The Fiamengo File - February 11, 2016


Feminist Terminology 3: Privilege - TFF Episode 24

Feminist Terminology 2: Lived Experience - TFF Episode 23 The Revolutionary Stupid Movement - TFF Episode 25

Episode Stats


Length

15 minutes

Words per minute

126.68

Word count

1,949

Sentence count

62

Harmful content

Misogyny

12

sentences flagged

Toxicity

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

2

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 I'm Janice Fiamengo from the University of Ottawa and my theme today is Privilege.
00:00:19 This is the third in my five-part series on feminist terms from academia that have been
00:00:24 successfully mainstreamed to shore up feminist arguments in the public sphere. 0.83
00:00:30 The two terms I've addressed so far are gender as a social construct, which has been
00:00:35 effectively used to argue that because there are no natural differences between the sexes,
00:00:40 any differentiation in men's and women's roles and achievements is due to patriarchal oppression
00:00:46 of women. The idea of gender as a social construct also justifies massive, really
00:00:53 unlimited social engineering to change male and female roles without the concept of gender as a 0.99
00:00:59 social construct much of feminism as we know it today would cease to exist the second term was 0.76
00:01:06 lived experience a term almost exclusively applied to women's experiences and beliefs with the 0.99
00:01:13 foundational assumption being that because women have always been outside of structures of power
00:01:20 female insights into the operation of our society are more valuable than men's and should be at the 0.99
00:01:27 center of research and discussion the term is often used to preempt criticism and to suggest
00:01:35 that no decent person would ever doubt women's experience and perceptions and to invalidate men's
00:01:42 experience and perceptions especially in such matters as claims of sexual assault and harassment
00:01:50 If she believes it happened, it happened. So the theory goes.
00:01:55 Incredibly damaging for men and boys in our society, it seems to me that these are the two 0.98
00:02:02 most important terms in feminist theory. One says that everything feminists don't like is because 1.00
00:02:08 of male power, and the other says that everything women believe, think, experience, and desire
00:02:14 is by definition true and must be taken seriously the next three terms are in a sense elaborations
00:02:22 on these two the terms are privilege a term used to shame men to make their achievements
00:02:28 in the world invalid and to suggest that they should give them up structural violence a term
00:02:35 used to make it seem true that even women who have led extraordinarily safe prosperous and
00:02:41 free lives are in some sense victims of violence, a brilliant rhetorical move, and microaggression
00:02:49 to make the case that even when actual incidents of violence become rare and sporadic claims of
00:02:56 victimhood by women and other groups can continue unimpeded. What is so important about all of these
00:03:03 terms, I will argue, is that they extend the discussion of discrimination far beyond the
00:03:10 domain of rational argument into the nebulous realm of emotion-based belief, where sane
00:03:17 people must but fear to tread.
00:03:22 So privilege.
00:03:24 This is a word that once neutral or even positive, as in, it's a privilege to meet you, has 1.00
00:03:30 been given a negative connotation by feminists with the suggestion that there is something 1.00
00:03:35 morally shameful in accidents of birth. 0.54
00:03:39 This concept of privilege was originally applied mainly to what Michael Walsh has jestingly
00:03:44 called the unbearable whiteness of being.
00:03:49 Though the term white skin privilege had been used throughout the 20th century, it was given 0.99
00:03:54 prominent academic currency in an article published in 1988 by Wellesley College Women's
00:04:02 Studies professor Peggy McIntosh, and it quickly became the Bible of every devout SJW of the time.
00:04:13 McIntosh's point was that racism is not just individual acts of discrimination based on race,
00:04:20 it is a whole system, advantaging whites and disadvantaging non-whites, much of it
00:04:26 invisible and therefore difficult to change or even to see clearly. So Macintosh made a
00:04:34 preliminary numbered list of such white privileges. It's a series of sweeping generalizations,
