The Fiamengo File - September 23, 2018


I Can't Cheer The Allegations Against Michael Kimmel - TFF episode 88

Two "Journalists" Attended ICMI 2018 - TFF Episode 87 To Understand Christine Blasey Ford, Take a look at Palo Alto University

Episode Stats


Length

11 minutes

Words per minute

127.66

Word count

1,454

Sentence count

29

Harmful content

Misogyny

14

sentences flagged

Toxicity

8

sentences flagged

Hate speech

10

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 What's an anti-feminist to do when the most famous male feminist in the world is called out for sexual 1.00
00:00:08 harassment? I won't be cheering, but not out of sympathy for Michael Kimmel, and that's my subject
00:00:14 on today's Fiamengo file i'm janice fiamengo of the university of ottawa most of us by now
00:00:31 have had some experience of me too a friend a neighbor's son a co-worker or a loved one is
00:00:37 suddenly accused of sexual misconduct and now he's suspended from his job pending an investigation
00:00:44 he's flat out fired or he's walking around under a cloud desperately hoping that another woman
00:00:50 doesn't put the final nail in his coffin and this is the brave new world we're all supposed to
00:00:57 celebrate in the name of gender equality but now some feminist icons are being fingered too 0.98
00:01:06 weinstein accuser asia argento accused of sexually assaulting a 17 year old boy 1.00
00:01:13 professor avital ronnell for sexually harassing her male graduate student and perhaps most
00:01:20 sensationally professor michael kimmel director of the center for the study of men and masculinities
00:01:26 at stony brook university in new york the ultimate male man shamer accused of sexual harassment by
00:01:35 various former students one of whom who had one of whom has come forward to accuse him under her
00:01:42 own name it looks like big time karma kimmel is the man who preached to men about being allies to
00:01:50 women when they accuse other men and who has had the gall to claim that he knows better than
00:01:56 working-class white men what and whom they should be angry at his main shtick is repeating cliches 0.96
00:02:06 about race sexuality and gender in which he always singles out straight white men for their toxic 0.94
00:02:13 masculinity the chief obstacle to racial equality has been the behavior and attitudes of white 0.98
00:02:25 people. The chief obstacles to sexual equality has been the behavior and attitudes of heterosexuals, 0.66
00:02:32 and of course the chief obstacles to gender equality have been the behavior and attitudes of men.
00:02:55 and this is the man who's made a career of telling untruths about men's rights activists
00:03:04 claiming for example famously that mras use the fact of gender symmetry and domestic violence
00:03:11 to conclude there should be no domestic violence shelters for women at all an argument no mra has
00:03:18 ever made. Let's grant every single empirical case as being true. Yes, it is true. Let's just 0.97
00:03:27 say, I mean, it is not true, but let's just assume that there is gender symmetry in domestic
00:03:34 violence, that women hit men as much as men hit women. If I were to say that, I would say, 0.53
00:03:40 And therefore, we need boatloads more funding for domestic violence to develop shelters and adequate interventions, because there's this hidden epidemic of men who are being beaten up by women. 0.99
00:03:54 Or, I could say, as the Men's Rights Movement do, therefore, we shouldn't have these shelters and we shouldn't fund them because the women are all lying. 0.87
00:04:02 Well, it seems to me that if you really believe in gender symmetry, it's not that you want to, you're not questioning the number of women. 1.00
00:04:10 You're just saying the number of men.
00:04:11 You would want to join with women who are anti-violence to say, we have a real problem here.
00:04:19 You know, it's not even a gender problem. 0.74
00:04:21 It's a problem of women hitting men and men hitting women. 1.00
00:04:23 We've got to get boatloads more funding. 1.00
00:04:25 Let's work together.
00:04:26 That seems the logical response to this.
00:04:28 But instead, they're saying it's like a zero-sum game.
00:04:31 if if we fund the women then we're going to ignore the men it's nearly impossible then not to feel a
00:04:39 bitter satisfaction as those like Kimmel who rode the waves of anti-male self-righteousness
00:04:46 now find themselves smashed on the rocks of public opprobrium just a few months ago he was being
00:04:54 fawningly interviewed in the feminist journal Signs, now the internet is alive with sermonizing
00:05:01 about what Kimmel must do in order to redeem himself. But this is not a development to be
00:05:10 celebrated, and it is definitely not, in my opinion, the beginning of the end of Me Too,
00:05:16 as some have hoped. Michael Kimmel isn't being criticized for misrepresenting men's issues or
