The Fiamengo File - September 06, 2018


Two "Journalists" Attended ICMI 2018 - TFF Episode 87

OMG, She Cheered For White Men! TFF Episode 86 I Can't Cheer The Allegations Against Michael Kimmel - TFF episode 88

Episode Stats


Length

20 minutes

Words per minute

136.54

Word count

2,747

Sentence count

104

Harmful content

Misogyny

7

sentences flagged

Toxicity

7

sentences flagged

Hate speech

15

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 If a tree falls at a men's rights conference, does any feminist hear it?
00:00:06 Not if we judge by two recent articles about London's International Conference on Men's
00:00:10 Issues, in which we find all the standard smear tactics.
00:00:15 Discredit, defame, demean, distort, deflect, and deny.
00:00:21 And that's my subject on today's Fiumingo File.
00:00:34 I'm Janice Fiumingo of the University of Ottawa.
00:00:37 In the second to last weekend in July, my husband and I attended the ICMI organized
00:00:43 by Mike Buchanan and Paul Elam and held in London, England.
00:00:47 involved a blockbuster lineup of presenters. All of the presentations will soon be online,
00:00:54 so I invite you to watch them yourself. These include researchers who have spent
00:01:01 years documenting the disadvantages men face socially, legally, medically, and in education,
00:01:07 such as male suicide, depression, their decline in educational attainment,
00:01:12 vastly disproportionate incarceration rates, false accusations, denial of the right to parent their
00:01:19 children, and increasing social stigma all across the culture. And there were advocates who have
00:01:26 poured enormous energy and ingenuity into opposing the feminist slander that men's 0.75
00:01:32 main problem today is a sense of entitlement. And there were individuals who told personal
00:01:38 stories of suffering at the hands of malevolent women in a culture so focused on protecting women
00:01:43 and girls it can hardly believe in men's pain at all even though nothing i heard at the conference
00:01:50 was really surprising still at times i felt an intense wave of pity and rage but rage or even
00:02:00 just ordinary anger at injustice is one of the things that you're never allowed to feel or at
00:02:06 at least never to express as a men's issues advocate, according to Lara White and Robert
00:02:12 Jackman. These are two feminist reporters, Lara White writing for an online publication called
00:02:20 5050 and Robert Jackman for Vice magazine. Not surprisingly, their sneering disdain doesn't seem
00:02:28 to have been even slightly dented by the conference, though they sat through at least
00:02:34 some of the same presentations I did. You wouldn't know that from their predictable dismissals in
00:02:41 which both argue essentially that whatever legitimate substance there might be behind
00:02:46 the men's rights movement, and both writers do acknowledge some substance, the movement can be
00:02:52 disregarded. Actually, more than that, the movement should be actively opposed because some men's 0.56
00:02:57 rights advocates are angry according to lara white conference goers quote fury and frustration were
00:03:05 quote palpable and quote at times distressing in other words were a lot of scary weirdos worthy
00:03:12 only of scorn both writers are quick to invoke the southern poverty law center's hate list white
00:03:22 tells us for example that Paul Elam is considered a purveyor of quote male supremacy by the SPLC
00:03:28 and that he once wrote a satire about domestic violence that declared October quote bash a 0.57
00:03:34 violent bitch month in other words he noted that the vast majority of domestic violence is two-way 0.77
00:03:40 both men and women involved and he argued that it's unfair to blame men who hit back at violent 0.87
00:03:48 women a contention by the way that i support 100 so put me on the list too please jackman tells us
00:03:56 on the other hand that in early 2018 the splc officially not just unofficially class two men's
00:04:05 rights organizations as hate groups and that it condemns the majority for their quote misogynistic
00:04:12 tone. It's well known that the SPLC applies the hate label to any organization or person,
00:04:20 no matter how committed to peaceful and fact-based advocacy whose politics don't correspond to their
00:04:28 far-left platform. Notably, the SPLC does not list Antifa or ISIS as hate groups, but that doesn't
00:04:37 diminish the enormous respect with which White and Jackman quote their pronouncements. In fact,
