The Fiamengo File - February 18, 2016


The Revolutionary Stupid Movement - TFF Episode 25

Feminist Terminology 3: Privilege - TFF Episode 24 Campus Thought - "Gender"

Episode Stats


Length

13 minutes

Words per minute

116.89

Word count

1,554

Sentence count

82

Harmful content

Misogyny

4

sentences flagged

Toxicity

6

sentences flagged

Hate speech

6

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 When I was a student I dreamed of being an animal rights terrorist. I wanted to
00:00:11 break the beagles out of the science lab on campus where they were being used in
00:00:16 experiments. I thought of student radicals as noble rebels crusading
00:00:21 against the indifference of mainstream society. I'm Janice Fiumingo of the
00:00:28 University of Ottawa. What a letdown it's been over the last few years to see some student radicals
00:00:35 in the flesh. Maybe men's issues discussions bring out the worst of the lot, but certainly 0.93
00:00:43 the anti-male protesters I've seen recently have been a pretty sad bunch. Now everybody expects
00:00:50 student radicals to flout the law occasionally, selectively, like Rosa Parks refusing to give
00:00:58 up her bus seat to a white person. The principle is that you peacefully break a bad law, risking
00:01:05 arrest for that, as happened to Parks, and in the process you show your society that the law is bad 0.64
00:01:13 and you're willing to sacrifice your comfort for a larger good, in this case the good of racial
00:01:19 equality. But with the student protesters I've seen, it's as if Rosa Parks had thrown whites 0.52
00:01:26 off the bus and threatened to drive over them if her vision was not immediately implemented. 0.51
00:01:32 The tactics are aggressive and pointless.
00:01:36 it's hard to see the righteousness in blocking the doors of a building where
00:01:49 students and others in the community are trying to hear a speaker it's hard to
00:01:59 see that as admirable no matter how you spin the subject being discussed and
00:02:04 they do spin the subject. On top of that, those creepy masks they wear, they make them seem like
00:02:13 bandits or cowards. Are they not bold in their advocacy? And I thought student radicals were 0.92
00:02:22 supposed to be interested in ideas. These ones aren't. They don't debate or discuss.
00:02:30 We're not super interested in talking to you first of all, but basically we're here to shut down an event that is promoting the patriarchy.
00:02:39 They ridicule.
00:02:40 You're doing it really well! Good job!
00:02:46 They chant slogans.
00:02:48 A-Alti-Alti-Patriarcha!
00:02:51 Their idea of agitprop never gets beyond verbal abuse and physical intimidation,
00:02:57 utterly devoid of wit, insight, or intellectual substance. 1.00
00:03:02 You are fucking scum. Fucking brave apologist, incest supporting, woman-hating, fucking scum. 1.00
00:03:10 They seem unable to articulate a single sentence without obscenities. 1.00
00:03:14 Tell them not to fucking do that. The law is favoring these fuckers. 1.00
00:03:17 Listen, listen. 1.00
00:03:18 And perhaps most disturbing of all, given that these are student radicals,
00:03:24 in the cases I've seen they haven't got a clue what they're demonstrating against.
00:03:31 One of the groups that I now expect to see at events sponsored by the Canadian Association
00:03:35 for Equality is the revolutionary student movement. Now first, for those of you who don't know,
00:03:42 The Canadian Association for Equality is a registered charity that provides men support
00:03:48 services and that advocates for social equality and equal treatment under the law.
00:03:54 A year ago, the Canadian Association for Equality opened the Canadian Centre for Men and Families
00:04:00 in Toronto, which provides counselling and workshops on men's experiences of sexual abuse,
00:04:06 violence, suicide prevention, and legal aid. They also sponsor talks to raise awareness about men's
00:04:14 lives. The revolutionary student movement, of course, declares CAFE a hate group. They don't
00:04:22 bring forward a single piece of evidence to say why because, of course, they can't find a single
00:04:28 piece of evidence. But that's business as usual for our revolutionary students who give off a lot
00:04:35 more heat than light.
00:04:38 Undeterred by the fact that communism has been an abject failure everywhere it has been
00:04:44 tried and has spawned almost inconceivable levels of repression and human misery in every
00:04:50 society organized on Marxist principles, this group aims to overthrow capitalism to bring
00:04:57 about a reign of peace and plenty.
00:05:01 do that, it's necessary to stop people from having forbidden conversations.
00:05:08 This was the group that shut down my talk in Ottawa two years ago on rape culture. 0.89
00:05:13 The point I had planned to make was that exaggerating the likelihood of a woman's being
00:05:18 raped on a university campus and pretending that our culture condones rape in any way
00:05:25 are damaging ideas damaging to both men and women leading to women's irrational fear and
00:05:32 unjust hatred of men but the revolutionary students didn't want to hear one word of that
00:05:38 characterizing it in advance as hate speech so they blew their horns and bang their drums
00:05:45 and sang the Communist Internationale.
00:05:48 Every time you interrupt, you're merely showing your virtue.
