The Fiamengo File - March 03, 2016


Feminist Terminology 5: Microaggression - TFF Episode 27

Feminist Terminology 4: Structural Violence - TFF Episode 26 Persecution at KSU - TFF Episode 28

Episode Stats


Length

14 minutes

Words per minute

129.34

Word count

1,856

Sentence count

57

Harmful content

Misogyny

9

sentences flagged

Toxicity

5

sentences flagged

Hate speech

5

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 I'm Janice Fiamengo of the University of Ottawa. My theme today is microaggression.
00:00:11 This is the last in my five-part series on key feminist terms from academia that have gone
00:00:16 mainstream with pernicious effect on honest dialogue about equality. In the latter half
00:00:23 of the series we've been looking at terms that are particularly invulnerable to reasoned attack.
00:00:30 privilege because it is by nature invisible, according to the experts,
00:00:35 and structural violence because it redefines inequality as violence, claiming that if one
00:00:42 woman can be shown to suffer violence or inequality, then all women are a victim class.
00:00:49 Now for our fifth term, the one that most obviously signals the irrational obsession
00:00:56 with victimization of feminists and other SJWs. The final term, microaggression, 1.00
00:01:03 has become the ultimate symbol of manufactured outrage.
00:01:08 The term microaggression was first coined in 1970 by Harvard University professor
00:01:14 Chester Pierce, according to Derald Wing Sue's book, Microaggressions in Everyday Life, published
00:01:21 in 2010. And it has been widely taken up by psychologists to describe the everyday,
00:01:28 normalized, verbal and nonverbal slights or insulting behaviors whereby members of dominant
00:01:35 groups communicate, consciously or unconsciously, derogatory messages to members of marginalized
00:01:42 groups. Quite recently, the term has been adopted by journalists and university students enabling
00:01:49 all variety of the walking wounded to describe the subtle ways in which their society makes them
00:01:55 other there's an online microaggression blog that contains many examples of these daily slights
00:02:03 the use of the word illegals for one example any expression of objection to gay marriage
00:02:10 relatives asking a lesbian who's home from college whether she met any nice boys there
00:02:17 A teacher asking a black student, quote, don't you think your reaction was offensive as well?
00:02:24 A t-shirt that says, cool story, babe, now make me a sandwich.
00:02:31 Microaggression. Actually, it's a clever term in its paradoxical insistence on the hurtful
00:02:38 significance of the admittedly trivial. In that way, microaggression is a potentially
00:02:45 apt descriptor for how human beings continue in a multitude of ways to hurt and disgust and outrage
00:02:52 one another even in a society as relatively peaceful and civil as our own the term might 0.99
00:02:59 be appropriately applied in many spheres how about to the manner in which women put one another down 0.98
00:03:07 all the time with seemingly nice comments such as, 1.00
00:03:12 that extra weight looks really good on you. I'll bet there's not a woman around who doesn't know
00:03:18 what I'm talking about. And if you're looking for one of the most disabling of microaggressions,
00:03:24 the use of the term privilege to describe the positions earned by brilliant and hard-working
00:03:30 white men is a fantastic example of the ultimate put-down. But the term is never used to describe
00:03:38 what two white women might say to one another or what women say about men. It's only used to
00:03:44 describe aggression by the so-called privileged against the so-called oppressed. So, a t-shirt
00:03:51 that says, make me a sandwich, is a misogynistic microaggression, whereas a feminist professor's 1.00
00:03:58 use of the phrase toxic masculinity in her lectures is not. Personally, I'd rather deal with a joke 0.55
00:04:07 t-shirt than an established theory supported by my professor and accepted by elite society
00:04:13 generally that says my sex has a genetic disposition to violence and domination. 0.91
00:04:20 This is the ultimate hypocrisy of microaggression. It claims to be about preventing subtle sexual
00:04:28 racial, and other forms of discrimination, but its insistence that only certain groups of people
00:04:35 can be affected exposes it for the blatant power play that it is. Like the terms lived experience,
00:04:43 privilege, and structural violence, the theory of microaggression affirms that certain perceptions
00:04:50 and experiences, those of women and other marginalized groups, should always be given
00:04:55 priority in interpreting the world, while the perceptions and experiences of white men
00:05:01 can be explained away or simply ignored.
00:05:05 Would any reasonable person claim that being expected to bring the coffee and donuts to
00:05:10 a meeting because you're a woman, if that really happens very often at all, is equivalent
00:05:16 in any way to being told, not by a few individuals whom you can correct or ignore, but by every
00:05:24 Every person in authority at your university, and at every university in North America,
00:05:29 and by every established media outlet and news organization, that because you're male,
00:05:35 you need to be taught not to rape.
00:05:38 Would any reasonable person claim that a donut expectation is a more hurtful and serious
00:05:44 problem in our society than a rape expectation? 0.87
00:05:49 Would any reasonable person really claim that a female scientist being mistaken for her 1.00
00:05:54 academic colleague's secretary, if that really happens very often at all, is equivalent
00:06:01 in any way to being told, not by a few individuals whom you can correct or ignore, but by the
00:06:06 Institute for the Prevention and Treatment of Mascupathy, that being male is a disease?
00:06:14 Sounds dramatic, doesn't it? 1.00
00:06:15 But it's true.
00:06:16 is an organization called the institute for the prevention and treatment of mascupathy
00:06:22 headed up by a team of credentialed individuals as far as i can tell i don't think it's a joke
00:06:28 with an advisory board made up of doctors psychotherapists psychologists and counselors
00:06:34 and even a christian pastor the institute claims that mascupathy is a pathology of masculinity
00:06:43 that quote erodes a balanced and healthy humanity end quote the first sentence of the institute's
