The Fiamengo File - September 02, 2018


OMG, She Cheered For White Men! TFF Episode 86

Feminists Lose Another Trial - TFF episode 85 Two "Journalists" Attended ICMI 2018 - TFF Episode 87

Episode Stats


Length

16 minutes

Words per minute

137.41

Word count

2,222

Sentence count

39

Harmful content

Misogyny

12

sentences flagged

Toxicity

8

sentences flagged

Hate speech

2

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 Do medieval studies academics believe in witches? It seems some of them do, and the witch in question
00:00:08 is a University of Chicago historian who wrote a blog post called Three Cheers for White Men.
00:00:15 According to a large number of medievalists and other academics, this post was so dangerous in
00:00:21 its presumed ability to spread hetero-patriarchal and white supremacist harm that the person who
00:00:26 wrote it has had to be chastised, called out as a white supremacist and, preferably,
00:00:33 fired from her academic position. And that's my subject on today's Fiomingo File.
00:00:48 I'm Janice Fiomingo of the University of Ottawa. Like many other academic fields today,
00:00:53 medieval studies has been rocked by claims that white supremacism and other far-right isms are
00:01:00 deeply embedded in the discipline and must be rooted out in fact that there is nothing more
00:01:06 important to do in the field than talk about white supremacism and hetero hetero patriarchy and that
00:01:14 anyone not willing to do that must themselves be white supremacists whose denials or even silence
00:01:22 harm people of color according to the self-anointed leaders of the social justice
00:01:28 movement in academia what is necessary now is the hiring promotion and quote centering 0.54
00:01:36 of people of color also necessary are explicit declarations on the part of every academic of
00:01:43 their abhorrence of whiteness and their declared commitment to center the voices and experiences
00:01:51 of people of color and furthermore there must be an enthusiastic take no prisoners hunting down
00:01:58 not only of alleged white supremacists but of anyone who fails to make the necessary anti-white
00:02:05 noises in a timorous academic culture very few fail to fall in line with the luminous exception
00:02:15 of dissident academic rachel fulton brown a professor of medieval history at the university
00:02:21 of chicago author of a number of well-received academic books as well as a committed catholic
00:02:27 an enthusiastic blogger a lover of western civilization and its christian underpinnings
00:02:33 a self-described entish intellectual a defender and friend of milo yiannopoulos and quite possibly
00:02:42 the boldest non-conformist in all of academia at the present time and for that not surprisingly
00:02:51 rachel fulton brown has been under attack for more than two years and has provoked
00:02:56 near apoplectic rage and an extraordinary level of verbal viciousness from her fellow academics
00:03:04 across the world for her refusal to recruit medieval studies for the social justice cause
00:03:12 Fulton Brown has consistently argued that claims about white supremacy and misogyny have really very little to do with the reality of the medieval period and seem designed mainly to taint the whole past of Western culture, which she claims deserves our respect and even our celebration, as is evident in the title of the blog post that started all the fuss.
00:03:35 three cheers for white men. Here Fulton Brown dared to defend Western Christendom as the source
00:03:43 of many of our most cherished values of gender equality and respect for individual worth. She
00:03:50 ended that little post by advising readers to, quote, hug a white man today. This led Dr. Rohit
00:03:58 Chopra, an associate professor of communications at Santa Clara University, to tweet with indignation
00:04:04 that, quote, the ugliest thing on academic social media now is white conservative academic Rachel
00:04:11 Fulton Brown defending the greatness of white men, end quote. How dare she? Fulton Brown has also 1.00
00:04:19 crossed the line into unacceptable conduct by writing many blog posts, one that ended up being
00:04:25 published in Breitbart magazine, defending Milo Yiannopoulos against detractors' claims about him,
00:04:32 And for that, she is now regularly labeled as by Nadir Firat, who is a lecturer at Nanyang
00:04:40 Technological University in Singapore as a, quote, fascist white supremacist professor, end quote.
00:04:47 The far left social justice academic crowd is so used to fawning obedience from their peers
00:04:55 that they become irrationally enraged by any opposition,
00:05:00 no matter how cheerful and gracious as Fulton Brown's has been.
00:05:05 And I strongly urge anyone who's at all interested in this case,
00:05:10 because I can't tell you all the details,
00:05:11 to read Fulton Brown's blog posts, as I've done,
00:05:14 and to see the degree of self-restraint,
00:05:18 the degree of generosity and lightness of spirit,