00:05:52 You're repressive tendencies.
00:05:54 You're not showing anything about your virtue.
00:05:59 The event organizers and security personnel pleaded with them to allow the talk to proceed,
00:06:06 suggesting that they could ask devastatingly good questions afterwards to make their point.
00:06:12 What do you bet?
00:06:13 Finally, the event was moved to another room and when we tried to proceed, somebody pulled the fire alarm.
00:06:21 I'm sure it wasn't a member of the revolutionary student movement.
00:06:37 movement.
00:06:39 Two years later, here they were again for a talk by former McGill University professor
00:06:45 Paul Nathanson, a religious studies scholar and author of four books on men in society,
00:06:52 including the voluminous and meticulously documented work Legalizing Misandry.
00:06:58 This time our friends showed their commitment to the people's struggle by blocking the
00:07:03 one entrance to the room so that those students and others wanting to attend the talk couldn't
00:07:08 get in and those already inside the room setting up were stuck there. What a blow for justice.
00:07:17 As usual, security personnel couldn't convince them to budge, but when the police arrived,
00:07:22 their revolutionary fervor evaporated and after what seemed a brief football-style huddle,
00:07:30 went meekly down the stairs and into the night. They're now complaining on their Facebook page
00:07:38 about the, quote, illegitimate repressive force used against, quote, non-violent student protesters.
00:07:46 Come on, guys. We've got the whole thing on film. There was no repressive force. The police came
00:07:54 and told you that they'd arrest you for breaking the law, which you were doing, and you scattered.
00:08:00 pronto. I don't blame you for scattering, but I do kind of blame you for lying about it.
00:08:08 I wonder if our not-so-brave crusaders had even a moment's qualm about attempting to prevent the talk 0.58
00:08:15 of a gay man who has spent his academic career collaborating with a feminist scholar,
00:08:21 Catherine Young, to document the legal and social position of men in contemporary culture.
00:08:28 Might it have passed through their minds that Paul Nathanson has something of value to offer
00:08:35 to men and women, gay and straight, who are thinking about the meanings of masculinity
00:08:41 in modern North America? Well, of course not, because they don't even know who Paul Nathanson
00:08:50 is. I am confident that not a single one of them has ever read a word he's written.
00:08:58 They don't even mention him on their Facebook page calling for the protest. You'd think that
00:09:06 if you were calling people to protest a talk supposedly promoting, quote, misogyny, anti-feminism,
00:09:13 and rape culture, as they alleged, you'd at least say who it was that was promoting it
00:09:21 and what he was known to have said that was misogynist. If they'd scoured his books,
00:09:29 they'd have been unable to find anything misogynist, but they're so busy trying to
00:09:34 prevent any discussion that doesn't toe their Marxist feminist line that they don't have time 0.95
00:09:40 for bourgeois pursuits like reading or thinking. We expect we'll see the protesters again one day,
00:09:50 and though we think their time might be better spent addressing real problems in society of the
00:09:55 sort café deals with—problems of homelessness, for example, suicide, inequitable treatment under
00:10:02 the law—all issues that affect men disproportionately—still we suspect the students will continue to
00:10:10 inconvenience and harass others, accomplishing nothing by their actions.
00:10:17 Actually, they do accomplish one thing. They make our point for us—that we live in a society in
00:10:26 which it's cool to attack the free speech rights of non-feminists who simply want to discuss men's 1.00
00:10:33 problems. We know that if there were a feminist group, or any group for that matter, talking about 1.00
00:10:41 women's lives that was being constantly disrupted, the protesters would have been hauled away in a
00:10:48 paddy wagon at the first sign of incalcitrance. So, congratulations students! You're fully part
00:10:58 of the establishment mainstream. You're on a path blazed by other bigots decades ago,
00:11:05 and you acknowledge that by the very fact that you don't even feel the need to read
00:11:11 the authors you're protesting to know what you're supposed to say and do about them.
00:11:18 You're utterly predictable, sloganizing followers of authority. And there's nothing revolutionary
00:11:27 about that. Here at Studio Brulee, we're going to run a pilot for a potential series on student
00:11:35 responses to topics covered in the Fiamengo file. Its working title is Campus Thought or Campus
00:11:43 Response. The series would use clips provided by viewers like you who are willing to collaborate
00:11:49 with us by going to campus and talking to students on film about a topic we'll provide. The initial
00:11:57 topic is should men's groups be allowed to form on university campuses why or why not interested
00:12:05 participants can send their clips directly to studio brulee contact information below
00:12:12 studio brulee will present a compilation of selected clips with collaborators given
00:12:17 full credit. Feel free to leave comments or suggestions below this video.
00:12:47 Thank you.