The Fiamengo File - July 12, 2018


Feminists Lose Another Trial - TFF episode 85

Why Can't We Hate Men - TFF episode 84 OMG, She Cheered For White Men! TFF Episode 86

Episode Stats


Length

16 minutes

Words per minute

140.82

Word count

2,320

Sentence count

32

Harmful content

Misogyny

14

sentences flagged

Toxicity

3

sentences flagged

Hate speech

5

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 what does a feminist say when a highly publicized sexual assault trial ends in acquittal for the 0.99
00:00:06 accused well the script is as predictable as the pious platitudes one would find at a women's 0.58
00:00:12 conference on decolonizing and indigenizing a lesbian poetics of resistance and if you think
00:00:20 that's an exaggeration you don't know academia like i know academia but that's not my subject
00:00:25 on today's Fiomingo File. I'm Janice Fiomingo of the University of Ottawa. Two weeks ago, after a
00:00:42 sensational case that dragged on for more than four years and ruined many young men's career
00:00:48 dreams through the suspension of the entire varsity team, two University of Ottawa hockey 0.55
00:00:54 players were found not guilty of sexual assault and at least one of the feminist activists who
00:01:00 used the case to advance an anti-male agenda couldn't care less about the men involved
00:01:07 this case shares similarities with a number of other high-profile sexual assault trials involving
00:01:12 a drunken hookup a story that changed over time and an accuser caught lying on the witness stand
00:01:21 It's a complicated case and one that has not been reported extensively, but in brief. The accuser
00:01:28 arranged a date with a varsity hockey player while the University of Ottawa team was in Thunder Bay,
00:01:34 Ontario, for a game. After drinking and partying together, the accuser and the hockey player had
00:01:41 sex in his hotel room. There was a lot of drunken partying going on at the hotel, with members of
00:01:46 the team coming in and out of the hotel room while these two were having sex not something i would
00:01:53 recommend to any of my friends male or female but nothing remotely illegal things got more
00:02:00 complicated when a second hockey player the roommate of the first man approached the woman for
00:02:06 sex and she did not object there's a discrepancy in the testimony as to whether she verbally
00:02:13 consented or not certainly she never said no she had sex with the second man and then she left
00:02:21 after the incident with the encouragement of a friend of hers to whom she may have
00:02:27 claimed to have been victimized in order to cover her embarrassment at what she'd done
00:02:33 she agreed to press charges against the second hockey player claiming that she was pressured
00:02:39 into sex with him and had never consented. She also pressed charges against a third teammate,
00:02:45 though he testified that he never touched her, having entered the hotel room only as part of a
00:02:51 drunken prank. In the verdict, the female judge, Ontario Justice Chantal Brochu,
00:02:59 found that the accuser had not given a reliable account to police, changing her story frequently
00:03:05 and had demonstrably lied in court, thus seriously weakening her credibility. In particular, the
00:03:11 accuser had claimed repeatedly on the witness stand that she did not coordinate her story with
00:03:16 the first man, but text evidence obtained by the defense showed that, in fact, she had texted
00:03:21 extensively with this man to consult about what they were telling police, and she explicitly
00:03:26 discussed telling a false story. In the verdict, the judge said that she thought the two accused
00:03:32 men had behaved badly, but not criminally. Now, there are a lot of things that could be said
00:03:41 about this case, which led to the disgrace of the entire University of Ottawa hockey team,
00:03:45 including young men who had nothing whatsoever to do with the incident in question, some of whom
00:03:51 weren't even in Thunder Bay at the time, but who were suspended anyway and cast under a cloud of
00:03:56 shame. It also led to a public scandal at the University of Ottawa over the supposed
00:04:01 rape culture on campus. Many decisions were taken in response to the case, and a great deal of public
00:04:08 money spent to study and make recommendations about sexual violence at the University of Ottawa,
00:04:13 and I have yet to hear anyone admit that the conclusion of the trial makes that years-long
00:04:20 exercise in anti-male grandstanding look pretty lame. But lack of evidence has never mattered
00:04:28 to feminist arguments about male sexual aggression and female victimhood. Let's look for example at
00:04:35 the Crown's closing arguments in this case and here I should mention that I'm drawing on a
00:04:39 reporter's tweets of the case and I should note that the statements were all originally in French
00:04:45 they're in translation obviously. The Crown had to rely on the hair-splitting rhetoric and
