00:13:38If you really are systemically persecuted and disadvantaged, as a significant number of the presenters showed men to be, anyone who doubts the substance behind men's claims of discrimination should take a good, long look at William Collins' magisterial summation of the evidence, available in video and on his magnificent blog, The Illustrated Empathy Gap.
00:14:03Find me anything there that is, quote, cherry picked, as Lara White had the gall to claim of the, quote, research and statistics she heard at the conference.0.52
00:14:14A person with a victim mentality is someone, usually a woman, who takes pleasure in and derives her identity and power from a fantasy of victimhood, a fantasy that others believe and for which she is rewarded with state-enforced accommodations and lots of public concern.
00:14:36The term doesn't apply to men's rights activists, not least because there are
00:14:42no advantages to men in claiming discrimination in a society that either doesn't believe them,
00:14:49doesn't care, or finds vulnerable men repulsive. Lara White gives Jackman a run for his money in0.85
00:14:57the category of feminist distortion when she informs us that she detected amongst conference
00:15:03goers quote what appeared to be a shared mourning for an idealized past end quote well this couldn't
00:15:13possibly be supported even with creative interpretation by anything said at the conference
00:15:19and lara if you'd done even a tiny bit of homework you'd have known that the vast majority of mras
00:15:26not only reject feminist gynocentrism, but also traditional gynocentrism. MRAs don't long for a1.00
00:15:34past in which men were expected to be the stoic, self-sacrificing providers working themselves into0.87
00:15:42an early grave in order to support the children they rarely saw and the wife who complained that
00:15:47they were never home but sure wasn't interested in having the money dry up. Lara, your statement
00:15:53tells us far more about your own echo chamber assumptions than it does about anyone who spoke
00:16:01at ICMI. Well, I've probably said enough to indicate the mindset of White and Jackman,
00:16:08and there's plenty more that I won't bother with. What is perhaps most striking in both their
00:16:15articles is the near complete absence of argument, if by argument one means logical fact-based
00:16:21rebuttal of any MRA claims. At one point, Lara White quotes Paul Elam as saying that, quote,
00:16:28almost all the sacrifice of blood and sweat and of life that is required to keep the world turning
00:16:36is male sacrifice. Women won't do it. Women can't do it, end quote. You can almost hear White's1.00
00:16:45teeth grinding in aggravation, but she fails to offer even a quip in Comeback, let alone a single
00:16:52example to show that Paul isn't right about that. Did you even listen to his talk, Lara?
00:16:58But hey, who needs to listen and argue when your only real thesis is that angry white men and their0.98
00:17:05few female and non-white male allies are kooky creeps who don't deserve a hearing? You can even0.99
00:17:12admit that those men have some legitimate issues to be angry about and ignore them anyway. White0.88
00:17:19says superciliously that, quote, the list of MRA grievances is long, but like any extremist
00:17:25movement, there are a few uncomfortable truths spurning the fury, end quote. I think she meant
00:17:32spurring, not spurning. She mentions male suicide, male educational underachievement, MGM, and lack
00:17:39of provisions for male domestic violence victims. Actually, a pretty hefty list. But her strangely
00:17:47constructed sentence, it's some version of the old saying that if you have 10,000 monkeys working at
00:17:5310,000 typewriters, sooner or later one of them is going to write Macbeth. So, sure, occasionally
00:17:58MRAs hit on a real grievance that even a feminist can't deny, but that shouldn't mean we stop0.61
00:18:03laughing. Jackman is even more smug in his backhanded acknowledgement of the real issues
00:18:11of the movement. At one point in his article, he admits that listening to the presentation of a
00:18:16male domestic violence victim, quote, you started to think there might be some utility in a men's
00:18:23rights movement. At least one started from scratch, untainted by what it has now come to represent,
00:18:29end quote. A paragraph later, after mentioning once again the supposed bigotry of MRAs, he says,
00:18:35quote, it's attitudes like this which make the movement hard to take seriously and which will
00:18:43ultimately harm those it wants to protect, end quote. And that's his last sentence. As sanctimonious
00:18:53and preachy as could be. Thanks, Jackman, for your concern that male victims aren't getting
00:19:00the support or attention they deserve because a tainted movement is advocating for them.
00:19:07If you advocated for them, that would be a different thing, I guess, because you'd do
00:19:11it the right way. But you're not going to, are you? You're not going to start your own
00:19:16movement for men or focus on the things that are real in the MRM because you're a pro-feminist
00:19:22guy who'd rather spend your time scoffing at MRA wackos and being appalled by their misogynistic
00:19:29tone. Your concern for real male victims, it's so deep it won't sully itself with any action0.62
00:19:37whatsoever. And thus we come full circle to MRA anger and the smug superior smirks of Lara White