00:05:20 as well as the intellectual heft that she has brought
00:05:23 to what has turned into a really ugly one-sided mobbing. Academics have set out to destroy this
00:05:30 woman professionally, and they have done it with remarkable single-mindedness and sometimes 0.93
00:05:36 vulgarity. For example, Joshua Clover, a communist poet, theorist of the riot as cultural expression
00:05:44 and radical professor of English at the University of California at Davis, has tweeted that, quote,
00:05:50 it would be in the interest of the movement to rid medieval studies of its own tacit enablers
00:05:56 of ethno-nationalisms and its own actual racists, such as Rachel Fulton Brown. He didn't say how
00:06:04 Professor Fulton Brown should be got rid of, and one can only imagine his reaction if someone
00:06:10 suggested that all third-rate communist poet propagandists should be got rid of. Across the
00:06:18 continent, Carl Steele, an associate professor of English at Brooklyn College at the City
00:06:24 University of New York, tweeted that, quote, there's hooking a wagon to a star, and then 1.00
00:06:30 there's Rachel Fulton Brown, who's hooked her dung cart to Milo's asshole, end quote. 0.99
00:06:38 Well, thank you, Professor Steele, for showing off your cultivated wit to the whole world. 0.99
00:06:43 Now what specifically did Fulton Brown do to cause all this outrage? Milo Yiannopoulos has
00:06:51 written a fantastic article outlining the scandal in detail, which I encourage you to read, but in
00:06:57 brief. In January of 2016, it was called to Fulton Brown's attention that a junior scholar named
00:07:04 Dorothy Kim had seized on the Three Cheers for White Men blog post and denounced it as an example 0.98
00:07:10 of quote white feminism that was engaged in quote upholding white supremacism and something called 0.99
00:07:19 military machines kim issued a dramatic and i think rather febrile challenge to fulton brown
00:07:27 and anybody else who might cheer the achievements of white men you'd better disavow the appropriation 0.93
00:07:33 of the medieval period for white supremacy or accept that you are a white supremacist whose
00:07:40 academic work empowers the war machine she wrote quote if medievalists imagine that their work is
00:07:49 not political or not going to be used in contemporary war machines then medievalists
00:07:53 must consider what privilege they have to dodge this the idea that this can be separated away
00:08:00 from the current now is a privilege of whiteness a privilege of hetero patriarchy end quote
00:08:08 in various other facebook posts and then in a medieval studies blog post dorothy kim continued 1.00
00:08:15 to attack rachel fulton brown as a white supremacist and nazi and continued to claim
00:08:22 that anyone who taught medieval studies neutrally or even positively as the root of much of that is
00:08:28 good in western culture was promoting white supremacism and acting as what she called quote
00:08:33 an ideological arms dealer end quote and she said in the post quote teaching medieval studies in a
00:08:40 time of white supremacism here are her words so are you going to be apathetic weapons dealers not
00:08:47 caring how your material and tools will be used do you care who your buyers are in the classroom
00:08:55 choose a side doing nothing is choosing a side denial is choosing a side end quote now when
00:09:04 fulton brown repeatedly responded to clarify that she was not a white supremacist and that she
00:09:09 rejected kim's description of the medieval period and how it can be used to support white supremacy
00:09:14 her response was interpreted by kim and by kim's various defenders as not only a statement of
00:09:20 fulton brown's inadequate understanding of racial theory but also as an action that endangered
00:09:27 dorothy kim always conveniently forgetting of course that it had been kim who had un-personed
00:09:34 fulton brown by repeatedly repeatedly calling her a white supremacist from here things snowballed
00:09:42 dorothy kim complained about fulton brown's so-called attacks on her stating at one point
00:09:48 that as a person of color her that's rachel fulton brown's views are violence to me and more and more
00:09:58 professors eagerly declared their solidarity with kim and their abhorrence of fulton brown's
00:10:03 supposed aggression twitter came alive with statements such as that by lila k noracko who
00:10:10 was an assistant professor in the department of english at the university of washington claiming
00:10:16 to be quote appalled by rachel fulton brown's attacks on dorothy kim our field she said is
00:10:22 worlds better for dorothy's presence in it and i stand with her end quote i'm always impressed by
00:10:28 how very brave english professors are when there's absolutely no risk to them in standing with
00:10:35 somebody almost no one has stood with rachel fulton brown pretty soon the gathering mob got