00:04:52 infantilizing assumptions embedded in the feminist affirmative consent standard which is now part of
00:04:58 canadian law the defense position in contrast was based in legal common sense the defense case was
00:05:06 that the accuser's behavior clearly indicated consent she did the same things with the second
00:05:12 hockey player that she'd done with the first and she acted in the same manner in other words she
00:05:18 She gave consent through her actions, even enthusiastic consent, according to witnesses.
00:05:25 And she definitely never said no or indicated in any other manner that she didn't want to
00:05:31 participate.
00:05:32 But according to the Crown, none of these facts should save these two men from prison.
00:05:40 All that is relevant to determining non-consent, according to the prosecutor, is what the accuser
00:05:47 tells us about her state of mind as he said quote the notion of consent is not based on what other
00:05:55 people saw or perceived it is based on the subjective state of mind of the complainant
00:06:03 and further quote it is not a defense to ask whether the complainant sufficiently
00:06:09 expressed that she did not want to engage in a sexual act i don't think one can exaggerate how
00:06:18 illogical and unhelpful such premises are as a basis for criminal law that sexual consent has
00:06:27 nothing to do with observed behavior and that the accuser need not say no for the sex to be deemed
00:06:36 assault such a standard is contrary in my opinion to any common sense understanding of human sexual
00:06:43 behavior and it is also outrageous in its pretense that adult women can't be expected to be able to 0.68
00:06:50 say no to sex they don't want though these same women apparently should have the sole authority 0.99
00:06:57 to send men to prison based on their after the fact reconstruction and reporting of an unknowable 1.00
00:07:03 thing such as their state of mind well thankfully the judge seems to have recognized the thinness
00:07:12 of the crown's legal case especially given the fibs of the accuser nonetheless the judge's verdict 0.93
00:07:19 which she read out in the courtroom on june 25th was notable for the moralizing disdain she seems
00:07:26 to have thought it appropriate to express towards the two accused men maybe she believed correctly
00:07:33 that the not guilty verdict wouldn't endear her to her feminist colleagues and therefore felt that
00:07:38 a little preemptive man-blaming was in order. In her verdict, she objected to one of the defense 0.65
00:07:45 lawyer's statements that the accused sought to, quote, clear his name. She corrected him to make
00:07:51 a pointed distinction, saying, quote, perhaps they testified to defend themselves against the
00:07:58 charges but they will certainly never be referred to as having been gentlemen end quote in other
00:08:04 words the two men don't actually deserve to clear their names ever well what an interesting old
00:08:12 fashioned word to choose gentlemen haven't the feminists been telling us for decades that we 1.00
00:08:19 shouldn't participate in the social shaming and stigmatization of lawful sexual behavior or is
00:08:27 that only in relation to women perhaps the judge isn't wrong about these two men's behavior but
00:08:34 would she say the same thing about the accuser that her decision to have drunken sex with a
00:08:40 man she had just met through a dating app while his teammates were wandering in and out of the 0.93
00:08:45 hotel room was hardly the conduct of a decent young lady not to mention her decision to lay
00:08:51 charges against them later on? We know she wouldn't. The judge's remark was a gratuitous 1.00
00:08:59 act of feminist partisanship. The fact is, of course, as she well knows, these men have already
00:09:06 been harshly punished over the past four and a half years, far in excess of what non-gentlemanly
00:09:13 behavior would warrant. Their hopes of playing high-level hockey were destroyed by a woman who
00:09:18 played fast and loose with the truth. Their entire lives were put on hold while they endured the 0.99
00:09:23 terrifying experience of the trial, and their names will for years to come be associated with
00:09:28 sexual misconduct. The woman, whatever embarrassment she may have felt at the time, and I can imagine
00:09:34 that she did feel very uncomfortable with what she'd done. Well, she's been protected from public
00:09:39 censure, her identity is still shielded by court-ordered anonymity, and she won't face
00:09:45 punishment for perjuring herself on the witness stand despite her lies in fact newspaper reports
00:09:51 continue to refer to her as the alleged victim and right on cue feminist advocates have come
00:09:58 forward to complain about the verdict not because it is yet another disgusting illustration of how 0.98
00:10:04 easily feminists are led by their anti-male ideology to rally around a proven liar and 0.96
00:10:10 perjurer but because apparently the judge's failure to find the men guilty might make other 1.00
00:10:16 accusers hesitate and we wouldn't want women to hesitate to come forward quote every time we see