00:04:44 with SPLC backing, it seems the two writers never feel compelled to show how anything said
00:04:50 by anybody at the conference was actually misogynistic. And, of course, they couldn't
00:04:56 have found a single thing. The bogeyman of the alt-right is also trotted out by both writers.
00:05:05 in what is perhaps the most ludicrous statement in an article filled with misrepresentations
00:05:10 lara white claims that at one point in a breakout room prior to karen strawn's keynote address
00:05:17 she lara was quote briefly the only woman in a room of entirely white men end quote there you go 0.99
00:05:25 my god the horror of it it was only briefly mind you because there were numerous women
00:05:33 and non-white men at the conference, both as speakers and attendees. But it must have been
00:05:39 a pretty scary experience, even for that split second, especially since the men were, quote,
00:05:45 entirely white, misplaced modifier there, and lots of implications of racial purity.
00:05:53 This brave woman had to endure a great deal to report on the dark, that is, white underbelly
00:06:00 of men's rights. Both writers also triumphantly seize on the fact that one of the presenters, 0.90
00:06:07 Oliver Hoffman, founder of an Austrian men's rights political party, advocated coalition
00:06:13 building with a wide range of groups, including white nationalists. And I would encourage anyone
00:06:19 who is concerned about this claim to watch Hoffman's presentation, which I think will soon
00:06:24 be online, and judge for yourself. His point was pretty clearly, in my opinion, that if men's rights
00:06:29 is to have any traction at the political level, it should consider partnering with other anti-feminist
00:06:36 and anti-SJW groups in order to advocate for the core values of Western civilization, which he
00:06:43 defined as individual rights and freedoms, rule of law, and equality before the law. Hardly neo-Nazi
00:06:51 themes. And yes, some of the conference attendees, especially those from Western Europe that have
00:06:59 seen the societal devastation that is resulting from mass Muslim immigration, have concerns 0.96
00:07:05 about multiculturalism and open borders. That doesn't equate to white supremacism by a long 1.00
00:07:13 shot, but white and jackmen want you to believe it does. Neither of these writers makes any attempt
00:07:20 to hide their mocking distaste for everything associated with a men's issues conference.
00:07:28 Lara White, for example, tells us as if exposing the bizarre superstition of a UFO crank
00:07:34 that organizer Mike Buchanan was reluctant to provide her with a journalist pass or even to
00:07:41 tell her the conference location. And this strikes her as giggle worthy. She says, quote,
00:07:47 I spent considerable time trying to convince Buchanan I was not the feminist my previously
00:07:53 published work might make me seem, end quote. In other words, she lied about having a genuine
00:08:00 interest in men's issues. And she tells us with evident amusement, and a dangling modifier by the
00:08:06 way, that quote, burrowed in the far reaches of London's Excel Centre, security at the meeting
00:08:15 was tight end quote yeah that's right lara the location was secret and there had to be security
00:08:23 because the people on your side of the ideological divide regularly shut down attempts to discuss
00:08:30 men's issues either by complaining to the venue about men's rights hate and thus forcing the
00:08:37 events cancellation as has happened countless times with the red pill movie which you falsely
00:08:43 claim was banned from cinemas in Australia. It wasn't banned. It was simply shut down by irate
00:08:50 feminists. Or they show up en masse and prevent people from going into the venue, something I've 1.00
00:08:57 witnessed over and over again. So men's rights advocates are compelled to take precautionary
00:09:04 measures that feminist speakers, no matter how radical, would almost never have to take.
00:09:10 and you wonder why some of the men at these conferences are a little angry.
00:09:16 Robert Jackman is even more upfront with his flippancy. He tells us from the beginning that
00:09:23 he wanted to attend ICMI, quote, to see whether the attendees really all were the women hating
00:09:30 wackos they are believed to be. His answer is, yes, we pretty much all are, perhaps with the 0.70
00:09:38 the exception of feminist-trained professor Eric Anderson and one or two others. In order to
00:09:45 reinforce his contention about the wackiness of those who attended the conference, Jackman often 0.96