00:06:51 website states its world view quote men often behave badly end quote due to masculinity as
00:07:00 it goes on to say well thank god women are not diseased in their humanity and that's the whole
00:07:07 point isn't it this movement of which microaggression theory is one strategy is about
00:07:13 making the hatred of men respectable a team of counselors doctors psychiatrists and health
00:07:19 researchers would never put their formal support behind an institute claiming that women who behave
00:07:26 badly suffer from femopathy a genetic based disease of femininity though such a theory would
00:07:33 have at least as much credibility as maskupathy does anyone suggesting that women's humanity 0.82
00:07:41 had been eroded by their narcissism pettiness and irrationality would probably be drummed out 0.96
00:07:46 of their positions but many powerful thought leaders in our society men included believe
00:07:54 that men need to be quote reinvented as the website claims microaggression ah not nearly
00:08:01 as bad as having your boss refer to you by your first name because you're female.
00:08:08 Like privilege, microaggression is a term that has in its very definition a built-in
00:08:14 immunity from a reason-based rebuttal. The blog Geek Feminism provides the following explanation
00:08:23 for why microaggression is hard to define and defend and why white males and other 0.82
00:08:29 privileged types therefore shouldn't question it this is what they say it's quote difficult for
00:08:36 oppressed people to explain the significance of microaggressions because it's difficult to convey
00:08:42 their relative frequency compared to the experiences of privileged people and easy for
00:08:49 privileged people to come up with plausible alternative explanations for any one microaggression
00:08:57 And here's the example they give. Quote, well, there's an Angela Smith and a Jane Smith, so
00:09:03 obviously it makes sense to call you Angela and Jane rather than Smith. Yeah, that would be a
00:09:11 plausible explanation for the so-called sexist microaggression of referring to Angela and Jane
00:09:18 by their first names. But that's too easy. It doesn't validate the paranoia of Angela or Jane.
00:09:26 So don't bother offering rebuttals to even the most obviously false evidence of discrimination.
00:09:33 It will merely prove that you're a privileged oppressor who has not done the morally necessary work of imagining the debilitating consequence of being called by your first name.
00:09:45 Shame on you.
00:09:46 We are in the realm of what? A deep irrationality, an illness of the mind, a culture-wide suspension of reasoning powers, a public readiness to reorder society, to punish perpetrators and compensate victims for entirely imaginary acts of intimidation and psychological violence.
00:10:10 If you think the effects of microaggression theory are confined to the fevered imagination
00:10:18 of a few activists with way too much time on their hands, or even to the insular conference
00:10:23 gatherings of a few highly paid academics, it's sadly not the case.
00:10:29 A few years ago, for example, a group of graduate students in Education and Information Studies
00:10:35 at the university of california at los angeles staged a sit-in to quote educate their professor
00:10:43 and other students about the racial discrimination they claim to have experienced in the course
00:10:49 at the sit-in they presented a list of racial microaggressions one of which in a perfect
00:10:55 illustration of the self-confirming logic of microaggression victimology involved a black
00:11:02 male PhD student whose research focuses on, wait for it, black male experiences of microaggression,
00:11:11 who claimed that comments made by his white peers about his microaggression
00:11:17 research being too subjective were in themselves forms of microaggression.
00:11:24 This is Alice in Wonderland, isn't it? But instead of reprimanding the students for
00:11:29 disrupting class the dean of graduate school responded by declaring himself humbly dedicated
00:11:36 yeah he actually word that used that word humbly to listening and learning from this experience
00:11:43 he claimed that quote together we will heal so the students risible complaints were validated
00:11:51 as has continued to happen at prestigious universities all across north america
00:11:56 words fail to adequately represent the ludicrousness of this cultural moment,
00:12:04 the cringe-making eagerness with which seemingly intelligent people prostrate themselves to learn
00:12:11 humbly from our era's priests and priestesses of the false god of moral outrage.
00:12:17 We dare not question, we dare not disagree, and we probably doubt ourselves. 0.72
00:12:24 I said in a previous video that I was going to offer my thoughts on resisting feminist
00:12:31 propaganda terms, but the more I thought about it all, the more dubious I became.
00:12:37 Can a culture-wide pathology be strategically resisted? I was going to remind you of the old
00:12:45 adage where reason fails to convince there is nothing left but ridicule. I had planned to say
00:12:52 that we need to laugh these words right out of existence, mock them, deride them, puncture their
00:12:58 carapace of righteousness, make faces, snort with derision, call them out for their corrosive 0.98
00:13:05 silliness. I'm still going to do that, but I'm not confident. The feminist narrative is not going 0.55
00:13:13 away anytime soon. I think we will see more nonsense, more men forced to apologize for 0.96
00:13:20 nothing more men hounded out of their positions more restrictions on free expression in the name
00:13:26 of protecting feelings why because it's a good gig for a lot of women and other professional 0.85
00:13:34 victims the people whose sickness it is to believe themselves the victims of white men
00:13:40 they don't want to get better their sickness feels good and it brings them attention and sympathy
00:13:46 and an identity and a self-justifying narrative that most of them are never going to give up
00:13:53 of their own accord. We can laugh all we want, and I certainly will, but I fear it won't make
00:14:00 enough of a difference. But it might. So, I'll keep on, on that slim chance, and I hope you will
00:14:10 too, if for no other reason than to stave off madness oneself. My husband says irony is good
00:14:18 for you. It's got iron in it.