00:10:44 the idea of writing an open letter to the history department at the university of chicago to 0.99
00:10:49 complain about fulton brown and to state that she was a disgrace to the department and had caused
00:10:54 harm to a vulnerable woman and to people of color in general and at least 1300 academics
00:11:01 probably more now have signed this letter amongst other things the letter claimed that quote while
00:11:08 tenets of academic freedom dictate that professor fulton brown is allowed to express any opinion
00:11:13 she wishes we do not believe that doing so in a manner that puts an untenured untenured scholar of
00:11:20 color or any scholar in harm's way is her right and while again she is allowed to say what she
00:11:29 likes her ignorance of basic theoretical principles of race theory renders her an ill informed and
00:11:35 substandard interlocutor in the rigorous scholarly discussion of this important subject to say the
00:11:41 very least her highly public statement reflects poorly on your department end quote the letter
00:11:49 well it could have been written by a social justice computer program rather than by any living
00:11:53 breathing persons so entirely hackneyed are its various claims and it's astonishing to me that
00:12:00 so-called intellectuals can't come up with anything more coherent than the argument that
00:12:05 fulton brown has a right to freedom of speech but not a right to freedom of speech when it
00:12:10 harms somebody but how had fulton brown endangered dorothy kim supposedly by including her picture
00:12:19 in one of her rachel fulton brown's blog posts but this is a picture that is widely available
00:12:26 on the internet and that kim herself included with her blog posts the letter writers don't
00:12:32 even try to say how anything fulton brown has stated could possibly be taken as a call to
00:12:38 violence even an implicit one although one certainly could argue that the repeated 0.96
00:12:43 declarations that medieval studies needs to rid itself of white supremacist fascists like
00:12:49 Rachel Fulton Brown could logically be taken especially by academics who glorify punching
00:12:55 Nazis as a call to violence well obviously the intent of the open letter was to have Fulton
00:13:03 Brown fired or failing that, at least to have her disciplined or given a talking to by her
00:13:08 department members eager to display their own progressivist bona fides. But so far that hasn't
00:13:13 happened. At the same time, the department has done nothing to support Rachel Fulton Brown other
00:13:19 than to issue a very vaguely worded general letter saying that she's free to express her views and
00:13:25 that they neither endorse nor condemn her. And they deplore hate speech and they fail to distinguish
00:13:30 between Fulton Brown's civil statements and the uncivil statements of her attackers, and they
00:13:36 end with an expression of commitment to fostering, quote, an inclusive and diverse, end quote,
00:13:41 academic environment. So while not exactly throwing Fulton Brown under the proverbial bus,
00:13:46 her colleagues are certainly keeping a wary distance. They don't want to find themselves
00:13:51 labeled white supremacist enablers. Fulton Brown continues to respond to her attackers with 0.90
00:13:57 civility and courtesy and again I encourage anyone interested to read
00:14:01 through her many blog posts to see the the self-restraint and the good cheer
00:14:05 with which she has handled their attacks why is Rachel Fulton Brown so hated
00:14:12 she's hated because she loves the history of Western civilization
00:14:16 particularly its Christian roots at a time when cultural self-hatred on the
00:14:21 part of white academics is a sine qua non of respectability she's hated because
00:14:26 she professes a biblical concept of virtue and everyone else is madly virtue signaling. I stole 0.99
00:14:33 that idea from her. And she's hated because she's utterly impervious, as far as any outsider can tell,
00:14:40 to attempts at intimidation. And Rachel Fulton Brown's Independence of Mind exposes the majority 0.86
00:14:48 of academics for the pusillanimous time servers enslaved to fashion and to groupthink that so 0.71
00:14:56 many are. My advice to Fulton Brown's detractors, you should stop trying to humiliate this woman 1.00
00:15:04 with your bullying and tweeting and your ridiculous open letters. It's not a good look 1.00
00:15:10 for you. At best you come off like heretic hunters in the service of a punitive pagan cult 1.00
00:15:18 and that's essentially what you are. Now the National Association of Scholars
00:15:25 has recently published an open letter defending the heroic Rachel Fulton Brown and any academics
00:15:32 watching this who'd like to add their names to the list of supporters can certainly do so. I'd
00:15:38 love to think that that list will equal or exceed the numbers of those who denounced
00:15:44 her. But given the current sad state of academia, I doubt it will.
00:16:08 You