00:09:52 mentions specific men's issues with a disdainful rhetorical shrug, inviting us all to chuckle along
00:10:00 with him at MRA's lunatic concerns. For example, he calls circumcision a, quote, huge hang-up for
00:10:08 the movement, end quote. And he says that MRA's advocacy of paternity testing is evidence of how
00:10:14 the movement is, quote, obsessed with cuckolding, end quote. Well, Jackman, maybe you don't give a
00:10:22 damn whether the boy you raise is your own son or not, or whether circumcision has serious 0.96
00:10:27 health and human rights implications, but your mockery proves little but your own lack of 1.00
00:10:34 seriousness jackman even goes so far as to fabricate evidence of misogyny at one point
00:10:41 he informs readers that quote the language used at the conference can be dehumanizing whether
00:10:48 deliberate or accidental men in general are quote men whereas women are usually females end quote
00:10:57 balderdash i happen to have an english prof's aversion to the use of the adjective female
00:11:03 as a noun, so I would have noticed if it had been used that way, and it wasn't. But even if it had,
00:11:10 it doesn't indicate misogyny. It's used because there is no noun in English that refers to both
00:11:17 women and girls. If that's the best example Jackman could find of attendees' supposed
00:11:24 dehumanization of women, it's no wonder he had to fall back on the libels of the Southern
00:11:29 Poverty Law Center. Now, where it isn't possible simply to demean through mockery or reference to
00:11:38 made-up language crimes, the writers resort to more blatant distortions, sometimes focusing on
00:11:44 individual presentations, sometimes generalizing about the movement as a whole. Lara White, for
00:11:51 example, tells us that Karen Strawn's keynote presentation, get this, was, quote, a peculiar
00:11:57 mix of personal anecdotes, riffs on female privilege and gynocentrism, and the odd scattering
00:12:05 of decontextualized fact, end quote. For anyone who's ever heard the master of cogent rhetoric,
00:12:11 Karen Strawn, speak anywhere, at any time, this is a bizarre allegation. What did White find so
00:12:20 peculiar or odd about Karen Strawn's talk? She doesn't explain. Jackman is similarly snooty
00:12:28 without specifics about individual talks. He tells us, for example, that philosophy PhD
00:12:34 Jeffrey Ketlin's presentation was, quote, rambling. Well, watch it for yourself and decide. I didn't
00:12:40 think it was. And he refers derisively to a, quote, weird spider diagram in Ketlin's presentation
00:12:48 naming individual feminists and detailing how they had wronged him, end quote. What was so
00:12:55 weird about it? Ketland is a professor of axiomatic logic who was hounded out of his
00:13:00 position at Oxford University by a feminist mob claiming without evidence that he was responsible
00:13:06 for the death by suicide of a mentally ill woman who had stalked him and his family for years.
00:13:12 It didn't seem to me particularly weird that he chose to name those who ruined his career.
00:13:20 Another blatant distortion is Jackman's claim that, quote,
00:13:23 MRAs commonly have a victim mentality,
00:13:26 viewing themselves as being systemically persecuted with women getting a better deal, end quote. 1.00
00:13:33 Now that is pure projection.
00:13:36 It's not a victim mentality.
00:13:38 If you really are systemically persecuted and disadvantaged, as a significant number of the presenters showed men to be, anyone who doubts the substance behind men's claims of discrimination should take a good, long look at William Collins' magisterial summation of the evidence, available in video and on his magnificent blog, The Illustrated Empathy Gap.
00:14:03 Find me anything there that is, quote, cherry picked, as Lara White had the gall to claim of the, quote, research and statistics she heard at the conference. 0.52
00:14:14 A person with a victim mentality is someone, usually a woman, who takes pleasure in and derives her identity and power from a fantasy of victimhood, a fantasy that others believe and for which she is rewarded with state-enforced accommodations and lots of public concern.
00:14:36 The term doesn't apply to men's rights activists, not least because there are
00:14:42 no advantages to men in claiming discrimination in a society that either doesn't believe them,
00:14:49 doesn't care, or finds vulnerable men repulsive. Lara White gives Jackman a run for his money in 0.85
00:14:57 the category of feminist distortion when she informs us that she detected amongst conference
