The Fiamengo File - February 25, 2016


Feminist Terminology 4: Structural Violence - TFF Episode 26

Campus Thought - "Gender" Feminist Terminology 5: Microaggression - TFF Episode 27

Episode Stats


Length

9 minutes

Words per minute

132.42

Word count

1,305

Sentence count

48

Harmful content

Misogyny

26

sentences flagged

Toxicity

3

sentences flagged

Hate speech

4

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 I'm Janice Fiumingo of the University of Ottawa. My theme today is structural violence.
00:00:09 This is the fourth in my five-part series on key terms from academic feminism that have
00:00:15 gone mainstream and significantly limited honest discussion of male-female relations.
00:00:22 Having explored gender as a social construct and women's lived experience in previous videos,
00:00:29 Last week I discussed the ubiquitous term privilege. The idea of unearned privilege 1.00
00:00:36 allows SJWs to rank the moral status of participants in public discussion, invalidating
00:00:44 the claims of the so-called privileged, and sanctifying the claims of the so-called oppressed.
00:00:50 The idea of privilege means ultimately that whatever you have achieved, whether as a result
00:00:56 of your own work and talent or that of your sex or race is morally tainted and can and should be
00:01:03 taken away from you moreover what is particularly dangerous or brilliant depending on your
00:01:09 perspective in the term is its imperviousness to reason because privilege is understood to be
00:01:17 invisible according to its framer peggy mackintosh and her many followers it is to a large extent
00:01:23 beyond the reach of logic. Evidence brought forward to disprove the existence of privilege
00:01:30 is by definition disallowed, since privilege, according to feminist advocates, is not merely
00:01:36 a matter of facts, but of attitudes, norms, conventions, values, and even unconscious 0.95
00:01:42 biases and assumptions. So once established as a term of publicly sanctioned denigration,
00:01:50 privilege is a very difficult idea to dislodge, justifying all manner of rank injustice.
00:01:57 The next term I will discuss, structural violence, extends the powerful illogic of
00:02:04 feminist thinking. Structural violence, which is sometimes also called systemic violence,
00:02:10 is a term that pairs effectively with privilege, functioning to name its obverse. It wasn't enough
00:02:16 for feminists to be able to claim that all men had what Macintosh called unearned assets for 1.00
00:02:23 which they must repeatedly apologize and feel shame. It was necessary to claim also that all 0.61
00:02:29 women are oppressed, not just some women or even most women, all women every day, every minute,
00:02:37 everywhere, no matter how prosperous, independent, and free they might seem. Feminists borrowed the 1.00
00:02:44 term structural violence from the Norwegian sociologist and founder of the Peace Studies
00:02:50 movement, Johan Galtung. Galtung is credited with coining the phrase to describe how an
00:02:57 entire unjust system works in tandem with direct violence to limit the victim's life
00:03:03 possibilities. He meant the term to describe the experience of those at the very bottom
00:03:09 rungs of the social ladder. Now, that obviously didn't describe the vast majority of Western
00:03:14 women in the latter half of the 20th century, but no matter. Feminists came up with an ingenious 1.00
00:03:20 theory about the workings of male violence to claim that even though only a small minority
00:03:26 of men are violent towards women, all women are harmed by that violence, particularly
00:03:32 because it is supposedly supported by society at large.
00:03:37 Now here's a standard definition taken almost at random from a social justice website.
00:03:43 Here's the quote.
00:03:44 The general belief about violence against women is that it is an extreme or isolated
00:03:50 situation, the website states.
00:03:53 But quote, on the contrary, it affects us all, that is all women, because we all have
00:03:59 experienced fear, changed our behavior, and limited our options due to the threat of violence."
00:04:09 The statement accepts that actual violence against women is not common but immediately moves to
00:04:15 extend the definition of violence to include the effects of violence. According to this line of
00:04:21 thinking, violence that directly affects only a relatively few women still affects all women
00:04:28 because women are made aware of themselves as potential victims. Of course, feminists don't 1.00
00:04:34 apply that logic to other realms. They don't claim, for example, that when a minority of mothers kill 1.00