00:05:24 smearing men's advocates. He's being taken down as part of the next phase of a movement of mass
00:05:31 vengeance in which many of us will be called to account, not only for our alleged misdemeanors,
00:05:38 but simply for being in the path of a mob. Anyone who has ever believed that Me Too is about
00:05:46 specific acts of sexual misconduct need merely read the long and helpfully detailed list of
00:05:55 allegations against Kimmel by a former graduate student to see the thoroughly narcissistic and 0.74
00:06:02 delusional nature of the Me Too scapegoating monster. And this monster will continue to grow 0.84
00:06:09 despite its evident hypocrisies because exponential growth is part of its DNA 0.88
00:06:16 the former graduate student is Bethany Koston now a professor of gender sexuality and women's
00:06:25 studies at Virginia Commonwealth University and she has published a melodramatic itemizing of
00:06:31 the campaign of terror Kimmel supposedly conducted against her it's called reclaiming my fear I will
00:06:39 no longer stay silent about michael kimmel from the title alone we know we're in the company of
00:06:47 a writer whose thinking is controlled by slogans feminist literature is full of women reclaiming 1.00
00:06:55 all sorts of things their bodies their lives their power and the fact that reclaiming power 0.95
00:07:01 for example and reclaiming fear can be used to mean almost exactly the same thing in a feminist
00:07:07 title indicates the essential meaninglessness of the phrasing early on in the article coston tells
00:07:14 us that she is quote called in to this conversation by the brave anonymous sources who spoke truth to
00:07:21 their experience of sexual harassment end quote yeah well i was quote called in to make this video
00:07:29 albeit belatedly by the pure tripe of finding anonymous accusations brave overall coston's
00:07:38 allegations are trivial by any standard and they have nothing to do with kimmel's relentless
00:07:44 demonization of men what bothers coston are the ways kimmel failed to fall in line with her 0.95
00:07:52 superior and even more rigid and punitive intersectional feminist ideology 0.99
00:07:58 according to coston professor kimmel profited from and exploited she claims her research assistance 1.00
00:08:06 during the time she was his graduate student but failed to fully grasp and acknowledge her superior
00:08:13 insights about lesbian sexuality transgenderism and second wave feminism the worst she can say
00:08:21 about him in the article is that he had her photocopy articles for him and look things up
00:08:26 that he could have looked up himself. What did she expect? He was a big-time academic,
00:08:32 proud to hobnob with the likes of Jane Fonda and Gloria Steinem, and she was a lowly graduate
00:08:38 student getting a chance to make her mark on academia and exploiting Kimmel's patronage for
00:08:44 all it was worth. She seems to have done well by it. Reading through Koston's list of Kimmel's 0.54
00:08:51 so-called misconduct almost well almost but not quite makes one feel sorry for kimmel apparently
00:08:59 he admitted to being uncomfortable using they them pronouns for individual students he didn't accept
00:09:07 coston's expanded definition of lesbian sex which would have made it possible to claim that
00:09:12 lesbians are equally sexually active as gay men he confessed to shameful heterosexual impulses
00:09:19 and he failed to keep up with transgenderism's ever-changing terminology perhaps professor 0.97
00:09:26 kimmel did all the unremarkable things bethany coston says he did and will now be tainted by
00:09:33 her allegations is this karma for kimmel only if it had anything to do with the real harm
00:09:41 kimmel has caused and it doesn't bethany coston is a vivid symbol of me too's manic momentum
00:09:51 she alleges that kimmel lacked empathy for those with different values or experiences from
00:09:57 his own but she spectacularly lacks empathy for anyone who might deviate from the suffocatingly
00:10:03 narrow range of opinion she deems acceptable which is even more self-righteous and priggish 1.00
00:10:10 than kimmel's her article expresses zero concern for the mostly male bodies that already litter 1.00
00:10:17 the revolutionary feminist battleground she simply wants to expand the scope of the slaughter and
00:10:24 have us all on our knees begging for forgiveness my point is yes it's satisfying to see me too
00:10:32 leaders hoisted on their own petards michael kimmel does deserve to be discredited in my opinion
00:10:40 for promoting and profiting from male misery but not with the bethany coston's of the world
00:10:46 leading the charge in coston's capable hands me too will continue to destroy careers and lives
00:10:54 mostly male but a few female and even feminist ones too no matter what real villain is being 1.00
00:11:02 targeted. Mobs are never about justice. 0.98