00:15:03 goers quote what appeared to be a shared mourning for an idealized past end quote well this couldn't
00:15:13 possibly be supported even with creative interpretation by anything said at the conference
00:15:19 and lara if you'd done even a tiny bit of homework you'd have known that the vast majority of mras
00:15:26 not only reject feminist gynocentrism, but also traditional gynocentrism. MRAs don't long for a 1.00
00:15:34 past in which men were expected to be the stoic, self-sacrificing providers working themselves into 0.87
00:15:42 an early grave in order to support the children they rarely saw and the wife who complained that
00:15:47 they were never home but sure wasn't interested in having the money dry up. Lara, your statement
00:15:53 tells us far more about your own echo chamber assumptions than it does about anyone who spoke
00:16:01 at ICMI. Well, I've probably said enough to indicate the mindset of White and Jackman,
00:16:08 and there's plenty more that I won't bother with. What is perhaps most striking in both their
00:16:15 articles is the near complete absence of argument, if by argument one means logical fact-based
00:16:21 rebuttal of any MRA claims. At one point, Lara White quotes Paul Elam as saying that, quote,
00:16:28 almost all the sacrifice of blood and sweat and of life that is required to keep the world turning
00:16:36 is male sacrifice. Women won't do it. Women can't do it, end quote. You can almost hear White's 1.00
00:16:45 teeth grinding in aggravation, but she fails to offer even a quip in Comeback, let alone a single
00:16:52 example to show that Paul isn't right about that. Did you even listen to his talk, Lara?
00:16:58 But hey, who needs to listen and argue when your only real thesis is that angry white men and their 0.98
00:17:05 few female and non-white male allies are kooky creeps who don't deserve a hearing? You can even 0.99
00:17:12 admit that those men have some legitimate issues to be angry about and ignore them anyway. White 0.88
00:17:19 says superciliously that, quote, the list of MRA grievances is long, but like any extremist
00:17:25 movement, there are a few uncomfortable truths spurning the fury, end quote. I think she meant
00:17:32 spurring, not spurning. She mentions male suicide, male educational underachievement, MGM, and lack
00:17:39 of provisions for male domestic violence victims. Actually, a pretty hefty list. But her strangely
00:17:47 constructed sentence, it's some version of the old saying that if you have 10,000 monkeys working at
00:17:53 10,000 typewriters, sooner or later one of them is going to write Macbeth. So, sure, occasionally
00:17:58 MRAs hit on a real grievance that even a feminist can't deny, but that shouldn't mean we stop 0.61
00:18:03 laughing. Jackman is even more smug in his backhanded acknowledgement of the real issues
00:18:11 of the movement. At one point in his article, he admits that listening to the presentation of a
00:18:16 male domestic violence victim, quote, you started to think there might be some utility in a men's
00:18:23 rights movement. At least one started from scratch, untainted by what it has now come to represent,
00:18:29 end quote. A paragraph later, after mentioning once again the supposed bigotry of MRAs, he says,
00:18:35 quote, it's attitudes like this which make the movement hard to take seriously and which will
00:18:43 ultimately harm those it wants to protect, end quote. And that's his last sentence. As sanctimonious
00:18:53 and preachy as could be. Thanks, Jackman, for your concern that male victims aren't getting
00:19:00 the support or attention they deserve because a tainted movement is advocating for them.
00:19:07 If you advocated for them, that would be a different thing, I guess, because you'd do
00:19:11 it the right way. But you're not going to, are you? You're not going to start your own
00:19:16 movement for men or focus on the things that are real in the MRM because you're a pro-feminist
00:19:22 guy who'd rather spend your time scoffing at MRA wackos and being appalled by their misogynistic
00:19:29 tone. Your concern for real male victims, it's so deep it won't sully itself with any action 0.62
00:19:37 whatsoever. And thus we come full circle to MRA anger and the smug superior smirks of Lara White
00:19:48 and Robert Jackman.
00:19:52 Thank you for watching. If you enjoyed this video, please support us on Patreon. If even
00:19:58 half of our subscribers gave us $1 per month, we'd be well on our way to creating more
00:20:02 and better content. And don't forget to subscribe to us on Studio Brulee.