences provide more valuable insights into the operations of social power 0.93
00:06:22 than men's, because women have lived society's oppressive power from the inside. 0.93
00:06:30 The Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy, in its entry for Standpoint Theory, states this 0.94
00:06:37 for us quite baldly, quote, marginalized groups are socially situated in ways that make it more
00:06:46 possible for them to be aware and ask questions than it is for the non-marginalized. Research
00:06:54 should begin with the lives of the marginalized, end quote. That is quite a statement. By the fact
00:07:04 of being oppressed or marginalized according to this tentative feminism, women's experiences
00:07:10 are revelatory in a way that men's aren't. This is a bold, groundless claim. Even if one accepts 0.56
00:07:18 that women are marginalized in our society, which I do not accept, one could argue that the feminists 1.00
00:07:24 have it completely backwards, that the more oppressed, the more marginalized one is, the 0.98
00:07:29 more distorted and unreliable one's understanding of the world. I'm not saying that's true either.
00:07:36 My point is that either view is just a made-up theory, impossible to verify,
00:07:41 and should have no place in serious sociological research. 0.96
00:07:46 No matter the feminist position has gained mainstream credence and is now often employed,
00:07:52 and this is where it really matters to those of us concerned about justice for men and boys,
00:07:58 it is now often used to create an opposition between women's lived experience of something
00:08:05 usually discrimination or sexual harassment for example and men's perceptions of those same
00:08:12 things according to the wiki site geek feminism what women experience is often not noticed by men
00:08:21 why well because of course men are trained to ignore the reality of women's suffering under
00:08:28 patriarchy so according to this theory men's perceptions are oppressive and women's perceptions
00:08:36 are real so we'll have a man say for example i never harassed her i was just being friendly and
00:08:43 i made one joke when she told me she was married and i said oh too bad for me that was it but the
00:08:49 experts say, ah, but women's lived experience of harassment is that what men routinely discount
00:08:57 as nothing at all can have serious impacts on women's sense of security in the workplace.
00:09:04 All these experts, conditioned to believe that women's lived experience has some kind of sacred
00:09:10 authority, will be inclined to believe that what the woman says she felt is more important than
00:09:16 what the man says he did. The woman may or may not be lying, but the point is that even if she did
00:09:23 really feel it, her lived experience of harassment doesn't make it harassment, but feminist theory 0.99
00:09:30 says it does. And the groundwork for this has been in the making in the academy for years
00:09:36 through the rhetoric of lived experience. A popular advertisement that I've now seen countless times
00:09:43 because it has headed up some of the Fiamengo files, is a perfect expression of this almost
00:09:49 mystical faith in the significance of women's lived experience. It begins portentously.
00:09:57 Fact. 97% of women have an I hate my body moment every day. My response when I hear that, which 0.98
00:10:08 should be the response of most reasonable people, I think is, well, that's too bad, but why are you
00:10:13 telling me about it. What's it to me? But the implication is that there is a kind of
00:10:19 social obligation to care about women's lived experiences of their bodies. We all owe it
00:10:24 to women to make them feel good about themselves because it's society's fault if they don't. 0.53
00:10:31 We almost never hear about men's lived experience, and the implication is that we all already 0.69
00:10:36 know all we need to know about that, because society is supposedly men's experience writ
00:10:42 large. There's no public appetite for men's experience because feminists have been so 0.97
00:10:48 successful in convincing us that it is synonymous with oppressive power, cruelty, indifference, 0.93
00:10:54 and so on. Women's lived experience, on the other hand, supposedly offers us a truth 0.97
00:11:00 long silenced by definition valuable and interesting so ultimately when you hear the term
00:11:08 lived experience in any discussion about women it is almost always being used to prevent
00:11:14 questioning of a feminist truth claim because the foundational assumption of the term is that
00:11:21 women's experience has been suppressed by a misogynistic society if you question it then
00:11:26 you are by definition perpetuating oppression in the very act of not believing. It is a wildly
00:11:33 successful means to invalidate anyone who would dare to observe that women's claims of victim 0.95
00:11:39 status are empty and it needs to be attacked at source by going after the idea that women's
00:11:46 experience must be believed and that men's experience doesn't deserve equal attention.
00:11:51 But that's going to be a very hard slog.