00:04:42 many of them difficult to prove or disprove, and that make no distinction between actual
00:04:48 racial discrimination and simple numerical fact, as in the following example. Quote,
00:04:55 I can go into a bookshop and count on finding the writing of my race represented, or into a
00:05:02 supermarket and find the staple foods that fit with my cultural traditions, or into a hairdresser's
00:05:08 shop and find someone who can deal with my hair. True in most majority white towns, though having 0.91
00:05:15 nothing to do with privilege or exclusion, and certainly not true in towns where non-whites
00:05:21 make up significant minorities, having everything to do with history, demographics, and supply and
00:05:26 demand. Many of Macintosh's assertions are actually highly dubious, as in this example,
00:05:34 quote, I am never asked to speak for all the people of my racial group. Not true then or now.
00:05:41 In fact, Macintosh was speaking for all people of her racial group. Here's another, quote, I can be
00:05:49 pretty sure that an argument with a colleague of another race is more likely to jeopardize
00:05:55 her chances for advancement than to jeopardize mine. Definitely not true then or now in the
00:06:03 politically correct world out of which McIntosh was writing, as any perusal of newspaper reports
00:06:09 about racially charged incidents on university campuses will reveal. Anyway, in addition to
00:06:18 signalling her virtue in being able to see what most whites couldn't or wouldn't see,
00:06:24 McIntosh had an ulterior motive with the list she compiled. She used it to suggest that the
00:06:32 work she had done to understand her invisible privilege as a middle-class white woman
00:06:38 was work that men should do to understand how maleness similarly advantaged them in multiple,
00:06:46 often deeply subtle and difficult to recognize ways. And feminists soon began compiling such
00:06:53 lists of male privilege, now widely available on the internet and granted the status of holy writ.
00:07:02 A correspondent friend from Australia recently told me that he and his colleagues who do
00:07:09 astronomical research were asked at the opening session of the Annual Conference of the International
00:07:16 National Centre for Radio Astronomy Research to study and discuss one such male privilege
00:07:23 checklist as a kind of consciousness-raising exercise to combat sexism in astronomy. They
00:07:32 had to pair up with a colleague to discuss the list and then, when called on, publicly
00:07:38 confess their privilege if they were male, or to itemize their victimization if they
00:07:45 were female. The similarity to communist sessions in public self-criticism designed to force
00:07:52 unity of thought and to discourage backsliding is stunning. Much of the male privilege checklist
00:08:00 would be laugh-out-loud funny if it were intended as satire, because it's a series of often
00:08:07 completely false assertions, such as, quote, my odds of being hired for a job when competing
00:08:15 against female applicants are probably skewed in my favor. The more prestigious the job,
00:08:22 the larger the odds are skewed, end quote. Not, end quote, as a child, chances are I got more
00:08:33 teacher attention than girls who raised their hands just as often, end quote. Emphatically not.
00:08:43 Even if these assertions had some validity, which they do not, the idea of a bunch of PhDs in
00:08:51 astronomy having to publicly confess their sinful privilege at the opening session of a radio
00:08:59 astronomy research conference is shockingly indicative of ideological totalitarianism
00:09:08 in time the idea of privilege spread to many other areas of human experience as well including
00:09:16 social class sexual identity body size disability and on and on and ritualized confessions of
00:09:24 privilege became a primary SJW oath and mark of membership I am a white
00:09:31 heterosexual male so I personally feel that I enjoy a lot of the privilege of a
00:09:34 lot of people in this room in this country in this world do not. On a conscious and
00:09:37 self-conscious level that I have benefited from being a white male. I'm white, I'm male, straight, 0.60
00:09:43 I'm temporarily able-bodied, and I'm socially acceptable body size so I just like to check my
00:09:48 privilege first. The term privilege, which often makes no distinction at all between the good