00:10:24 a high profile sexual assault trial result in an acquittal it sends women back 50 years according
00:10:31 to julie lalande an ottawa-based women's activist quote an acquittal like this is certainly not
00:10:38 going to encourage more women to come forward that's for sure end quote well we probably
00:10:44 couldn't ask for a clearer statement of the feminist position note that every time we see 1.00
00:10:51 a high-profile sexual assault trial result in acquittal it sends women back every time
00:10:58 not just in cases where the proof of the man's guilt seems unquestionable
00:11:02 not just in cases where the woman clearly suffered from a brutal violation no from the feminist point
00:11:08 of view any case that goes to trial should result in a conviction so that women can rest assured 0.99
00:11:16 their word is law julie lalon's disappointment at the verdict it's not surprising because she 0.91
00:11:24 has a lot invested in men being found guilty of sexual assault she's made male sexual violence 0.73
00:11:31 her career. Lalonde was one of the community partners brought on to the U of Ottawa task
00:11:38 force that was formed in response to the hockey scandal. Commissioned with much fanfare by the
00:11:46 then president of the university, Alan Rock, the task force created a 55-page document titled
00:11:54 Ending Sexual Violence at the University of Ottawa, and I recommend everyone take a look at this
00:11:59 document which is available online if you can stomach the pages the thousands of words of
00:12:05 feminist anti-male sermonizing the document took as a matter of faith that the hockey players were
00:12:12 guilty and it proposed sweeping recommendations to address what it called gender inequality and
00:12:18 gendered violence at university of ottawa even though its own survey showed that male students
00:12:25 reported near equal and in some cases greater levels of harassment in comparison to women
00:12:31 including violence threats of violence and death threats the report's recommendations focused
00:12:37 overwhelmingly on men as perpetrators and women as victims and amongst a litany of feminist
00:12:44 inspired proposals for sensitivity training and sexual violence prevention protocols and
00:12:51 bystander intervention workshops and public awareness campaigns to keep on banging away
00:12:57 at the myth that women on university campuses are constantly being victimized by men
00:13:02 the report approved something called empathy enhancement for men this is on page 28 if you
00:13:09 want to take a look that among other things teaches men to view male sexuality from a
00:13:15 feminist perspective i.e as always at least potentially harmful that men have often
00:13:22 reported feeling shamed stigmatized stereotyped and collectively blamed by these kinds of
00:13:29 approaches is of course never mentioned in the report as a concern and not once in this voluminous
00:13:39 report is the problem of false allegations raised not once do we hear about the terrible harm that
00:13:47 false allegations caused to men including not only ruined careers and permanently damaged
00:13:53 reputations but depression self-harm suicide physical assault and murder not once is it
00:14:00 suggested that women have any responsibility and sexual interactions to communicate clearly with
00:14:07 men not once is it suggested that women should be taught the difference so they don't confuse the
00:14:13 two between sexual assault and just plain bad sex sex they didn't enjoy for a variety of reasons
00:14:21 not once is it mentioned that women should not allow themselves to be talked into charging a
00:14:28 man with sexual assault out of jealousy or hurt pride or embarrassment or regret or just plain
00:14:36 meanness though we men's rights activists can provide plenty of examples of women who have done
00:14:41 precisely that not once is it mentioned that contrary to feminist myths women do lie about
00:14:49 sexual assault and that our culture needs to emphasize more clearly that lying about it is a
00:14:56 despicable crime of course not once do the report authors acknowledge what i believe which is that
00:15:03 we live not in a rape culture but in a cry rape culture in which women are repeatedly encouraged
00:15:11 by feminist authorities to reinterpret their experiences as assault and to make allegations
00:15:18 against the men they chose to be sexual with it's ironic that empathy enhancement was one
00:15:27 of the feminist practices mentioned in the task force report the obvious implication being of
00:15:32 course that many men lack empathy for women's pain i've found through many years of speaking
00:15:41 with men and women that the opposite tends to be true most men are repulsed at the thought of
00:15:48 causing any kind of harm to women women on the other hand are quite frequently unable to recognize
00:15:56 harms to men at all. And no wonder, because they've been told over and over again by the
00:16:03 Julie Lalons of the world that they don't have to.
00:16:26 You