00:04:41 their children, which they certainly do, that therefore all children are endangered by their
00:04:47 mothers. They don't claim that when women hire contract killers to dispose of their husbands, 1.00
00:04:52 which we know they certainly do, that all men must now quake in fear. The penumbra of violence
00:04:59 is legitimate only when women are the victims. The phrase structural violence enables feminists 1.00
00:05:05 to claim that essentially anything that happens to a woman that feminists don't like is a kind 0.99
00:05:11 of violence because they're women in an inequitable male-dominated society. Female victimization is 1.00
00:05:18 thus described as existing on a continuum, extending from actual violence and threats
00:05:23 of violence to far more subtle manifestations of structural violence.
00:05:30 Structural violence takes such forms, and here I'm quoting from the same website, it
00:05:35 takes such forms as, quote, sexual and psychological harassment in the workplace, that's now
00:05:41 violence, and even the, quote, commodification of women's bodies, for example, advertising
00:05:49 that makes use of beautiful women, that's now violence too. 1.00
00:05:55 Second wave feminist Andrea Dworkin phrased it most memorably when she explained how it 1.00
00:06:00 is that women are by definition oppressed. 0.99
00:06:04 She explained that when a man and woman walk out of their home, no matter how good the
00:06:09 man is how well he treats his woman how seemingly equal their relationship it still still can't be
00:06:16 a truly equitable relationship because quote he is in a world of his supremacy based on the 0.99
00:06:23 existence of his cock and she is in a world of humiliation and degradation because she is 1.00
00:06:29 perceived to be inferior and because her sexuality is a curse surely most third wave feminists though 1.00
00:06:37 perhaps not even aware of the brilliantly depraved writings of Andrea Dworkin, are still 1.00
00:06:44 Dworkin's ideological heirs. A random search on the internet using the search term structural
00:06:51 violence against women immediately brings up a 2013 paper by Kerry Cross, a PhD student at
00:06:58 the University of Notre Dame. This is a paper presented to the annual meeting of the American
00:07:04 Political Science Association, the most prestigious gathering of political studies academics in North
00:07:10 America. The paper is called The Gendered Effects of Structural Violence. And in this paper,
00:07:18 Cross argues that structural violence against women does more harm even than armed conflict. 1.00
00:07:26 Feminists have always been bothered a bit by the attention that dead men tend to garner, 0.82
00:07:32 and Cross mentions almost resentfully that a lot of peace research in political studies
00:07:38 has been focused on the male victims of armed conflict. So, she proposes to radically widen
00:07:45 the definition of victim of violence. In Cross's use of the term structural violence,
00:07:51 it's any form of inequality including economic and social inequality. This is what she says about it,
00:07:59 quote, unequal structures are themselves violent. So this is the feminist methodology to a T. 1.00
00:08:09 Take a word with a clear and precise meaning, such as violence, and stretch it so that a woman 1.00
00:08:16 earning less than a man is equivalent to, or even maybe worse than, a man's death in war. 0.82
00:08:22 Well, of course, feminists might not exactly say that, but the whole point of the phrase
00:08:28 structural violence, as Cross uses it, is clearly intended to make the case that
00:08:34 female victims far outnumber male victims of violence and that the bulk of research,
00:08:40 government spending, and societal concern should be focused on women.
00:08:46 So when you hear the phrase structural violence, get ready for the argument that because
00:08:51 some forms of economic or social inequality exist, all women are still victims requiring urgent
00:08:59 action. Why is it that the $0.23 wage gap is so often cited, so tenaciously held to,
00:09:08 despite the fact that it does not prove discrimination? Well, it's because it
00:09:13 supposedly makes women as a class victims of economic structural violence. But if one day 1.00
00:09:21 even all economic and social indicators prove that women are not oppressed as a class, 1.00
00:09:29 that won't stop feminism. At that point, my final term, microaggression, will be brought 0.99
00:09:36 even more aggressively into play, for it is marvelously effective even in the absence of
00:09:43 any examples of real inequality. Stay tuned.