00:09:55 things one has earned in life, or that one's race or sex have earned, and the good things one is
00:10:01 born into, depends on the assumption that unless one can claim some form of victimhood, one cannot
00:10:07 really be said to have fairly earned anything. This aspect of blame and delegitimization is
00:10:15 explicit in Peggy McIntosh's text, in which she speaks of whiteness and maleness as conferring
00:10:23 quote, unearned assets, end quote, by which the recipients find that quote,
00:10:31 many doors open through no virtues of their own, end quote.
00:10:37 Privilege proves in McIntosh's words, quote, the myth of meritocracy, end quote.
00:10:46 I've noticed that some SJWs deny the implicit slur in the idea of privilege that men and whites
00:10:53 have been given everything for free. The compiler of the male privilege list that my astronomer
00:11:00 friend had to adopt actually states that, quote, being privileged does not mean men are given
00:11:06 everything in life for free. Being privileged does not mean that men do not work hard, do not
00:11:12 suffer, she claims." In practice though, the term privilege does translate to pretty much exactly
00:11:21 that men are given everything free and can't really own anything of their own.
00:11:27 Some of you may have seen a few months ago Kate Brooks' performance in the 2015 Oxford Union
00:11:34 debate on freedom of speech and the right to offend, in which Brooks accuses Peter Hitchens
00:11:41 and Brendan O'Neill, her debating opponents, of being privileged white men. I really recommend
00:11:48 watching that video clip if you can bear Brooks' voice and asinine argument. In one of her very 0.85
00:11:55 first statements, Brooks claims that those concerned about offensive, hateful speech,
00:12:01 the good SJWs, do not want to silence white men like Hitchens and O'Neill,
00:12:08 but to, quote, erode, and this is her voice, erode the platform that our racist and misogynistic
00:12:16 society has given to two privileged white men. Note her words. This platform is given by society
00:12:26 to privileged white men such as Hitchens. In other words, they earned nothing through their
00:12:32 own talents and hard work. Standard social justice lingo—a smug and dishonest devaluation
00:12:39 of the skills and dedication of men everywhere. Conversely, emphasis on privilege also suggests
00:12:47 that there is something morally admirable in being a victim or an outsider—that lack of privilege
00:12:55 Privilege brings with it special insights and a totally justifiable rage that victims
00:13:02 have the right, even perhaps the obligation, to express.
00:13:08 Leveling charges of privilege becomes a game of moral one-upmanship in which whoever can
00:13:13 accuse the other of the more reprehensible privilege has earned the right to belittle
00:13:18 that person and to vaunt their own purity.
00:13:23 the claim of invisibility for privilege provides the perfect shield from logical rebuttal.
00:13:30 If you deny that you have experienced privilege, that merely confirms that, see, we told you
00:13:37 so, privilege is invisible.
00:13:40 No matter how many concrete legal and societal barriers, disabilities, and acts of discrimination
00:13:46 might be cataloged, quantified, and analyzed, the SJW will continue to claim that a widespread,
00:13:54 unacknowledged, intangible, and even conveniently unprovable privilege still justifies and even
00:14:01 mandates more SJW activism. I suggested earlier that the terms gender as a social construct and
00:14:10 women's lived experience should both be logically attacked, the first through exposing the scientific
00:14:17 untenability of feminist claims about gender, the second through rationally dismantling the idea
00:14:24 that women's experience deserves any kind of sanctifying status as a more reliable source
00:14:31 of knowledge than men's. But what can be done about the term privilege? I don't think it can
00:14:40 be attacked through reason. It is specially designed, as I have shown, to be impervious to
00:14:47 reason. This is perhaps the special genius of much of third-wave feminism that it doesn't rest on 0.99
00:14:55 verifiable claims but on assertions about the world that simply through reiteration establish
00:15:02 a powerful, felt reality. Doesn't matter if the claims aren't true. They feel right. How to engage
00:15:12 with them, then? Well, stay tuned for the final two terms in my series and for my reflections on
00:15:21 and combating them.